Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Education Minister Tracy-Anne McPhee

Schools won’t be ‘business as usual,’ YG warns

Kindergarten to Grade 12 students will return to classrooms the week of Aug. 18 with safety guidelines and contingency plans that prepare for a resurgence of COVID-19.

By Gabrielle Plonka on June 10, 2020

Kindergarten to Grade 12 students will return to classrooms the week of Aug. 18 with safety guidelines and contingency plans that prepare for a resurgence of COVID-19.

“This has been a school year like no other; this has been a challenging time for everyone,” Education Minister Tracy-Anne McPhee told a news briefing Tuesday afternoon.

“Education is an essential service, and the longer that students are away, the larger the impact.”

McPhee said schools – whose closure was announced April 7 – are at the beginning stages of planning to host students in classrooms again for the 2020-21 school year.

Each school will create individual operational plans based on safety guidelines provided by Dr. Brendan Hanley, the chief medical officer.

These plans will be shared with parents in August, and will likely look different from community to community.

Hanley told the briefing operational plans will generally include hand washing stations, physical distancing rules and potentially smaller class sizes and shorter hours.

A document was shared with parents and guardians Tuesday outlining some of the things to be expected from the new school year.

Currently, the plan is for students to return to classrooms full-time. 

If the risk of COVID-19 rises, school capacities may be limited to 50 per cent, 20 per cent, or shut down entirely.

If capacity is limited, essential groups of students with disabilities or diverse learning needs would be prioritized to remain in classrooms.

At 50 per cent capacity, the remainder of students would attend school on a part-time rotating schedule. At 20 per cent capacity, only essential students would attend school.

The document advised that “schools will not be business as usual during the pandemic.” Busing arrangements, school schedules, lunch hour and recess all may be adjusted.

If some students need to remain at home, they can continue their learning by distance.

Guardians will be contacted by their local school to confirm each child’s attendance.

Hanley said the risk for children contracting COVID-19 at Yukon schools is lower than the negative impact of keeping children at home long-term.

Hanley explained that data from other parts of Canada show that children are more likely to catch COVID-19 at home than at school, and tend to experience a milder form of the disease.

Since the beginning of the pandemic, children under 19 represent seven per cent of COVID-19 cases, with less than one per cent requiring hospitalization and no deaths.

“It is most important for children’s health to stay active, and stay actively learning,” Hanley said.

Keeping children away from school puts some kids at risk of domestic violence and social isolation.

“The social issues from this pandemic will have longer-reaching impacts than the virus itself,” Hanley said.

“Even while incurring a calculated risk of COVID introduction, we know this small risk must be balanced with the harms of keeping students out of school for too long.”

McPhee noted that the government is still at the initial planning stages, and more detail will be available for students and guardians into summer.

Yukon Party MLA Scott Kent told the Star this morning he found the announcement leaves many questions unanswered.

“I think, again, the lack of details in yesterday’s announcement was disappointing for many families, and there’s certainly a lack of transparency about what schools might look like for the upcoming year,” said Kent, his party’s education critic.

The lack of clarity on classroom and bus schedules is challenging for families, Kent said.

“The big thing that I’m disappointed about is that the planning isn’t further along,” Kent said.

“When the initial reopening plan was released by the Yukon government, they talked about conversations taking place in May and June with communities.

“They are just starting to engage with school councils now.”

Sharing operational plans this spring, rather than waiting until August, would have allowed some room for conversation and adjustment, he pointed out.

“Leaving it so late in the game and not making it public until school is scheduled to go back in creates some challenges,” Kent said.

NDP Leader Kate White said she was relieved to see the announcement about schools reopening.

“I know for lots of families and lots of parents right now, the challenge of trying to work from home and educate their children at the same time, while doing it remotely, without being teachers, has been incredibly challenging,” White said.

“That’s not even including all the reasons why schools are important for kids.”

White said she is confident that school staff will iron out the details in time for a successful start to the school year.

“I have to give full credit to the Department of Education and educators – they are fluid and flexible; they’ll get it sorted out,” White said.

“I think loading us with details that may change isn’t effective.”

Comments (7)

Up 5 Down 4

Juniper Jackson on Jun 16, 2020 at 9:12 am

Well Justin, you nailed it. I don't see what good letting 6 people into a 50 seat dining room does for the business. Or for staff or people. While I do not promote civil unrest which often leads to violence, I do promote civil disobedience when the laws are bad.. any law is only as good as peoples willingness to keep them. If people are afraid, jeez..stay home! I did not drink the fear koolaid, offered free of charge to the thirsty. Believe what you want to believe. I am out there living my best life, or life as best I can when coming face to face with total opposites in belief. Silver probably extended the State of Emergency because Trudeau did.. they all want a long, taxpayer paid for holiday. I am amazed by so many sarcastic.. BUT, rational comments. Common sense is not dead and gone..its still alive in a remaining few.

