Photo by Vince Fedoroff
A DEFENDER OF THE ENVIRONMENT – Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is seen above during Thursday afternoon's news conference in Whitehorse. Following his Alsek River excursion this weekend, he will give a public talk Monday evening.
Photo by Vince Fedoroff
A DEFENDER OF THE ENVIRONMENT – Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is seen above during Thursday afternoon's news conference in Whitehorse. Following his Alsek River excursion this weekend, he will give a public talk Monday evening.
Bobby Kennedy Jr. has added his voice to the contingent of Yukoners who say the Peel watershed planing process has been undemocratic.
Bobby Kennedy Jr. has added his voice to the contingent of Yukoners who say the Peel watershed planing process has been undemocratic.
But today, Environment Minister Currie Dixon called those comments laughable.
Kennedy, an environmental lawyer and president of the binational Waterkeeper Alliance, is in the Yukon for a whitewater rafting trip down the Alsek River – a journey which will take him past Mt. Kennedy.
Meeting with the local media late Thursday afternoon in Whitehorse, Kennedy commented on a variety of pressing issues on the Yukon environmental scene, including the Peel.
Kennedy noted that as he understands it, the majority of Yukoners and the four First Nations involved supported the final recommended plan for the pristine watershed. It was a compromise for the First Nations, which wanted to see 100 per cent of the region protected.
The government's new planning options essentially handed the Peel over to oil and gas extractive industries, said the 59-year-old Kennedy.
"It seems to me that was not an ideal example of democracy at work.”
"Subversion of democracy” is one of the biggest challenges facing people concerned about the environment across the continent, as he sees it.
"Democracy and the environment are intertwined. Wherever you see large-scale pollution, you're also going to see the subversion of the democratic process.
"You're going to see the disappearance of local control, of planning and zoning processes that are shut down to local public and put in the hands of large industries that in the United States can easily dominate state political landscapes, and in Canada, provincial political landscapes,” he said.
Dixon was less than appreciative of Kennedy's take on the situation.
"On behalf of the Government of Yukon, we'd like to welcome Mr. Kennedy to the territory,” Dixon said in an interview this morning.
"We're always happy to have rich tourists come to the territory and spend their money.
"But I have to say I think it's a little bit hilarious and embarrassing that a rich, elitist, celebrity, activist lawyer from the lower 48 would come up here and spew such ill-informed non-sense about an issue and a process about which he clearly has no understanding.”
Dixon went on to say that Kennedy was factually incorrect on a number of his statements.
However, he refused to list which ones, saying he hadn't seen a transcript of the lawyer's comments.
"But for him to suggest that the process was somehow undemocratic and that it was driven by, I guess, oil and gas interests, I think he said, is silly at best,” he said.
Kennedy clearly doesn't have an understanding of the Umbrella Final Agreement, Dixon said, issuing assurances that the government has followed the required process.
Kennedy also spoke about hydraulic fracturing.
As a member of a New York State committee examining fracking, he urged the Yukon legislature's select committee to conduct studies and examine the science behind the controversial extraction technique.
"Initially, I was supportive of fracking. In fact, I did an article for The Economist in 2008 that hailed the potential benefits of fracking for reducing our dependancy on oil and coal particularly,” Kennedy said.
"I've been convinced not by sentiment, or emotion, but by science, that it cannot be done safely, and it's a menace not only to local environments, but because of methane releases, we now know that there is no benefit for global warming over coal,” he concluded.
Permitting fracking would be permitting a few people to become billionaires at the expense of our common assets, he added.
Again, Dixon gave little credence to the comments.
"This from the scientific mind that opposes vaccinations for children in the United States despite the overwhelming consensus of health professionals in both Canada and the United States that vaccinations are a safe option for keeping our populations healthy,” the minister said. "So again, I don't really take his scientific advice too much.”
Dixon did point to the committee's mandate, which requires the members to gain a scientific understanding of the potential risks and benefits of the practice.
