Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

THE BIG MOMENT – The ribbon at the tiny homes project on Sixth Avenue is cut on Friday afternoon. From left to right are Community Services Minister John Streicker, Patricia Bacon, the executive director of the Blood Ties Four Directions Centre, Nick Hull of Ketza Construction and Tony Zedda, the co-owner of Kobayashi and Zedda.

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

200-SQUARE-FOOT SITE – The homes feature a washroom (with toilet and shower), kitchen (with microwave and sink) and loft-style bed upstairs.

Thinking small: five tiny homes unveiled

The territory officially cut the ribbon on its newest tiny homes project on Sixth Avenue on Friday afternoon.

By Palak Mangat on January 21, 2019

The territory officially cut the ribbon on its newest tiny homes project on Sixth Avenue on Friday afternoon.

Five of the city’s most vulnerable are slated to make the move into the $800,000 sites by around the end of March.

That move will be facilitated by the Blood Ties Four Directions Centre, the organization behind the project.

It will begin a staggered move into the five sites (one home of which was already built years ago).

“I think we’re excited to be in the next stage now, to have people (go) into the units,” said Patricia Bacon, Blood Ties’ executive director.

Among those on hand for the ribbon-cutting, Bacon has been involved with the project since at least the last year and a half.

“Homelessness’ cause has been mired in myth and misunderstandings, and the homeless have been victims of hatred, stigma and violence,” she told a crowd gathered on Sixth Avenue and Jarvis Street.

While she acknowledged it’s easy for people to say “why can’t we just build more housing, for those of us in the know, we know that the fix isn’t as simple as a hammer and a nail.”

Making the dream a reality has been a process, to say the least.

“I learned resolving homelessness is about relationships and a lot of coffee,” Bacon smiled, referencing the lengths to which the board and her went to secure funding, for instance.

The project received a $100,000 nod from the territorial government through its Community Development Fund while Ottawa pitched in $100,000 through its Homelessness Partnering Strategy and a number of private donors made other contributions.

In partnership with the feds, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. and the Yukon Housing Corp. (YHC), there was an additional $200,000 put toward making the homes what they are today.

The city also granted just under $15,000 last summer to help cover demolition and development costs, with Bacon noting a big chunk of the $800,000 all-in price included buying the land.

Friday afternoon’s event came complete with a chance to tour some of the houses.

They feature a washroom (with toilet and shower), kitchen (with microwave and sink) and loft-style bed up at the top accessible via the stairs – all within a 200-square-foot site.

Noting they were furnished, Bacon explained the original design was fairly similar to what she was standing before, save for a couple minor changes like raising the roof on some of the homes.

“For people staying for long-term, not being able to stand up in the loft, that can get tiresome,” she said.

Those expected to move into the site are to be Blood Ties clients, after the group does an intake period and assesses what their housing needs are as well as other social challenges (like accessing health care, for example).

That’s important, Bacon said, because some who she’s shown the sites to think it’s too small or doesn’t meet their needs in other ways.

That’s why there will be a “sweet spot” the group will look for on the scoring of the vulnerability assessment tool it will use to determine who is best suited for that type of home.

“We should not be thinking a one-size-fits-all is the right model for every person who is precariously housed,” she explained, noting it may be a good choice for only a select few Blood Ties serves.

For instance, that includes those who want to have a sense of mastery and control of their space, “but not too much space that it presents challenges around guest management and those kinds of things.”

She also acknowledged that a 20-unit apartment building, on the other hand, with shared hallways and greater traffic may not be the best call for others, depending on their situation.

The group expects there to be a mix of men and women at the site, with the goal of integrating residents in to the larger city’s community.

“About five on one lot is good, but we’re not necessarily feeling like we should congest and put all people who are poor or use drugs in one big apartment group.

“That’s kind of ghettoizing people and it further marginalizes them.

“All people belong in all communities, and the tiny house community is part of the bigger (one),” she smiled.

The centre first built a tiny house, dubbed the Steve Cardiff House, in 2012, with the aim of providing safe, secure and transition housing for a client up to a year.

That house was eventually put into storage, but the board quickly began to think of ways to further its mission and support others in a similar situation.

That was after 2016, which saw the structure house five different people but sit on an undeveloped lot not owned by Blood Ties.

