Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by CP

FROM PREMIER TO SENATOR – Then-Yukon premier Pat Duncan removes a microphone after a television interview at the premiers’ conference in Vancouver in 2002. CP PHOTO/Adrian Wyld

Senate seat filled after 16-month wait

After a 16-month vacancy, Yukoners now know who will be filling the sole seat as their territorial representative in the Senate: one-time premier Pat Duncan.

By Palak Mangat on December 12, 2018

After a 16-month vacancy, Yukoners now know who will be filling the sole seat as their territorial representative in the Senate: one-time premier Pat Duncan.

Currently employed with the territorial Department of Justice, Duncan enjoyed two years as the first female premier of the Yukon from 2000 to 2002. She headed the territory’s first-ever Liberal government.

Reached by the Star this morning, she said the announcement of her appointment came down as somewhat of a surprise.

“I kind of didn’t think it was going to happen, but I’m thrilled (that it did),” she laughed.

She spoke shortly after the federal government detailed in a release her and three other senators’ appointments (see related coverage, p. 10).

While Duncan explained there is no one topic nor cause that she plans to focus on going forward, she did recall her roots as a child after her late father, Tommy, immigrated from Scotland.

“It goes all the way back to my days in the Girl Guides: leaving your campsite cleaner than you found it,” she said. As a result, she said, issues like climate change and global warming are near to her heart.

“Responsible economic development” is another, she added.

She has served in various roles – most recently as a manager of the workers’ advocate office with the Yukon government.

Duncan is no stranger to the political realm: she served on the Canadian Advisory Council on the Status of Women, was the Yukon’s commissioner for the Girl Guides of Canada and chaired the city’s environmental health board.

“We are servants of the Canadian taxpayer and the public,” she said.

Yukon MP Larry Bagnell, reached early this afternoon, said it’s great to have another woman and northerner in Ottawa.

Calling Duncan an “esteemed Yukoner,” he said there is especially a need for the legislative body to have a number of senators who have experience in how things work – which Duncan is well-suited to bring.

“She’ll bring great strength in that respect, and it’s great to have more of a gender balance in the Senate too.”

Bagnell explained the house of sober second thought being full will also help to ease the workload on the House of Commons, where he serves, as MPs can have often hectic schedules.

As the release noted, the number of women in the Red Chamber has increased from about 37 to 47 per cent under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

The number of those who identify as Indigenous has more than doubled, it added.

Yukon NDP Leader Liz Hanson also weighed in on the appointment.

“I think it’s lovely,” Hanson said of Duncan’s new role, adding she is surprised but pleased.

Hanson referenced the one-time premier’s time in Ottawa as having included her role as constituency affairs assistant during the 1980s under the late MP Erik Nielsen. (The Whitehorse airport bears his name.)

With Duncan having been premier more than a decade later, Hanson expects she will be armed with at least some insight into the territory’s land claim agreement negotiations and devolution of powers.

“She should have a good background in terms of being able to represent Yukoners,” Hanson said, adding she sees Duncan as very accessible.

For her part, Duncan agreed being accessible and relevant, especially to the younger crowds, will be important to her as a future member of the Senate.

“I think Pat’s the kind of person who is pragmatic; she can be one of those voices that will allow the Senate to work in a way that is focused,” Hanson said.

“She’s got some good people to be joining there,” the leader added.

No one from the Yukon Party was available to comment on the senator-designate.

Premier Sandy Silver did weigh in, saying he is pleased with the appointment of his party’s former leader.

“Duncan has an outstanding record serving Yukoners,” he said in a statement this morning. “I am confident she will continue to represent us with the utmost integrity as senator.”

Duncan also received praise from one-time Liberal MLA Jack Cable this morning.

Admitting he hadn’t been following the developments around the Senate appointments too closely, the former commissioner did call her a hard-working citizen.

“She’s had quite a varied background,” he said.

He referenced her time with the Whitehorse Chamber of Commerce and involvement in volunteering for sporting events like the Canada Summer and Winter Games, and her roles with the Whitehorse Glacier Bears Swim Club.

