Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

TRAGIC DETAILS REVEALED – Officials answer questions from reporters this morning at a press conference held to release further information on the five people found dead in a Porter Creek house Sunday. Left to right: Whitehorse RCMP Sgt. Don Rogers, Yukon chief coroner Sharon Hanley, Whitehorse fire chief Clive Sparks and Yukon fire marshal Dennis Berry. They were speaking at the Public Safety Building atop Two Mile Hill.

‘We are confident that this is a tragic accident'

A relatively inexpensive carbon monoxide detector could have saved the lives of five people in Whitehorse last week.

By Ashley Joannou on January 31, 2012

A relatively inexpensive carbon monoxide detector could have saved the lives of five people in Whitehorse last week.

When firefighters entered the home of Bradley and Valerie Rusk last Sunday, their two children, 11-year-old Rebekah and 13-year-old Gabriel and fellow renter

Donald McNamee, the amount of carbon monoxide gas in the air was 10 times what would have been detected by a standard household machine.

It was that gas that killed them in their home in Porter Creek. They had no warning alarm.

The RCMP, Yukon coroner, fire chief and fire marshal held a press conference this morning to provide more information into the tragic deaths — the first of their kind in the city in 30 years.

Their bodies were found Sunday morning by a concerned friend. It is still unclear exactly when the deadly gas killed them.

"It could be any time from Thursday night to maybe Friday that it happened, and then they were discovered on Sunday,” said chief coroner Sharon Hanley.

Fire chief Clive Sparks said homes like the family's, built in the 1960s, do not legally require a carbon monoxide detector.

The alarms were made mandatory in residential homes when Canada's National Building Code was updated in 2005.

"For a building that age, they are not a requirement,” Sparks said.

"Anything that is built newer than about 2005 would require the alarms but in older buildings, it is not required.”

The RCMP have concluded their part of the investigation said, spokesperson Sgt. Don Rogers.

"At this point in time, we are confident that this is a tragic accident,” he said.

"If anything new comes to light, we certainly will examine that, but at this point, there is no grounds for a criminal investigation.”

The probe into the deaths is now in the hands of the coroner's office and fire marshal Dennis Berry.

Berry said his investigation is focusing on the house's heating system, which included a wood fireplace as well as an oil fire boiler system.

"This is obviously not a normal state of operations for any heating system,” he said. "The investigation is ongoing.”

The heating system was running when firefighters entered the home, Sparks said.

The fire marshal's office will eventually produce a report for the RCMP and the coroner's office.

As for who is responsible for maintaining the heating system in a rented home, Rogers said he could not comment on this case while the investigation was ongoing.

It may depend on the individual landlord/tenant agreement, he added.

Rogers said "recent” inspections were done on the heating system, but would no provide specific dates.

The family had been living in Whitehorse for four or five years and had roots in Alberta, officials said.

Fewer details were available on McNamee, who had been living in the city for about a year.

People with carbon monoxide poisoning can have such symptoms as dizziness, nausea and disorientation before eventually losing consciousness, Hanley said.

In the days leading up to their deaths, all five people appeared to have been feeling unwell.

"I can tell you that the children were absent from school the previous week, the family had been experiencing some illness, possibly flu-like symptoms, which maybe or may not be related to carbon monoxide poisoning,” Rogers said.

Both the children's schools and the parents' employers were told not to expect them that week.

McNamee, 47, had been in the hospital the previous week with an unrelated illness.

"If you take it into the context that all of these people had been experiencing known illnesses in the days previous to this. .. they may have associated any symptoms (of carbon monoxide) to the previous illness,” Rogers said.

Adding to the tragedy, officials agree, is if the deceased had kept going to work and to school, the fresh air would likely have helped clear their systems of the poison.

The last death from carbon monoxide poisoning in the city occurred about 30 years ago, Sparks said.

"From a safety prospective, certainly a carbon monoxide alarm in your home is going to help because it will warm you if the levels start to build up, and maintaining your heating system in good working order is also going to help.”

