Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Pictured Above: ROSS FINDLATER and LIZ HANSON

Tenters expected to set down new stakes

The co-chair of the Yukon Anti-Poverty Coalition says all signs point to another tent city appearing somewhere in Whitehorse as soon as the weather gets warm enough.

By Ashley Joannou on April 11, 2012

The co-chair of the Yukon Anti-Poverty Coalition says all signs point to another tent city appearing somewhere in Whitehorse as soon as the weather gets warm enough.

Ross Findlater says he and others who work with the territory's hard-to-house are incredibly frustrated that not much has changed since last summer's headline-grabbing protest.

For about five months starting last June, as many as 40 tents were set up in the shadow of the Yukon legislature to draw attention to the lack of affordable housing in the territory.

"I can't see how things have changed since last year,” Findlater told the Star this morning.

"The population continues to grow and we still have a near zero vacancy rate,” he said. "There still remains a huge need for housing here, and so I would not be the least bit surprised if it (tent city) happens somewhere.”

Last year's tent city campers remained until November.

Last Nov. 9, the White Pass and Yukon Route, the transportation company which owns some of the land, helped the remaining tenters move about three metres closer to the government building, onto YTG land.

Nine days later, the government gave campers 48 hours to leave.

Officials with the Department of Health and Social Services said the eviction notice was prompted by concerns for the individuals' health, as temperatures continued to drop.

Two remaining campers at the time were offered alternative accommodations.

Findlater said the coalition and other groups met with officials from the territorial and city governments and local First Nations last summer while tent city was in place.

All agreed that housing is an important issue, he said.

"The question for me is: how much will exists in the decision makers to improve the housing situation for all Yukoners?”

One suggestion for the City of Whitehorse was to expand the Robert Service Campground.

"Robert Service is a Band-Aid solution, but at least it would meet the need during the year when it's possible to camp,” Findlater said.

City manager Dennis Shewfelt said expanding the campground onto the land north of the softball diamonds is still something the city is considering and is a possibility for the future.

But it did not make the cut for this year's budget.

Instead, Shewfelt said the city is focusing on supply — making space for people to build new homes.

The sale of new homes will open up rentals for others looking for a place to live, he said.

The additional camping space, which would expand the size of the Robert Service Campground by about 50 per cent, would take about one building season to prepare, Shewfelt said.

During question period Tuesday, Opposition Leader Liz Hanson questioned whether the government is trying to prevent the return of tent city by proposing changes to the Financial Administration Act.

"The Act to Amend the Financial Administration Act would allow for the creation of regulations respecting the management, maintenance, proper use and protection of public property and confer power on the ministers for enforcement,” she said.

Hanson criticized the government for not informing other MLAs about the proposed changes.

"It has been a well-established custom for the members of this House to receive briefings on new legislation or on amendments to legislation the government is intending to bring forward,” she said.

Brad Cathers, the government's house leader, said the practice has been for the government to provide briefings on major or comprehensive pieces of legislation.

On more minor amendments, he said, the practice has been to bring them before the house and permit opposition MLAs to ask questions during the committee of the whole sessions.

"There will be the opportunity for members to get into detailed questions and detailed responses by the ministers responsible ... at that time,” Cathers said.

"I would encourage the member to direct her questions to the minister and to officials during debate.”

Even if campers are not allowed on the government's lawn, they will find somewhere else to put down stakes, Findlater said.

And no one should be surprised, he added.

"It's so predictable,” he said.

"You don't need to be a rocket scientist to know that if there is a problem and nothing changes, it's going to grow.”

Suggestions for remedies during last year's tent city included having the government buy the Westmark Klondike Inn and/or the old Canadian Tire building, or using the old medical practitioners' residence off Hospital Road.

None of these ideas came to fruition.

The government, for its part, has pointed to such initiatives as making a parcel of land near the Range Road-Mountainview Drive intersection available for affordable housing development.

Comments (25)

Up 0 Down 0

Robin Reid-Fraser on Apr 21, 2012 at 3:54 am

Woah...I'm seeing a lot of comments here that are basically implying that if a person doesn't have the resources to pay for housing at whatever the current market price is, they don't have the right to live there.

