‘We can't let people die in houses that aren't safe'
Action from officials as well as better education are needed when it comes to oil-fired appliances in the territory, a jury has ruled.
Action from officials as well as better education are needed when it comes to oil-fired appliances in the territory, a jury has ruled.
The jury at last week's coroner's inquest into the deaths of five people from carbon monoxide poisoning in January 2012 has made nine recommendations for how to help prevent similar deaths. The jury unveiled the recommendations late Friday afternoon.
After listening to a week's worth of testimony, the jury of six ruled the deaths accidental.
Of the recommendations, two surround improving the public's education surrounding oil-fired appliances.
An ad campaign should be developed immediately to let the public know about the importance of having their masonry chimney inspected, the jury said.
A crumbling, unlined chimney, which was the inappropriate size for the heating system, led to ice, debris and soot building up and eventually trapping the deadly gas in the rented home, experts testified.
Similar problems are common around the Yukon, the jury heard.
An annual awareness campaign regarding the need for carbon monoxide detectors needs to be tied into the fire prevention programs currently taught in the Yukon education system, the jury recommended.
Carbon monoxide detectors were required according to the building code, both when a wood stove was installed in 2006 and when the oil heating system was installed three years later.
No such detectors were in the home.
The jury also calls on the government to implement recommendations from multiple studies done regarding oil-fired appliances in the Yukon.
A 2012 oil-fired appliances working group created after the tragedy recommended improved public education, training and creating an act specifically for oil-fired appliances.
But years before that, an expert was already warning the government of potential dangers.
Rod Corea completed five reports for the Yukon government between 2007 and 2010 calling attention to dangerous problems with oil-fired appliances in the territory.
In total, only four of the 305 appliances that were inspected met the safety codes, Corea testified Friday.
Corea made a number of recommendations for improving safety. When none of his recommendations were implemented, Corea refused to come back to complete more studies, the jury heard.
His recommendations also touch on the need for better education and legislation.
The trades should also improve documentation, the jury said.
This should include written information, photographs, and/or video of installation and modifications to fuel-fired appliances be included in the home's permit and inspection file.
Homeowners should be given similar written reports, the jury says.
A blank inspection checklist for oil-fired appliances should be made available online and a sticker describing inspections should be developed and placed on fuel tanks.
The jury goes as far as recommending a permit be issued before any new or used oil-fired appliance can be sold.
Inquest juries do not place criminal blame following a tragedy. Their recommendations are not legally binding.
After sitting through a week's worth of testimony, many members of the family shed tears after the recommendations were read.
Brad's brothers, Cameron and Greg, say the family will be keeping an eye on things to make sure the recommendations are implemented.
"I think the recommendations call for public awareness and for governments to push things at a faster pace,” Cameron Rusk said.
"We need to move forward. We can't hold back anymore. We can't let people die in houses that aren't safe.”
Cameron said the testimony from Corea was particularly hard to hear.
"It's hard to hear that. We always hear that governments don't do things fast enough and we've been part of that process now,” Cameron said.
Both brothers said they hope some good will be able to come out of their tragedy.
"If the recommendations here move forward, than at least we can know that they didn't die in vain,” Greg said.
Comments (6)
Up 0 Down 0
Arn Anderson on Feb 13, 2013 at 4:05 pm
Being a former renter in good ole Whitehorse I've experienced many buildings as did my friends. I won't go into the details about these places but in all honesty, landlords only care about their bottomline and not about your health, safety or circumstances.
The tenant act? Blah, if it wasn't for oil and modern thought we would still be living as serfs if we had Yukon landlords having their way.
Condolences to the family and the relatives, I hope you find inner peace regardless of what happened.
Up 0 Down 0
Slumlords A plenty here on Feb 12, 2013 at 3:45 pm
"We can't let people die in houses that are not safe"...Ummm, a word change suggested?
change can't with shouldn't and it makes more sense. You can let folks die, because you did...by the USUAL inaction on a issue despite having years of written advice from the experts that this WILL and DID in fact happen!
Slumlords up here have had a awesome time raking in the cash in the last couple decades, more so as of late. The Landlord & Tenants act I think it is called is a freaking joke and STILL has yet to be redone I believe. The many "crats" we have for "inspectors" are even more laughable than the act. If it were a G.L&TG;/temporary worker issue the crews would have jumped right on it to appease the PC Crusaders we are infected with here.
But this issue of having many folks wedged into slums and shanties many of which were never built/inspected right to begin with?
No waaaaaaay too busy trying to get Hockey Day in Canada here...re-branding our town...lacing Mt.Sima with bling...and appeasing it seems EVERY special interest group in the city and STILL are too.
Governments...ALL OF YA...at all levels, get your act together and do your freaking jobs already! Inspect things as you should PROPERLY...Fine and or SHUT DOWN contractors that just don't get it. If you use a home for revenue, like any business it must meet a certain criteria to function as a business do they not?
Case in point, Wheel chair access & fire alarm/suppression provisions are there, right?
So why the hell are the governments not "inspecting" said business called rental shanties?
I'm not a fan of governments being in every crack of ones life but I think the issues around rental property is one where they need be pro active Vs. reactive as always. Nothing gets the attention of any slumlord better then hearing...no cash comes in...till your up to code PERIOD!
but my post just as this inquiry are a waste of time here...as not a single damn thing will change.
5 dead and why...?
Up 0 Down 0
Northone on Feb 12, 2013 at 10:30 am
I for one hope YTG proceeds carefully and cautiously on this issue. If they react without considering all possible outcomes, Yukoners risk being ripped off by technicians who will jack up all their prices once any regulation saying only certified technicians can service oil burning equipment comes into effect. Also, who will service furnaces in communities outside Whitehorse if only a few technicians Yukon wide are qualified?
Everybody always calls for more and more regulations. Why not some responsibility for a change? Landlords are responsible to ensure their properties are safe for tenants and equipment is properly serviced. Homeowners have a similar responsibility to ensure their heating equipment is properly serviced. Ask your service technician if he is qualified. If you are unhappy with the answer, call someone else. Not too complicated, eh?
Up 0 Down 0
blackpowder on Feb 11, 2013 at 10:47 am
Sounds like another "made in Yukon solution"....how about this, why not adopt the standards that are in use in the REST of the country? Full adoption and following NFPA and Oil Burner codes would be a great start, heck, the Federal Fire Protection Office (that would be in HRSDC, if any Yukon Gov. staff would be bothered to look them up...) even has personnel and resources that are available to the Yukon to help us out. I read this ruling and feel that there was a big rug, but even a bigger broom to sweep things under.
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Feb 11, 2013 at 10:29 am
The government can pass all sorts of regulations to ensure that only qualified people work on heating and ventilating equipment, however unless landlords are held responsible for making their rental units meet standards then incidents like this will occur again.
Up 0 Down 0
Brice Carruthers on Feb 11, 2013 at 9:02 am
"This isn't the south! We don't need your darn regulations up here!"...How often have we heard this from contractors in every industry up here? There seems to be a culture some contractors believe in up here that implies they are entitled to huge profit margins without scrutiny, quality standards, and accountability. If some level of enforcement occurs, then they start whining. It is this same culture that leads to protests like Norcope's two summers ago. There was probably intense lobbying against regulating the oil-furnace industry. If the Yukon Government has been weak in one area, it is expecting less from our contractors (just because we live in the Yukon) and always being reactive to situations instead of being proactive to avoid a tragedy before it happens. Government needs to grow a spine, get some gumption, and make safety of the public paramount instead of coddling local contractors.