“It’s also a question of how the Senate is going to work as independent senators; I’m curious how that’s going to work,” Cable said before laughing.

“She will have her hands full,” he told the Star.

He also acknowledged that the appointment was “a long time coming” since Conservative appointee Dan Lang’s departure in August 2017, but was glad to now have an answer.

Sue Edelman, a one-time cabinet minister under Duncan’s Liberal government, is confident that she will represent the territory well, given her “impressive résumé.

“I’m extremely pleased,” Edelman said this morning.

She noted Duncan’s familiarity with land claim agreements and negotiations will prove helpful in setting the territory apart from other areas which are more familiar with on-reserve systems.

“More than that, she comes from a strong volunteer background in community and sports, so is very involved.”

Edelman laughed that the appointment didn’t really come as a complete surprise to her.

“As soon as I heard there was a vacancy, I sort of thought about Pat just because of her knowledge of the workings in Ottawa as well as the Yukon.

“I just am so pleased and I can’t think of anybody better to fulfill that role.”

For her part, Duncan agreed that her “knowledge as a Yukoner and of the legislative process” will come in handy as she assumes her Red Chamber seat next year.

Last July, the Whitehorse Chamber of Commerce sent out a notice from the Advisory Board of Senate Appointments encouraging Canadians to apply for the Red Chamber position. The feds’ announcement today comes nearly five months after that notice.

As announced by Ottawa, the other vacancy in the North was filled by Margaret Dawn Anderson for the Northwest Territories. She is a public servant who has participated in self-government negotiations.

Trudeau said in a statement the four new senators named today bring a wealth of knowledge and experience that will benefit both Parliament and the country.

“They know what it means to serve, and have dedicated their careers to making a difference in the lives of others,” he said. “I look forward to working with them on issues that matter most to Canadians.”

Duncan will sit as an independent, bringing the Senate up to a total of 105 senators for the first time in almost a decade.

The Senate acts as a secondary body to the House of Commons that reviews bills before being passed, with its work often being done via committees of about about 12 to 15 senators.

These allow for public hearings from those interested citizens.

Currently, each of the three territories holds one seat in the Senate while Ontario and Quebec have 24 each. With today’s announcement, all vacancies have been filled – with under a year left until the 2019 federal election.

YG’s justice department did not comment further on the appointment but did confirm Duncan is still employed with it and wished her well.

For her part, Duncan said she will now undergo a transition period and leave the department to fulfill her federal role in the new year, which is when the swearing-in is also expected.

Lang and his predecessor, former Liberal senator Ione Christensen, could not be reached for comment on the appointment.

Comments (21)

Up 1 Down 1

Mick on Dec 18, 2018 at 3:40 pm

The Yukon's shortest serving Premier. The 'her way or the highway' style of politics cost her the government and eventually her job. Not sure this is the temperament we want to see in the upper chamber.

Up 6 Down 10

G Boisvert on Dec 18, 2018 at 12:09 am

Congrats Pat. You more than deserve this. Saw that in you a lot of years ago.

Up 11 Down 13

Ed Norton on Dec 17, 2018 at 4:38 pm

I will take my chances with Pat over some of the so called Yukoners the neo cons appointed to this seat. At least she has an appreciation and understanding of First Nations Agreements and people. I also like what she is saying about climate change, that is where we collectively need some real leadership.

Up 33 Down 8

Max Mack on Dec 14, 2018 at 11:08 pm

Independent. Hahahahahahaha!

Up 25 Down 8

My Opinion on Dec 14, 2018 at 9:09 pm

@BnR

The conservatives did the exact opposite actually. Much to my chagrin they left 23 seats empty and handed over the reigns to the Liberals. They say it is totally non politically influenced. I say BS. Convenient it was a Liberal and a Woman. Imagine that. Fits right into their Mantra.

Up 28 Down 35

Rural Resident on Dec 13, 2018 at 4:24 pm

Congratulations Pat, I know you will do an excellent job.

