Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Nils Clarke

Speaker’s activities could be seen as partisan: YP

The official Opposition is advocating for Nils Clarke, the Speaker of the legislature, to be constrained from partisan activities by an official code of conduct.

By Gabrielle Plonka on October 30, 2019

The official Opposition is advocating for Nils Clarke, the Speaker of the legislature, to be constrained from partisan activities by an official code of conduct.

On Tuesday, a motion was brought forward by Watson Lake MLA Patti McLeod requesting a set of official guidelines for Speaker activities.

In an interview with the Star, interim Opposition Leader Stacey Hassard expressed concern that Clarke frequently appears in government advertising and takes part in government-to-government discussions like the Yukon Forum.

Hassard said his party has noticed Clarke’s inclusion in political fundraisers and attendance at other events as a Liberal member of government.

Hassard’s party pointed to several social media posts by the ruling party in which Clarke is photographed standing alongside other Liberal party members.

The Yukon Forum, it was pointed out, can only be attended by members of the Liberal caucus. This could leave the impression that Clarke attended the forum as a Liberal member.

Hassard expressed concern that Clarke’s activities may cause him to appear biased toward the Liberal government.

“We know the Speaker is supposed to appear neutral,” Hassard said. “I think it’s important that we uphold that.”

He said the question of a potential code of conduct has been discussed several times within his party. The code of conduct, he said, would be helpful to all future Speakers.

“It’s not just for us, it’s not just for the Speaker,” Hassard said.

“It gives some understanding for Speakers to come as to what they are and aren’t supposed to be doing, and it just makes it fair for everyone that way.”

Though he is concerned with future fairness, Hassard said, his party has taken particular issue with Speaker neutrality during Clarke’s three-year reign and in particular during the fall session.

“We’ve raised some concerns about Speaker activity in the past,” Hassard said.

Clarke was unavailable for comment on the issue before press time this afternoon.

Premier Sandy Silver told media on Tuesday afternoon that Clarke adheres to all rules and procedures set for the Speaker of the House.

“Booming economy, lowest unemployment rate in Canada, they have to talk about something,” Silver said.

The final definition and guidelines of the code of conduct would have to be decided by the Standing Committee on Rules, Elections and Privileges.

In the legislative assembly’s procedural handbook, the Speaker’s role is described as one of “authority and impartiality” working to balance the ruling and opposing parties and ensure business is carried out in an orderly manner.

The Speaker is described as serving all members of the house equally.

Comments (7)

Up 27 Down 9

JC on Oct 30, 2019 at 8:52 pm

Lowest unemployment rate? Accept for the high paid government jobs it's mostly low paid food vendor jobs where the worker has to have at least 2 jobs to survive. Or did the government just go on a wild hiring frenzy?

Up 21 Down 12

JC on Oct 30, 2019 at 8:49 pm

Hey, this is the Liberals. Anything goes for them, until it's another party attempting to play the dirty tricks.

Up 10 Down 22

Arturs on Oct 30, 2019 at 7:39 pm

Great job in keeping the uniformed straightened out as to proper legislative procedures Nils. You have to consider where some of these persona came from and realize there's no proper procedure in a Teslin gravel pit.

Up 19 Down 7

D. Mock-Rassy on Oct 30, 2019 at 5:53 pm

Dear Politico - Of all the problems in the Yukon this is an example of “THE” problem. This government and the Yukon political system generally is plagued with biases to the point that “no” reasonable person could expect any fairness in the system, period!

There are many reasons for this. Collectively:

1) We use words like majority to describe the official government when they only receive 30-40% of the votes cast in an election where only 60-70% of the eligible voters cast a ballot.

a) Then there is the first past the post system in which a party receiving a
lesser percentage of the popular vote wins the election - Wow! That is
certainly a bias.

2) Judicial activism regularly thwarts the democratic process - Unconstitutional! Our elected officials are sideshow distractions, attractions or detractions. One cannot take them seriously.

3) The repatriation of the constitution (81/82) locked Canada into a system of stratified rights contests in which the resources to litigate are required to assert those very rights. Your rights are not absolute.

4) Canada is divided into various rights regimes locked into contestaction: Big business, Boomers, millennials, caucasians, First Nation, blacks, Chinese, LGBTQ+, and so on - It really gets ridiculous when everything washes out.

All these things suggest that Canada is a nation truly divided against itself. Fairness - WTF! Your rights are not absolute and the chaos we call “democracy” exists in name only. The system whether intentionally or not is designed to generate poor results, generalized apathy and a rather disastrous level of sociopathology.

Fairness - No. The system cannot be just and fair. There are only winners and losers. A speaker of the house is not above the human condition.

We really need to redefine what we want from democracy and move towards it. We need to de-emphasize results and look at the processes and restate them in a more democratic fashion - Perhaps Canada would benefit from defining democracy? This voting crap is not working for anyone but those who are elected as a “result”.

Up 15 Down 15

Funny how that works on Oct 30, 2019 at 5:53 pm

@North of 60... that’s a great idea, the Yukon Party SHOULD make a code of conduct, like the one they made when they were in power...oh wait. Funny how they had like 12 years to make one, and in that time their speakers were very much Yukon Party stalwarts, found at every fundraising opportunity or party function, but it was never a concern. I guess what’s good for the goose isn’t good for the gander. I’m sure they’ll get right on making a code of conduct to limit “their” speaker when they get into power. If you believe that, you’ll enjoy the kool-aid they sell you when they’re in power...oh wait, you’re already drinking it by the gallon.

Up 54 Down 16

North_of_60 on Oct 30, 2019 at 4:45 pm

This Speaker often acts as a Liberal shill and should be reigned in with clear guidelines in an official Code of Conduct to guarantee impartiality. Those who disagree with this are clearly in favor of partisan bias.

Up 17 Down 40

Politico on Oct 30, 2019 at 3:33 pm

All the problems in the Yukon and this is what they waste taxpayer money on.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.