Whitehorse Daily Star

Yukon’s WCB substantially overfunded: CFIB

The territory has one of the most over-funded workers’ compensation boards in the country, second only to that of Prince Edward Island.

By Stephanie Waddell on November 2, 2017

The territory has one of the most over-funded workers’ compensation boards in the country, second only to that of Prince Edward Island.

The figures, as of 2016, were revealed in a report released Wednesday by the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB).

The territory’s system is funded at 149.8 per cent, with P.E.I.’s being funded at 159.4 per cent.

Workers’ compensation in six other regions also falls into the over-funded categories.

They are New Brunswick at 112.1 per cent, Newfoundland and Labrador at 126.1 per cent, Saskatchewan at 133.1 per cent, Alberta at 133.8 per cent, British Columbia at 141. 7 per cent and Manitoba at 145.9 per cent.

Quebec and Nunavut/Northwest Territories are the only regions that are within what the CFIB deems the “ideal funding range” of 100 to 110 per cent.

Meanwhile, Nova Scotia and Ontario are the only jurisdictions where the WCB is underfunded, at 84.1 per cent and 87.9 per cent respectively.

The CFIB argues the overfunding in eight regions is depriving employers of money that could otherwise go into their businesses, creating jobs and improving wages and worker safety.

“Boards are holding onto $6.8 billon in extra money,” said Laura Jones, CFIB’s executive vice-president and chief strategic officer.

“Typically when you overpay your taxes, you get a refund. It’s time boards give that refund.

“There is no shortage of great ways it could be put to work in a business, including investigating in staff. The bottom line is that overcharging employers is unfair, unproductive and unnecessary.”

Across the country, workers’ compensation systems are funded through employer premiums and earnings from investments.

The funding position is measured as the ratio between the board’s assets and liabilities.

The report by the CFIB recommends a funding position of 100 to 110 per cent, providing for a 10 per cent “cushion”, which officials believe is “more than enough” to protect against volatility.

Marvin Cruz is a senior research analyst who authored the report.

He argued that additional funding beyond the 110 per cent should be returned to employers, who bear the sole responsibility of funding the system.

As an example, it was noted the rebates for a business with five employees would range from $500 in N.B. to $8,165 in B.C.

That would mean a financial boost to small businesses that would benefit many, including governments – which are also subject to workers’ compensation rates.

“This is a pretty straightforward policy,” Jones said.

“We aren’t asking governments to spend more money, just to give back the excess they’ve taken.”

The territory has one of the highest overfunded WCBs in the country.

However, efforts are underway to bring rates more in line with the true cost of caring for injured workers. That was noted earlier this year, when the board revealed 2018 rates employers will pay.

Rebate cheques

It has also issued rebate cheques totalling $9.8 million in 2015 and $9.7 million in 2016 to Yukon businesses. A decision on whether rebates will be offered this year has not yet been made.

Of course, the Yukon WCB “fully supports” a system that is fair to both workers and employers, Yukon WCB spokesman Andrew Robulack said.

In addition to the rebates, employers are benefiting from subsidized rates, given the financial position the board is now in.

As Yukon WCB chair Mark Pike said last month when the 2018 rates were revealed:

“Rates are artificially low because the surplus in our funded position places a downward pressure on rates in the form of subsidies.

“With the support of employer and worker stakeholder organizations, we’re engaged in a prudent long-term plan to reduce that surplus along with the subsidies in assessment rates.

“When employers pay rates that reflect the actual costs of caring for injured workers, it helps them recognize the value of preventing injuries and getting workers back on the job as quickly and safely as possible following an injury.”

The average rate is set to rise from $1.87 to $1.93 per $100 of payroll next year for the 3,576 businesses in the territory that pay into the system.

During that press conference, the Yukon WCB pointed out that while most employers will see a rate increase next year, nearly all are paying less than they did between 2009 and 2015.

Robulack said that while the CFIB argues anything over 110 per cent is overfunded, the territory sets its target funding range amount at 121 to 129 per cent.

“The 100 per cent to 110 per cent target range expressed by CFIB is unrealistic for Yukon, and it’s unclear how the CFIB arrived at that range,” Robulack said.

