Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Steve Geick and Sean Secord

Rural nurses are working 15-20 days alone

“You’re on your own.”

By Aimee O'Connor on October 27, 2015

“You’re on your own.”

That’s the hard reality for nurses working in the territory’s communities, according to Yukon Employees’ Union (YEU) president Steve Geick, who had worked as a community nurse himself for 15 years.

“When it comes to the delivery of health care or first responders, you never see just one paramedic driving an ambulance, or one RCMP officer, or one firefighter going out to extinguish a fire....

“It’s just not heard of.”

Last week, Geick wrote an open letter to Health Minister Mike Nixon. Published in Friday’s Star, the letter urged him to “get out from behind his desk” and address some of the hardships occurring in the area of community nursing.

Geick told the Star Friday his letter marked the first time the issue has been approached in such a way – perhaps a testament to a long battle against a staffing issue that has yet to be won.

The majority of Yukon communities are meant to have two full-time registered nurses employed – both on call 24 hours every day.

There are some exceptions, such as Dawson City, which has five nurses on staff, with one on call 24 hours each day. Or Destruction Bay and Beaver Creek, both with just one nurse on duty and on-call.

Even though those numbers are what’s written on the Department of Health and Social Services’ website, it’s not how many are actually currently employed.

The numbers of vacant positions is blurry – Nixon, the department and Geick have all previously reported differing numbers.

There has been a posting seeking community nurses on the Yukon government’s job website, with the label indicating it is a posting that will stay “until filled.”

But backing away from specifics, any number of vacant positions in communities that have only two nurses to begin with could have repercussions.

“I would worry less about the exact numbers, and more about the gap that the numbers create,” NDP Health critic Jan Stick said Monday.

“When a nurse has to work alone, she’s alone.”

In Geick’s letter to Nixon, the turnover rate and staffing problems should have the department’s alarm bells ringing, he writes.

“What I say, and the NDP says, is that we have people who are saying they’ve worked 15-20 days by themselves,” Geick said.

“You burn out easily.”

When it comes to taking time off, a nurse working alone would require an auxillary on-call employee (AOC) to be flown in to cover the nurse leaving.

The easy solution, according to Geick, would be to increase the number of nurses in most communities from two to three.

Along with the employees’ union, the Yukon NDP has climbed aboard the issue, raising it in legislature last spring.

Opposition Leader Liz Hanson quoted the Clinical Services Plan from 2014. It references a recommendation that the recruitment and retention of community nurses “continue to be a priority until vacancies have been eliminated to the level where individual responsibilities can be fulfilled within the existing job descriptions.”

In the report, there was a note that nurses were commonly providing non-nursing functions because of limited resources and staffing.

Nixon noted the department had not accepted the report’s recommendations yet, and that “every government department finds that there are vacant positions from time to time.”

Later in the session, Stick asked why support for rural health professionals haven’t been a priority.

Premier Darrell Pasloski responded by telling the assembly how proud he was of the Yukon Party’s vision to make the territory a net financial contributor to Canada.

When Stick raised the issue in legislature yesterday, Nixon admitted the retention of community nurses has been challenging in the past, and continues to be now.

He added that the department has tried to be creative with its recruitment strategies, posting advertisements on job sites, using word-of-mouth and attending job fairs across Canada.

Speaking to Stick later, she told the Star Nixon’s response was not exactly surprising.

“I would like to hear him take it seriously. Today we heard back exactly what we thought we would,” she said.

The NDP released a recent statement that said the Yukon Party approach to recruitment and retention of health professionals is failing miserably.

But Sean Secord, the president of the Yukon Registered Nurses Association (YRNA), told the Star this morning the Yukon typically does not have issues attracting nurses to work in the territory.

“We haven’t felt the brunt of the nursing issue that other jurisdictions have,” he said.

However, the nurses’ association is on board with the need to accommodate staffing, Secord said.

Nixon has previously noted that the department will continue to “work with YRNA on recruitment and retention.”

“We haven’t had a working group per se,” Secord said.

“(But) we’ve made him aware of the problem and I trust that he will continue to work with us and listen to our concerns.”

Nixon declined to be interviewed by the Star for this story.