The consequence of that approach is gentrification, in which places that historically had low housing prices become attractive to people who could afford to pay more and by moving to those areas change the socioeconomic landscape and cause those low prices to rise. This can force out people who previously lived there because it was the only housing which actually WAS affordable to them.

The diversity of housing options is reflective of the diversity of socioeconomic status that makes up the community. Their prices/rental rates should also be reflective of that.

The problem is that the Yukon is experiencing an economic boom that is bringing in all of these people to work, but the availability of housing has not kept up with that. This is causing ALL types of housing to become more expensive, even the places that are normally available for folks who don't have high-paying jobs.

DG I find your remarks particularly insensitive to the reality that many members of our community face serious problems of substance abuse, mental illness and/or physical disability.

What your comment fails to reflect is the fact that the process of white colonization - particularly the administration of residential schools, in which countless cases of mental, physical and cultural trauma occurred - continue to have severe impacts to this day and are at the root of much of the poverty and unstable housing.

You say that people do not deserve to live here if they cannot support themselves, and yet the ones who are most impacted by the current situation are also those whose ancestors were stripped of their land and culture by European colonists in the first place.

Please be considerate to the fact that most people who are chronically unemployed and/or abuse substances and/or without stable housing have not chosen those life circumstances. I imagine that most would change their situation in an instant if they could. However, living on the street is not conducive to the consistent, long-term recovery process that is required. Studies have shown that substance abusers have a much higher chance of recovering if they have a secure place to live before they start the detoxification process.

To respond to the folks who are criticizing Tent City based on the fact that Robert Service campground is just around the corner, I see your point. If the tent city was JUST a bunch of young people looking for free camping for the summer, then I would find that criticism totally valid. However, the campground does not serve the needs of people who legitimately need a year-round place to stay.

I think the comments here reflect the fact that the tent city was a physical representation of an amalgamation of issues. Homelessness is one that has existed in Whitehorse for many years without a long-term holistic plan to address it, one which incorporates the mental and physical health needs of those affected.

The recent high housing prices and low availability are reflective of a need for a plan on the part of the government and private sector to accommodate all the people who will be attracted to the north because of the many available jobs, while continuing to account for the long-term residents who for various reasons are in lower-income brackets, and require a consistent source of housing which continues to be affordable.

Tent City was a protest against a lack of attention to all of these issues. This is why it took over some very public space, and why those who spent time there did not simply retreat to Robert Service campground where their various reasons to live in a tent could stay relatively hidden from the public (and government) eye.

If tenting is the only realistic solution for folks who can't find (much less afford) real housing, then I support it being in a public space to make sure that the city and government cannot ignore these problems.

Up 0 Down 0

Billy Polson on Apr 21, 2012 at 3:47 am

Well done DG!.... affordable is just that....affordable. Stop being silly...and well done!

Up 0 Down 0

Concerned Citizen on Apr 20, 2012 at 4:42 pm

CMHC defines affordable housing...

What is the common definition of affordability?

The cost of adequate shelter should not exceed 30% of household income. Housing which costs less than this is considered affordable.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon Sally on Apr 20, 2012 at 3:41 am

@ DG - Affordable housing is low cost housing for sale or rent, often from a housing association, to meet the needs of local people who cannot afford accommodation through the open or low cost market, or subsidized housing.

And I agree that affordable housing is severely lacking in the Yukon. On the other hand, the only downside to this whole protest is many, no all, of the individuals who were a part of tent city were evicted and in a lot of circumstances these people have no respect for the housing provided and the housing in turn becomes depleted from neglect.

This whole situation is a loss for everyone. One point someone else made was that we need more social programs to assist the addicts, homeless and mentally ill so that they are able to become functioning members of society. That being said we do also need "affordable housing" for these people if not more half way houses to assist them in getting on their feet.

Up 0 Down 0

DG on Apr 19, 2012 at 5:24 pm

I have a personal view that every member of society can and should be able to provide something for the betterment of society as a whole. That is why I fundamentally disagree with what happened on the lawn of the legislature.

Now I am not saying that I agree with the whole housing prices business, I agree that it is out of this world to see most homes that were affordable ten years ago so highly priced.

