Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Justine Davidson

Top: PROTEST CAMP – Two Whitehorse women, Helen Hollywood (seen here) and her friend, Linda, camped out on the lawn of the Yukon legislature last night to protest the lack of affordable housing in the city. Both women have been without a reliable home for a number of years. Bottom: TALKING 'BOUT A REVOLUTION – Liberal Leader Arthur Mitchell, centre, and NDP MLA Steve Cardiff, right, join Helen Hollywood for a coffee at her camp on the YTG building lawn this morning. MLAs from the Liberals and NDP visited throughout the day to talk about the housing crisis.

Women camp out in protest on lawn at legislature

"Rich and poor, they're scamming everyone.”

By Justine Davidson on June 9, 2011

"Rich and poor, they're scamming everyone.”

That is Helen Hollywood's explanation of why Yukon Party MLAs arrived at work this morning to find a dozen pieces of heavy machinery parked in front of the legislature and a tent city springing up on the lawn behind.

"When I heard about these guys protesting, I figured they could give us some back-up,” Helen said this morning, pointing to the huge trucks parked about 100 metres away from her tent. "Now they've got it coming from all sides.”

Helen was one of the people recently involved in a discussion at the Salvation Army about starting a tent city to both protest the lack of housing in Whitehorse, and also to simply establish a place to live.

She said when she heard the news about Norcope Construction protesting what they called a "behind closed doors contract” yesterday, she found a tent and came down to stage her own peaceful protest.

Helen and her friend Linda, who camped out at the legislature last night, have both been through the wringer of Whitehorse housing.

Helen's last place was a $1,000-a-month basement suite in Granger with no heat.

"It got pretty cold down there when it rained last week,” the 57-year-old said, noting she suffers from both osteoporosis and asthma, and is recovering from a bout of pneumonia. "We might as well have been sleeping rough. It's nicer camping outside than inside, so here I am.”

Linda, 61, has been staying at the Robert Service Campground, where she has lived the last two summers, spending her winters in hotels and temporary apartments.

"The last apartment I had, when I met the guy who was renting it, he told me, ‘I run half the rentals in Whitehorse, so if you mess up with me, you're done,'” she said this morning, pouring herself a cup of cowboy coffee off a small propane burner. "I let a friend stay over 'cause he had nowhere to go and they kicked me out.”

Helen has been in the Yukon for more than a decade and Linda came here from Atlin in 2010; both women have struggled to find stable, affordable housing.

They are not alone.

According to Kate Mechan, an anti-poverty advocate whose current job is focussed on helping the "hard to house” get a permanent roof over their heads, the housing situation is so bad that the Department of Health and Social Services is suggesting people get a tent.

"Social assistance is referring people to campgrounds,” she said today. "That shows how dire things are if government is looking at camping as the only option for people.”

The government "has dropped the ball,” she said.

"We've lost another building season, and the people who have the means to make all the decisions haven't stepped up to the plate yet.”

Mechan said she knows at least 60 people "who are rotating in and out of the shelter, camping – not at Robert Service – or who are very, very precariously housed, and that's just a list off the top of my head.”

Many people have been kicked out of the city's hotels and motels to make room for tourists, she said. Keeping a handle on who is going to lose their place next, or where people might be able to go is difficult, Mechan added.

"Calling around to the hotels, depending on the day or who you talk to, you get different answers about whether they are providing monthly rentals or accepting people on social assistance,” she said.

By ignoring the housing crisis, the government is burning up everyone's resources in the non-profit sector, and on the streets.

"I spend the majority of my time helping people find housing,” she said of her job. "It's time-consuming and exhausting. It's the most exhausting for the people actually out there looking for gear and tents and so on, but it's also exhausting for the support workers.”

A spokesperson from the department told the Star today that all requests for comment about the housing situation are being forwarded to Health Minister Glenn Hart, whose silence was noted by many of those who stopped by Helen's and Linda's tent this morning.

"Where is the minister?” Liberal Leader Arthur Mitchell asked, as he and the NDP's Steve Cardiff sat in the camping chairs by Helen's tent. "He knows we're here; he can see us from his office.”

"This government has the money to address the housing crisis,” Cardiff said. "They have $17.6 million in housing money sitting in reserve, so where are they?”