Full autopsies are not planned in this case, Hanley said, but blood from all five people is being sent to the toxicology lab in Vancouver for analysis.

See statement from the Yukon New Democrats in letters.

Comments (8)

Up 0 Down 0

eesmith on Feb 9, 2012 at 9:43 am

Dear Christopher - I completely understand your anger and frustration. The current housing situation in the Yukon enables landlords to rent out unsafe spaces - where else will renters go? And the lack of appropriate regulations lets everyone off the hook. Carbon monoxide detectors can only go so far - having proper regulations ensuring annual checks of these dangerous heating systems would have also helped. In regions of Canada where the govt actually creates and enforces life-saving regulations, it is illegal to fill oil furnaces that don't pass safety code. Of course, the YG would have to have a safety code to pass first. Ultimately, it's the government that's culpable in this tragic crime. They were grossly negligent in not informing the public of the 99% failure rate in oil & gas furnaces in the territory FIVE years ago. As for the landlord... I wonder if like every other landlord in the Yukon, they'll keep the damage deposit? Or will they return it to any surviving family members as a person with a soul would?

Up 0 Down 0

anonymous on Feb 7, 2012 at 10:15 am

"Maybe it should be mandatory that all old houses be upgraded as such before they can be rented out"

Did you even read my whole statement? It was no ones fault. I do believe though that we have to look out for ourselves in this life. No one is going to do it for us.

Up 0 Down 0

christopher mcnamee on Feb 7, 2012 at 6:00 am

@anonymous

It wasn't your family that died.

Its easy for you to just fluff it off as an accident.

I really find it funny that new houses where people live sensors are required but in older homes its not....really?

Its only $40 for the home owner?

If the sensors aren't important then why are they required on new homes?

Seems to me that if a new home needs one then any home needs one.

Up 0 Down 0

Christopher McNamee on Feb 7, 2012 at 5:54 am

So, my brother and the family he lived with is dead and the owners walk away as if nothing happened?

Its the owners of the house who are responsible to make sure that that house is suitable for living.

Its obvious to me that the locals appear to just want to wash their hands of this as none of the people who died were from there.

Up 0 Down 0

anonymous on Feb 2, 2012 at 8:44 am

I have to disagree Lenora. If a carbon monoxide detector was not available in stores then I would say it was the landlord's responsibility. However, they are available in stores so I think that it is also up to each and every one of us to protect ourselves.

It isn't about a poor person not getting what they need. They are only forty dollars. I'm sure there was a time that not all people had smoke detectors and now they do.

Unfortunately they died but you know that until an accident happens people are not safety conscious. Houses built after 2005 are now required to install carbon monoxide detectors but that doesn't mean that all landlords should be held responsible for their tenants if they have an old house. Maybe it should be mandatory that all old houses be upgraded as such before they can be rented out but until that happens landlords will just expect their tenants to get a carbon monoxide detector.

If these people had owned their own house would you blame them? No, it's just an accident. With accidents comes knowledge of how not to repeat what has happened in the future.

Up 0 Down 0

Lenora Minet on Feb 1, 2012 at 5:57 am

My deepest condolences to the families and all effected by this senseless, preventable accident.

I have to wonder how many other people could be affected by this same exact problem. The landlords and Owners should be held accountable. There needs to be mandatory testing, for all... poor and rich.

Up 0 Down 0

Jaymanc on Jan 31, 2012 at 11:18 pm

Now did they own the house, or were they renting it out. How old was the furnace? Had it been inspected?

Up 0 Down 0

Pierre Garneau on Jan 31, 2012 at 8:34 am

I am sadden to learn that a friend and ex co worker of mine at Shipyards Park in the summer of 2010 has passed away along with his family and boarder.. My deepest condolences to his family and my thoughts are currently with you. Working with him everyday that summer I grew fond of a family man who talked highly of his kids, wife and his love for the country and landscape that surrounded us at Shipyards Park. RIP Bradley, You along with your family and boarder will be missed.

Pierre Garneau.

Ps. Any news on their dog ? I know he used to bring his dog to work with him while at the park..

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.