Whitehorse Daily Star

‘We have work to do': education minister

The Yukon ranks last in almost every subject in the latest report card on schools' performances.

By Nadine Sander-Green on November 29, 2011

The Yukon ranks last in almost every subject in the latest report card on schools' performances.

Once every three years, the Pan-Canadian Assessment Program (PCAP) measures Grade 8 students in their reading, math and science skills.

The report has the Yukon ranking at the bottom of science and reading and third to last (after Manitoba and Prince Edward Island) in mathematics.

The Yukon was the only Canadian territory to participate in the assessment.

"It's not unexpected,” Christie Whitley, the assistant deputy minister of education, told the Star today.

"We've known this for quite some time and this confirms it.”

Whitley thinks it's important to recognize a lot of students are doing well, but there are also many who are "not doing well.”

She said her department has been working on education reform for the past three years, following in the footsteps of jurisdictions like Ontario and Alberta.

Since these two provinces performed well in the report card, she continued, that means Yukon officials are on the right track.

The Yukon is working on reducing the number of students in primary classes and changing the way students are assessed, Whitley said.

Individual communities are looking at exactly what their own needs are instead of decisions being made from afar.

The department is also considering video conferencing for rural students who have to leave their communities and attend high school in Whitehorse.

"We're already doing it, but we want to do it on a larger scale,” Whitley said.

She didn't comment on the roots of why the Yukon is ranking so poorly in these type of assessment.

She did admit attendance is a problem, which she thinks is a reflection of cold weather, the distances some kids have to travel to school and First Nations cultural differences, like dealing with a death in the family.

She said the school in Old Crow is hosting events like pizza lunches to try to keep kids in the classroom.

Scott Kent, the Yukon's new education minister, told the Star today these results show the territory definitely has work to do.

He said these results, along with the 2009 auditor general's report and input from school councils and advisory committees help Yukoners know which direction the territory needs to go.

As for why Yukoners' literacy skills in particular are dropping, Kent said he's "not too sure”.

"Obviously, we have work to do,” he repeated.

Jim Tredger, the New Democrats' education critic and retired teacher and principal, said he's concerned the Yukon results are not improving.

He said rural areas tend to perform worse than cities when it comes to education rankings.

In the big picture, he continued, the entire Yukon is a rural area.

Tredger thinks Yukoners need to move on from all the discussions and meetings and create an action plan.

"The new minister needs to establish performance targets with measurable outcomes. Let's look at what's happening now and what we can do to improve it.”

On a per capita basis, the Yukon has one of the best-funded – if not the best-funded – education systems in Canada.

Comments (10)

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon Graduate on Dec 7, 2011 at 7:35 am

I for one must say that from my experience as a student a lot of the teachers are spending more time on "problem" children rather than teaching those who are there to learn. I think parents need to be held accountable for teaching their children that attendance and paying attention in class are important tools that develop good work ethics. I also felt that some of the best teachers I had that did a great job were actually the substitute teachers. Subs need way more credit and many of them are better teachers than those who are on full time. Not to mention the fact that they have to pick up a lesson plan designed by someone else and roll with it.

It's not just the system that is flawed and everyone needs to coordinate and work in unison to achieve higher education standards in our territory.

Up 0 Down 0

Reality Check on Dec 7, 2011 at 3:09 am

I think there is only one person who has made a single valid comment on this page, interested parent.

You people will complain no matter what the issue, if your children were to come home and not given any options of extra-curricular activity you would have a problem.

This is NOT just a problem for the department of education, or the teachers, this is also a problem for parents, family and the community.

The schools are there to help to teach your children, but their jobs have expanded so much that they are not only trying to teach our children academics, they are having to teach them things they should be learning at home.

They are having to battle to get their students in the seats on a regular basis so they have the chance to learn.

And you are absolutely right, they are having to battle to try to teach students at a grade 2 level in a grade 6 classroom at the same time they are trying to challenge a student in the same class who is a grade 9 level.

