Photo by Whitehorse Star
Tony Palmer
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Tony Palmer
With the Alaska government onside and decades-old Canadian legislation favouring TransCanada,
With the Alaska government onside and decades-old Canadian legislation favouring TransCanada, company vice-president Tony Palmer didn't come to Whitehorse yesterday to sell the Alaska Highway Pipeline so much as to trumpet what he believes is a fait accompli.
Speaking at the Yukon Inn to a lunch crowd who paid $25 for sandwiches, salad and a chance to hear Palmer, the pipeline czar delivered a meat and potatoes lesson on my-way-or-the-highway developmental economics.
Here's Palmer on TransCanada's negotiation tactic with first nations on the pipeline's right-of-way:
"We are a commercial party, looking to do a commercial transaction with first nations, individual first nations or groups, as they see fit, in order to advance the project to a successful conclusion. That's our mandate. That's what we will be focused on.
"We'll be focused on bringing them specific benefits that can advance their entities and advance their agendas, but TransCanada will not be involved in individual land claims.
"And I will also tell you that this project cannot wait for land claims. This project, we have a right-of-way, have held a right-of-way since 1983 through the entire Yukon. It's a valid right-of-way and we will use that right-of-way to advance the project."
And the project, if it goes ahead, would be one of the largest of its kind ever attempted in North America.
Pegged at $26 billion US to construct, the 2,744-km pipeline would be capable of shipping five billion cubic feet of natural gas per day from Prudhoe Bay, Alaska to Boundary Lake, Alberta and on to customers in Canada and the Lower 48.
To date, the United States government has offered $18 billion US in loan guarantees to back the project (with word that figure could climb to $30 billion US).
On Tuesday, Palmer highlighted Alaska's cash commitment and TransCanada's stake in the action.
"The State of Alaska is prepared to advance $500 million of their money to advance this project and TransCanada is advancing more than $100 million of our money over the next four or five years to advance this project so you can see how committed we are as a company."
Despite 2014 being the earliest construction could begin, Palmer would not speculate on the cost projections five years down the road, nor potential increases to U.S. loan guarantees, except to say new figures from TransCanada would be available soon.
"At the present time, our latest capital cost estimate that we completed in 2007 had a $26 billion US cost to the project from Prudhoe Bay to Alberta.
"We'll have a new cost estimate in about a year's time and we'll put that out to the public when it's finished."
While Palmer was not offering an up-to-date price tag, he was more than forthcoming on benefits for Yukoners. Here's TransCanada's lead Alaska Highway pipeliner on the riches for the territory if the project cuts through the Yukon:
"If this project is successful, you will see massive construction jobs, you'll certainly see access to natural gas as consumers in the Yukon, which is significant because I know how high fuel bills can be here as they are in Alaska.
"But I will also highlight what the direct taxes will be in the Yukon from this pipeline.
"These are solely direct property taxes and income taxes from the pipeline - no spin-off jobs, no spin-offs or multipliers - they are $3,300 per Yukoner, per year, for 25 years. That is a massive amount of taxes that we will be paying if we can make this project a success, all to the benefit of Yukoners."
Based on 34,000 people who currently reside in the Yukon, that's $2.8 billion.
But before pipeline excitement reaches fever pitch, TransCanada must be able to sell potential customers on its ability to get gas to market at a competitive rate.
This period of wheeling and dealing is known as open season, and is expected to get underway this time next year, concluding in July 2010.
Palmer said if customers commit their gas to Asia or the southern states in the Lower 48, the Yukon could be skipped altogether in favour of building a parallel pipeline to Valdez.
There, gas would be converted to liquid (LNG) and shipped out of Alaska.
But with no LNG plant at the oil transfer station at Valdez, and little interest by third parties to build one, piping the gas south remains the most viable option.
In answering concerns about the difficulties in building a buried four-foot diametre pipeline through the Alaskan, Yukon and B.C. terrain, Palmer said it would be easier than when TransCanada had to blast "foot-by-foot" through the Canadian shield in Ontario.
He also offered assurances that TransCanada's construction methods were as sound as its authority to build the pipeline.
"We're not proposing to apply 1978 standards for something we're going to build in 2014/2015.
"However, the go-no-go decision on this project has been made. It will not be revisited. So what we're talking about is meeting the standards of 2014/2015."
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (6)
Up 0 Down 0
Francias Pillman on Jun 4, 2009 at 1:53 pm
Its rather sad. The environment and animals are only looked at in one light, money, money, money.Who cares about jobs, leave some things alone, haven't us useless humans done enough damage? I'm not an eviromentalist, I just have a brain. Unlike you buffoons who exploit everything this earth has given us.
Up 0 Down 0
armin on Jun 4, 2009 at 6:17 am
Why does everyone want a piece of everyone else's pie. I don't think anyone really understand how big and huge this progject really is 26 billion dollars is a lot of money and even though the gas won't be refined in the Yukon, yukoners will see the banfits of this project from trades jobs like welding and steel work to engineers and drafts men and women. With more then likely a huge support staff as well.
Let me give you an example right now I'm working in Alberta at shell scotford working on the upheader expansion 1 project this job is a 8.6 billion dollar job and eight now with all trades and people on site we have a workforce of over 1600 people that's not including all the jobs that went into prefab and modules.
No matter what happens the goverment and the people should try and get there hands out of the cookie jar and think about the work and economic bonuses that this job will bring to a place that needs it badly. Wouldn't it be a shame if they said there is just too my poltics and geedyness and went for the next option of just bypasing the Yukon, it would be a sad loss
Up 0 Down 0
Francias Pillman on Jun 1, 2009 at 6:40 pm
Look at his face, lol. I don't trust him. Hey mr tim,, who cares what it is. It could be kool aid in the pipes. The point is, the money generated will go right past all the community's its near. PERIOD
Take your failed pipelines elsewhere.
The animals have told me to pass this message along.
If their words fall upon deaf ears, well, the moose have some funny games in store for your made in china pipeline dreams.
Up 0 Down 0
Arn Anderson on Jun 1, 2009 at 10:25 am
Doesnt matter, where there is gas there is oil, and still the POINT stands.
Up 0 Down 0
Tim Howell on May 31, 2009 at 2:13 pm
It's gas, not oil read first then engage brain
Up 0 Down 0
Arn Anderson on May 27, 2009 at 10:50 am
Yup, pump those profits right by us. Why not develop an oil refinery in Whitehorse? That makes too much sense and I dont expect YTG regardless of whose in power to pick it up.
On the issue of right of way thats a joke, old legeslation brought back in todays world. Another failure of democracy where old out of date dead legeslation still governs us in todays world. Wake up MPs and start chuckin it out of the door instead of worrying about useless stuff.