Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Anna Crawford

WE GAVE IT A TRY – Bernie Phillips (right), who finished third in the mayoral race, shakes hands with second-placer Rick Karp on Thursday evening at city hall (top). NUMBERS TOLD THE TALE – Rick Karp watches election results flow into city council chambers Thursday evening.

Second-placer knew early that victory wasn't to be

Rick Karp sat quietly in the middle of city council chambers Thursday night, occasionally exchanging casual conversation as his chance to be mayor melted away, slowly but steadily.

By Stephanie Waddell on October 19, 2012

Rick Karp sat quietly in the middle of city council chambers Thursday night, occasionally exchanging casual conversation as his chance to be mayor melted away, slowly but steadily.

Right from the beginning, when the results of the Oct. 11 advance poll were delivered, the dominating support for mayor-designate Dan Curtis was crystal clear. The night's eventual victor had jumped out in front with 190 votes in the advance poll, compared to 99 for second-placer Karp.

It remained so for more than four hours until the last of the 23 polls reported in well after midnight.

"It looks like Dan ran a strong campaign,” Karp said in interview, with results from seven of 23 polls flashing on the big screen directly behind the mayor's chair: Curtis, 643; Karp, 321; Bernie Phillips, 223; Scott Howell, 150; Mandeep Sidhu, 480.

"He is 320 in front,” Karp observed. "So he is pulling away from everyone.”

Indeed.

By the end of the night, Curtis had secured 2,375 votes, or 43 per cent of votes cast for mayor, compared to 1,100 or 20 per cent for Karp's second-place showing.

Karp and his campaign team spent most of Thursday in their headquarters at the Gold Rush Inn, monitoring, emailing, and providing transportation to polling stations for anyone who needed a ride.

Only a handful called for lift.

"I was targeting people who had expressed an interest in the campaign through email and FaceBook,” Karp said.

"There were several hundred people who were active on the FaceBook page, asking really interesting questions.”

All in all, said the long-time president of the Whitehorse Chamber of Commerce, it was difficult to gauge the electorate because everywhere he went, residents gave him a positive reception.

"People here are like that,” he said. "This is Whitehorse. In Whitehorse, we are the happiest people in Canada.”

Though not willing to throw in the towel with just a third of the polls in, the widening gap wasn't lost on Karp.

"It's not over until it's over, but it seems like Dan is pulling away,” he said. "First he was 100 ahead, and now he is 320 up on me.”

It wasn't long before the lead was 400 votes, then 500, and with 13 of 23 polls reporting, Curtis has established a lead of just over 700 votes.

Karp left his chair to congratulate Curtis shortly after the mayor-designate arrived at city hall with results from several polling stations still outstanding, but the result obvious.

Karp stayed, and continued his casual conversations.

The spokesman for the Whitehorse business community built his campaign on the need for financial accountability and restraint on property taxes that have gone up and up and up, year after year after year.

The city, Karp maintained through his campaign, needs new leadership; new direction to face the challenges of a growing city.

City hall does have a role to play in creating the atmosphere for new business initiatives and economic diversification, he insisted.

As the night wore on and the numbers grew thinner at election central in council chambers, Karp's phone rang.

"I'll be home soon,” he told his wife, Joy. "Put the kettle on.”

City manager Stan Wesby came by to shake Karp's hand and acknowledge the candidate's willingness to stand for public office.

"Tough luck,” Wesby offered.

"No, not tough luck,” Karp replied. "I gave it a shot, and I will be back at the chamber, and we'll be seeing you.”

Karp said if there had been fewer than the five candidates for mayor, the numbers would have been different, but probably not the outcome.

"I think Dan still would have won because he had a machine behind him.”

The local business owner said he is happy to return to the chamber.

"This whole thing has been good for the chamber,” Karp said. "It was a wonderful experience for me, and I enjoyed it immensely.

"You have to try everything once.”

The fight, however, is not over by any means, he insisted.

Karp said there are a number of pressing issues staring city hall in the face.

There's still the lack of affordable housing to address, he pointed out.

There is also the safety and security of residents. That issue raised its head during the campaign with recent incidences of residents being accosted on city streets, even during daylight hours, he pointed out.

"Our biggest issue right now is the affordable rental market, and the city has a big role to play in that, and the chamber will be working on that.”

Young Yukoners living Outside for whatever reason who want to return home can't because there's no place to live, or the cost of accommodations is just too high, he said.

Karp pointed out he received a call from one senior on a fixed income.

She feared being forced to leave her home because the landlord was raising her rent to $1,500 a month.

City council needs to make some fundamental changes, he said.

The city, Karp said, is not going to stop growing, and city hall needs to be ready for that.

While he's returning to the chamber, Karp said, he's taking the business of the city with him.

Comments (3)

Up 0 Down 0

Lisa on Oct 22, 2012 at 12:48 am

I'm glad Mr Karp did not win office, as a young, new voter, I felt he is out of touch with what we need for this city.

Congrats Mr Curtis, You have three years to show Yukoners how you can shine, Don't let us down

Up 0 Down 0

A Numbered Company on Oct 20, 2012 at 12:01 pm

Actually, I didn't vote for Dan Curtis because of the money and the robocalling, and many people have said that to me. But those votes didn't go to Rick Karp. I'm puzzled at that connection, because they seemed to have distinctly different ideas.

It's nothing against Dan Curtis, but I don't like the idea that Whitehorse is drifting towards that kind of campaign and I didn't want to reward it.

Up 0 Down 0

scott herron on Oct 19, 2012 at 8:13 am

Rick Karp continues to place responsibility for Dan Curtis' victory on the fact that Dan had "a machine behind him". I personally was initially going to vote for Rick until he began making his irrational attacks against Dan Curtis. To me, this raised serious concerns about Rick Karp and what kind of person/mayor he would be. Rick's attacks resulted in me switching my vote to Dan Curtis; I suspect I am not the only voter who had this reaction. It is sad that Rick Karp did not come to recognize this even after the vote.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.