Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Council of Yukon First Nations’ Grand Chief Peter Johnston

Yukon Forum finale involved ‘a lot of planning for the future’

The fourth and final Yukon Forum of 2019 took place Friday at the Kwanlin Dün Cultural Centre.

By Whitehorse Star on December 16, 2019

The fourth and final Yukon Forum of 2019 took place Friday at the Kwanlin Dün Cultural Centre.

Premier Sandy Silver and his cabinet members met with Peter Johnston, the Council of Yukon First Nations’ grand chief, and Yukon First Nations chiefs.

The leaders discussed traditional knowledge, an education data sharing agreement and a Yukon strategy for the Murdered and Missing Indigenous Women and Girls (MMIWG) report.

There was also a debrief and discussion about Yukon Days meetings in Ottawa earlier this month.

The leaders also took a tour of the new youth transitional housing program on Wann Road in Porter Creek, which launched on Dec. 6.

Silver told media at the forum’s agenda focused on presentations and updates, and was a “little more soft” than some forums have been in the past.

“A lot of philosophical conversations today, and a lot of planning for the future,” Silver said.

The leaders discussed traditional knowledge and the importance of respect without ownership.

Silver said his government plans for a future in which traditional knowledge is as important to decision-making as scientific knowledge.

Johnston noted, however, that traditional knowledge is never something the government owns. Being respectful of this requires a fine balance when creating policy that considers traditional knowledge.

The leaders also discussed the Yukon strategy on the MMIWG Report.

“We’re in an interesting place right now,” Silver said. “The Yukon has been at the forefront of this conversation.”

Johnston said the big difference between the Yukon and other places in Canada is self-governance. He said he is optimistic for successful government-to-government dialogue in the creation of an action plan around the report.

There were discussions of “decolonizing” the conversation around the MMIWG and opening it up to all Yukoners.

“The lion’s share of the work has been done … now it’s a matter of understanding we can’t do this alone,” Silver said.

Silver said he is anticipating a draft of the Yukon strategy on the MMIWG Report in the near future.

The forum also discussed a “monumental initiative” toward an education data-sharing agreement.

“We are moving into that reality,” Johnston said. “We are definitely moving ahead in regard of how we deal with First Nation education in the territory.”

Johnston added that shared data will be a very important aspect of moving forward, and the governments are working to co-ordinate efforts on it.

Both leaders agreed that the Yukon Days meetings in Ottawa earlier this month were successful.

Johnston said it was clearly communicated to federal ministers that the Yukon needs more police resources and important anecdotal information was shared about the impact of community safety officers in the territory.

Silver conceded that the new government in Ottawa made Yukon Days chaotic, and discussions were had between the leaders on how to improve meetings in the future.

Looking forward to 2020, Johnston said the plan is to push Silver’s government to set the bar high and continue constructive dialogue.

Silver added that a “new normal” has been established through the 12 successful forums conducted so far.

Now, there is room to reimagine what Yukon Forums will look like going forward, the leaders said.

Johnston said the meetings have evolved from operating on a set agenda to a more organic dialogue, and the leaders are continually open to changing the way the meetings operate.

“We are always willing to consider change, because we want to make sure these are as effective as possible,” Silver

Comments (10)

Up 0 Down 0

Robert Plant on Dec 26, 2019 at 8:56 am

Come out, come out wherever you are - Pebbles:

Traditional Knowledge is a status enhancing way of talking about personal experience and giving it credibility by virtue of its existence. I believe therefore I am.

Given its fluidity it will be a dangerous tool in the hands of our current Liberal government who will likely use it to undermine the practice of evidence-based decision making. This too shall be chaos!

The good ship SS Liberal has really become the Ship of Fools. Brimming to capacity, riding low in the occasional shallow waters with jagged, pointy rocks below scraping at keel only to emerge from the shallows to charge forth through the deep, stormy waters taking on water... This bilge pumps working overtime...

This is no good ship and we have been along for a dangerous ride to arrive at a point where nothing means nothing... One hopeful point to consider is that in the days of actual Ship of Fools many of the fools simply returned from where they were transported and in this sense the nonsense was restored senses...

Up 1 Down 3

Pebbles on Dec 22, 2019 at 11:39 am

Dear Mr. Groucho, sorry, you too know not of what you speak.

Up 13 Down 3

Groucho d'North on Dec 19, 2019 at 12:34 pm

For the past couple of decades there has been a fair amount of discussion on the value of Traditional Knowledge. Not the value for the benefits it can provide to planning, but rather what is its value in monetary terms? These so called partnerships among project participants will often see one of the partners paying for survey work or drilling or some other requirement for the project. Other participants will pay for other components such as roadwork or clearing, licensing or other costs related to the project development.
First Nations do not have the deep pockets other project proponents may have so Traditional Knowledge is being considered as a resource they may contribute to advance the project. But being an oral history with little to no documentation- what is Traditional Knowledge worth at the boardroom table? Surveys and other data are frequently stamped by engineers to confirm accuracy in case something goes wrong and blames need to be laid on the faulty element or who produced it. When one of these failures end up in court, responsibility and ownership of the problem mean everything, and that too comes with a price.

Up 9 Down 6

Yukoner on Dec 19, 2019 at 10:44 am

I will not complain because for the first time in my 40 + year of voting eligibility, I chose not to. Silver is not a politician, in fact the Territory has very few of them.
Think of it this way...TRUMP is NOT a politician either.

Up 4 Down 22

Pebbles on Dec 18, 2019 at 2:30 pm

Sorry jc you know not of what you speak.

Up 25 Down 6

b on Dec 18, 2019 at 1:14 pm

Very dissapointed in our present premier. Remember the SS when he was the lone lib opposition?Had the answer for everything. Give me the last time you have heard this leader say anything that acutually means something or makes a difference. Takes his marching orders from PJ and hides behind PF who was given all the tough portfolios. If this is what we are going to get for leaders in Yukon then God help us. Pathetic.

Up 31 Down 8

jc on Dec 17, 2019 at 9:09 pm

"Traditional knowledge" is not exactly "Historical knowledge". Traditional knowledge changes throughout generations. Can't really be trusted. In fact, it can be anything anybody wants it to be to serve their particular purpose.

Up 40 Down 8

BnR on Dec 17, 2019 at 7:52 am

“Silver said his government plans for a future in which traditional knowledge is as important to decision-making as scientific knowledge.”

While TK can be helpful, it should never, ever take precedence over science-based information.
Guess we know for sure who’s driving the Libs agenda....

Up 26 Down 9

Max Mack on Dec 16, 2019 at 10:21 pm

"Traditional knowledge". What does that even mean? And on par with scientific knowledge? Really? Well, given the state of "science" these days, why not? Sounds about right, actually.

Up 39 Down 5

Groucho d'North on Dec 16, 2019 at 4:25 pm

An issue that has dominated local media over the past six months has been dealing with the 'problem individuals' staying at or hanging around the former Salvation Army Centre. How did that not get on the agenda for all to consider?
I read new-age words like "decolonizing" and wondered to what purpose does this topic get nominated for discussion, when larger problems impacting elders, and individual health and safety for the addicted and impacts to local businesses and residents are not discussed? Another F on the report card Sandy.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.