Put into storage until a more permanent home could be found, it will now be nestled neatly between four other homes to create the Steve Cardiff Tiny House Community.

Community Services Minister John Streicker said it was great to see it become a reality after recalling first touring the site when it was full of pits in its early stages.

“It’s really nice to see things happening,” he said, “where we can see a place that’s going to be more inclusive and allow us to embrace the diversity of our community and support people where they are at.”

It was also a fitting tribute to a man who did so much for the community, he said.

Cardiff was a Yukon NDP MLA who died in a highway collision south of Whitehorse in the summer of 2011.

Meanwhile, Yukon MP Larry Bagnell, representing the feds, joined Kobayashi and Zedda (KZA) co-owner Tony Zedda at the event as well.

“They say a community is judged by how it treats its most vulnerable,” Bagnell said, “and the fact there’s so many people in -16 C shows how great the Yukon is in that, and how much you care.

“Nothing is more important than a home, I’m sure most of you know,” the MP added.

He reminded onlookers of Ottawa’s $40-billion National Housing Strategy unveiled in 2017, which aims to reduce chronic homelessness by 50 per cent in the lead-up to the decade after.

Meanwhile, KZA, the Whitehorse-based architecture and planning firm behind the design of the homes, acknowledged it had been a fun, difficult but rewarding process.

“This is an example ... when a group of people called a community come together and try to think about their fellow human being and how to help them find housing,” Zedda smiled.

“It’s through this effort of the community that we have this today,” he added. It can open the door for other projects down the road to be considered as well, he added.

With the end goal to have the homes filled come the end of March, Bacon added that the moves could begin as early as February.

Comments (27)

Up 21 Down 1

William Thad Flannigan [WTF!] on Jan 25, 2019 at 3:29 pm

The first part of the headline really explains it all. It is a capacity issue. Thinking small. They certainly are. This is the problem with politics and politicians and it is one that is really amplified in this small town. The Yukon fish-bowl.

I agree with jean - Virtue signalling ignorance. Expensive virtue signalling ignorance to boot.

I agree in principle with Juniper - Equalizing the playing field for the illusion of equality is contemptuously stupid. That is an irresponsibly dangerous message to give to people - regardless of your efforts and abilities you’re all the same, you get the same, you deserve the same.

Heck - We could do away with elections though. That might be good. Anyone over 18 has their name placed into a draw - Just think - That individual who was just convicted of a sexual assault could be the next Justice Minister. The guy who was just convicted of cutting that guys face a while back could be the next Health and Social Minister.

Why not? Everyone is equal. There is no more good or bad. As Judge Cozens reminded us rather poignantly there is the likelihood that they are not guilty anyway, at least legally so perhaps.

Up 25 Down 0

jean on Jan 24, 2019 at 7:36 pm

Dinky Houses are a fad designed by architects and 'planners' to create very expensive virtue signals for social housing. They're almost entirely built with public tax dollars. The per-square-foot cost of Dinky Houses is outrageous, unless you're an architect/developer laughing all the way to the bank. Very few people in the real world are building them because they all know you can build a lot more house for the same money.
The one small group this makes sense for are those who are illegally squatting on public land or a friend's rural residential lot. The wheeled portability of these trailer cabins make them an easy way around the land laws for some.

Up 24 Down 1

Juniper Jackson on Jan 24, 2019 at 5:59 pm

"The better approach is to have neigbourhoods that integrate all walks of life so that there is no upper or lower class neighbourhoods."

Mr. Mangus: personally, I'm upper poor, live within my means, my income never goes up as much as the price of trying to live; I find myself constantly battling increases.. that being said, so you don't think I'm wealthy, on the defensive.. IF I ever had any money, I am never going to put it in a home with the 'vulnerable', the street people that 'deserve' a roof living next door. IF I had money to put into a home, it's going to be in a neighborhood with incomes akin to my own, that I might have something in common with my neighbors, where needles in the park might not be an every day event..or the pet stopping to smell the puke on the sidewalk...

I also feel there is not a damned thing wrong with upper class/lower class/no class. Why should I with High School and 2 years of U of A be in the same 'class' as the guy that went to school for 15 years and is now saving my life? or pet, or putting a rocket into space? I detest the current trend which is..if you have $900 but I only have $700 the gov takes a $100 away from you and gives it to me, so we both have $800 but only one of us worked for it. Just sayin'.. I believe you should get what you deserve to get.

