Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Supt. Peter Clark

Senior officer ‘shocked and disappointed'

With a promise to speak "openly” and "personally”,

By Justine Davidson on May 10, 2010

With a promise to speak "openly” and "personally”, the Yukon's top cop released a prerecorded statement Friday about the police-custody death of Raymond Silverfox.

In a video posted on the Yukon RCMP website, Supt. Peter Clark says he is "shocked and disappointed, as are many members of the RCMP, that Mr. Silverfox had to endure the insensitive and callous treatment he endured while he was in our care.”

This echoes comments Clark made in a press release late last month, following revelations heard at a coroner's inquest into the circumstances of the 43-year-old man's death.

The coroner's jury learned that Silverfox lay in a filthy cell, covered in his own vomit and feces, for more than 13 hours before anyone gave him medical assistance.

During that period, he threw up 26 times, and often appeared to be unable to stand or even move away from the vomit which surrounded him.

The only attention the Little Salmon-Carmacks First Nation man received from police and guards after his arrest and before the ambulance was called were insults and laughter at his expense. During his stay, no one suggested he be changed out of his filthy clothes, or moved to a clean cell, as RCMP policy dictates.

He was not violent or verbally abusive to his guards, nor was he a chronic visitor to the RCMP cells.

On the one occasion he spoke to his keepers, to ask for a mat to lie on, he was told: "Sleep in your own shit.”

"I acknowledge that the RCMP did not meet the high standard of care we have established for ourselves and that you should expect us to achieve,” Clark said in his scripted statement. "I want to speak openly about this and how the RCMP has reacted.”

However, Clark has not spoken directly to the media, nor has he spoken to Silverfox's family, since the end of the inquest in spite of repeated requests from a number of individuals and news agencies.

RCMP spokesman Sgt. Don Rogers defended the commanding officer's decision not to hold a press conference or do one-on-one interviews with reporters.

A prerecorded statement, posted for everyone to see, avoids any "inaccuracies” journalists might make when reporting on the subject, Rogers said. He said the superintendent may be available for interviews later this week.

The video was given to Silverfox's family and the first nation before it was released to the public, Rogers said, but he did not know if or how they had responded.

During the inquest, Silverfox's sister Deborah, his daughter Deanna Charlie and Little Salmon Chief Eddie Skookum all said they wanted a personal apology from the police, but Clark has still not spoken directly to the family, Rogers confirmed today.

In outlining the steps the RCMP have taken since the inquest, Clark noted five officers are currently under code-of-conduct investigations, while the two civilian guards working in cells the day Silverfox died are no longer at the RCMP detachment.

"One of these individuals, while still working for the Commissionaires, is no longer deployed in an RCMP facility,” Clark said. "A second individual has left by personal choice.”

All of the officers, however, remain on active duty.

Police are not releasing the names of the Mounties who face code-of-conduct hearings, although Rogers said they are among the 13 officers who gave evidence at the inquest and all had contact with Silverfox the day he died.

One officer, Const. Geoff Corbett, told the inquest he was being disciplined for his treatment of Silverfox.

The internal investigation will look at video and audio recordings of the cell block taken the day Silverfox died, as well as other evidence gathered by police and statements made at the inquest, Rogers said.

During the inquest, the two constables in charge of the cell block – Jeff Kalles and Dennis Connelly – denied making certain disrespectful comments which are shown in the audio transcript.

Rogers said the code-of-conduct investigators will look into the truthfulness of their statements to the jury.

Clark reiterated what was said during the inquest and since about changes in RCMP policy since Silverfox's death. Better record keeping, tighter supervision and more extensive training have all been implemented since his death.

Comments (6)

Up 0 Down 0

Anonymous on May 17, 2010 at 5:39 am

I for one would just like everyone to stop looking at the fact that he was intoxicated and the terms at which he came to his end and just understand that this was a human being who desereved some compassion.

Race has nothing to do with this, a man has passed in a terrible manner due to the negligence of those who are to serve and protect. I for one would like to say shame on you to the ambulance who accepted his decline to go to the hospital. Since when does a heavily intoxicated person know what's best for them...never, that's when. They should have stepped up and requested police assistance to get him into the ambulance and off to the hospital for help. This man was not one of the dirty dozen, he was a functional member of our community who celebrated a bit too much for his birthday. The ambulance attendants should be ashamed of themselves as they should know better.

This whole thing makes me sick, how are we Yukoner's supposed to trust the RCMP or the ambulance attendants when they don't even give a damn about what happens to us. All they care about it a paycheck.

Up 0 Down 0

Not Acceptable on May 13, 2010 at 2:47 pm

The writer calling him or her self JC is really an insensitive racist. From your letter I can gather you hold certain views of F. Nations being "paid out" and that the police and guards are not at fault.There doesn't need to be a wait time to determine "guilty"; the paliantologist already confirmed in the hearing he died due to negligence by those who were supposed to care for him. Did you know Ray Silverfox's daughter Deanna Lee already had to endure leukimia when she was 12? Now to watch her Dad's passing away in such a horrific, abusive way...a little much to endure in one's lifetime. Your comments are callous, insensitive and reek of racism.

Too bad the Star has to let such garbage comments like that be printed. Out of respect for the family I think JC's should be REMOVED!

Up 0 Down 0

D G on May 13, 2010 at 1:19 pm

"NOM NOM NOM NOM" good foot lol

Anytime I hear Silverfox from now on I can't help but think of the drunk man who can''t hold his liquor.

I doubt that is the way the daughter or the family wants Raymond Silverfox to be remembered but they are the ones escalating this.

I used to work at Home Hardware and helped Mr. Silverfox several times when he came into town for materials for his job. I remembered him as a decent guy but this whole thing has tarnished his image for the worse.

Rather than battle the courts do the civilized thing and move on.

Up 0 Down 0

tommy smith on May 11, 2010 at 12:45 pm

if the guards are so underpaid they can find a job elsewere. and i believe the silverfox family would rather have there loved one back rather than money. who wears diapers in jail. you jc i havent heard of anyones diapers being changed or worn in there maybe you though huh. maybe not sounds like your the purrrfect man in yukon. so dumb some of these comments. i think they really put there foot in there mouths.

Up 0 Down 0

anonymous on May 11, 2010 at 2:25 am

Why on earth would there be a continued need for RCMP in the Yukon. On so many levels such a concept will never succeed. Consider philosophy, administration, and finance to name three. Philosophically and administratively there have been public admissions of failure too many times to count. Financially, the cost of policing the Yukon with the RCMP is off the charts. RCMP individuals make a ton of money coming to work in the Yukon and leave too soon. Its a revolving door with money and people flying through it.

Its time for a Yukon police force and all the advantages that accompany same. More connectedness with the populace,more commitment to long-term living in the community, more local accountability vs. accountability to some far off center in Ottawa, and FAR LESS COST.

Up 0 Down 0

JC on May 10, 2010 at 8:55 am

The guards at the police cells are grossly underpaid. The cops get at least double what they get. Why should the guards have to change prisoners diapers and clean up their vomit? Let the overpaid traffic cops do it! And now that the top cop makes the admitance and humble apology before any future court case, you can be sure that the Silverfox family will receive a nice generous check from the tax payers. He could have at least waited for final results of a court case or law suit. Too late now. And now, the two underpaid guards get fired while the 5 overpaid traffic cops get transferred. Typical!

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.