But a line needs to be drawn in the grass and these people told to actually do something for themselves. Miss Hollywood since she was a recent example had apparently been offered housing but turned it down several times for whatever reason. I don't know the details but I do know this "Beggars CAN'T be choosers". I would give the shirt off my back to a person who is actually trying to turn a crummy motel room into a mobile home (for those that don't get my statement I mean buy a mobile or heck a house even).

FYI @ Billy I signed a new 5 year mortgage term July of last year, and yes it is a mobile home in a trailer park.

On a side note can anyone actually define the term "affordable housing" for me?

Up 0 Down 0

baffled on Apr 18, 2012 at 4:42 am

I think that some people may be missing the point. Housing prices and slumlords are a real problem in this town. Yet their are 2 separate issues here. Some of the tenters have no jobs and serious issues. Would you want Ms Hollywood as roommate or a tenant? A lot of these people need some serious help. The housing crisis affects a lot of us who are just too busy working to protest. Initially I thought it was a great idea, just realizing that most inhabitants of tent city are unemployable and not many of them are getting up to go to work in the morning like the rest of us...

Up 0 Down 0

flyingfur on Apr 18, 2012 at 4:28 am

DG: I respect the fact that you make it a "priority in life" to provide for your family. Me too. I also make it a priority in life to be the kind of father and husband, not to mention member of the community, that understands that everyone is not as fortunate as I am to be physically and mentally able to provide for my family and realizing that, I like to give a hand up as opposed to having the kind of attitude that you seem to have.

Up 0 Down 0

Billy Polson on Apr 17, 2012 at 3:39 pm

Did I miss your point DG?.....did you buy a house here in the past 5 years?... it's a constitutional right to protest in Canada, where the Yukon is.

Some folks, who qualify for home loans, don't camp at the 'Ledge', but they need the same thing. Affordable housing.

Unless you find yourself needing a place to live, that is affordable, the 'Ledgers', could teach you a thing or two.....(1986).

Up 0 Down 0

Wayne on Apr 17, 2012 at 10:05 am

YG? Shouldn't that be YTG?

Up 0 Down 0

DG on Apr 16, 2012 at 2:47 pm

Those who don't deserve to live here are those that WON'T support themselves. If I can afford to put a roof over my head and provide for my family then they should be able to as well.

"The way I see it, the only people who will side with the YG, on this issue, is YG and people who don't deserve to live here - you have no understanding of, or appreciation for, what living in the Yukon is all about. "

Just to be clear I was born in Whitehorse General in 1986 are you trying to say that because I side with government on housing issues I don't belong here... or that I make it a priority in life to provide for my family rather than sit on someones doorstep and beg or even better give those that would sit on your doorstep a reason to continue doing so?

If you can't make it in one place you move on. I dare say ask the First Nations what their ancestors did if game (wildlife) which is in essence equal to money in modern times moved on. Did they sit and protest?

Up 0 Down 0

Billy Polson on Apr 16, 2012 at 6:46 am

Wow JaymanIc, the open mind concept not your cup o tea, eh? It's called a protest.

And Why would anyone support the kind of housing prices we are seeing in the Yukon? Like why? If folks have more money to spend on items other than housing the whole economy thrives....there are good seasoned Yukoners you are encouraging to move away which would leave a dearth of available, expensive housing, only to be filled by folks who are not from the Yukon. Probably all winers too.

Up 0 Down 0

What housing? on Apr 16, 2012 at 5:27 am

I agree with many of the comments with regards to the fact that there is housing available but you also have to factor in that the prices on the homes for sale are way above their actual value. I am a working professional, make decent wage and I was just barely able to buy one of the new condos in town last year. When I look at the fact that houses are priced at least double what I paid for my place it is no wonder why they aren't being purchased.

I'm not saying free housing by any means as I worked hard to be able to purchase a home but I do feel that AFFORDABILITY is the problem here. I mean how many people can honestly afford $1600 a month for rent and still be able to eat every day? Not to mention the fact that rental units, if you manage to call before they get snatched up, are priced way to high for what you are getting. Many of the rentals are severely degraded and have expensive heat or electrical bills. On top of all that you have older homes for sale listed at half a million dollars but when you factor in the amount of work needed to be done on many of them to bring them up to modern day building codes your spending upwards of $600,000.00.

