Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Pictured Above: DORIS BILL

‘We must prevent these tragedies from continuing’

The minister responsible for the Yukon’s Women’s Directorate is calling Wednesday “a historic day.”

By Sidney Cohen on August 4, 2016

The minister responsible for the Yukon’s Women’s Directorate is calling Wednesday “a historic day.”

Elaine Taylor was discussing the launch of a national inquiry into missing and murdered indigenous women and girls in Canada.

“The Yukon has long supported a call for a national inquiry,” Taylor told the Star Wednesday afternoon.

“This is a national tragedy, and it’s not the responsibility of any one government, any one organization, any one individual. It’s going to require the collective efforts on everyone’s part.”

Before an emotional crowd in Gatineau, Que. Wednesday morning, Carolyn Bennett, the minister of Indigenous and Northern Affairs, declared the start of a long-awaited inquiry into missing and murdered indigenous women and girls, and presented the five commissioners who will lead the effort.

The commission’s mandate is to explore systemic forces – assimilationist policies, racism, poverty, and more – that cause violence against indigenous women and girls, and increase their risk of experiencing violence.

The commission has also been directed to make recommendations for “concrete and effective action that can be taken to remove systemic causes of violence and to increase the safety of indigenous women and girls in Canada.”

Indigenous and non-indigenous leaders in the Yukon applauded the announcement.

“Like so many Canadians, we are pleased that Canada will hold a national inquiry into what has happened to our stolen women and girls,” Doris Bill, the Kwanlin Dün First Nation chief, said in a statement released Wednesday afternoon.

“Yukon is prepared, and we will be fully engaged in the long-awaited federal inquiry. We must prevent these tragedies from continuing and provide the families with some measure of peace,” she said.

Indigenous families and communities have been sounding the alarm about disproportionate rates of violence against their women and girls for decades.

Why do indigenous women continue to be victims of violence at higher rates than non-indigenous women and men?

What are the causes? What can be done to fix it?

In its 2015 report, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada called on the federal government to hold a public inquiry into the disappearances and deaths of indigenous women and girls in Canada.

In 2015, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau campaigned on the promise that he would launch a national inquiry into the missing and murdered if elected, something Stephen Harper wouldn’t do when he was the Conservative prime minister.

The exact number of missing and murdered indigenous women and girls in Canada is unknown.

A 2014 RCMP report counted 1,181, but that report only took into account police-documented homicides and missing persons cases between 1980 and 2012, and did not include suspicious deaths.

Right now, the CBC is investigating at least 34 other cases of missing or murdered indigenous women where police ruled out foul play but family members aren’t convinced.

After wrapping up pre-inquiry meetings with victims’ family members, minister Bennett said last February that the number of missing and murdered indigenous women and girls is “bigger than 1,200; way, way bigger than 1,200.”

Taylor noted that the Yukon and the North in general has “some inordinate levels of violence against women, and when it comes to indigenous women and girls, they are much higher.”

“This has long been identified as ... a very important issue of concern by Yukoners and aboriginal women and organizations,” she said.

While lower than that of the other two territories, the Yukon’s rate of police-reported sexual offences against women was more than 3.5 times the average of that in the provinces, according to a 2013 Statistics Canada report.

The Yukon’s rate of police-reported violent crime against women was also significantly higher than the provinces, though lower than Northwest Territories and Nunavut.

The same 2013 Statistics Canada report, called Measuring violence against women: statistical trends, found that “aboriginal women were disproportionally represented as homicide victims.

“Similarly, victimization data indicates that aboriginal women have higher rates of self-reported spousal and non-spousal violence.”

Last Februrary, the territorial government, Kwanlin Dün First Nation and the Yukon Aboriginal Women’s Council held a regional roundtable to discuss the high rates of physical, sexual and domestic violence against indigenous women and girls in the territory.

The meeting was co-chaired by Taylor, Bill and Doris Anderson, president of the Yukon Aboriginal Women’s Council.

The three leaders signed a document in which they acknowledged the harmful impacts of discrimination, poverty, substance use, residential schools and the loss of language and culture on indigenous women.

They committed to working together, and with governments and the private sector, to address these issues and support healing.

“As the inquiry commissioners listen to the testimonies from the families of missing and murdered women and girls, we will continue to bring a strong and united voice in support of the families of Yukon’s missing and murdered indigenous women and girls,” Anderson said in a statement on Wednesday.

“We will ensure that the messages we heard at the Family Gathering, at the family meeting with minister Bennett and at the Yukon Regional Roundtable are delivered, and we hope that this inquiry helps the process of healing continue.”