Up 3 Down 20

Hugh Mungus on Jan 24, 2019 at 2:23 pm

@ Jim who said "But to suggest that no matter what the cost, everyone deserves the same standard of living"
I never said or suggested that. What I said was:

"The better approach is to have neigbourhoods that integrate all walks of life so that there is no upper or lower class neighbourhoods."

That means you wouldn't have RR designations and the like but you could have modest homes/apartments mixed with higher priced homes/condos. So no ghettos and no exclusive 'hoods.

Up 19 Down 0

Groucho d'North on Jan 24, 2019 at 11:42 am

What's old is new again. At the height of the gold rush Dawson City or more properly Louse Town district to the south of Dawson City had a collection of these tiny houses, back then they were called cribs and were used by the "Soiled Doves" or prostitutes of the era.

Up 21 Down 2

lmao on Jan 24, 2019 at 10:07 am

$160,000.00?
North Point or Chaperral fifth wheel will cost you less ... and it sleeps 11. Plus it's mobile.
https://www.rvingplanet.com/blog/top-5-best-fifth-wheels-for-full-time-living/

What the f**k were they thinking?
Also, why would you use materials that are weak? Here comes another horde of "someone punched a hole in the wall so we had to replace" contracts...

Up 23 Down 1

Jim on Jan 23, 2019 at 7:00 pm

@ Hugh Mungus - not sure if you understood my comment. What I was saying is that apartment living has been the norm for a lot of people. Not just the criminals, drug users and dealers. But being in an apartment does not have anything to do with “ghetto”.
But to suggest that no matter what the cost, everyone deserves the same standard of living no matter if they are drug users, criminals or your average working family is communism. What you would be looking for would be government funded social housing for all. The only difference would be watering down the criminal and drug elements so that everyone has a share.
Most of us in our life time have lived in apartments, trailers or shared accommodation without being a ghetto. Let’s at least use the money we are wasting on these pet projects to help as many homeless as we can without the photo-ops.

Up 16 Down 1

martin on Jan 23, 2019 at 6:29 pm

Affordable housing is if a medium wage earner worker can afford it. Not this case. Good publicity stands for politicians. A medium-paid worker not smiling. Got to love the Yukon how we like to lie to ourselves.

Up 18 Down 20

Lost In the Yukon on Jan 23, 2019 at 2:56 pm

Bravo to Bloodties and Patricia Bacon. You may not agree with the concept but at least someone did something to address the housing situation of the hardest to house.

Blood ties didn't ask for money to do yet another study, something this current government does as well if not better than previous ones, they presented an idea, got buy in from key partners and got it off the ground. Good for them.

If people are mad about the cost of this project then it should be directed at Pauline Frost, Sandy Silver and John Streaker because of their lack of vision, leadership and action.

Power to now get things done in Yukon now lies outside of the elected officials, the elected government. Sandy Silver has surrendered his Premiership to others.

Up 23 Down 0

BnR on Jan 23, 2019 at 2:04 pm

PHOTO OP!!!!!!!
And WTF is Streicker doing in the photo? Having a tug-O-war?

Up 5 Down 24

Hugh Mungus on Jan 23, 2019 at 1:21 pm

@ Jim on Jan 22
The ghettoizing occurs when a building or neighborhood has all people of the same class/economic standing in a single spot. Surely you driven through the DTES of Vancouver, Canada's poorest neighbourhood. It's rife with crime, drugs, prostitution, etc., and the city of Vancouver has has turned a blind eye as poor people have no option but to live there regardless of whether they are addicts or criminals. Right now the people living in the DTES are being evicted as gentrification is happening and Gastown is pushing in putting up Condos and cafes on former squats.

The better approach is to have neigbourhoods that integrate all walks of life so that there is no upper or lower class neighbourhoods.

Up 20 Down 2

Woodcutter on Jan 23, 2019 at 10:14 am

Nice places of you can get in for free.

