Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Energy, Mines and Resources Minister John Streicker

Streicker defends priority on renewable energy

Energy, Mines and Resources Minister John Streicker is calling a proposal by the Yukon Party to rely more heavily on fossil-fuel generation of electricity “impractical.”

By Whitehorse Star on February 28, 2022

Energy, Mines and Resources Minister John Streicker is calling a proposal by the Yukon Party to rely more heavily on fossil-fuel generation of electricity “impractical.”

Streicker was responding to a statement Feb. 9 from Yukon Party MLA Geraldine Van Bibber.

She said her party is continuing to hear from Yukoners “who are facing record-setting electricity bills that the rising cost of electricity is putting their personal finances into bad shape.

“Under the Liberals, the cost of living has been rising, and their misguided electrical policies are making it too expensive to live in our beautiful territory,” she said.

During an interview on Feb. 18, Streicker acknowledged that many people are feeling the bite of their electrical bills this winter.

December and January were brutally cold, he noted, particularly early January. That drove demand up to record levels on several days.

The subject was a hot one on social media as well earlier this month.

“I live in a TINY trailer and my electric bill was 1000 dollars for one month, doesn’t matter where you live,” one person posted.

“When the revenue guarantee rider is 40 per cent or so of the usage, your bill goes from $500 to $700 and then add on the other crap and suddenly, it’s as much as a mortgage payment,” another person wrote.

A third said, “Costs will continue to climb as everything is going electric. Usage up, costs up! Simple ... YTG is adamant that electric is the way to go, demonizing fossil fuel consumption, but not looking at the bigger picture.

“How do we keep the generators going ... fossil fuel. No new dams, no great advances in geothermal, solar, well good for part of the year ... we need a mini nuke ... they work, they create stable power, they are used in a variety of settings from military ships to cities ... but alas, we live in the ‘dark’ ages.”

The main point Streicker said he wants to convey to Yukoners unhappy with their electrical bills is that the actual rate they pay for electricity hasn’t gone up.

Streicker also said he understood that the current electrical bill had an extra week carried over, affecting the amounts.

He defended the government’s efforts to switch the Yukon more toward renewable energy than traditional fossil-fuel based sources.

“We don’t want to invest in fossil fuels. We want to have more renewables. Does it makes sense to rely more on diesel to generate energy? That feels disingenuous to me, and we don’t want to go that way.”

Streicker added that he is also concerned about the steep rise in price to consumers for gasoline and diesel.

Those prices have risen nearly 20 cents a litre in the last month or so, Streicker said, and that kind of sticker shock is what the government wants to avoid.

“We need to work to prevent shocks like this to the system,” he said, without going into specifics.

Streicker also wanted to remind people of the various programs the government has introduced to refit and retrofit homes to make them more energy-efficient as one of the best ways to cope with rising electrical bills.

Van Bibber, however, takes a different position.

“During the 2021 territorial election campaign, the Yukon Party saw this looming electricity crisis and promised to freeze electrical rates for two years to unravel this government’s Kathleen Wynne-like electrical policy that has resulted in shocking rate swings,” she said, in reference to Ontario’s former Liberal premier.

“The Liberals’ continued policies are driving up the cost of electricity, the cost of heating our homes, and the cost of necessities like groceries,” Van Bibber said.

“The comments from the minister last fall demonstrate how out of touch the Liberal government is and their lack of solutions to the real costs and challenges Yukoners are struggling with day to day,” she added.

Comments (24)

Up 3 Down 0

Groucho d'North on Mar 6, 2022 at 11:56 am

@melba
You may be aware that the Wynn Liberal government in their zeal to make Ontario greener implemented a number of policies that had a disasterous impact on the price of electricity in Ontario. Many of those former Ontario government workers are now working for the Yukon government and our electrical prices continue to ramp up. Coincidence? Perhaps not, but even Ms. Wynn is now saying that they chose their Green Energy Act policies poorly. It appears that YG is not learning from these mistakes either.
Have a read for yourself. https://niagaraindependent.ca/truth-at-last-wynne-admits-electricity-mistake/

Up 1 Down 3

melba on Mar 6, 2022 at 8:47 am

Can VanBibber specify what about the 'Liberal's policies' is 'Kathleen Wynne like'?

