Photo by Whitehorse Star
Pat Living and Diane McLeod-McKay
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Pat Living and Diane McLeod-McKay
The families of about 340 students at Christ the King Elementary School have been left wondering what hands their children’s personal information is in.
The families of about 340 students at Christ the King Elementary School have been left wondering what hands their children’s personal information is in.
They were recently informed dental records for the school have gone missing.
Last week – at least a month after officials realized the information was missing – families received letters from the Department of Health and Social Services explaining the dental health community log book from the school “has been lost or misplaced.”
The log book includes each child’s name, date of birth and student identification number.
It also outlines dental treatment plans and progress notes that could contain a student’s name and dental charts that might have been transferred from another school.
Department spokeswoman Pat Living today described the log book as a four-inch binder containing the information which is limited to the student’s name, number and dental information.
Living said it became clear the book was missing at the end of the past school year.
Letters weren’t sent out until July 28, she explained, because the department was conducting a major search, and officials believed it would be found.
A search of school dental clinics, the main dental health office and all government vehicles used by dental hygienists has been done.
While the hunt continues, Living said, when the book was not found in any of those places by just before the end of July, it was time to inform families of the situation.
“We’ve really done our due diligence,” she said, stressing the department takes the protection of privacy seriously and is reviewing its policies around it.
She noted the log books don’t contain information that would likely be used for identity theft.
This is the first time anything like this has happened, Living noted.
The territory has been running the children’s dental program since the 1990s, when it took it over from Health Canada.
Under the program, dental services are provided to children throughout the territory, delivered through the schools.
In Whitehorse, the program is in place until students enter high school, while in the communities, it remains in place until the end of Grade 12.
When dental hygienists work at a school, they may be working there for a couple of weeks or longer.
They sign out that school’s log book from the children’s dental program, located in the Whitehorse Health Centre building on Quartz Road, and have it for the time they are working at the school.
They are then required to sign it back in again.
It’s possible, she acknowledged, that someone who came across the book may have thought it belongs to the Department of Education and returned it to an Education building, but nothing has come up so far.
The letter to families, signed by Paddy Meade, Health and Social Services’ deputy minister, apologizes for the situation, noting: “We are keenly aware of how important your child’s personal information is.
“My department is committed to providing quality services, including protecting your child’s personal information. I want to assure you that we are reviewing our current procedures and implementing changes to ensure that this type of incident does not occur in the future.”
It goes on to note the situation has been reported to Diane McLeod-McKay, the territory’s information and privacy commissioner.
In an interview this morning, McLeod-McKay said she has been made aware of the situation, but could not go into detail on it due to confidentiality requirements.
She explained that while there’s no mandatory requirement to report breaches, she can make recommendations to prevent similar instances happening in the future.
In this case, Living said the incident has been reported to the privacy commissioner, but no recommendations have yet been made.
The department’s review will look at what will and won’t work to keep the records secure while ensuring dental hygienists can properly do their work in the schools.
The loss of the book has not been reported to RCMP.
“We do not believe it’s a theft,” Living said.
The department is still looking for the book which could be in a school or building that has not yet been searched.
One parent of a student at the school, who asked that his children not be identified, said this morning when his wife opened the government’s letter, they were shocked to learn their son’s information could be accessed by anyone out there who might come across the book.
It shows there hasn’t been enough security or safety measures in place to protect his son’s information, the father said.
He also wondered whether the search had extended to include personnel who would have access to the elementary school, but not be associated with the dental program – property management staff, janitors and the like.
And there’s a question about why the information isn’t available to hygienists in digital form.
“You’d think everything would be digitally encrypted,” he said.
Living said she could not answer why the department doesn’t have a digital system for the school dental files, noting it may be something considered in the future.
For now though, officials will continue their search for the four-inch binder containing the dental information while also reviewing their policies around the protection of private information.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (5)
Up 18 Down 19
BnR on Aug 10, 2014 at 10:16 am
This is outrageous! What if this information fell into the hands of Al Qaeda?
Up 13 Down 13
Molar on Aug 9, 2014 at 11:57 pm
Front page news? This article is a storm in a tea cup & full of misinfo. Firstly it is Dental Therapists that work in schools, not Dental Hygeinists. As a former DT I feel confident that childrens' actual dental records are not included in the missing binder because a school's worth simply wouldn't fit.
Things have changed in recent years, but all that used to be in the school dental binders, listed by grade, was child's name, priority of treatment & date of completion. The biggest problem is going to be for staff to re do the contents of binder. Obviously the binder has been misplaced because who in their right mind would want to steal it to discover which 7 yr old needed 5 appointments or who had good teeth? Are they going to check children's teeth to steal identity? Big question is why is binder for Whitehorse schools, that have a permanent dental clinic, not left locked in filing cabinet in the school clinic along with dental charts? I guess a system that worked for Health Canada had to be reinvented by YTG.
Up 21 Down 4
Doug Rutherford on Aug 8, 2014 at 9:46 pm
As breaches go, this could have been much worse with the loss of information that would have been valuable for identity theft, e.g., social insurance numbers, banking or finance records, criminal records, etc.
What is more appalling is the comment by the Information and Privacy Commissioner that there is no mandatory requirement to report privacy breaches. Identity theft is one of the few types of crime that is not declining in Canada and if there is no requirement for the Government to report the loss of information, you may have no protection at all against this. It is time for the Yukon Government to match the laws of other jurisdictions and enforce mandatory reporting of information loss or theft. This is the minimum standard we should accept, and if the government is unwilling to do so, it is time we got another.
Up 24 Down 8
Miss Helen on Aug 8, 2014 at 9:10 pm
@June Jackson, it may not be the "biggest news event ever to hit Whitehorse" but it is most certainly newsworthy and should not be brushed off. I'm a mother of children who attend Christ The King and I find it disturbing that my children's information could be in the wrong hands, presumably with my own personal information as I have to sign the consent forms. Identity theft is certainly a possibility here. How on Earth does Pat Living know whether or not this was a theft, and if the information could be used for identity theft?! Is she an expert on the topic?
Up 8 Down 29
June Jackson on Aug 8, 2014 at 4:10 pm
Well...I don't know that this is the biggest event to ever hit Whitehorse..however..it does serve to illustrate how lax the Department is in protecting its information in general.
On the other hand.. everyone with a record is at risk in this digital age. I can't see anyone searching for a 6 year old with good teeth, but I can see someone searching for "who has AIDS" in Yukon. Now there is a privacy disaster waiting to happen.