Photo by Photo Submitted
SUBDIVISION WILL GAIN A SCHOOL – Shown above is a schematic design rendering of the future school for the Whistle Bend subdivision. Photo courtesy Kobayashi + Zedda Architects
Photo by Photo Submitted
SUBDIVISION WILL GAIN A SCHOOL – Shown above is a schematic design rendering of the future school for the Whistle Bend subdivision. Photo courtesy Kobayashi + Zedda Architects
Work on the first new Whitehorse elementary school in more than two decades is moving forward – but the Yukon Party is questioning the latest cost.
Work on the first new Whitehorse elementary school in more than two decades is moving forward – but the Yukon Party is questioning the latest cost.
The territorial government has awarded a $42.8-million design-build contract to Whitehorse-based Ketza Construction Corp. for the new school in Whistle Bend, to be located at the corner of Olive May Way and Casca Boulevard.
Ketza will work with Colliers Project Leaders, the Owner’s Advisor, for the duration of this project to design a school that reflects the needs and goals of the school community, the government said last Wednesday.
The government has worked with the Whistle Bend Project Advisory Committee throughout the planning process to help inform decisions about the school’s elements.
The school is being planned to accommodate up to 425 students from kindergarten to Grade 7. It is expected to be completed during the 2023-24 school year.
“This is an exciting time for the families in Whistle Bend, who will soon have access to a nearby, high-quality learning environment,” said Education Minister Jeanie McLean.
“This is more than an investment in a new building, this is an investment in our children’s future that will provide benefits for years to come.”
École Émilie-Tremblay was the last elementary school built in Whitehorse. It opened in 1996.
“This is an important milestone for the future Whistle Bend school, which will provide students in the area with a modern learning space closer to their homes,” added Highways and Public Works Minister Nils Clarke.
“It will be a welcome addition to this rapidly-growing neighbourhood.”
Ketza has been established in the Yukon for more than 50 years and specializes in northern climate construction.
“As a Yukon company with strong community involvement, Ketza Construction is proud to have been selected to deliver the new Whistle Bend Elementary School,” said Eric Brohman, Ketza’s general manager.
“Our commitment to Yukon First Nations and local content will be beneficial to all Yukoners. Ketza’s Design-Build team is excited to draw upon our strong educational experience to deliver a thoughtful design, executed with decades of construction experience.”
The Yukon Party, meanwhile, said the school is $6.3 million over-budget.
On March 8, Richard Mostyn, then the minister of Highways and Public Works, stated that the Liberals had only budgeted $36.5 million for the project, the Yukon Party said last week.
According to the government’s website, the bid selected was the highest of four bids and was $6 million higher than the lowest price submitted, the official Opposition party pointed out.
“Department of Education officials confirmed earlier this year that there have been project delays due to additional time needed for design work and review processes,” the Yukon Party said.
“This means another capital project managed by the Yukon Liberal government is coming in late and over-budget.”
Responding to this, a cabinet spokeswoman said Friday the school project “continues to move forward.
“This will be the first new Whitehorse elementary school in more than two decades and we have worked closely with the stakeholders to ensure we develop a high-quality learning environment that will meet the needs of the community now and into the future.
“When the tender for this project closed in May, all bids came in over the original estimated cost and additional approvals were needed to award the contract.
“Although higher than projected, the cost of the contract reflects the current high prices for building materials like steel,” she added.
“A value-driven procurement process was used to make sure the project brings as much value as possible to the community and the territory by factoring in considerations like northern experience and First Nations participation.
“The project remains on track for winter of 2023-24,” she said.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (21)
Up 5 Down 0
John on Aug 14, 2021 at 8:05 am
It looks like a prison.
Up 5 Down 3
Charlie's Aunt on Aug 13, 2021 at 2:41 pm
Capacity of 425 doesn't seem adequate at rate WB is growing. It will lower numbers at the schools where WB children now attend so there should be a load of spare portables available for expansion. Oops, guess what could be seen as trailer trash wouldn't be acceptable in WB, only suitable in other parts of town.
Up 5 Down 3
Ice Fog on Aug 12, 2021 at 7:24 pm
@ Groucho d'North
Have you seen ANY commercial building? Like… ever? Almost none have a pitched roof.
A flat roof (they are actually slightly sloped) are cheaper, more durable and last longer than a pitched one.
Up 8 Down 7
Groucho d'North on Aug 12, 2021 at 12:45 pm
So is the flat roof design for those in need of winter employment shovelling off the snow? The Global warming advocates are saying our snow levels are on the increase, so does this design really make sense?
Up 10 Down 7
Ella on Aug 12, 2021 at 8:12 am
Considering YG's track record of keeping projects within budget, I expect this school to be a Billion dollar project.
Up 18 Down 10
Jim on Aug 11, 2021 at 9:03 am
I cannot believe the insanity of this “value driven” awarding of major contracts. The last 2 major building projects have been awarded to the highest bidder. This has cost the taxpayers of Canada around $12 million. All under the guise of local content and First Nation benefits. The points system is always subject to bias and now you throw a race card into it. Is this going to employ more local trades people? Not likely, just try and find a carpenter, plumber or electrician. One can only assume this extra will go into pockets of company owners and selected First Nation individuals.
And no, tender opening and contact awarding is not open to the public. And I for one would be really curious who this neutral 3rd party would be. As far as bringing in a project manager, what happened to the YTG department that used to oversee these projects? Has property management been closed or are they just staying at home getting paid. Maybe YTG should start awarding contracts by “best value for taxpayers“ as they are spending their money.