She's throwing all the blame on the Yukon Liberal Party, and that might even be accurate, but can't be bothered to specify how their 'policies' have resulted in our too high electrical costs.

Up 12 Down 0

Jim on Mar 5, 2022 at 10:59 am

Streicker is concerned with steep rise in consumer costs of diesel and gasoline. Really? If that was true his government would have negotiated a carbon tax exemption for heating fuel like NWT did. But being a Liberal government would they dare go against Trudeau’s wishes? We have another carbon tax increase coming in April so his concerns are a little hollow. There will never be another dam project in the Yukon, especially under this government. We will be held hostage by insane and overpriced batteries and windmill projects that taxpayers pay for but control none. And let’s not forget the buying of electricity from another province through an out of territory First Nation at an undisclosed price.

Up 11 Down 1

Bingo on Mar 4, 2022 at 12:45 pm

@snowman...all the feds have to do is adjust the equalization payments that alberta feeds Quebec. Once that gravy train dries up you would see all systems go for a pipeline east. To think a municipality could shut down such a thing...only in La Belle province.

Up 3 Down 5

Snowman on Mar 3, 2022 at 9:00 pm

@Simba How should the federal government do that? Are you one of the people who has no idea about legal jurisdiction and think that the federal government can somehow overrule the Quebec provincial government AND the municipal government of Montreal and force them to accept the pipeline east? No matter who was in power federally, this project would have been stopped at the provincial and municipal levels.

Up 15 Down 3

Simba on Mar 3, 2022 at 12:50 pm

@Snowperson or Snowflake...you are correct Canada didn't import the oil that vlad suggested BUT they did import 365,000 barrels of refined oil products..jet fuel gasoline etc., so your are right but wrong! Also you are right oil companies have no choice but to import because this dysfunctional government would rather that than provide jobs and income by using our own.

Up 5 Down 10

Snowman on Mar 2, 2022 at 9:21 pm

@Yukoner - you can't just 'build another dam in Yukon. A total of 0 First Nations would entertain a new dam on their territory. They only care about the environment when it comes to their traditional territory. They don't care about climate change, otherwise we would indeed have another dam.

@Aphasic - there was never a widespread scientific prediction of an ice age. You were probably just fooled by that false Time magazine cover back in the 70s or 80s. Global Warming has been theorized for over a 100 years.

@Vlad - Canada has not imported any oil from Russia since 2019. You are just virtue signalling. As for other countries like Saudi Arabia, it is Canadian oil companies who buy that oil, not the government of Canada. If you want government to tell companies where in the world they are allowed to buy things, maybe you would be happier in Venezuela.

Up 29 Down 4

Groucho d'North on Mar 2, 2022 at 8:48 am

In support of North_of_60's comments below regarding green investments, I'd like to see an audit performed on the Carbon Tax since it was implemented. How much money has been collected including the GST? How has that money been invested into green technologies and which consumers are benefitting from these green investments? They might even want to measure how effective these have been in reducing GHGs.
I think they've created a giant slush fund for their own nefarious purposes.

Up 20 Down 6

bonanzajoe on Mar 1, 2022 at 4:51 pm

It'll take up to 1/2 to an hour to charge up an electric vehicle at one of their public chargers. I will be joyfully driving by in my old gas fueled car watching all the donkeys lining up for blocks waiting to charge up their new electric vehicles. And watching them pushing them to the charger will be the biggest laugh of all. LOL

Up 39 Down 6

North_of_60 on Mar 1, 2022 at 2:40 pm

Repeating a lie does not make it true. Just because there's no exhaust coming from solar panels, wind turbines and batteries does not make them clean or green. Using apparently "clean" renewables while exporting monumental levels of pollution to Asia is NIMBY head-in-the-sand environmentalism.

► Building wind turbines and solar panels to generate electricity, as well as batteries to fuel electric vehicles, requires, on average, more than 10 times the quantity of materials, compared with building machines using hydrocarbons to deliver the same amount of energy to society.

► A single electric car contains more cobalt than 1,000 smartphone batteries; the blades on a single wind turbine have more plastic than 5 million smartphones; and a solar array that can power one data center uses more glass than 50 million phones.

