Photo by Whitehorse Star
Elaine Schiman and Jim Tredger
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Elaine Schiman and Jim Tredger
The Ross River School has been closed indefinitely due to concerns over the building’s structural integrity.
The Ross River School has been closed indefinitely due to concerns over the building’s structural integrity.
The closure was announced Sunday by the Yukon government. It’s the second time in just over a week the building has shut down, after cracks were discovered in the walls.
Two independent structural engineers investigated the structure on Jan. 10 and determined it was safe, though trusses would be reinforced to prevent further shifting.
The school reopened two days later.
But further investigation last week, culminating in an engineering report submitted late Friday, showed there are “concerns with the structural integrity of the facility,” the Department of Highways and Public Works said in a news release.
“We’re further assessing the situation,” said spokeswoman Doris Wurfbaum.
She said officials are meeting today to discuss the issue, but would not comment further.
Cynthia Tucker, the department’s assistant deputy minister for property management, and the school board superintendent are in the community today, meeting with parents, teachers, and the Ross River Dena chief and council for community input on how to proceed.
“Right now, our main priority is to minimize the disruption to students and staff in the community,” Department of Education spokesman Ronuk Modha said this morning.
“We recognize that the closure of the school is putting a lot of stress on students, parents and staff.”
About 50 students from Kindergarten to Grade 10 attend the school, plus 17 staff – eight teachers, seven educational assistants and two aboriginal language instructors.
Yukon College’s Ross River Dene Cho Kê’endį campus also runs classes out of the building. Roughly 50 students and instructors are affected by the closure, said college spokesman Michael Vernon.
Two heavy equipment technician courses are continuing in the mobile trades trailer located outside the school. Arrangements are being made to provide washroom facilities for the 13 students and two staff.
The college is still searching for alternate classroom space in the community for upcoming courses, including bulk water delivery, knitting and drum-making, Vernon said.
Today’s community meeting will look at the potential options available for Ross River students. They include searching for any other facilities in town to hold classes in the meantime, bring in temporary facilities, like trailers, or bus students to Del Van Gorder School in Faro.
“We’re looking at all the options that are potentially available,” said Modha. “We haven’t made any final decisions. We want to discuss all these options with the community.”
The department has taken some initial steps to see what might be possible.
Modha said there’s space for Ross River students the Faro school. Alternatively, Yukon College has trailers that could serve as classrooms in the interim.
The official Opposition called on the government this morning to explain why the initial engineering assessment deemed the school was safe.
“While it is reassuring to know that Ross River students are out of danger, we need to know the circumstances that led to the building being declared safe last Tuesday,” said Education critic Jim Tredger.
“As a result of the initial engineering assessment, students may have showed up for class at an unsafe facility for the better part of a week. Why?”
When asked about this, cabinet spokeswoman Elaine Schiman said: “I think that’s the question we’re all looking at right now .... We are also asking about that. We can’t really answer it. It’s a question we have as well.”
New Highways and Public Works Minister Scott Kent was not available for comment before press time this afternoon.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (5)
Up 1 Down 2
north_of_60 on Jan 23, 2015 at 5:30 pm
The Ross River school built in 1975 used a successful application of heat-pipe cryo-anchors. The 1975 design placed the heat-pipes beneath a slab-on-grade foundation.
This successful design was not used with the new school in 2000, which has a heated, below-grade, shallow basement, with a few vertical heat-pipes located next to the building.
Both the new Ross River school and the Dawson Rec Center have a heated, below-grade, shallow basement in permafrost. The heat-pipe applications in both cases used a deficient design as compared with the 1975 Ross River school, and it failed to stabilize the permafrost around a heated shallow basement in both cases.
Yes, the engineers should have known better.
Up 5 Down 0
Wilf Carter NDP don't represent the workers of YTG on Jan 23, 2015 at 9:34 am
NDP blame everything on someone else. Here they blame the YTG employees engineers for the problem. Blame game gets you nowhere in life especially in government.
Up 12 Down 2
Tater on Jan 20, 2015 at 4:23 pm
So I hope taxpayers are not on the hook for repairs. YG spends a fortune on soil testing and engineers before any building are constructed. Shouldn't those experts be responsible for the repair costs?
Up 21 Down 2
flying on Jan 19, 2015 at 4:15 pm
Give it a rest Jim. It's pretty obvious that the initial information from the engineers deemed the school to be OK for occupation, but after receiving the full report HPW did the prudent thing and acted on their concerns, and immediately closed the school. That's about as fast as any department in YG works from my experience. Stop trying to make political hay out of nothing at all. The real issue is what to do with the school now. The building is only about 9 years old. Is this an issue with the construction of the school or is it something unforeseen and unavoidable because of shifting or melting permafrost? What is the future of the Ross River school and where will kids from that community get their education? The temporary solution to go to Faro is great...but obviously not a long term solution,
Up 19 Down 3
Wilf Carter on Jan 19, 2015 at 3:46 pm
This poor politicians opinion does not help anything but try to make the the NDP political points in the news.
When you build any building on a river bottom based soil anything can happen over the years to make a building move. Water could have got in under the building which would remove support for the building as an example. There could be an underground stream in the area.
For all the good Yukon Government workers here you have the NDP criticizing your work and trying to make news for only one interest - their own and to get votes. YTG workers don't be tricked by this tactic.