Whitehorse Daily Star

Yukon Energy clarifies financial contribution

Yukoners will contribute $22 million of the $40 million estimate to extend the Whitehorse-Aishihik-Faro grid from Pelly Crossing to Stewart Crossing, says the president of Yukon Energy.

By Chuck Tobin on December 17, 2009

Yukoners will contribute $22 million of the $40 million estimate to extend the Whitehorse-Aishihik-Faro grid from Pelly Crossing to Stewart Crossing, says the president of Yukon Energy.

David Morrison said the contribution will come from the Yukon government, and the Yukon Development Corporation.

Yukoners will also contribute $29.4 million to the $120 million Mayo B hydro expansion, he explained.

A budget document attached to the contribution agreement between Yukon Energy and Ottawa for the extension of the Whitehorse-Aishihik-Faro grid and Mayo B was delivered to members of the legislative assembly Tuesday.

The document, however, was silent on some substantial figures, as it only addressed the costs that would be eligible under the contribution agreement, such as the cost of construction, new equipment required and so forth.

There are other costs which are not eligible under the agreement, such as any costs incurred prior to the agreement being signed last May, like costs of feasibility studies or project preparations.

In the case of Mayo B, the budget delivered to the legislature shows that from the $120 estimate from the entire project, $106.7 million is eligible under the joint-contribution agreement, leaving $13.3 million unaccounted for in the document.

For the Mayo B project, the contribution agreement states:

• Ottawa will contribute up to $53.35 million of the $106.7 million from its Green Infrastructure Fund;

• Yukon Energy and the First Nation of Nacho Nyak Dun will contribute $36.7 million. (How much each of the two parties will put up is still under negotiation, Morrison explained.)

• Yukon government will contribute $16.65 million.

Morrison explained the remaining $13.3 million not covered by the agreement will be picked up by the Yukon government and the Yukon Development Corporation, which he said is essentially one in the same.

Altogether, according to the figures, Yukoners – not ratepayers – will contribute $30 million to Mayo B.

In the case of the Pelly-to-Stewart transmission line extension, the budget delivered to the legislature shows that of the $40 million project estimate, $35.3 million is eligible under the contribution agreement, leaving $4.7 million unaccounted for in the document.

A contribution of $12 million is itemized in the document, though the identity of the contributing party is blacked out.

For the Pelly-Stewart extension, the contribution agreement states:

• Ottawa will contribute up to $17.65 million of the $35.3 million;

• The Yukon government will contribute $5.35 million;

• Yukon Energy will contribute $300,000;

• The unidentified party will contribute $12 million.

Morrison said the Yukon government and the Yukon Development Corporation will cover the $4.5 million not covered by the contribution agreement.

The president of Yukon Energy said the party left unidentified for the $12 million contribution is the Yukon government and the Yukon Development Corporation.

Addition of all the figures shows Yukoners will be contributing $22 million to the extension of the transmission line.

The unidentified contributor of the $12 million was the subject of a terse exchange Wednesday between Premier Dennis Fentie and Liberal Leader Arthur Mitchell, who pressed Fentie to reveal the identity of the contributor.

"Who is that generous secret investor willing to subsidize the government's energy project to the tune of $12 million?” Mitchell asked during question period.

In his reply, the premier did not provide the identity of the contributor, but reminded Mitchell how Yukon Energy negotiated a contribution from the Minto Mine toward the extension of the transmission line from Carmacks to Pelly Crossing.

"This is similar to what the energy corporation will be working on into the future as far as building Yukon's publicly owned, through its public utility, overall infrastructure and assets,” Fentie replied to Mitchell's second attempt to get an answer.

When asked by the Star this morning who was putting up the $12 million, Morrison simply replied the Yukon government and the Yukon Development Corporation.

Morrison was not asked who blacked out the identity of the contributor, or why, and he was unavailable later this morning, as he was on an airplane south.

Cabinet spokeswoman Emily Younker said this morning she did not know who blacked out the identity of the contributor, but was certain it was not the premier or any of the political staff.

Fentie and his Yukon Party have come under fire of late from the Liberals accusing them of making a huge miscalculation with the original project estimate of $32 million for the entire Carmacks-to-Stewart extension of the main grid.

With the cost of the Carmacks-Pelly section completed a year ago for $29.5 million, and with the $40-million estimate for phase two, the budget has climbed to $70 million from $32 million, Liberal energy critic Gary McRobb reminded the legislature recently.

He suggested Fentie and his colleagues have feasted on the report by the auditor general of Canada indicating the Mayo-Dawson transmission line, which came in significantly over budget and behind schedule, was grossly mismanaged under the former Liberal government.

But now that the shoe is on the other foot, McRobb told the house, Fentie wants nothing to do with it.

In his defence, Fentie pointed out all projects in excess of $3 million, including the phase two line extension, have gone before the Yukon Utilities Board for review.

And both Fentie and Morrison have emphasized when the grid extension was originally envisioned in 2005, cost estimates for both the first and second phases were based on very preliminary numbers.

Morrison reiterated the same this morning, and he also emphasized that just because Yukon Energy is spending money, doesn't mean rates are going up.

The new assets will go into the rate base, but Yukon Energy believes the $40-million phase two extension will be rate neutral, he said.

"Ratepayers, in my estimate, are getting a great deal because these assets are going to be around for a very long time, and they are getting that benefit for a very low cost.”

Morrison also pointed out when the cost of the entire transmission line went before the utilities board a couple of years ago, the cost of phase two alone was estimated at $33 million to $35 million. The jump to $40 million today, he said, is due in part to increasing costs for new substations.