He was referring to federal money earmarked in 2006 for housing but kept in the bank which Yukon Party MLA Jim Kenyon revealed during his recent failed leadership run.

In an interview with the Star last week, outgoing Premier Dennis Fentie said the money would be spent when a viable project was proposed.

It was Cardiff who first called attention to the women's protest yesterday afternoon, and asked security guards at the legislature to make sure they were not bothered during the night.

"It's good to know we have our own security,” Helen joked. "This might be the nicest place I've ever stayed.

"We were a little worried about our safety here last night, but when Steve came and told us that these guys were going to watch out for us, I could actually close my eyes and sleep.

"I won't stay on the river,” she said. "It's not safe for anyone.”

Housing is not just about a roof over one's head, Mechan pointed out.

"They have a right to security and they have a right to express their frustrations in feeling under supported,” she said.

So far, it seems the women will be allowed to remain on the legislature lawn.

"It's about finding the balance between public expression and operational activities,” government spokesperson Doris Wurfbuam said today when asked if the women would be kicked off the property.

"Currently neither protest (Helen's tent and Norcope's trucks) is impeding that and we deem them as peaceful, so we are onsite monitoring. At this point, everyone is behaving.”

Helen said she has no plans to leave anytime soon.

"As long as I have to,” she said when asked how long she plans to stay. "Someone has got to help us find a home, or at least figure out this Landlord and Tenant Act so we can have some stability when we find a place – not get kicked out whenever the landlord wants.”

By press time today, Hart still hadn't responded to interview requests, and no one at the Health and Social Service department could talk about how they plan to deal with the growing number of homeless in Whitehorse.

"For whatever reason, nobody in decision-making positions seems to care,” Mechan said. "That's how it feels. It's a crisis. We need options yesterday, not at the end of August when the summer's over and winter is coming quick.”

"I really just want a home,” Helen said. "And this is the nicest place I've been. Anyone is welcome to join us.”

Comments (15)

Up 0 Down 0

Brice Carruthers on Jun 18, 2011 at 6:33 am

Bobby Bitman that last comment was awesome! It totally drove home the ridiculous argument they are making.

"From each, according to his ability; to each, according to his need”

--- Karl Marx

We need a counter protest for people who value hard work, entrepreneurship, ingenuity, and personal responsibility.

Up 0 Down 0

bobby bitman on Jun 15, 2011 at 10:03 pm

I was away recently and got really good restaurant meals for $15, including salad. I think the Yukon government should put a cap on what restaurants in the Yukon can charge. Plus the government should force them to serve better food too.

Everyone has to eat and it is not fair that I should pay whatever the restaurant chooses to charge, or that I should eat what they are choosing to serve! I can't cook for myself, so somebody has to provide me with this service!

Up 0 Down 0

yukonwoman on Jun 15, 2011 at 2:28 am

Wow i can not believe some of the comments here..Frances you seem to have an opinion on every article. Although I understand freedom of speech, you are so critical of people in general, you must have an awful sad life.

There is a majority of people who have either hit bottom or for various reasons have had to obtain some sort of assistance in their lives, yes there are a few who possibly may abuse the system but if you take just one day and sit in the office of social service and just ask the people going in there if they like getting this discrimination I am sure that 9 out of 10 will say they wish that they could provide for themselves and not have to rely on any of that money. If our government and community would sit down and come to some sort of "cap" on the rental market maybe just maybe both landlords and tenants would be able to do the same.

I personally have begged my landlord to fix things that were not to par when I moved into my place and that was ten years ago and still nothing! I can not afford to go anywhere else and I work two jobs. I don't drink or party nor do I do drugs yet people like you put me and others like me in that category all the time.

I am just sick of it! Start some positive action to help others for a change, you just may see that there are "a lot" of decent people out there!

Up 0 Down 0

Kailey Irwin on Jun 14, 2011 at 9:25 am

I agree that the rental situation in Whitehorse is ridiculous and there needs to be some form of cap on what can be charged depending on the quality of the rental unit. People are paying $1200 a month or more to live in a trash heap, this is not acceptable. Especially when there are many hard working individuals out there looking for a place to rent that's reasonably priced.

