Photo by Whitehorse Star
John Streicker
Photo by Whitehorse Star
John Streicker
The Yukon government has reached a settlement agreement with Corix Water Systems regarding the Dawson City wastewater treatment facility.
The Yukon government has reached a settlement agreement with Corix Water Systems regarding the Dawson City wastewater treatment facility.
The government filed the $39.5-million lawsuit in 2017 – alleging that Corix’s plant didn’t work.
Two years later, a joint statement released Friday afternoon stated the two parties have agreed not to pursue any further legal action.
A non-disclosure agreement bars either party from revealing how much money has changed hands in the settlement.
The release states that the “contractual relationship between Corix Water Systems and the Government of Yukon is now over.
“Neither the Government of Yukon nor Corix will pay the other any amount of money in addition to what has been paid to date.”
It adds that both parties are “satisfied” with the settlement.
John Streicker, the minister of Community Services, told the Star early this afternoon that non-disclosure agreements are “typical” of commercial settlements.
Streicker said his government is working with Dawson City to replace the wastewater facility with a better solution. In January, Dawson City’s council voted unanimously to go forward on a sewage lagoon.
Streicker said his government has known from the start that the wastewater facility would need replacement.
“We know that the plant was expensive to build, we know that it is taking nearly a million dollars a year to operate,” Streicker said.
“We know all of that makes it not a long-term solution at all.”
Streicker said he has been working with Dawson City for more than a year to solve the problem.
Sewage lagoons are used across communities in the Yukon, Streicker noted. The annual cost of operations ranges according to the lagoon’s location, but is usually less than $100,000.
Streicker wasn’t able to estimate the building cost of the lagoon in Dawson, but guessed it will be “a lot less than the $30 million” spent on building the wastewater facility.
Dawson currently contributes $210,000 to the operations of the wastewater facility, which will continue operating for several years, until the lagoon replaces it.
“If we get to a sewage lagoon, it’s going to be less expensive for them too,” Streicker said.
Streicker said the government typically seeks federal funding on such infrastructure projects, and his department will work with the City of Dawson to get the project done.
Mayor Wayne Potoroka could not be reached for comment.
The opposition parties have expressed the desire for more transparency on the issue, particularly regarding the end result of the two-year legal dispute with Corix.
Kate White, the leader of the NDP, said today Yukoners have a right to know the outcome of the settlement.
“I think hiding behind a non-disclosure agreement is the easy answer right now,” White told the Star.
White added that Yukoners have a right to know how much money the government has sunk into the failed facility, and the potential cost of reversing the mistake.
She noted that the current ruling government inherited the treatment facility from the previous Yukon Party government, which “doubled down” on the facility working during its reign.
“One could say the chapter has been closed on something that never worked and has never been proven to work,” White said.
She suggested the decision to move forward on a solution outside the wastewater facility could have come sooner in the three-plus years the Liberal government has been in power.
“It should have come much quicker; it’s essentially a money pit,” she said.
Madison Pearson, a Yukon Party spokesperson, said today it’s hoping for more information about the Corix settlement.
“We would like to hear more concrete details from the minister on this secretive agreement,” Pearson wrote in an emailed statement.
“Yukoners should be informed about the amount the Liberal government received as part of the secret settlement.
“Further, we look forward to hearing the government’s explanation on their rationale behind the settlement.”
The $34.3-million wastewater facility has been an ongoing issue since it became operational in 2012, consistently failing to meet the terms of its water licence.
The facility saw a number of cost escalations that year, leading to the City of Dawson’s refusing to accept ownership of the facility after its trial run period.
The government took over operations of the plant from Corix in 2015, making a “last-ditch effort” to make the plant compliant two years ago.
Last year, the Star reported that the cost of maintaining the plant had ballooned to $950,000 annually.
Streicker described the costs as “significantly higher than in any other Yukon community” at the time.
Streicker said these costs were expected to rise as the plant aged and additional maintenance was required.
The operating failures of the plant from the get-go spurred the government to file the lawsuit against Corix.
The government was seeking $27 million to cover construction costs, and $12.5 million for a bond Corix filed with its insurer.
A request for comment from Corix Water Systems was not returned.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (15)
Up 14 Down 2
Sylvia Burkhard on Mar 6, 2020 at 10:04 am
This story goes back a fair ways, I think the blame goes back to Mayor Everitt who pleaded guilty (on his own) when DFO showed up at City Offices to charge Dawson with polluting the Yukon River. We did have a primary sewage treatment plant unlike the days when our sewage went straight into the river in three outlets. Since we have bleeders the discharge into the river was pretty diluted in the winter. There were plans to build a new or secondary treatment plant when Dawson was charged. I recall COD getting $4.5 million from the Liberal Duncan government to study and begin work on a plant. If anyone recalls we had a mayor who liked to spend government money like it was his and this was used for anything but a new treatment plant.