Work has already started on the phase two of the line extension to Stewart Crossing and the completion date is scheduled for the spring of 2011.

Peter Kiewet, a large international company, has already been selected to build the Mayo B project. Morrison said he expects they will be signing off on the actual construction contract in the next week or so. Construction is expected to begin this spring, with completion slated for 2012.

Mayo B will bring an additional 10 to 12 megawatts to the system, on top of the five the Mayo Dam produces now.

Morrison said he cannot break down the joint contribution of $36.5 million to the Mayo B by Yukon Energy and the First Nation of Nacho Nyak Dun simply because the deal is not done.

At this point, he said, all that's firm is that there will be a $36.5 million contribution coming from Yukon Energy and the first nation.

"How much they want to invest is still a question,” he said.

Morrison said whatever portion the first nation doesn't buy into will come from Yukon Energy and will be a cost added to the rate base.

When phase one of the grid extension to Pelly Crossing occurred, it was built largely so that a spur line into the Minto Mine could be built and the mine put on the much cheaper hydro power. Yukon Energy insisted because the extension was being built primarily to service the mine, it would not only have to pay 100 per cent of the cost for the spur line, but that it would also be required to contribute $7.2 million to the main line extension.

Yukon Energy has stated emphatically that if another industrial user like the Carmacks Copper mine ever wants to hook into the grid, it would have to contribute to phase two of the transmission line extension, under the same principle the Minto Mine was required to.

There has been no announcement of any deal to date.

Comments (11)

Up 0 Down 0

Robert Kuipers on Dec 24, 2009 at 3:10 am

I fully agree with Max - each and everyone of us is entitled to his or her opinion. But look at Francias' first and second one: is that an opinion? Interesting. More is expected here. And then apparently feeling ganged up on ..... well, if you can't stand the heat ..... Points that Max makes are well taken - substantiated and worth a thought, and so are Janet's. I prefer to continue to discuss along that line. Francias, could you please add your disagreement?

Up 0 Down 0

Kailey Irwin on Dec 24, 2009 at 12:13 am

francias,

For the record I think your comments are quite commical and I really do enjoy them.

PLay nice everyone, haha.

Up 0 Down 0

Arn Anderson on Dec 23, 2009 at 2:59 pm

Someones wallet is getting fatter as we speak!

Up 0 Down 0

francias pillman on Dec 23, 2009 at 9:18 am

Ohhh, ganging up on me. Aww the wittle babies need a group to make themselves feel justified. I guess people like you enjoy paying for a service that seems can't be kept on. I'm sorry for not supporting incompetence, I'm so very sorry.

Up 0 Down 0

Kailey Irwin on Dec 23, 2009 at 6:46 am

I think it's great that they will be extending the powergrid; however, I hope in turn they will be able to supply constant power to the additional areas. I mean with the amount of power outages we have in Whitehorse alone, I hope they aren't biting off more than they can chew. Although if it will lower the cost of power I am all for it, the electrical bill is really hard on the wallet these days!

Hopefully we don't get a flock of birds flying low, it could cause a near Yukon wide power outage!

Up 0 Down 0

Max on Dec 23, 2009 at 3:56 am

Robert -- Francis Pillman has as much right as anyone else, including representatives of Yukon Energy Corp and yourself, to voice her opinions.

Janet's blatant attempt to shame Francis into silence by stating "We notice that the comments you make online are often based on false assumptions or misinformation" does nothing to instill confidence in either Janet or Yukon Energy Corp. Play fair, Janet.

Janet falsely argues, in my opinion, that Stage 1 of the Carmacks-Steward line and the "new industrial customer" has resulted in a rate decrease. Janet also goes on to suggest that Stage 2 will somehow "save money". Let's not forget that Janet is a Yukon Energy insider and it's her job to quote the company line.

These projects have a very high capital cost for a very small user base -- I doubt very much that these projects are cost-effective and I expect they will lose money for years to come. Those losses will be passed onto Yukon Energy customers.

Up 0 Down 0

Wil Borgman on Dec 22, 2009 at 1:18 pm

And where does YTG's $$$$million come from?

Us, the taxpayers!

Up 0 Down 0

Robert Kuipers on Dec 22, 2009 at 2:38 am

Way to go Janet, it is so easy to shout THIEVES without any further useful input or observations. Francias should either quit being an unconstructive contributor to the Comments section, or clean up her act - expiry date reached.

Up 0 Down 0

francias pillman on Dec 21, 2009 at 10:49 am

Ok, if that's the case ill expect to not see our bills increase. We will see. But my point of saying, THIEVES, still stands, because we are still paying for faro, unfortunately that is a fact.

Up 0 Down 0

Janet Patterson on Dec 21, 2009 at 3:05 am

To Francias Pillman: it's because we built Stage 1 of the Carmacks-Stewart line and secured a new industrial customer that we were able to ask our regulator for a rate decrease. The line has meant your power bill has gone down 2.47 percent. By completing Stage 2 of the line, we will have more flexibility in terms of the hydro we have available to us. Ultimately it will mean we'll need to burn less diesel than we would without the line, which will save you money and will be beneficial to the environment. We notice that the comments you make online are often based on false assumptions or misinformation. We would be happy to talk to you should you be interested in knowing the facts. Thanks.

Up 0 Down 0

francias pillman on Dec 18, 2009 at 7:55 am

Yup, and we get increased bills yet again. Why is our duty to pay for your upgrades? THIEVES.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.