Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Mike Gau

Windrows are marooning seniors: resident

Just a day after the city released a statement on the work it's doing to clear streets of the recently fallen snow,

By Stephanie Waddell on November 24, 2010

Just a day after the city released a statement on the work it's doing to clear streets of the recently fallen snow, Peggy Smarch found herself having to shovel the hard-packed snow that graders left in front of her mother's Arkell home.

"I know this has been a problem for several years,” Smarch said in an interview Tuesday afternoon. She spoke after shovelling the windrow in front of her mom's house so she could get to an appointment.

As Smarch explained, her mother is in her 70s and lives on her own. She is on the city's list of seniors and those with disabilities who are eligible to have the snow removed by city Bobcats.

But rarely does the city show up quickly enough, Smarch said. That leaves her mother and other senior neighbours on Heron Drive stuck inside their homes until the city eventually decides to show up, she added.

Smarch is often out of town for weeks or months at a time working in Alberta. Last year, she said, her mother ended up hiring a Bobcat service herself to come in and deal with the windrows left by city crews on the roads because the city took so long to get there. It's something she's now considering again for this winter.

Yesterday, Smarch said, she was glad she was here when her mom called so she could get her out, though it's left her wondering what will happen when she leaves shortly for another stint of work.

Shovelling the hard-packed snow was no easy task. She saw other elders, perhaps also tired of waiting for city Bobcats, come out and try to shovel themselves. One woman had such difficulty she ended up giving up and going back inside.

It's not healthy for seniors to strain their bodies by shovelling, Smarch argued.

When she contacted the city, she said she was essentially told the Bobcat would be there when it could get there.

"The city doesn't really want to do anything,” Smarch said.

It was only after she told city staff she was contacting the media that crews showed up on the street in the late morning, she said. She wondered what would happen if there was an emergency and vehicles were unable to get in.

"I've just basically had it with them,” Smarch said, adding she wonders how many other seniors are in the same boat as her mother.

Mike Gau, the city's acting director of operations, said Tuesday there are just over 100 seniors with disabilities on the city's list of those to have the windrows removed.

Seniors without younger people living in the home, and those with disabilities, must fill out an application and show some form of proof of their age or disability.

"(Tuesday), we had three Bobcats going at full speed,” he said.

Smarch suggested the city graders could somehow deal with each of the homes as they come to them, or have a Bobcat follow the graders as they clear to deal with the windrows. Gau noted that could end up taking even longer to clear city streets, which are priorized for clearing by a city policy.

Just as the city priorizes what roads are cleared of snow first, it can do the same for those eligible to get their windrows removed.

If the city knows a resident on the list for windrow removal has an appointment, Gau said, they will work to have the Bobcat at the home to deal with the windrow in time for the resident to make it to wherever he or she needs to be on time.

Had crews known the woman had an appointment Tuesday, they likely would have been on the street sooner, he said. He also acknowledged the woman may not have known that.

In the past though, the city has headed to particular areas where people have indicated they need to be out of their homes at a set time.

Getting to 100 homes where people are all waiting for the same service can take time, Gau stressed. Emergency vehicles are equipped to be able to get through windrows.

Mayor Bev Buckway emphasized Monday that street-clearing can take some time, though crews have been working around the clock to do so.

"Over the past few days, Whitehorse has experienced a significant amount of snowfall, and as a result, city graders and sanding trucks have been out in force,” she said in a statement.

"As it will take a little bit of time to ensure that all roads are clear, I encourage all drivers to exercise appropriate caution when driving.”

Major arterial roads including Two Mile Hill, Robert Service Way and Second and Fourth avenues are the first priority for snow-clearing, with major roads in subdivisions being the next priority, followed by all remaining streets.

"We're asking all motorists to be aware of road conditions and leave sufficient distance between your car and major equipment such as graders and sanders,” the mayor said.

Comments (7)

Up 0 Down 0

Francis pillman on Nov 25, 2010 at 11:08 am

I'm not bagging seniors with my comment. I was just using it as an example. And for the person who said "they are doing the best they can" Well they need to try harder. Saying that everything is spaces out is a weak argument. 10 years ago I don't remember seeing streets cleared once every winter. Aw well, sticking up for the COW is not something people should be doing. Taxes keep going up for no reason and essential city services continue to be cut. That is unacceptable and embarrassing to say the least.

Up 0 Down 0

Jerry Johnson on Nov 25, 2010 at 10:54 am

Other municipalities have their graders equipped with a hydraulic operated wing which can be dropped to carry snow past driveways and then dump it. Why can Whitehorse not do the same.

Up 0 Down 0

shenya on Nov 25, 2010 at 9:25 am

We have same experiences here in Dawson. And yes Pillman, some of us are seniors still enjoying our independence but to shovel a whole pile of windrow is a dangerous health issue for some of us. As citizens to our town we pay for services. Perhaps the City of Dawson can review the contract agreement as this happens over and over again. And lately its no fun. We hire someone, we should foot the bill to our city.

Up 0 Down 0

Anthony on Nov 25, 2010 at 7:50 am

Buckway:

Plow the streets.

Enforce the sidewalk clearing bylaw.

Enforce the bylaw prohibiting people from plowing their driveways onto the street.

Up 0 Down 0

DG on Nov 25, 2010 at 5:14 am

How funny everyone complains when they don't get served immediately or when they believe they should be served.

I feel no empathy for these people who complain.

The city crews work hard to get the job done working around the clock to clear snow that happened to seriously dump on us all at once.

Have some patience, we happen to live in a very large area for such a small population. It takes time for a little bobcat to drive from point a to point b even if they use truck and trailers to get there plus they have to clear the snow.

@ Marg Bowfiel do you sit and watch as all the little vehicles pass by. Just because you only see one does not mean there is not more out there. I drive a chevy cavalier and I have not found it hard to get where I need to go perhaps inconvenient but not hard.

Up 0 Down 0

Francias pillman on Nov 24, 2010 at 3:15 pm

It's funny that this snow removal issue hits the paper if a senior is involved. What about the rest of us? The basic service of removing snow can't be done by the people running this town. And you want to add 10k+ more people in Whistle Bend? I don't understand any of this. But there is one thing I do understand. Taxes continue to rise every year, but the level of service received for that money doesn't exist. But hey you folks voted for Bev Buckway. What has she seriously done for this town except make everything worse?

Up 0 Down 0

marg bowfiel on Nov 24, 2010 at 10:04 am

I work outside everyday and I cruise our city streets... in the last few days I have seen only ONE sand truck laying sand at the intersection of Qwanlin mall. Start clearing the roads Buckway around schools, the cop station etc... i damn near have to have a skidoo to drop my kid off at school in the mornings because the snow is so deep

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.