As far as social housing goes we do need more of this but at the same time consider the fact that social housing should be available for those who deserve it not those who abuse this privilege.

Housing is a right? The first nations survived centuries in this land in teepee's and did very well for themselves. Housing is worked for and earned.

Up 0 Down 0

Jon Steedman on Jun 14, 2011 at 8:57 am

I work in a gas station. I work hard and put in long honest days, week-in, week-out. I can't pick up my family (two kids) and pitch our tent with those who are protesting because I am working - I don't have the time. I get paid just over $12/hr and appreciate the work. I enjoy my family life. I don't party, I am not homeless and I am not disabled. I have never been kicked out of a rental unit and I have always worked. I don't need charity, I don't need 'the government'.

Please know that there are many people struggling to find adequate housing who aren't camping outside YTG because they are too busy trying to make ends meet. So I ask myself, is signing up to post this message enough or would the commenters above prefer me to join the protest so they can pump their own gas, pour their own coffee, take their own order, stack their own shelves, work their own till. Not everyone in the Yukon is on a tidy annual salary or drunk and homeless. Some of us don't fall into these two catagories and those that don't are very, very frustrated.

Up 0 Down 0

Francias Pillman on Jun 14, 2011 at 3:51 am

I never said there is not a handful of people who are truly disabled and welfare is all they have. What I'm talking about is the other 95% of people who collect welfare when they should not be getting a dime in the first place. These able bodied welfare warriors are the ones I'm talking about. They deserve nothing but a shot glass of reality. They better be careful as this stuff is 100%, and we wouldn't want them to O.D.

Up 0 Down 0

bobby bitman on Jun 12, 2011 at 5:07 pm

Roger, how do you suggest that we achieve more competition in the residential rental market in Whitehorse? If it is such a great deal to be a private landlord, why are people not entering the market to provide rental housing?

Why don´t you for instance, invest in a property, get a mortgage, and rent out a unit to a low income family? Probably for the same reason that others do not - it is extremely expensive, it is risky, and it is a long term investment.

Playing with the act to make it even more difficult for residential rental investors to control and protect their investment will not increase competition, ie; will not result in more rental housing in Whitehorse.

Some existing landlords may well decide this is a very good time to sell to private owners, in order to move their money into investments that have less risks and less headaches, and hopefully better returns.

I agree fully that sleaze balls on both sides, landlords or tenants, should be held accountable, but most landlords and most tenants are very decent people who get along well with one another.

Up 0 Down 0

Bobby Bitman on Jun 12, 2011 at 4:58 pm

"Someone has got to help us find a home, or at least figure out this Landlord and Tenant Act so we can have some stability when we find a place – not get kicked out whenever the landlord wants.`

Actually the current Act requires a minimum of one calendar month´s notice in order to ask a tenant to leave, and that would be the contract that the tenant signed when she rented the unit. Ie, both sides should be clear on that from the outset. If the tenant is not paying rent or is damaging the unit, or is in breach of the contract in some other serious way, there are mechanisms in the act to shorten the notice, but there is no mechanism in the Act to ´kick tenants out whenever the landlord wants to´.

It is okay to quote people, but the reporter should do his-her homework and also report the facts behind the statement.

If some landlords are indeed in breach of the act, mechanisms should be put in place and utilized in order to enforce the current rules. I am not sure that is the case however, all we got in this article was a very broad and unsubstantiated statement. In fact, a statement that suggested that the Act needs to be changed because right now it allows landlords to ´kick people out´ whenever the landlord feels like it, which is not even true!

More responsible reporting would be appreciated. As usual, landlords are being demonized for not providing social housing on behalf of the Yukon Government. Sorry, that is what we pay taxes for - so that the difficult to house will indeed be housed, by the government! Private landlords do not run homeless shelters, just like the grocery stores are not providing soup kitchens!

Up 0 Down 0

Roger Rondeau on Jun 12, 2011 at 1:14 am

It is not surprising to read some of the comments above. It shows why the small 'c' conservative mentality is not doing anything about the housing situation as they see it with the same blind eyes of most of the above.