You must see that there is a problem when we have high paid workers staying at the local hostel because they can't find anything to live in, and these people make a decent wage.

Up 0 Down 0

Jaymanc on Apr 15, 2012 at 3:40 am

Well if you can't afford to live here than move somewhere you can. The campgrounds are cheap to rent so stay there and quit littering our parks with your tents and whining story of how it cost to much. Go to a camp ground!!! If I have to pay my property taxes and other taxes to keep these parks clean like everyone else than why should you (tenters) be able to live somewhere for free because its not in your budget, get a second job or find someone to split the costs. There are so many houses for sale this is ridiculous and absurd. You won't find affordable housing it no longer EXISTS!! Its 2012 better shape up or move out!

Up 0 Down 0

Yukoner on Apr 14, 2012 at 10:39 am

Paws - I arrived in the Yukon in the early 70's. I like it here. I loved it here because it used to be very different than life in the southern provinces. Now we have people like you, up here, trying to change the Yukon into another BC city, with a large city mentality. We have long, dark and cold winters, but we stay here for the freedom and lifestyle that no other city Canada can offer - and I appreciate that.

I don't like what the Yukon Party is doing to the Yukon. I don't like what Harper is doing to Canada. Selling sovereignty is their game.

I care about this issue because the Yukon Party is trying to put a law in place that benefits and protect them, at the expense of Yukoners. YG knew, more than a decade ago, about this housing shortage, and now we are supposed to just shut up about it.

Let us protest - if you don't want to protest, keep quiet while the rest of us stand up for your sovereignty.

The way I see it, the only people who will side with the YG, on this issue, is YG and people who don't deserve to live here - you have no understanding of, or appreciation for, what living in the Yukon is all about.

As far as I go, I am a retired, private, businessperson. I don't need another house, but I do want Canada and Yukon to wake up and smell the rats that are selling the future to get more for them and less for most everyone else. I vote tent city stays until YG does their job!

Up 0 Down 0

Paws on Apr 13, 2012 at 8:40 am

In this city, as with any other city, the cost of living is what it is. If you can afford to live there you do; if you can't you move to a place you CAN afford to live. If you can't afford to live here move to somewhere you can afford to live, where your employment income matches the cost of living better. There is so much of an entitlement mentality in this territory....like nothing I have seen anywhere else I have lived and I have lived in 4 other provinces. Everyone wants something handed to them.

Up 0 Down 0

JDangles on Apr 13, 2012 at 6:47 am

Totally agree Yukoner,

My attitude is not one of entitlement, it is of equality and prosperity for all.... yes I said all. Not just the people who can afford it or who got here first.

If your attitude is "those who have some deserve more, and those who have none tough break." Then perhaps you yourself should move down south like you seem to tell everyone else to do, because your attitude is the worst kind.

It is not that I can't find affordable housing, it is that affordable housing doesn't exist right now. No one can find it. What IS available is overpriced housing or overpriced rentals or nothing.

And once again, most peoples comments are so focused on the tenters that they are failing to see the problem (a downfall of public protest). I myself don't feel tenting at the Ledge is the right answer, but what do you suggest people do to get results with this gov't? Write letters?

Get ready for another bold assumption North of 60... I bet everyone who thumbs down my comments are living comfortably in their affordable house!

Please reply to this, I am really interested in hearing your enlightened opinion and all your good ideas for a solution.

Up 0 Down 0

Guncache on Apr 13, 2012 at 12:20 am

I agree with north of 60. Let the tenters camp in Liz Hansons yard. The grounds of the Admin. building is not a place to camp. Additionally they were not all homeless, some were tourists passing through who found a free place to camp with running water inside the building. SWEET!!. I worked hard for my house and did not expect or ask for a government hand out. There are too many dead beats in Whitehorse and too many people who want to give them a hug.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukoner on Apr 12, 2012 at 12:29 pm

North_of_60 is usually out of touch with reality. It reminds me of Archie Bunker who did a great job of showing us the stupidity and ignorance of the day. His comments are too funny to be serious. If he is serious, it's still funny to read his comments. I don't think too many readers take him seriously, though, but some do and that's funny. - Keep up the good work North.

