Turmoil surrounding animal shelter continues unabated
Amidst multiple court cases, the Humane Society Yukon (HSY) has been forced to lay off four employees.
By Ashley Joannou on November 20, 2012
Amidst multiple court cases, the Humane Society Yukon (HSY) has been forced to lay off four employees.
It has also postponed its annual general meeting (AGM) and is having nearly $40,000 in funding withheld by the Yukon government.
The Mae Bachur Animal Shelter, which the society runs, is full of animals and doesn't have enough money nor space to take care of more animals, acting president Shelley Cuthbert said in a statement Monday.
"As a not-for-profit business, decisions have to be made all the time. It was necessary to lay off four casual staff at this time to decrease expenses,” Cuthbert said.
A legal hearing in Yukon Supreme Court, originally scheduled for today, has now been postponed until December.
The Supreme Court case revolves around a report by the territory's registrar of societies earlier this year.
It found the society lacked the appropriate financial records and was banning members from the Tlingit Street shelter without cause.
Registrar Fred Pretorius also ordered an annual general meeting be held and a new board elected.
Not long after the orders were issued, the humane society said it was planning on seeking a jurisdictional review in Supreme Court.
No application for judicial review has been filed, the registrar says in court documents.
Instead, the registrar has also gone to Yukon Supreme Court, asking a judge to enforce his rulings.
On Monday, Supreme Court Justice Leigh Gower decided to delay the society's AGM, which was originally scheduled for the coming Friday.
"The idea was to have that hearing before the AGM,” Tom Ullyett, assistant deputy minister, legal services explained Monday.
"Now that the hearing has been postponed, the AGM also needed to be postponed.”
It will be up to the court to set a new date for the AGM, Ullyett said.
Charges have also been laid in in territorial court against board members.
In court today, all five board members pleaded not guilty.
They will appear in court next month to set a date for trial. In her statement, Cuthbert insists the shelter is not closed and will have to wait for spaces to free up before it can accept more animals.
"HSY and staff have not wasted money on anything, as it has all gone to the care of the animals and the maintenance of the building,” she said.
Costs for the case involving the registrar are covered by insurance.
Costs for a second legal fight over the construction of a cat trailer are coming from the government, as it paid for half of the trailer, she said.
One person has been donating to the society specifically to help cover legal costs.
It costs approximately $450,000 annually to run the shelter, Cuthbert said.
Among those costs are $20,000 a month in staff wages, $4,000 a month in building utilities and $5,000 a month in vet care bills.
"This runs the shelter operating total to a base amount of $29,000 per month before any other miscellaneous costs,” the statement said.
"Our base funding is only $79,000 per year, and the rest is raised on bingos, fund-raising and adoptions.
"The shelter also has several special needs animals in foster care that HSY has been paying for.”
However, half of that $79,000 is currently being withheld by the government.
It's common practice for organizations to receive half of approved government funding at the beginning of the year and half in the fall, Matt King, a spokesperson for the Department of Community Services, said today.
"But we can't advance money to an organization that is not in good standing.”
Once the humane society straightens out the registrar's concerns and complies with any orders that may come from the court, it should be able to receive the money, King said.
The shelter opened 14 years ago this month.
Comments (10)
Up 0 Down 0
Jackie Ward on Nov 29, 2012 at 5:02 pm
Gee, what a load of sick comments. Just kill them because they are no use to anyone? Every living being deserves to live, period. Just humans playing God. Truth of the matter is humans can't even manage themselves. Maybe we all should have that same attitude with your guys grandparents. If they are sick, your attitude should remain the same. Cull the herd. Doesn't that just sound stupid? Why is it ok for you to just kill animals when they become inconvenient? Obviously you blood thirsty commenters don't own a pet or never have. And I pray to God you never do. Have a heart, something that's missing out of this world, replaced by the almighty dollar. Pathetic.
Up 0 Down 0
Joel on Nov 29, 2012 at 11:00 am
Just because all humans are animals, does not make all animals human.
Up 0 Down 0
Atom on Nov 29, 2012 at 7:56 am
To the MarkKelly who replied to Mark Kelly (?).....animals are not humans.
UNJUST (not cool to use all-caps...ever) would be subject to discussion and interpretation.
Get over the passion for sickly, infirm and deranged mutts, no matter how they got that way.
Up 0 Down 0
DG on Nov 29, 2012 at 7:17 am
"Animals are human too"?? Not. Animals are animals. I agree with the comments that, as sad as it is, cats and dogs are not endangered and I think that euthanizing may be the best option for aged or ill dogs, rather than have them suffer and take away money and resources from other more adoptable animals. Also it would be much better if owners got their animals spayed and nutered BEFORE there is an over population of unwanted animals.
Up 0 Down 0
MarkKelly on Nov 29, 2012 at 12:22 am
First Off, Mr. Kelly, that's like sending your children to their grandmothers, and sayings its okay kids, grandpa's dead but at least he's dead so grandma can save money.
Dogs are like people, and they should be treated as so. It's people like you that give animal volunteers no luck in trying to succeed with what there doing.
Second off, it is against the law to kill an animal with an UNJUST cause. People were let go, because they don't need that many handlers. The animal shelter runs fine, even with the over animals.
I think the city should fund the only non-kill animal shelter in the Yukon. Change the prices around to get more fosterparents for the animals, and everyone should get over it.
Animals are Human too, and they should have a right to have what we have. A HOME.
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Nov 28, 2012 at 11:14 am
Mark is right. The shelter is failing because the people in charge are not making the hard decisions needed to run an effective animal shelter. Dogs and cats are NOT endangered species. Do the right thing and cull the herd.
Up 0 Down 0
Mark Kelly on Nov 27, 2012 at 9:48 pm
If they would start putting these useless animals down, and stop wasting space and money. Who the hell wants to adopt a dog thats 14 years old just to have it die on their kids.
Thats why they want to keep certain people out of the organization.
Up 0 Down 0
It just seems so simple... on Nov 21, 2012 at 3:38 pm
It would seem to me the the HSY is fully functioning, and is functioning well past its capacity.
Perhaps the change needs to happen with the animal owners...
Spay and Neuter your pets!
That there was over 30 puppies surrendered to the shelter this week alone...For Shame!
Making another group responsible for something easily dealt with before it happens...that's just wrong.
Just leaves me beside myself.
Up 0 Down 0
stan rogers on Nov 20, 2012 at 1:46 pm
OK
I have had enough. We need the Humane Society Yukon (HSY)to be fully functioning.
The dysfunctional recent past has to stop immediately.
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Nov 20, 2012 at 10:56 am
The government should run the shelter and hire 'animal lovers' as staff. The long standing and on-going problems with shelter administration demonstrate that 'animal lovers' are not qualified to make the pragmatic administrative decisions which a viable shelter requires.