A cabinet spokesperson said the minister intends to respond to Geick directly about his open letter.

In the meantime, it’s clear the parties involved won’t be letting the issue go anytime soon.

The YEU is gearing up for this winter’s round of bargaining, with about 150 demands from members throughout Yukon government.

“There’s a good majority (of demands) brought forward by community nurses,” Geick said.

Nixon told the house Monday the department is looking forward to try to address the issues during the upcoming round of bargaining.

“We can’t tell the government how many people to employ, but throwing money at the (problem) isn’t fixing anything,” Geick said.

“Right now is the worst I’ve seen it.”

But, Secord said, from the YRNA’s perspective, it is an issue that doesn’t just pertain to unions.

“It needs attention,” he said.

Comments (9)

Up 0 Down 0

Rob the medic on Apr 3, 2016 at 2:37 am

I'm working 24hr shifts on a 8-4 rotation...I have a rez in my coverage area that has 11% HIV rate, that doesn't include the Hep alphabet prevalence. Last month I filled two ICUs 300km apart and put 1200km on an ambulance in one shift (28hr). I love it because I love helping people. I don't complain to the press about my lower than expected wages and at times overworked days...because I knew how broken the system was before I went to school.

Up 10 Down 4

Double lifelong Yukoner on Oct 31, 2015 at 10:19 am

I'm just a little perplexed as to how the communities have survived the last 100 years? This is not meant to have a political bent but is put forth as a straight forward question of reality. When you move into a community you do so realizing the services available or don't live there. Harsh but this has been the reality of the situation forever. If you want the Mayo clinic you have to move wherever that is. What am I missing here?

Up 24 Down 2

LD on Oct 29, 2015 at 3:17 pm

Communities require practical nurses where there are no doctors - not just RN's (or LPN's). RN's are fantastic and I'm so grateful we have so many amazing ones right here in Whitehorse but practical nurses are better for communities where there are no doctors practicing regularly.

Although off topic - I agree with others who are saying that nurses are not valued as they should be.

Up 26 Down 3

Lifelong Yukoner on Oct 29, 2015 at 12:05 pm

I am just wondering why anyone would down vote Alex's comment? If there were nurses in the family, and there are currently first nations students from the community attending and graduating nursing school who can hopefully one day work as nurses in the territory that is terrific news isn't it?

Up 23 Down 3

Lifelong Yukoner on Oct 28, 2015 at 6:45 pm

@Alex: And yet most the small northern communities are still almost totally reliant on importing health care professionals from southern Canada, without which there would be almost no health care. Good for your family with the nurses but as you know we're no where near being self sufficient in providing our own health care professionals to fill these never ending nursing position vacancies.

Up 24 Down 2

nurse on Oct 28, 2015 at 4:54 pm

Working for Health Canada in Manitoba is the same. Work all day, on call all night, and work the next day. The system just does not value nurses.

Up 42 Down 8

alex on Oct 28, 2015 at 2:19 pm

@ Lifelong Yukoner

My grandmother and 3 of my aunties were nurses. I can think of 3 girls in my community currently at nursing school, one who will graduate this year. And guess what, they're all first nations!

Up 42 Down 8

Lifelong Yukoner on Oct 28, 2015 at 10:06 am

Over the years I've heard this from several of my friends who are community nurses as well, they just get exhausted and burnt out. They sometimes work their normal day shift alone, and then the phone rings in the evening and overnight requiring them to be up half the night if not more. Then they are expected to be back at work for 8 am by themselves again, before repeating the entire process day after day. There are times where there are extended periods of time when they don't have anyone to relieve them or help out, period. Considering the majority of them are from elsewhere and only ended up in the community for their job, it's no wonder there's a lot of turnover in these positions and they can be hard to fill.
As we are talking about mostly small Yukon communities, where good employment for locals is in demand, I often wonder why more locals and especially first nation people don't enter the nursing profession. They would have a good paying job guaranteed for life in their home community.

Up 37 Down 5

Lost in the Yukon on Oct 27, 2015 at 5:36 pm

Nixon has finally shown he is in over his head and his micro managing Deputy Minister is no help.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.