Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

SAFEGUARDING THE TERRAIN – Christina MacDonald, Philip Merchant, Peter Harms and Chris Wilkinson (left to right) speak to the media Wednesday about the use of off-road vehicles.

‘We have miles of trails in the Yukon. Let's use them'

By releasing its 10 Common Beliefs document, the Trails Only Yukon Association (TOYA) is hoping to kick-start discussion around ATV regulations in the territory.

By Stephanie Waddell on May 22, 2014

By releasing its 10 Common Beliefs document, the Trails Only Yukon Association (TOYA) is hoping to kick-start discussion around ATV regulations in the territory.

TOYA released the document at a press conference Wednesday afternoon.

While legislation for off-road vehicle use has been passed, the group noted, there are no regulations in place.

The Yukon government is set to do consultations on the regulations this summer.

As TOYA member Peter Harms described it, having legislation with no regulations is essentially like having a car without an engine.

The 10 beliefs focus on responsible ATV use, effective education and enforcement, and various levels of ATV management for different areas (including certain areas being designated as non-motorized from April 1 to Nov. 1).

They also touch on ATV registration and requiring ATVs to travel on hard-bottom trails in alpine and sensitive wetland areas.

"We went right to the core of why are we doing this,” TOYA's Philip Merchant said of drafting the 10 points in the document.

Harms stressed that TOYA is not anti-ATV, which he commented seems to be a misconception among the public. He and many other members enjoy getting out on their ATVs, but more and more damage to the land off the trails is becoming prevalent, he said.

"We are trying to prevent damage,” he said. "We have miles of trails in the Yukon. (Let's) use them.”

With the territory being one of the last regions in the country without ATV regulations, Harms said, there are many coming from Outside, adding to the damage on the land.

In one case, he came across a visitor whose truck had a hydraulic lift to load and unload off-road vehicles.

When Harms commented on the "nice rig,” the man told him he loves the Yukon, having heard about the lack of rules on ATV use.

But that doesn't necessarily mean good news for tourism.

As Chris Wilkinson of the Wilderness Tourism Association noted, while many operators use ATVs for their tours and many tourists rent or make use of ATVs as part of their Yukon experience, they come to enjoy one of the few pristine environments left.

Wilkinson's group considered the 10 Common Beliefs document carefully before agreeing to endorse it, Wilkinson said. Members soon realized the document is important for several reasons, including the need to protect wilderness.

It recognizes the territory's large trail network allows access to the wilderness, but keeping ATVs on the trails would limit damage to the environment, he said.

Also on hand to voice support for the document was Christina Macdonald, the Yukon Conservation Society's wildlife co-ordinator. She said it presents an opportunity to create good management on ATV use.

"ORVs (off-road vehicles) are facts of life here,” Macdonald said, emphasizing the importance of public engagement for off-road vehicle regulations.

Merchant said the group also reached out to other organizations like the Yukon Fish and Games Association, Wild Wise Yukon and similar groups.

While they share a number of the same concerns as TOYA, they weren't yet ready to endorse the document.

Merchant hopes TOYA can continue working with those groups.

After hearing support from many Yukoners for regulations around ATV use, TOYA is encouraging residents to contact their MLAs and attend any consultations done on the regulations in the coming months.

Comments (9)

Up 11 Down 3

big northern man on May 27, 2014 at 5:11 am

@Roger Gillies - I think that TOYA has jumped the gun with this document and has a very narrow perspective of what YUKONERS want. Yes, I say Yukoners (not just those living in Whitehorse). This is why there is such backlash.

After some research it is clear that there has been very little consultation done, or for that matter thought.

There is some reference made to Yukon Fish and Game statistics from surveys conducted in the past (closest one was 4 years ago - that's a long time ago) and TOYA has only picked and chose what information to use.

The chart indicates that a majority of people surveyed think that there should be more regulations placed on ATV's. What does this mean? Were these regulations meant to be for Whitehorse only? Were random people surveyed from every community (this point speaks to the fact that communities may view things differently? With the ATV cards and license plates becoming more common is this what they meant? There is too much vagueness to discern what these individuals were talking about.