Kennedy noted that over his decades working as an environmental lawyer and activist, he's learned that it's not for the sake of the birds or the bees that we work to protect our environment.
"We're protecting it for our own sake because we recognize that nature is the infrastructure of our community, and that if we want to meet our obligations as a nation, as a civilization, as a generation, which is to provide for our children the same opportunities for dignity and enrichment and prosperity and good health as the communities that our parents gave us, we've got to start protecting our environmental infrastructure,” he said.
Kennedy's father, the late Robert F. Kennedy, climbed the Yukon's Mt. Kennedy in 1965 as tribute to his brother, U.S. president John F. Kennedy, who had been assassinated two years earlier.
That trip spurred the Kennedy family's passion for whitewater. The next summer, two years before Robert Kennedy was assassinated in 1968, the family rafted the Colorado River, igniting a passion that Bobby Kennedy and his siblings continue to explore today.
"Some of the best water in the world is here in the Yukon, and I'm looking forward to doing it,” Kennedy said Thursday.
Following his trip down the Alsek, during which he'll be accompanied by two of his chidren, Kennedy will present a lecture on Monday evening called Our Environmental Destiny at the Yukon Arts Centre.
The talk, which will start at 8 p.m., will be followed by a reception at 9 p.m.
The event is a fund-raiser for the Waterkeeper Alliance. Tickets are still available.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (28)
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Aug 7, 2013 at 5:38 am
"The US north Pacific fishing fleet is decimating salmon stocks due to greed and bycatch practices."
Gd'N makes a good point, unfortunately I doubt if RFK jr. is listening.
It's easy to challenge the policies of a small territorial government. Going up against the billion dollar US north Pacific fishing business is another matter.
I hope he proves that I underestimate him.
Up 0 Down 0
Pistols at dawn on Aug 6, 2013 at 3:04 pm
RFK jr. = Time Magazine's Hero for the Planet
Currie Dixon = Captain of the local softball team
Love to see a live debate between these two!
Up 0 Down 0
Glenys Baltimore on Aug 6, 2013 at 12:45 pm
I object strenuously to people who state strong and particularly disrespectful opinions anonymously.
Up 0 Down 0
not impressed on Aug 6, 2013 at 9:54 am
Stella said: "Well said Dixon!"
Seriously?? Dixon's chose to attack the man rather than his opinion, he couldn't even point to a single thing that he disagreed with. That is pretty ridiculous. Fentie must be giving 'back room bully' lessons because frankly, I am surprised that Currie would stoop to this kind schoolyard taunt. I've lost an immense amount of respect for him.
This guy is the Minister of the Environment for god sake and he is going of half cocked like this? It is really embarrassing to say the least.
Up 0 Down 0
Jack on Aug 6, 2013 at 8:43 am
@ Stella: Well said? He came across like a country bumpkin. Rather than focusing on the issues raised by Kennedy, Dixon made unprofessional (and inaccurate) attacks about Kennedy's public record (i.e. vaccinations - which is irrelevant to tracking). Hopefully he learns from this gaffe. Think before you speak - otherwise you will continue to sound like a fool.
Up 0 Down 0
Groucho d'North on Aug 6, 2013 at 6:55 am
If Mr. Kennedy wants to take on an eco-project with some meaning, perhaps when he returns home he can encourage his fellow Americans to adopt more sustainable fish harvesting practices. The US north Pacific fishing fleet is decimating salmon stocks due to greed and bycatch practices. The cross-border meetings at the bureaucrat level have taken place for years with little positive results; perhaps with Mr. Kennedy's sway something positive could happen, I encourage him to consider this challenge.
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Aug 6, 2013 at 5:54 am
RFK was misinformed, and some of his statements were out of line for a guest visiting a foreign country. Dixon's inane comments only made it worse.