Not long after Dawson was charged the City was put into care by YTG ($800 a day trustees etc, more money wasted). I can't really remember but Dawson may have already had a deadline to get a new treatment plant so this was of course delayed by the lack of Mayor and Council, we also had a 18 month forensic audit done on the city, it's quite a fascinating read. When order was restored to the land back to the drawing board for the plant. A site was selected just past the Dome Road turn off for an aerated lagoon at a cost of around $1 million if memory serves. For some reason folks thought this was not a good idea, there were concerns of smell and that somehow sewage would seep into the Klondike river. The City held a referendum which resulted in a no lagoon vote and it was taken off the table. However I do seem to recall TH offering a site in the old Lousetown site across the Klondike for a lagoon. I blame a lot of the ridiculous fuster clucks in new infrastructure projects on the "design build" concept that is the new norm. Instead of having engineers who study the site, know what is needed, draw up plans, submit them to the government, the best one is picked and tenders submitted to build what the plans describe. Instead we have project being pitched by companies like they are selling a product. Enter Corix with their deep shaft treatment plant, as Wilf Carter says he took a look at Corix projects and the only one working is in Homer, Alaska. For Pete's sake, we had a town in Manitoba write the local papers and say "don't do it, it doesn't work" COD went to Alaska and looked at the Homer plant, it was costing them way more than quoted to run it. At the same time they looked at a very cost effective aerated sewage lagoon working just outside of Fairbanks.
So instead of having a working sewage lagoon in a year for a couple million tops we got a $40 million turkey that has never worked. Also like to mention that the sewage gets pumped down 300 feet I think, its a lot (pretty cold down there, microbes are supposed to break the sewage) into a storage tank that I may have heard has had structural issues, all less than about 600 feet from our water wells on front street. The plant has repeatedly failed the water tests, at one point just to get it to work Corix was using a huge amount of chemicals which of course is not allowed. There has been millions spent trying to make this turkey work, we have had sewage flowing down 5th Ave, sewage is constantly being pumped out and taken to a lagoon (how ironic). Let's not forget the biomass boiler that was built for the treatment plant and was supposed to heat other buildings as well, also a bit of a lemon, think that cost over $5 million. There were other options submitted for the treatment plant, one seemed very viable and was a Yukon firm and for some reason just not considered and yes, the highly paid YTG engineer that pushed for this plant is probably still in government with an even more lucrative job. Absolutely no consequences for squandering tax payers dollars, responsibility lies entirely on YTG and yet we are told that unfortunately the WWT plant didn't work as it was planned, immmm, yes it did and you knew it, but carried on. Dawson has had at least a hundred million spent on projects that have to be replaced, a condemned Arena (which we didn't need anyway, my opinion, we just had a new one in 1981) a stupidly small pool which spends a lot of time closed, gets less use than the old outdoor one, and the WWT plant. Oh and now the new water treatment plant is coming on board and apparently has way too much water pressure so now the streets will have to be dug up and new water lines fixed, I hope I'm not the only one not surprised at this news. If we don't start getting vocal and hold the government responsible for their projects it will become totally unsustainable, actually it already is.
What amazes me, sadly, is how quickly the folks in charge conveniently forget the facts, we know which government was in charge when these projects were done, rather hypocritical to be holding the present government (who may also have the same track record of failed promises) for their past incompetence. I don't take the governments word for anything but it is becoming more and more difficult to find facts these days and it does not bode well for us peons. There was a time when the elected folks listened to the tax payers who put them there, not anymore, it's sad and very scary. Stay tuned for more scuttlebutt on the new water treatment plant, I saw an expression of interest (another stupid way of doing business, my opinion entirely) for water metering for Dawson, heaven help us if that happens!
Up 13 Down 1
stephen on Mar 5, 2020 at 1:08 pm
Ok this is funny. First people are talking about the public get back no funds or 10 cents on the dollar. Where in the article does it say this?
Second I agree if this went to market or it was direct awarded there should have been due diligence by asking for references on locations this system is being used in a similar environment. There should have been a check before any agreement this size went into play. Should some people be fired for this? Absolutely. To say there is no fault here means someone can't say listen the YP screwed up badly and another government is having to fix their problem. It is the government's job and at that time the YP job to say I want reference checks on this system before we move ahead. As one person said here, all 10 failed so the reference checks would have found this detail out.