Up 11 Down 4

Isnuckapeek on Jun 14, 2020 at 11:21 pm

Well done Justin... Well done... It is a rare privilege to have some balance in these forums. Too often we read from the agenda of some pathological mind. For example, a Prime Minister using his conscious bias to state that every Canadian has unconscious bias whole intending that prejudice unidirectionally to further incite intolerance towards certain segments of a previously more civil society...

I like that, it’s easier to fool people than to convince them that they have been fooled. What we are in the middle of right now is the well articulated sociological observation that conformity has replaced consciousness. These are dangerous times as we are in the middle of a great impulse towards madness wherein normative behaviour is in a downward spiral to some lowest common denominator.

There is no safety for anyone. And there is no “new normal” only the same old chaos in a different light. There is no hope that things will stabilize in the near future. Keep your chin up:

Those who are able to see beyond the shadows and lies of their culture will never be understood, let alone believed, by the masses - Plato (STA).

Up 13 Down 6

Gringo on Jun 14, 2020 at 7:02 pm

Why can’t it be business as usual we have NO covid in the territory. I just had to go through my sons graduation... gong show. He spent 13 years in school and his graduation was based on the sitcom funny farm, all the while ZERO Covid cases. There is no reason at present why anything should not be back to the way it was prior to this pandemic here in The Yukon.

Up 28 Down 17

JC on Jun 11, 2020 at 9:04 pm

Mitch, don't ever join the Armed Forces. You wouldn't even make a good grunt with that kind of thinking. You haven't thought of the collateral damage caused by this long lockdown around the world, such as suicides, spousal and child abuse, alcohol and drugs etc. Of course the mainstream media didn't mention this, had to search the underground media for this info. Nothing like this was done over all the other viruses of the past. Why now? This whole thing had little to do with the virus, but power. Now the government leaders know a little more how to control the people. Just a training course for them. It's more healthy to take chances than lock oneself in a closet.

Up 26 Down 30

Mitch on Jun 11, 2020 at 12:34 pm

Hi Justin, I know there are lots of people like you who believe what you wrote and that the world is flat and the center of the universe.

Do I believe our politicians are always right and don't make mistakes, no I do not. All politicians make mistakes. But I also believe that if the world did not shut down during this pandemic, a lot more people would have died. We have almost 8 thousand in Canada and over 459 thousand world wide and it is not over. If you are not afraid of covid then you should join the front line workers in the hard hit continuing care locations in Ontario or Quebec. They need help.

Up 40 Down 18

Justin on Jun 10, 2020 at 7:17 pm

Hello everyone,

I would like to take this opportunity to thank our CMO, and our local territorial elected officials, for taking their time to perpetuate the fear and brainwashing surrounding the entire pandemic issue. Folks, as the old saying goes, you’re beating a dead horse.

Watching our national “leaders” preach distancing, while actively engaging in protests involving hundreds, if not thousands of people, with no regard to social distancing. That kind of drops a large rock on the toes of your argument. Admitting that kids are less likely to catch this flu at school than at home... really? Wow. Waiting until the last days of the school year to begin consulting with educators, another dropped ball. All of this tomfoolery, courtesy of those who appear incapable of planning anything of substance, possibly even a lunch date.

I’m going to ask a question of all the people of the Yukon Territory.

Are we collectively so brainwashed/stupid, as to believe anything that our elected officials, or bureaucrats tell us anymore. I haven’t heard a thing of true substance from any of them, since all of this foolishness began. True Yukoners watch out for each other, and help their community when in need. They are a very awake and conscious folk, with the ability to reason for themselves when the need arises. They are not easily led, nor pushed into poor decisions or actions instigated by others. There are many solid people out there, I am lucky enough to see many of them. Not cowering in fear of the government, or the media spin on everything. These people are going about their lives as normal, helping where it’s needed, looking out for everyone.

All I have seen from our elected representatives, is a lot of nothing. On all sides. It is a sad state of affairs.
For the sake of the children, let's get back to normal. Stop scaring them, stop trying to brainwash them. As responsible adults, we owe it forward to the children, to do much better than we currently are.

I’m going to take a lot of flack for this comment, and that is good. It means that something here has made people think. I cannot teach anyone, I can only hope to make them think, and question.

In the words of Mark Twain,
“The glory which is built upon a lie soon becomes a most unpleasant incumbrance. … How easy it is to make people believe a lie, and how hard it is to undo that work again.”

This saying has been paraphrased to state “it’s easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled”
Take care everyone, and step up, live your best life!

Up 65 Down 13

Yukoner on Jun 10, 2020 at 3:39 pm

Why not keep the border closed, keep our cases at zero and then at least the lives of our children can return to normal with school. How much in tourism dollars are actually expected by opening up the border and is that enough to risk having to keep our children home? Look at New Zealand, they are at 0 cases, keeping a tight border and are able to reopen everything.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.