► Replacing hydrocarbons with green machines under current plans—never mind aspirations for far greater expansion—will vastly increase the mining of various critical minerals around the world. For example, a single electric car battery weighing 1,000 pounds requires extracting and processing some 500,000 pounds of materials. Averaged over a battery’s life, each mile of driving an electric car “consumes” five pounds of earth. Using an internal combustion engine consumes about 0.2 pounds of liquids per mile.

► Oil, natural gas, and coal are needed to produce the concrete, steel, plastics, and purified minerals used to build green machines. The energy equivalent of 100 barrels of oil is used in the processes to fabricate a single battery that can store the equivalent of one barrel of oil.

► By 2050, with current plans, the quantity of worn-out solar panels—much of it nonrecyclable—will constitute double the tonnage of all today’s global plastic waste, along with over 3 million tons per year of unrecyclable plastics from worn-out wind turbine blades. By 2030, more than 10 million tons per year of batteries will become garbage.

https://www.manhattan-institute.org/mines-minerals-and-green-energy-reality-check#
https://energynewsbeat.co/2021/06/the-dystopian-lake-filled-by-the-worlds-tech-lust/

Up 37 Down 8

bonanzajoe on Mar 1, 2022 at 11:05 am

Politico. So, you're saying that oil energy is more expensive than Solar and Wind? Tell that to Ontarions. Their energy costs at least doubled after setting up thousands of wind turbines. Oil is the least expensive. Do some research instead of believing the lies the Liberals and NDP like to spew daily. But, like the old Colonel said, "You can't handle the truth". But, "the truth shall set you free". And by the way, the Oil industry is not destroying the planet - they are feeding the planet CO2 so the vegitation can provide all living things with the needed oxygen.

Up 9 Down 33

Spud on Mar 1, 2022 at 10:58 am

Oh Geraldine, we love you but your comments are so wrong. It will be a challenge to vote for you again.

Up 34 Down 10

Groucho d'North on Mar 1, 2022 at 9:25 am

Too many seem to believe that we can click our heels together three times and we are magically at a place and time where we have all the clean energy we need. Our infrastructure, transportation methods, creature comforts like home heating and many hundreds of other service methods we depend on were developed utilizing fossil fuels as an power source. All this does not get changed in a short period of time. Technology evolves just like the rest of the world. Yes oil and gas could be outlawed today, but what would be the outcome? There would be global disruption and a dramatic reduction in quality of life for very many. Replacement technologies are not yet ready to take up the energy-supply tasks that were created over the past century.
Since Al Gore began this wholesale campaign to reduce hydrocarbon consumption, the time frame for making these changes was based on political ambitions and not on the real time required to develop and perfect energy replacement technologies. The politicians still march on with their hyperbole to create a carbon-free environment without considering the hardships that our societies are forced to take in stride.
In 31 days the national carbon tax will be increased yet again because of a political decision made by our PM who is in a competition with other world leaders for accolades in who is greener. Our already excessive cost of living will get another jolt when the new carbon tax will be added on to everything we consumers consume. The ivory tower politicians who did not miss a day's pay during the COVID restrictions have no concept of how their save the world decisions are impacting on the public at large. And more is the pity, it appears they do not seem to care.
We will own nothing and we will be happy? Horsesh*t!

Up 25 Down 6

martin on Mar 1, 2022 at 8:24 am

@Politico; Thanks God for people like you. Preaching this will ensure that never again the NDP get to form a Gov't.

Up 32 Down 9

Vlad on Mar 1, 2022 at 12:37 am

It should be now crystal clear during this crisis in Ukraine that relying on others for oil or transitioning to so called "green energy " will have serious consequences. Canada buys 365 million barrels of oil a year from Russia while our resources stays in the ground, we also buy from other countries with horrible human rights but that's ok? We will still need to consume oil for many years, pretending we are not oil dependent is inaccurate, short sighted and expensive. Enlighten yourself with how the work works peeps like politico. Padding Putins pockets to invade Ukraine surely doesn't sound right, eh?