Up 0 Down 0
and the numbers say on Aug 6, 2013 at 5:36 am
... 85% of all respondents think Minister Dixon was wrong
Up 0 Down 0
Stella on Aug 5, 2013 at 11:33 am
Well said Dixon!
Up 0 Down 0
Michael Eckford on Aug 5, 2013 at 10:01 am
Prime Minister of The Interdependent Sovereign Nation of Michael Eckford calls The Yukon Minister Against The Environment Currie Dixon's "laughable" comment "just plain stupid". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupidity
Up 0 Down 0
Grizzly Adams on Aug 5, 2013 at 8:13 am
I am proud somebody finally stood up to the self righteous eco bullies.
Not all of us can have cushy government jobs...or a silver spoon lineage..where a lack of industry doesn't matter.
Thanks Mr Dixon for the common sense and courage.
Up 0 Down 0
Mike Hawk on Aug 5, 2013 at 7:20 am
GREAT comments Minister Dixon...could not agree more!
Thanks for having the cajones to make a stand!
Currie for Premier!
Up 0 Down 0
Brice Carruthers on Aug 5, 2013 at 4:26 am
Currie Dixon is a talented and bright young politician for the Yukon. The key phrase is "for the Yukon". I would hate to see him engage in a one on one debate with Mr. Kennedy. Afterall, Mr. Kennedy is a Harvard educated lawyer and comes from the greatest political dynasty of modern American times. Currie's a bit young and lacks life experience. I chalk this one up to youth. In the future, Mr. Dixon could very well be Premier or our MP, or make a dent on national politics. However, he needs to keep his ego in check as all Yukon politicians should. Just because you got elected to office in the Yukon, does not mean one is particularly intellectually gifted or talented.
Up 0 Down 0
Louisa Gee on Aug 5, 2013 at 3:38 am
Whether you agree or disagree about the comments of our visitor/guest from the U.S., fine, that is your prerogative. For you to be so publicly ignorant and disrespectful to our visitor is truly a reflection of what an immature kid you really are. I sincerely hope your face is not on any of our Tourism posters, you silly little donkey!!
Up 0 Down 0
CJ on Aug 5, 2013 at 3:36 am
Currie Dixon has an undeserved reputation for being well-spoken. He's soft-spoken, it's not the same thing, when the content is so often belligerent.
It's sad, because if the situation was reversed and Currie was in Kennedy's backyard, he'd almost certainly be treated with more respect -- even though we can probably guarantee he'd say something ignorant. This man knows more about a life lived in public service than Currie will ever know, or apparently feels the need to know.
You don't speak for me, Currie, and never have, though you are supposedly my MLA. For the record, I was impressed with Kennedy's grasp of the Peel River issues and felt better-represented by his remarks.
Up 0 Down 0
Jonny on Aug 4, 2013 at 8:12 am
Say that you follow UFA process without question is wrong. There are major question about if the process was followed, you can say that RFK jr does not understand, however trying the say that Thomas Berger (who is on video stating that the plan is not in keeping with UFA), means there is argument for the other side. In terms of Mr. Dixon comment, they're shameful and insulting truly hurt the image of Yukon as a welcoming place. Shame.
Up 0 Down 0
G.K. on Aug 3, 2013 at 11:54 pm
Of course he regurgitates ill informed nonsense,after all that is what eco zealots do.
What does Ted Nugent think of the Peel plan? IMHO Ted has more cred. than this rich tourist.
Hopefully he buys a fishing license whilst on his nag tour, unlike Saint Suzuki (most likely) during his last entitlement tour...I hate poachers!
Up 0 Down 0
Sam Hall on Aug 3, 2013 at 4:55 am
I have never been to the Peel watershed but do know people who have shown me photos and talked about their river adventures and how pristine it is.
I have traveled the world and have seen the pollution and environmental changes that come with human use and misuse of the earth
There are mountains everywhere and beautiful rivers run through it. The Peel is very special.
I may not get up there but the Peel belongs to us- its ours and we want to protect it forever.