Not every person chooses to be on SA and not all SA recipients are using the system. What about the disabled or mentally ill? And what about the low income family earners who cannot afford a sub-standard rental unit because the prices are completely out of control due to lack of competition.

Most of the comments above are arrogant and/or ignorant of the facts.

Not-so-red-neck-sourdough.

Up 0 Down 0

Groucho d'North on Jun 11, 2011 at 2:01 am

In investment terms, the local housing market is red hot for some new housing projects, perhaps an apartment complex or two to address the chronic homeless situation or the low-income sector. The housing market is eager to buy the housing products investors could develop. It has been this way for a few years now - so why is nobody moving ahead with this kind of investment if the market is ripe for it? I think it is because nobody wants to become the newest zoo-keeper.



Talk with a local landlord and you'll hear of horror stories of how tenants have destroyed the rental unit or are causing any number of problems to other tenants with parties at all hours of the day and night, fear of violence as the party crowd moves through the buildings at all hours. Not a great environment for anybody to live in- yet we as a community look the other way in our politically-correct blindness and blame governments for not building more housing which is virtually just-about-free for as long as you want to live there. Government housing is no different than private landlords, with destruction, abuse and irresponsible tenants running amok.



The present lament of; "There's no land to build on” is the result of short-sightedness by previous governments who did not have a sense of a positive future and the return of a prosperous economy to Yukon.

The local First Nations have plenty of land suitable for housing development which could ease the pressure on vacancy rates, they could create some business enterprises, and more jobs and training opportunities for the next generation of construction workers. The first nations, banks and mortgage companies need to develop some bullet-proof rules and contract terms for 99 year leases and then some development could move forward.



All it would take is the various governments - Lord knows we have enough of them here - to sit down; agree on the objectives, then they all pitch in some money and build some housing solutions.



How far do you think $18 million would go before the fund is a zero again? It would be more prudent to use that money to leverage private sector partnership investments to build some low-cost apartments, rather than government building another low-income housing project that taxpayers will be on the hook to maintain in perpetuity.

And lets admit there are some less than desirable tenants out there who are screwing it up for many others. Perhaps a tenant code of conduct could be included in the Landlord and Tenant Act.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon Student on Jun 10, 2011 at 1:02 pm

I'm sick of nonsense too. People don't ask to be homeless, and they don't ask for sub par housing, they don't ask for mental disabilities, and they aren't happy jumping from place to place.

They are worried about where they will stay in the winter, they are worried about how they are going to afford their 800 hundred dollar a month hole in the ground. Whether your rich or poor or middle class, everyone can see that the housing prices in the Yukon are extremely high and the people who pay the highest price are the poor and disabled.

How are homeless people supposed to "contribute to society" when their biggest concern is not freezing to death in the winter? I've been working and talking with people in the thick of the housing crisis for over a year now--I haven't seen any prancing.

Up 0 Down 0

Working but homeless on Jun 10, 2011 at 12:24 pm

Although I agree with everyone that people need to take responsibility for themselves, I have genuine concerns about the lack of any kind of available housing. Even for those willing to pay their own way, there are no rentals available and housing prices are ridiculous. Nobody should expect housing for nothing when they are not willing to contribute to society. It is very scary to bring a family to Whitehorse when expecting to start work only to find there is no place to live.

Up 0 Down 0

sick of this nonsense on Jun 10, 2011 at 5:35 am

Here we go again...

'Government isn't holding up their end of the bargain'??? And what bargain is that? To give every layabout free housing? What does the other side of the so-called bargain involve? Oh yeah - nothing! Laze around, collect your social assistance and demand free stuff. Give me a break. Enough is enough!

Up 0 Down 0

Francias Pillman on Jun 9, 2011 at 10:26 am

I'm so sick and tired of this argument. You people on welfare prance around and act like you are owed the world. Newsflash, people on welfare are not the only ones affected by a shortage of places to live. But it's funny that the "disadvantaged" are the only ones who deserve a place to stay. You people bleed the system dry and continue to just sit there with your hands out. Please contribute something to our society. You are not owed a single thing.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon Eddie on Jun 9, 2011 at 8:34 am

Liberal Mitchell and NDP Steve Cardiff - The Ravens come to scavenge! Must have heard there's an election this fall.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.