Up 38 Down 4

Jim on Jan 22, 2019 at 6:52 pm

So when did apartment living become ghettoizing? Most of us all started out renting apartments or basement suites. Some even lived at the old YWCA in the cluster rooms. Basically private bedrooms with shared living quarters. It was cheap, and it worked. For some reason the myth of the homeless is they need private stand alone buildings without shared hallways so they have a sense of mastery and control of space. I guess in a perfect world we would all love that. But if we can use the same amount of money to put a warm roof over twice or three times as many people, that should be the goal first. Till then be a little humble and thankful for a roof over your head.

Up 42 Down 4

db on Jan 22, 2019 at 3:21 pm

How did this project even get the go ahead? This proves the incompetency of shameless politicians in wasting OUR money. I’m thinking a job requirement for senior personnel making these decisions on our behalf should require proven moral judgment and a bachelor of commerce to know the difference between waste and feasible expenditures.

Up 44 Down 2

Atom on Jan 22, 2019 at 11:57 am

Wow. Nick and Tony are happy! 800K.

Real Estate and land development in Yukon is F#^*%$!
Politicians, City and YG land depts need a good smackin!

Up 52 Down 5

Darrell Drugstore's smartest neighbour on Jan 22, 2019 at 10:10 am

Wouldn't a 5 unit row house be WAY more efficient to build
and heat and maintain ?

This was a really stupid thing to do methinks.

Up 39 Down 6

Peter Watters on Jan 21, 2019 at 11:19 pm

Waste of money. Someone's getting raped here for sure.

Up 48 Down 5

Peta-hazel Hazel on Jan 21, 2019 at 10:47 pm

Government only knows how to waste public funds. They will build ghettos for the homeless because rather than talk to those who know about housing in a smaller footprint, they will hire Architects who cannot think below their fee structure and come up two hundred sq ft at $160k which is not affordable for anyone on the poverty line.
Why not use $800k to make land available for true tiny house community with infrastructure in place so those who believe in a lower footprint on the environment can build their own structures and hereby having a wider cross section of people living in very safe neighborhood for larger public good

Up 53 Down 4

Even Higher on Jan 21, 2019 at 8:44 pm

Upon reading the article, I see that there were only 4 homes for the $800,000. One was the existing tiny home that was in storage now “be nestled neatly between the 4 other homes”. So I’m guessing that puts the square footage price up to about $1000.00 per foot. For the amount of money we have spent on buildings like the Salvation Army, apartments for vulnerable that don’t want to get off drugs and this type of project there should not be one soul living on the street.

Up 46 Down 2

Gringo on Jan 21, 2019 at 5:43 pm

$800,000 man....”Zedda said with a smile”..that about sums it up.

Up 55 Down 2

jean on Jan 21, 2019 at 5:38 pm

This is NOT the most effective way to spend limited social housing resources. This is NOT affordable housing. This dinky house fad costs much more per sq-ft to build as compared with a multi-unit building. A 12-plex of apartments could have been built for the same amount of taxpayer funding, and would cost half as much per unit to heat and maintain.
Money wouldn't be wasted on this fad if it wasn't taxpayer subsidized.

Up 47 Down 3

Dont Bring Home the Bacon! on Jan 21, 2019 at 5:31 pm

@ Thomas et al. - That explains the Whse real estate market. At 800 per square foot my 2000 square foot home is now worth $1,600,000. I am rich! I can now retire and afford to buy a home in Vancouver!

What a way to end homelessness!
Why are these people still in office? Can’t we impeach them? Can we hold a vote of non-confidence?

This is asinine!

Up 42 Down 4

Jerry from Queens on Jan 21, 2019 at 5:27 pm

It took a diverse team of stakeholders to coordinate and see this awful idea come to fruition. Keep up the great work!

Up 48 Down 5

Rod on Jan 21, 2019 at 5:04 pm

Wonder how long these will take to get destroyed!

Up 81 Down 21

Facepalm on Jan 21, 2019 at 4:09 pm

$800,000 to create a trailer-park guaranteed to be filled with drug addicts in the middle of a residential area. You just can't make stuff like this up lol

Up 85 Down 8

Joe on Jan 21, 2019 at 4:00 pm

What a waste of money. Could have built twice that many units for that budget if they went multi. No more donations from me.

Up 99 Down 5

Thomas Brewer on Jan 21, 2019 at 3:17 pm

$160,000 per unit at 200 sq feet is an INSANE $800 / sq foot, likely one of the most expensive residential building costs in the entire Yukon.

Who the hell green lights projects like this??

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.