Up 35 Down 9

North_of_60 on Feb 28, 2022 at 10:00 pm

The biggest problem is not that Mr. Streicker continues to gaslight Yukoners with half-truths and evasive answers; we've come to expect that from Lieberals because that's what they do most of the time. No, the biggest problem is that the so-called YP "opposition" isn't doing their job. It seems like they accept his smug deception and don't call him out with any meaningful challenges.

For example when Streicker says "We don’t want to invest in fossil fuels. We want to have more renewables", then why isn't the YP telling him to show what renewable energy he is investing in like more hydro dams to provide useful renewable energy at those times of the year when we're burning the most fossil fuels? The solar panels and wind turbines he's subsidizing don't provide useful energy when we need it in the winter.

When Streicker says that the actual rate we pay for electricity hasn’t gone up, then why isn't the YP telling him to explain why our electric bills keep increasing every year? Streicker gets away with typical Lieberal smug evasiveness because the YP isn't doing their job as an effective Opposition like we elected them to do.

That needs to stop - Do Your Job !!

Up 31 Down 11

Aphasic Wonders Everywhere on Feb 28, 2022 at 9:06 pm

In response to Poolitico: You’re still going on about that anthropomorphic climate change hokum? Give it a rest already. There is no credible evidence to support the manifest alarmism of the climate change hysterics and their patented falsehoods.

First it was an ice age - We’re all gonna freeze.
Then it was global warming and everybody is going fry.
Then we were told that all the climate change brouhaha was actually more complicated and what it actually meant was weather extremes - Hot, cold, windy, wet etc.

Everybody is running around like chicken little… The sky is falling, the sky is falling… It’s so awful and terrible and everything sucks… Those climate depressives going on and on and on about the end of the world - SHUT UP ALREADY!

The climate will balance itself! Trudeau’s tried and true method of balancing budgets can now be applied to climates. Turn the oil and gas taps back on, lower those prices, and stop making electric vehicles cause burning gas and oil will, by Trudeau’s tried and true economic methods, cause the climate to balance itself… Burn it all!!!

What? Now? You have a problem with Liberal logic now? Really?

Up 22 Down 10

Matthew on Feb 28, 2022 at 8:52 pm

And please. So many kinds of free and clean energy, they don't want it folks! So many out of work and oil companies shut down overnight.. follow the money, simple.

Up 30 Down 8

Matthew on Feb 28, 2022 at 8:51 pm

#ThankALiberal haha it's really that simple.. not sure what people expect when they wanted a carbon tax.. not sure what people expect when we doubled our national debt in 2 years.. remember, "you will own nothing and be happy!" WEF -Klaus Schwab

Up 30 Down 6

Mitch Holder on Feb 28, 2022 at 3:42 pm

Streicker can't even figure out how to regulate and sell marijuana right, if that indicates anything to you. The guy thinks a decommissioned nuke is a better idea than what is in place - typical Liberal fantasy in a world that cannot afford it.

Up 40 Down 53

BnR on Feb 28, 2022 at 3:09 pm

So Van bibber and the YP would have frozen “electrical rates for two years...”. Really.
So who would have paid for that Geraldine?
Man, it’s a really tough call as to which Yukon politician is the most out of touch with reality.

Up 78 Down 4

Charlie's Aunt on Feb 28, 2022 at 2:35 pm

Along with reminding us of YT programs to retrofit homes so they are more energy efficient, Streicker might add some insight into where anyone can find contractors when they are busy building Whistle Bend. That subdivision will add to our electricity needs, big time. I don't see too much more than hot air blowing here, especially when he also says YT wants to avoid sticker shock on gasoline and diesel, just how are they going to accomplish that?

Up 93 Down 6

Yukoner on Feb 28, 2022 at 2:15 pm

Build another dam. Just start work on it instead of dragging your feet; yes it will be hard to convince all the nimby environmentalists but it has to happen. Solar panels are not a solution in the Yukon where at the same time it's minus 40 there is 0-5 hours of sunlight depending on your location. Stop wasting everybody's time and money on quick path work and do the hard job.

Up 27 Down 91

Politico on Feb 28, 2022 at 2:14 pm

The YP continue to believe that an energy source that is killing our planet is what we should be using to save a few bucks. Drunk with oil!

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.