Up 13 Down 8
Priority One on Aug 11, 2021 at 5:03 am
The pandemic has the ridiculous cost of building materials soaring even higher which the YP supporters seem unaware of. The previous administration had not envisioned the need for schooling anywhere in the Territory as evidentiary evidence shows. Rather they built multi-million dollar hospitals in Dawson and Watson that medivac anything more serious than a nose bleed to Whitehorse anyhow.
Up 15 Down 9
Max Mack on Aug 10, 2021 at 8:53 pm
Between the 1996 Census and the 2016 Census, K-7 age groups have decreased by almost 25% in the Yukon.
And yet, here we are building another K-7 school at a cost that will well exceed the stated $42.8 million by the time all the pre-planning, planning, design work, inflation, cost over-runs, design changes, and related infrastructure costs are added in to the mix. And perhaps an extra 15-30% for FN participation?
Anyone want to bet north of $70 million? Worth it?
Up 13 Down 0
yukon56 on Aug 10, 2021 at 8:18 pm
Also, who produced the estimate, what year, things have changed. I suspect a hired consultant not from here. It is expensive to build.
Up 12 Down 1
yukon56 on Aug 10, 2021 at 8:14 pm
With the current high prices for materials and the advance lead time to procure what do you expect? Easy to submit a bid thinking "I'll make it up on extras and loopholes in the tender documents, specs, clauses etc. etc. The PCL concept learned from Peter Kiewit. Have some faith in a local contractor who employees local talent.
Up 24 Down 10
Davis on Aug 10, 2021 at 1:33 pm
Ahh the Whitehorse Star comments, where everyone is an expert on everything.
@Highest Bidder - in my experience YG's procurement system for large projects like this is not "shady" at all. How the tender scores will be calculated is all laid out in the tender documents for everyone to see, and the public can even go watch the proposals being opened. YG even gets a neutral 3rd party "fairness monitor" to oversee the evaluations to ensure it is truly a fair process and at the end of it all anyone who submitted a proposal can request a debriefing to see where they lost points.
@Yep this means another level of management on a project between YTG and the contractor - maybe you should do a little more research on constructions costs as the two schools you're comparing against are not very relevant. This new school is expensive, yes, but have you seen how much construction costs have gone up over the last couple years?!? It's crazy! Not to mention inflation costs since the early 90's as well. Also, Hidden Valley and Holy Family schools are about 1/3 the size of this new school.
Up 9 Down 14
Dale Scaber on Aug 10, 2021 at 12:41 pm
My Childs New K to 9 school for 750 students built in Edmonton back in 2016 cost on 19 million to complete.
Up 27 Down 14
Yep this means another level of management on a project between YTG andd the contractor on Aug 10, 2021 at 8:16 am
This means exactly what it sounds like. A Cover Your Ass layer inserted into another expensive process. There is another layer of management involved which will shield the bureaucrats when this project goes hugely sideways. The estimated costs of this project are a whole lot higher than the Hidden Valley Elementary school and the Holy Family Elementary built in the early 90's.
Both those schools used the same design concepts and cost less than $5 million each. These figures are all available, in Legislative records, if someone wants to do the research.
Up 23 Down 6
Windy Arm on Aug 10, 2021 at 12:50 am
John.
Colliers Project Leaders is a project management firm. They will advise the owners (Property Management) over the course of the project to commissioning and beyond. This is how any private/public project happens.
Schools don’t build themselves.
Up 38 Down 19
Highest Bidder on Aug 9, 2021 at 11:17 pm
Congratulations to the highest bidder for winning this contract. I'm sure the $250,000 donation to Yukon U and donations to the Liberal Campaign had nothing to do with the extra points you got on the value-driven portion of this contract.
Procurement in the Territory has always been shady...but under this government they don't try to hide it. They just assume the voters can't add.
Up 23 Down 8
JustSayin' on Aug 9, 2021 at 10:29 pm
YP - this is why it is over budget. -- “A value-driven procurement process was used to make sure the project brings as much value as possible to the community and the territory by factoring in considerations like northern experience and First Nations participation.. .
Up 22 Down 17
Himbo on Aug 9, 2021 at 10:22 pm
Wow the government sucks, should have offered the contract out of territory and could have gotten it for likely half the cost. Who do you think is paying for all this? Time to move soon. I can’t support the Yukon regime anymore.
Up 26 Down 7
Yep on Aug 9, 2021 at 8:03 pm
Another building to look like a space station. Just wonderful.
Up 27 Down 1
Yt on Aug 9, 2021 at 5:14 pm
It's funny reading comments from from people like John who have no idea of how project management works.
Also, I'd love to read a news article on the new $25,000,000.00 + gymnastics club facility that taxpayers will be paying for, also being built in Whistle Bend.
Keep the money coming Ottawa, the special interest groups of The Yukon need more stuff.
Up 36 Down 10
My Opinion on Aug 9, 2021 at 5:11 pm
Where do these Government estimates come from? Do they just pull them out of their A$$? YTG has tons of people to do these estimates, they know how much costs of materials have gone up. If they don't then they shouldn't be working there. I notice the contractors are all expected to figure out the costs. Government is a JOKE, working from home, or the campground.
Up 66 Down 12
John on Aug 9, 2021 at 3:29 pm
What does "Colliers Project Leaders, the Owner’s Advisor" mean ?? contracted out government work? buddies?