People have to be ok with saying hey YP screwed up badly and the DM’s and Bureaucrats should be fired for this. Where the hell was supply chain in this as they should have caught this if they were doing their job?
Up 26 Down 8
Irony on Mar 3, 2020 at 10:12 pm
So the Yukon Party is demanding to know the details of how the current government fixed their huge screw up? Oh the irony here is just too much, lol. If the YP had any political sense they would just say 'pass' on this issue and let sleeping dogs lie. To keep bringing it up is to keep digging up dirt on their own party. Not sure who their political advisors are currently but they are definitely asleep at the wheel!
Up 24 Down 3
Boyd Campbell on Mar 3, 2020 at 5:57 pm
Corix gets its gag order and YG gets what? No money changing hands other than whats been done. People should be fired for this and it's just another day in Youcorn. BTW isn't the engineer that pushed this system to get it built now up in gov somewhere around the ADM level. Pitiful beyond words.
Up 19 Down 4
North_of_60 on Mar 3, 2020 at 5:34 pm
YTG Project Mismanagement strikes again. People should have lost their jobs over this and the Dawson Rec Center fiasco. Of course they settled out-of-court, this government wouldn't want their incompetence exposed and entered into the public record in court documents. It's obvious they have something to hide.
Up 25 Down 6
Groucho d'North on Mar 3, 2020 at 4:22 pm
@BNR
This mess was created because In 2003, the Yukon territorial court ordered a new sewage plant be built after Dawson was charged, under the federal Fisheries Act, with pumping sewage into the Yukon River.
Just like Montreal and Victoria BC were doing to their local water ways, oddly though neither Montreal or Victoria were ordered by any court to fix the problem like Dawson City was. Assume what you like to why that was and why their dumping of sewage into the St. Lawrence and the Straight of Juan de Fuca remains the same today
Up 27 Down 4
My Opinion on Mar 3, 2020 at 2:38 pm
It is the DM’s and Bureaucrats that run the show and lead the ministers. They should be gone. No golden hand shakes either.
Up 9 Down 25
Wilf Carter on Mar 3, 2020 at 10:42 am
The real truth of this project was the people of Dawson and Yukon Government were sold a group of lies on this type of system at the time. It was a great and wonderful new system that will solve your waste water problems but in fact was a dud. I have managed development of waste water systems in Yukon and found out after this was built what had taken place in Dawson. So with an engineering friend we did some digging into this system and the company had built 10 of these and they all failed. None that has been hidden. There is no one at fault here . If the NDP want to blame someone think again. Far as the agreement it was a very costly mistake for all of us to accept but we have to just move on and build for the future and hopefully learn from this.
Up 28 Down 5
Groucho d'North on Mar 3, 2020 at 9:21 am
Considering this failed project was ordered to be built by the Yukon courts, what responsibility does government assume for forcing an expensive and poor decision on the community?
Refresh your memories here: https://www.whitehorsestar.com/News/dawson-sewage-issue-back-before-judge
Up 25 Down 8
My Opinion on Mar 2, 2020 at 7:11 pm
This was Greenwash from the start and the Liberals, NDP and First Nation were against a lagoon. Go figure, it is all about the footprint and money is not an object.
Up 34 Down 5
My Opinion on Mar 2, 2020 at 7:07 pm
This is not as much a political joke as it is a statement as to how out of control our paid (highly paid) employees are making horrible decisions with our money and there are no ramifications. Peter Densmor fought to try and build a lagoon system but the Govy knew better. What a bunch of losers. People should be losing their job. This was a virtue signalling exercise. Gone Bad.
Up 24 Down 10
John Ward on Mar 2, 2020 at 5:48 pm
The information dissemination regarding this settlement is on a need to know basis.
Why was this another failing 'Yukon Party' project? Disgraceful.
Up 34 Down 15
Jack on Mar 2, 2020 at 5:02 pm
Another screw-up by the Yukon Party that was passed on to the Liberals. Now the Yukon Party tries to take the high moral ground about "secret deals" - yah, right: we remember the Yukon Party's golf course deal, etc. A bit rich, even for Yukon politics.
Up 30 Down 4
Miles Epanhauser on Mar 2, 2020 at 4:09 pm
This secret agreement should be public since it may demonstrate that the government settled for something like 10 cents on the dollar meaning we lost 10's of millions on it.
Up 38 Down 7
BnR on Mar 2, 2020 at 3:05 pm
I’d like to know the details of why the YP got taxpayers into this mess in the first place.