Up 0 Down 0

north_of_60 on Apr 12, 2012 at 10:34 am

JDangles you seem completely out of touch with reality on this one. Just because YOU can't find what YOU consider affordable housing does not give you any justification to make unfounded judgements and assumptions about my housing arrangements, or what you perceive my attitude on affordable housing to be. Don't vent your frustration by judging me. Perhaps it's your demonstrated attitude of entitlement that's causing your housing problem.

Up 0 Down 0

D Drake on Apr 12, 2012 at 9:03 am

If one paid attention to who was camping on the Legislature grounds last summer this is what I saw. Campers that were visitors passing through. Katimivick persons, Persons that were probably asked to leave other housing because of various reasons. Persons from other communitees that have housing. My question is why would you move to a communities without first finding out what the cost of living is, we're you are going to sleep or stay and what you are going to be earning.

There are many campgrounds in and around Whitehorse. Why do some persons think that everyone else should pay the bills for them. Governments cannot solve all our problems. We have to take responsibilities for ourselves.

Up 0 Down 0

withheld for fear of criticism on Apr 12, 2012 at 8:58 am

with all the mining and industry work, why not find a large parcel of land and set up a mining camp similar to say Minto, Mayo, Wolverine, etc. How many people are residents of those camps? what is the foot print and cost per square foot. Not exactly top of the market housing but certainly not too bad. With all the equipment, camp projects already set up, there should be expertise and connections that should make this an attainable task in the very short term...

Set it up near the old village, on the copper haul road (old norcope quarry), near the snow dump at bottom of south access, McIntyre creek area, Yukon College property....

Up 0 Down 0

and yet... on Apr 12, 2012 at 7:51 am

Affordable rent is not the issue - at least not all of it. The tenters could have gone to the Robert Service campground (which was nearly empty all summer) or just about anywhere else. But, no, they wanted to camp on the lawn of the government building so they could use the washrooms and other facilities. Their behaviour and lack of respect for every other resident in town was disgusting... garbage everywhere, drugs, drunkeness etc. Plus, their presence diminished the ability of normal people to use the park facilities and attend the government building.

It's more about entitlement than anything else, and all the sob stories published in the paper support that statement.

Why should your shelter be free?

Up 0 Down 0

JDangles on Apr 12, 2012 at 3:56 am

Really? North of 60, you seem completely out of touch with reality on this one. The issue is not the tenters, it is why they are there and what they are fighting for. I know alot of people dont agree with public protest, but at least the public is more aware that there is a serious problem here.

The lack of affordable housing in Whitehorse is completely rediculous. It must be easy for you to sit in your house that you bought 20 years ago and judge others who have to try and get into the insanely high housing market. How smart of you to get into the housing market early. Well I'm 26, with an education, a good job and am still struggling to find an affordable place to raise my family.Sorry, I don't think it's my fault that I couldn't buy a house when I was 6 years old.

I can't imagine the struggles of those who are forced to live in tents, I feel for them because like them, I am a victim of poor city planning, lack of availability, increased population, greedy landlords and real estate fat cats. None of which are within my, or any of the tenters control.

While you may not agree with their methods, you have to respect the problem and the fight for a solution. A true Yukoner would agree that everyone deserves an affordable home for them and their familes.

Up 0 Down 0

June Jackson on Apr 11, 2012 at 10:57 am

Why on earth would Mr. Findlater think that all the tenters are the 'hard to house?". Rents are so high in Whitehorse that people with jobs have to tent out in the summer just to pay rent in the winter, and of course, students come here to earn some money for their education, and can hardly blow every cent they make on rent. The government is putting money into peoples homes to build/convert/upgrade their homes so they can have a renter.. that is so dumb, but it sure benefits folks who wanted to upgrade their homes.

There are plenty of rentals.. what we don't have is affordable rent. Affordable being the key word here. The government has steadfastly refused to tackle landlord greed. Its like a fungus.. greed just grows and grows.

I have totally changed sides about Occupy. I hope they win.

Up 0 Down 0

north_of_60 on Apr 11, 2012 at 7:54 am

Put up No-Camping signs and if they camp by the government building again then kick them out right away.

They can go camp out in NDP MLA's yards.

Perhaps other 'do-gooders' will volunteer their yards too.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.