Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Pictured Above: DON ROBERTS

‘Why are we racing to have this gas and oil?'

The Yukon government is moving too fast exploring oil and gas possibilities in the Whitehorse Trough, according to the majority of Yukoners who attended a public meeting Wednesday night.

By Nadine Sander-Green on March 1, 2012

The Yukon government is moving too fast exploring oil and gas possibilities in the Whitehorse Trough, according to the majority of Yukoners who attended a public meeting Wednesday night.

The Hootalinqua Fire Hall off the Mayo Road was jam-packed with people concerned about the potential side-effects of developing the industry in their backyards.

"Why are we racing to have this gas and oil?” asked long-time Whitehorse resident Don Roberts.

"A lot of us are good readers. We see what has been destroyed in other places, and that's why we're here.”

Roberts, a former Liberal and independent MLA, helped circulate a petition asking the government to stop oil and gas exploration until more research has been done.

"We're going too fast, too quickly, and somewhere the homework hasn't been done,” continued Roberts, a retired school principal.

"Basically, I think we've got the cart before the horse.”

This drew a round of applause.

Debra Wortley, the manager of rights and royalties for the Department of Energy, Mines and Resources (EMR), and Ron Sumanik, EMR's director of oil and gas resources, were at the meeting to explain the disposition process and ease the crowd's worries.

Twelve areas of interest were targeted by oil and gas companies in January, all of them in the Whitehorse Trough – a 4,113 square kilometre area of land between Carmacks and Carcross.

This is the first time since the disposition process began that industry has been interested in this basin.

The government does not make public which or how many companies are looking to explore the area.

EMR is now in the public consultation phase.

A report to minister Brad Cathers will be compiled, and by-mid June, the highest bidder will be issued rights.

Since the oil and gas interest was made public in early February, the government has been stressing it will not necessarily issue rights; it depends on the consultation process and the final say from the minister.

The government says the territory is running out of energy, and that oil and gas might be the next best option.

It's cheaper and better for the environment than running diesel, and the industry would open up more jobs and further boost the local economy.

Those opposed are concerned about everything from water contamination to how the industry would clean up its mess after it leaves. Many say the government does not have the regulations in place to deal with controversial extraction methods like fracking.

But EMR says yes, we do.

That doesn't mean the regulations can't be enhanced, Sumanik told the meeting.

Concerns from the gathering seemed to stem from a lack of trust in the government, especially after last month's push to open the Peel watershed to industrial development despite heated public opposition.

"I have difficulty dealing with this process,” one citizen said. " I can't help but wonder, at the end of the day, if the public doesn't want this, will it go ahead anyway? The same as the Peel?”

Others felt it's already too late; that the government should have consulted with the public before permitting industry to get involved.

Some fear Yukon will become the next Alberta.

"I left Alberta because of the oil and gas industry,” one person said.

"Some people look to the province with envy, because of their economy.

"We should look at Alberta and what they don't have. We have fantastic wealth in the Yukon, and I'd hate to see it go where Alberta's has in the past 40 years.”

When the conversation turned to remediation and who is responsible for clean-up and environmental disasters, EMR representatives were clear: it's up to the industry.

Richard Corbet, of EMR operations, emerged from the back of the crowd to talk about the worst-case scenario should oil leak into the ground.

"If something horrible happens, the best thing to do is stop it as fast and safely as possible,” he said.

But if there is contamination of aquifers, it could take years to remediate, he said.

In that case, the water would be pumped into porous formations underground.

Corbet stressed regulations are in place to ensure that this situation would never happen.

"Can I offer an unconditional guarantee that it won't happen?” he said. "No, of course not.”

The next public meeting will take place at 7 p.m. March 5 at the Mt. Lorne Community Centre.

There will be a meeting and open house March 23 at the High Country Inn.

Comments (10)

Up 0 Down 0

drifter on Mar 4, 2012 at 5:30 am

jobs, economy, energy, and moving forward as we finance China's military machine, and destroy our natural habitat. We are dealing with a lack of imagination, and a mind set of lies,propaganda, greed and power.

A few people in positions of power will determine our future, a future that resembles their own rationalistic and political psychosis. A world of nomadic migrant workers ignorant of local history and culture voting for a Govt that will wreck the environment so they can have a job.

Up 0 Down 0

Billy Polson on Mar 3, 2012 at 7:17 am

Well Joel for one is passionate about this....I guess the point is, suddenly more land will have a grid pattern of trails cut across it, which may provide a source of energy, but to what cost environmentally as there are few rules that exist to protect water and ecosystems from this type of development. Leaving the once quiet Yukon ( that gets lots of money from Ottawa to operate and support business that will remain and have little effect on the environment forever as Ottawa certainly can't help but support their North due to the other nations looking to claim it, it's called sovereignty) without the only real renewable resource it possesses...wilderness.

How those who don't appreciate the last of the wild places can so boldly cast it off and condemn all those who do is truly moronic.

Up 0 Down 0

jack p on Mar 2, 2012 at 8:56 pm

The entire territory should be off limits to development of any kind...anything existing should be ripped up and areas returned to their natural state. All humans moved south and allowed to see Yukon only through a chain link fence (except for 'people who grew up here').

Up 0 Down 0

Joel on Mar 2, 2012 at 9:00 am

Here is the problem, I don't see anyone racing here. Can anyone point out the location of the operating wells in the Yukon right now? What about all the other capped wells that are in the territory?

Up 0 Down 0

Art Pearson on Mar 2, 2012 at 2:27 am

One of the biggest concerns facing the future of the Yukon is a source of power. If there is a source of natural gas close to the power grid it would be a blessing that could produce clean energy and take the pressure off the other alternatives such as raising the level of Marsh Lake, the daming of other rivers flooding precious natural landscapes, or mining and burning coal. To allow controlled exploration to determine if the natural gas option is feasible is surely not putting the "cart before the horse" but , in my opinion, a reasonable approach to the energy question.

Up 0 Down 0

Northone on Mar 1, 2012 at 11:03 am

Relax, everyone. No O+G development will occur anytime soon, there is no infrastructure in place to ship hydrocarbons to market, nor an infrastructure to refine it for our own use. We're not about to become Fort Nelson North, even if exploration showed great promise, infrastructure for development is decades away.

Chill out, everyone...

Up 0 Down 0

Patrick on Mar 1, 2012 at 11:01 am

Joel- I think many people attended this meeting with the same thought that Don Roberts thought forward- "Why are we racing to have this gas and oil?” asked long-time Whitehorse resident Don Roberts.

I do not think MR. Roberts is seeking the spotlight. In my mind he has a sincere interest in reponsible governance and having the Yukon developed in a manner that protects natural resources.

Up 0 Down 0

Joel on Mar 1, 2012 at 9:47 am

Yes Don, we are racing to getting oil and gas. Those carts that are running before the horses have been running without the horses for a long time already.

Time to catch up to reality Don. I know you want the spotlight ever since you were voted out of politics, but I don't think this will get you there.

Up 0 Down 0

mark on Mar 1, 2012 at 9:34 am

who's racing, i think the government is taking their time. We need jobs in this town, we need entertainment, the Yukon needs some sort of lift. Not everyone can work for ytg and get atrocious wages

Up 0 Down 0

Northerntut on Mar 1, 2012 at 8:32 am

When the Yukon government can prove that they can deal with all the abandoned mines and waste sites adequately, then I might be convinced they are mature enough to handle the largest most powerful industry in the world. They are like a bunch of elementary school kids deciding to play tackle football with college professionals. They are out of their league, and its time for the parents (Yukon Votes) to ground them until they learn to listen.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.