Regulations can mean different things to different people. TOYA needs to do some more work and then come back. It also needs representation from other individuals who can speak to the other side of the story for a proper discussion. GOOD LUCK

Up 4 Down 5

Steven shorty on May 27, 2014 at 3:47 am

I could see miles of trails but I could also see most of them move into or around first nations traditional hunting grounds........

Up 19 Down 3

Max Mack on May 26, 2014 at 2:51 pm

I think we need regulations to govern the pedestrians, campers, bicyclists and hikers that cause so much damage to our fine Yukon wilderness. Not only do their dogs crap anywhere/everywhere and chase/harass wildlife and other trail users, but they damage ecosystems by breaking and using trails, frighten wildlife, strew garbage, and all other manner of environmentally irresponsible behaviours.

Just trying to make a point, folks. Oddly, anti-ATV activists never see themselves as the problem.

Up 6 Down 17

Roger Gillies on May 26, 2014 at 6:54 am

@ mary laker

True, the founding fathers of TOYA are hunters. True, they have killed sheep.

Let's be clear though. The harvesting of these Rams is done with the greatest care and with utmost concern for the breeding population. Every scrap of meat comes down the mountain on their backs, not the backs of their ATVs.

I have hunted (unsuccessfully I might add) with these guys, and let me tell you, It is hard work. To characterize their hunting area as a "private shooting gallery" is complete nonsense. First of all, it's not "private". Anyone who wants to can put in for a permit.

If anything, yes, they might get peeved if someone uses an Argo to smash their way to the top of a mountain they climbed in silence so as not to spook every animal up there. Isn't that understandable?

These guys are conservationists, pure and simple. They are not anti-ATV. They do want to preserve the pristine high alpine for future generations and I take my hat off to them for their efforts.

All the backlash on here seems very short-sighted and self-entitled to me.

Up 28 Down 5

Pro-Science Greenie on May 24, 2014 at 1:17 am

Hands off my old ATV and sled please. If there are problems with Outsiders then deal with the Outsiders. If there are problems affecting wildlife during hunting season then deal with it in the hunting regs. If there are problems in Whitehorse city limits then let the solutions stay in city limits. If there are problems with high power machines then deal with those separately. Stop messing the all us people that use our machines like small tractors or that go slowly and drive with care.

Up 23 Down 7

Josey Wales on May 23, 2014 at 6:11 am

Yes there are many trails here indeed.

Be awesome if TOYA and their minions took the ones going south for days...and stay.

Up 14 Down 16

mary laker on May 23, 2014 at 2:49 am

The biggest concern I hear about TOYA is about their motivation. They are a group of avid hunters who have killed many, many animals for sport. Make you wonder about their true concern for the wilderness. I have heard people say they are just trying to keep others out of their own shooting gallery and that they themselves use quads to get close to herds and to haul out their dead animal trophies and meat. I would like to see these concerns openly addressed. Are there any loop holes for hunters? ie; are hunters allowed to leave the trails for the purpose of blowing away animals? I heard that there are exceptions like this, and for mineral exploration work. What are the details of the document in this regard? Where is a link to the document? I would love to get on board if this really is about keeping EVERYONE on trail, and out of sensitive areas. Including hunters and resource industry workers. I am a dirt bike rider and I do stay on trail, even avoiding flowers that are on the trail. I do want nature protected and fully agree with on trail riding only.

We do need rules, no question. Especially with outsiders traveling up here to har-har it up, tearing up the land with their recreational rigs.

Thank you Ken et al for your work, I'd love to believe in you 100% and be able to correct those with doubts about your motives, so please let us know where we can read your document in full.

Thanks.

Up 40 Down 15

Atom on May 22, 2014 at 9:00 am

Then regulate the non-resident's and stop trying to 'save' the rest of us.....regulations for this group will require hoop jumping prior to riding the ATV that I paid for.....get out of my Yukon.

Up 11 Down 16

Rider on May 22, 2014 at 7:39 am

I agree with you on many points, but please remember if you have areas that are NON-Motorized, please ensure there are signs up and clearly visible. It is nice to hear that TOYA is not totally against ATV riders & use. Although I would like to see what areas you are proposing to being designated as non-motorized from April 1 to Nov. 1.

Signage will be very important, as many of the unruly riders do not like to read pamphlets and do not usually check trail maps. Good luck with it all.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.