“They appear to be painting all Canadian jurisdictions with the same colour when, the reality is, each of us must address differing sets of economic realities.

“One size of workers’ compensation does not fit all Canadian jurisdictions.

“Boards across Canada must constantly balance the risks associated with workplace health and safety unique to their regions and the influences of the investment market,” Robulack added.

“In many jurisdictions, that has resulted in surpluses, as it has in Yukon.”

Comments (8)

Up 0 Down 0

Josey Wales on Nov 8, 2017 at 4:17 pm

Ahhhh...the overlords of safety and their expensive parasitic reality.
They should, using the same stellar planning as the last one...erect a sign in -45 above the other...illustrating the costs per day to feed that fiefdom.
Is it a mere coincidence that so many there are off the BMI chart?
Besides accident safety that costs everyone, so too does encouraging obesity and all the side effects of that.
There too like most offices here...f/a for accountability.
Hence the epic growth of crats in this sty...breed faster than the bacteria of those entitled blowholes.

Up 12 Down 7

warlord on Nov 3, 2017 at 6:49 pm

Power and corruption in high places. All the reforms initiated by Yukon Injured Workers Alliance were rolled back by Union reps, Chamber of Commerce, Board of Directors, and the Minister responsible under The Fentie regime. They created the worst Legislation in Yukon History. Illegal policies, alteration of legislative language on Board reports leading to illegal policy and kickbacks to Employers paying premiums by putting Injured Workers Pensions into hands of Local Insurance companies who pay premiums. How so? Well, the legislation says ..."must provide an annuity". Board report leading to policy changes the word provide to purchase!
All the evidence of this is on record. And injured workers alliance former members still in Yukon have all the facts. If you think the perpetrators of this abuse will face exposure or justice, dream on! They are deep cover. Protected by the protocols of the last bastion of institutionalized abuse.

Up 28 Down 3

Math on Nov 3, 2017 at 7:46 am

Marvelous. So government taxes our businesses to pay for bureaucrats to cruise the conference cocktail circuits trying to drum up investment capital to Yukon, while at the same time removing scarce capital from our businesses through WCB and investing it off to the multi-nationals of the TSX instead. Outstanding.

Up 41 Down 4

Just Say'in on Nov 2, 2017 at 5:53 pm

They march into local businesses like the Gestapo looking for violations. They categorically refuse to tell you how to remedy the situation, it is up to you to come up with the fix. No direction no help. They are so risk adverse they know that if they tell you do this, and there is an accident then they don't want to be seen as responsible. Yet as an employer you are shouldering all of the risk, while the organization that we set up to protect the business and the worker is shunning its responsibility, and being a tyrant with its creator.

Up 39 Down 4

Just Say'in on Nov 2, 2017 at 5:43 pm

For those that may not know. WCB was set up by businesses to pool their money and protect their employees, much like an insurance so as to distribute the risk.
Somewhere along the line that has changed, now they are some quasi Government organization. But worse they do not answer to Business, or the Government. They have used the funds that small Yukon employers have provided to build an empire. Millions on Computer Systems, Millions on Security upgrades to the building, and unknown Millions on the massive building and the new expansions.

The bulletproof glass and security out front should give you a look into their customer satisfaction rating, both for injured workers and the business providers.

Up 63 Down 10

Just Sayin' on Nov 2, 2017 at 4:57 pm

WOW! No wonder they can afford all the fancy additions to their building and new vehicles. I am astounded they are allowed to rip off business in such a manner and they should return the monies to the businesses with interest.

Any further increases should be passed by a legislative body at least their would be some discussions and people would have their say. Why is this one of the bodies which can rate hike without public discussions???

Up 62 Down 10

ProScience Greenie on Nov 2, 2017 at 4:55 pm

Audit and housecleaning at WCB please. Also time to look at ending their monopoly on worker / workplace insurance.

Up 65 Down 8

Nile on Nov 2, 2017 at 3:42 pm

We also have the most bloated WCB in Canada. Almost twice as much staff as other jurisdiction. Ironically when Richard Mostyn looses his seat in the next election he will get to go back to his job as the WCB spokesman.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.