Up 36 Down 19

Henry Wensleydale on Dec 13, 2018 at 2:40 pm

Someone like Joe Sparling would have gotten my vote.

Up 41 Down 19

YT on Dec 13, 2018 at 7:51 am

And folks are losing their collective minds over this.
Will Mrs Duncan do a good job? Probably. She has experience at all government levels. She is articulate. As I said, who else was on the list?
I am acquainted with both of our last senators. I recall speaking to Danny at the airport after a few months on the job. His reply was that he hadn't realized how much work it was. And that's true. I think both of our past two senators did a good job, political affiliations aside.
Just look at the many negative, ill-informed comments in this section.
And people wonder why we don't get many good choices during elections; who would want to subject themselves to the critique of ignorant, misinformed fools.
Until such time as Canada adopts some other type of governmental system (the US systems is working out well eh?) this is what we have.
Poor choices can be made, remember Brazeau and Duffy?
I think Pat will work hard for us and Canada.

Up 37 Down 8

jackpot on Dec 13, 2018 at 7:26 am

This must be a little like winning the lottery.

Up 36 Down 22

jack on Dec 12, 2018 at 11:18 pm

Her term as premier marked by Liberal in-fighting with no accomplishments of note.
Didn't even serve a full term as premier (only 2 years) and now gets a lifetime gong as Senator?

Up 28 Down 20

BnR on Dec 12, 2018 at 9:17 pm

For god sakes.
It's like you people have no idea how the present senate election works.
It's an independent board.
And here is everyone crying partisan, like they forgot who our last senator was and who appointed him. Yeah, sure, it's ONLY the Libs who "take care of their own".
And who should we have as our senator? Juniper Jackson? Wilf??
Anyone could have applied, so how about this? People write in, here, in the comments, who they think would have made a better senator.
Come, quit your bitching and whining and let's hear it.

Up 28 Down 14

Hugh Mungus on Dec 12, 2018 at 7:15 pm

@Juniper Jackson I’m guessing your application didn’t make the cut? Or do you just complain about literally everything including the colour of the sky?

Up 48 Down 14

Hugh Mungus on Dec 12, 2018 at 7:10 pm

In a tree lined ditch, somewhere in the Yukon a fully camouflaged Ryan Leef is seething.

Up 19 Down 27

Yukon Justice on Dec 12, 2018 at 4:54 pm

Pat is a person of the Yukon and that is all the qualifications she needs.

Up 58 Down 34

A good choice on Dec 12, 2018 at 4:41 pm

Pat was my MLA and she represented everyone in her riding, whether they voted for her or not. I think this is an excellent choice, and I believe she'll do a great job for Yukoners, no matter what political beliefs they have.

Up 45 Down 39

Ginger Johnson on Dec 12, 2018 at 4:22 pm

MEH - could have been worse

Andrew Scheer would appoint Dennis Fentie or Darryl Pasloski

Up 39 Down 14

So much for non-partisan on Dec 12, 2018 at 4:19 pm

@YT and who appointed people to the "non-partisan" group? I'll give to a hint. When you don't win gold you get...

Up 52 Down 30

Juniper Jackson on Dec 12, 2018 at 4:11 pm

Hey YT.. how did you know that folks would lose their heads over the selection of a dyed in the wool Liberal to the Senate? Ms. Duncan was a Premier for what? A month? There is a reason she lost it all..

Up 48 Down 35

Beverly Sembsmoen on Dec 12, 2018 at 4:11 pm

Congratulations and best wishes in representing Yukon in the Senate Pat!

Up 39 Down 36

YT on Dec 12, 2018 at 3:27 pm

Ok, before everyone loses their heads, remember, you had to write in your own application, and it was a non-partisan group who vetted and selected from the applications. The PMs office was not involved.
Before everyone flies off the handle, just keep this all in mind and ask yourself this; who else was on the list.

Up 45 Down 34

So much for non-partisan on Dec 12, 2018 at 3:27 pm

Not at all surprised to see the Liberals start to stack political bodies with partisan members so close to an election they may lose. I will give it to the Liberals, they always take care of their own.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.