It is very easy to slag this off as someone elses responsibility, but we are ALL responsible. Own up to it, if you are a parent, a teacher, an employee at the department of Education, a coach a community member, we all play a role in this communities education...

Up 0 Down 0

Interested parent on Dec 5, 2011 at 1:42 pm

I think a lack of attendance leads to most academic problems. Look at how many kids are walking around during the middle of the day or late in the evenings.

Another idea may be to look at what do we want to teach our children in our system? There needs to be a balance of social & academic skills that need to be taught at both elementary & secondary schools.

However not every student is suited to follow an academic career and go to university. Why isn't there a better trades program offered for students who can build decks/fix cars etc. but don't want to read Shakespeare?

Up 0 Down 0

Teachers teach pls on Dec 2, 2011 at 4:08 am

As a parent of 2 elementary school students I am shocked at the amount of non academic events at and outside the school. The school they attend is welcoming, pleasant and appreciated. What I do not appreciate is the high level or permissions letters sent home for all school swims, celebrations, choir practice, bowling etc. Then the quantity of homework that gets sent home because there is not enough class time. PLEASE teach my children and let me have time for recreation and fun with them in the evening and weekends.

Up 0 Down 0

Hello? Wake up on Dec 1, 2011 at 10:25 am

The reason why kids are failing is not because of the school, the teachers or the education system. It's the parents. Parents have a lot to do with their child's education, and its up to them to make sure that their children are in school.

Up 0 Down 0

Puh-lease on Nov 30, 2011 at 7:36 am

There is no accountability in the system period. Not for the kids, who cannot/will not fail, and not for the teachers who also do not meet performance expectations.

The teachers who are dedicated (and MANY of them are not) are too busy trying to teach kids who should have failed 3 grades ago rather than teach the kids who are average or bright. The bright ones get lost and bored and they flunk out too.

Why are we so afraid to say no to kids? Afraid to say 'sorry - not good enough, you do not pass go and collect $200'. I guess the only positive thing here is that all these illiterate kids will be able to get teaching jobs! Lots of room in the YNTEP!

Up 0 Down 0

john jack on Nov 30, 2011 at 12:32 am

Blame the administrative decisions for this the teachers have no back up. eg. No discipline, assignments don't have to be on time just when they hand them in. Attendance doesn't have any recourse, a volleyball game is more important than studies for kids that are failing. Kids can't fail even if they don't know what they are supposed to know. Grade 11 and twelve can't spell. Guidance personal are causing a lot of the problem passing students that shouldn't be. No wonder it's not working. Teachers concerns are not listened to and the list goes on. The decisions at the top are totally ridiculous. This is fact!!!!

Up 0 Down 0

Steve E on Nov 29, 2011 at 11:52 am

Ah, best funded though. Yup, it has one of the best funded education systems in Canada, but it stinks. Keep those pizza lunches coming to boost attendance, that seems to work. This is a travesty. I see they are trying to partly blame First Nation cultural differences as usual.

Up 0 Down 0

Tom Stevens on Nov 29, 2011 at 10:08 am

Another indication of failure within the Yukon school system. I wonder if Mr.Kent will have a bigger set of kahunas than the previous Minister and seriously do something about this charade. Over and over again it has been demonstrated that for all the money being spent by Ms. Whitley and her friends there has been consistent failures. Time to really look deeply into the schools and spend some time there Mr. Kent. You will find that many are holding areas for kids with no process in place for attendance and academics. These reports do not lie. Time to stop the fluff and concentrate on schooling. If Ms. Whitley and her buddies are not prepared to do that, send them down the road. The kids of the Yukon are being horrifically punished by this Dept. of Education.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukonlinda on Nov 29, 2011 at 8:59 am

Maybe these kids shouldn't be getting so many days off! Everytime I turn around they get another four day weekend! When I was in school parent-teacher interviews happened after school, they didn't give us two full days off for them!

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.