It’s still early days, and details of how the inquiry will play out in the Yukon are unclear.

According to its mandate, the commission may set up “regional advisory committees” – local groups of family members, loved ones and survivors – to consult on issues relevant to certain parts of a province or territory.

Taylor said it’s too early to know if such a committee will be established in the Yukon.

There is also the option to set up advisory committees on specific issues.

These committees could include family members, elders, young people and representatives from local and/or national indigenous organizations.

It’s also unclear whether the Yukon will get any special funding to go toward the inquiry’s activities in the territory.

“We have questions, there’s no doubt. Pretty much every other territory and province will have their questions,” said Taylor.

“Once we know further what this information is, how this council is going to unfold, it will help inform our next steps.”

Something she heard loud and clear at the regional roundtable, Taylor said, was that the Yukon’s work can’t stop even though the national inquiry has begun.

“It’s absolutely critical that we work collectively,” she said.

“This is really for the benefit of our entire country, our entire territory.”

See related coverage.

Comments (14)

Up 10 Down 1

Indigenous Women on Aug 10, 2016 at 12:48 pm

I am happy that this inquiry is occurring, but my worry is how we will handle the truth when it comes out... I too believe that the inquiry is going to expose many groups that have victimized aboriginal women. What I am specifically worried about is there actually going to be anything done about it... I can only speak of my community, but once these crimes are exposed there is people in higher positions that cover it up. It is covered up and god forbid you ever bring it up... or seek help or shed a tear about it... Those famous words "Don't talk about it, your just trying to cause trouble."
I am thankful that I had enough support to escape the abusive relationship I was in... but do I dare set foot in my community, it was my fault, I should of learned when to "SHUT UP" and now I am shunned even by my own elders, why because certain people have the power to do that... and we hold our men with a higher standard then our own mothers, sisters, daughters, aunties and grandmothers. We allow individuals to continuously abuse others, men and women, but when it comes time to honestly report the crimes, or help the victims it is covered up and low and behold we have one of the lowest crimes rates... Who is responsible for this... i hope this inquiry exposes all including the women and men in high positions that cover up the abuse and bully people to cover up abuse... If you hide it then you are just as guilty...

Up 1 Down 11

@North of Sixty on Aug 9, 2016 at 7:07 pm

You're going to go with stats from the RCMP? I've got an ice bridge for sale.

Up 33 Down 3

north_of_60 on Aug 7, 2016 at 12:49 pm

RCMP statistics show that about 90% of murdered aboriginals are killed by aboriginals.

Up 20 Down 1

cameron on Aug 7, 2016 at 11:17 am

I really hope that something will be done with regards to any person in Canada who goes missing and is never found. It is so terrible for the family who is left behind not knowing what happened.
It does not seem as if this particular route is going to help anyone. Seemingly the Commissioners will have no jurisdiction within the Provinces and Territories and will not be able to demand that certain recommendations have to be followed. All the enquiry will do is make recommendations but have no authority to see that they are followed. Sound familiar - all that time and money
(not ready until 2018) and nothing will come of it. Just (in my opinion) the politicians making it all go away.

Up 20 Down 4

June Jackson on Aug 6, 2016 at 10:42 am

I went to Groucho's link and read the letter written by Joan Jack. The link she talks about is lack of political power for First Nations. I disagree. And I don't agree with the way she has written the following quote. Yes.. aboriginal men kill and rape aboriginal women and girls..but so do White men, Asian men, Black men etc. I do not believe these girls and women are killed because they are aboriginal. I believe ALL women who are prostituting themselves, drug addicts, or alcoholics, etc. living on the streets by choice in most cases, have made themselves easy targets. If keeping women off the streets is the solution, there are shelters, programming, education opportunities already available.. most choose not to take advantage of them and remain targets until someone kills them...There aren't any easy solutions, even though everyone knows that the problem is the breakdown of the family.

By Joan Jack
"In my opinion, there is a link. Aboriginal men kill aboriginal women and girls, rape aboriginal women and girls, beat aboriginal women and girls, and no one is really talking about the moose in our living room."

Up 6 Down 23

@North of Sixty on Aug 5, 2016 at 8:15 pm

Robert Pickton was not an aboriginal. The serial psycho from the Highway of Tears is suspected to be a truck driver. What are your sources for your 90% of murdered aboriginals are killed by aboriginals please? I question the veracity of your statements.

Up 16 Down 3

Arturs on Aug 5, 2016 at 7:54 pm

Where was the vociferous Minister at the time when her illustrious Prime Minister (Stephan Harper) stated that the need for an Inquiry was something that was " not high on the Conservatives radar". I remember hearing nothing from her and if Harper had won the election she would still be in that mode of operandi. Her integrity on this matter is indeed in question.

Up 36 Down 1

prevention on Aug 5, 2016 at 2:50 pm

IF this level of investment was made in these missing women before they went missing then most would still be here. Most of these missing women were young, vulnerable, disconnected from family, disconnected from community, raised by compromised parents (residential school, addiction, abuse, trauma). Learn the truth of why/how these young women are forgotten while alive to then only become a campaign in their death. The system needs to partner with the First Nations and acknowledge the breakdown of tradition and family but don't get stuck in blaming. Move into a solution and supporting the education of FN people on how to parent, be a family, deal with your children, not give up and hand over to the system to raise or fix ( to all the criticism I will get for this comment, I ask the young women in care right now if they would rather be at home with family or in care).
Stop blaming and researching but develop legislation and policies that ensure that parents are responsible and accountable for their children for life. Invest in supporting the family early and not later when there is breakdown and laws broken....

Up 37 Down 3

Max Mack on Aug 5, 2016 at 11:49 am

This political show-trial (yes - I know it's an "inquiry") is intended to generate lots of money and resources to help aboriginal women. But, what about the many thousands of missing and murdered aboriginal men and boys? Do they not count?

What about the well-known fact that it is aboriginal women, not men, in the Yukon that are the principal beneficiaries of free (or mostly free) university education? What about the highly skewed job situation in the Yukon, where aboriginal women are employed in higher paying, permanent year-round jobs and aboriginal men, by and large, are in precarious or seasonal employment -- that's if the men have jobs at all.

There is violence against women in aboriginal communities. There is also violence against aboriginal men. A lot of it. To suggest that aboriginal women are more likely to experience violence than aboriginal men is simply ludicrous. We accept the violence against men as though it is a fact of life. We shrug our shoulders and say, "They deserve it." But, it is women, who are as much a part of the problem as the men, who get the sympathy and societal support.

So, we simply send the men to jail (or, at least those who haven't died due to accidental death, suicide, alcohol poisoning, drug overdose or haven't been murdered). Sending more aboriginal men to jail will not end this cycle and I sincerely hope that is not the end product of this "inquiry". But, I suspect it will be.

Up 44 Down 5

jc on Aug 4, 2016 at 10:09 pm

Are the FN ready for the truth? Or will the truth be allowed to come out? I'm not betting on either.

Up 48 Down 7

north_of_60 on Aug 4, 2016 at 5:51 pm

Yet another inquiry to confirm once again that 90% of all murdered aboriginals are killed by other aboriginals, usually people they know. As well, nearly all the violent abuse is aboriginal on aboriginal. This story is written with the usual apologetic tone which tries to imply that the violence comes from outside the aboriginal community. That is the 'moose in the room' everyone is trying so hard to ignore.

To actually solve the problems, aboriginal communities have to ask themselves what makes their children drop out of school, join gangs, do drugs and engage in risky behavior including crimes to pay for the drugs, and eventually 'go missing' or end up dead. This is an aboriginal problem that begins in aboriginal communities, often at an early age, and only aboriginal communities can solve it. No endless litany of inquiries or compensation payments will ever accomplish what aboriginals must do for themselves.

Up 22 Down 4

Josey Wales on Aug 4, 2016 at 5:22 pm

Hey Groucho...indeed I read that a long time ago.
Is that not so ABSOLUTELY predictable that a truthful letter as that gets virtually no exposure. I even tried to post that letter here, but since it destroys the false narrative...never posted.
Too radical I suppose those inconvenient truths?

Do not forget to discuss the moose in the room during your latest round of meetings and revisionist guilt trip discussions.
Oh yeah, many of your brothers have vanished and have been killed by feral humans too. Often at the hands of their own brethren.

Up 21 Down 2

Groucho d'North on Aug 4, 2016 at 4:40 pm

I encourage all to read a letter submitted to the Winnipeg Free Press some time ago by a female First Nations lawyer named Joan Jack who also ran for the AFN . It is called A Moose in the room, and like elephants, it is often ignored. Perhaps this expensive new investigation will not only identify the problem, but also create some solutions. I wonder what they will spend $53.8 million on? I hope that Ms. Jack is involved at some capacity as well.
Link is here: http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/opinion/analysis/aboriginal-women-fear-their-own-kind-the-most-285701831.html#history_popup

Up 58 Down 4

let me guess on Aug 4, 2016 at 3:48 pm

When an aboriginal male is sentenced to 2 years for murdering an aboriginal female in cold blood, this is an issue. And that has nothing to do with racism. Wonder if this will be discussed by the inquiry

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.