Currie Dixon may be out of a job after the next election. Currie is usually well spoken, what happened here? Protecting this area may promote a legacy that lasts forever- destroying a pristine natural area is a legacy of a different character. Lets make the right choice Currie.
Up 0 Down 0
Lee Carruthers on Aug 3, 2013 at 3:54 am
Dixon embarrasses himself and his constituents with his simple-minded conservative rhetoric. He certainly doesn't represent my views or the views of the majority of Yukoners. Time to throw these small-minded fools out of office and elect someone with a vision for a sustainable future.
Up 0 Down 0
jack on Aug 2, 2013 at 6:40 pm
Who is this guy anyway and why should we care just because his Father and Uncles were a famous politicians (and lotharios)?
Up 0 Down 0
oicu812 on Aug 2, 2013 at 2:26 pm
have to agree with Sam ,Dixon really dazzled us all with his comments.Where was his speech writer?
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Aug 2, 2013 at 1:26 pm
Of course it's undemocratic, that's how the Canadian political system works. A majority government doesn't have to listen to anyone. If you don't like that change the system. The opposition parties could form a Yukon govt if they stopped squabbling among themselves and worked strategically. Until they do that, they're not fit to govern.
RFK and any other foreigners can keep their opinions of our government to themselves when they're visiting as guests. The country he calls home is no 'pillar of democracy' either.
Up 0 Down 0
Shameful on Aug 2, 2013 at 12:14 pm
Ask yourself this Currie: what is Kennedy's motivation versus yours?
Then ask yourself this why wouldn't the YP disclose their stance prior to the election?
Truly you come off like a backwoods hick. I'm ashamed to say I voted for you.
Up 0 Down 0
bobby bitman on Aug 2, 2013 at 11:41 am
Dixon is crass and juvenile. I am shocked by the simple minded childish insults. I guess I should not be, given what I hear of the debating style of some members of the Yukon Party, on display at the legislature. All Curry Dixon did with his ill informed ('can't come up with an example') rant was to show me the level of intellect we are dealing with in Currie Dixon. He did not tell me much about Robert Kennedy.
Well, thanks for letting us know, Currie. I really did not know much about you before this display.
Reminds me of Cathers with his fairies and sunshine speech, telling us that Yukon government lawyers would not stand a chance against smart mining lawyers, and therefore we should just give the Peel to industrial interests.
What a pack of dimwits.
Up 0 Down 0
Jack Malone on Aug 2, 2013 at 10:27 am
Unbelievable. I cannot believe Dixon's comments as a member of the Yukon government and the territorial Cabinet. I try to be non-partisan and focus on issues but it is clear that only Dixon's comments are "hilarious and embarrassing" - painfully so for all Yukoners. What a goof. C'mon Yukoners - enough with MLAs who lack life experience and maturity. We deserve better.
Up 0 Down 0
Mr. Nixon you are the one who is laughable on Aug 2, 2013 at 9:05 am
One would hope that our political leaders would display a higher level of maturity ... or intelligence.
Agree to disagree with Mr. Kennedy, Minister Nixon, but to be rude, condescending and dismissive in your statements reflects poorly on your Party, our Government and you.
You owe Mr. Kennedy and the Yukon people an apology.
Up 0 Down 0
fred norris on Aug 2, 2013 at 8:51 am
"Dixon went on to say that Kennedy was factually incorrect on a number of his statements.
However, he refused to list which ones, saying he hadn't seen a transcript of the lawyer's comments"
So why would you offer a comment to the media without due diligence? I'm just as ticked about some entitled Outsider running his mouth about our affairs, but please, Mr. Dixon. You get paid a lot of scratch to do your research. Next time, for the sake of all Yukoners, engage brain, then put your mouth in gear.
Up 0 Down 0
Sam Fister on Aug 2, 2013 at 8:18 am
"We're always happy to have rich tourists come to the territory and spend their money.
"But I have to say I think it's a little bit hilarious and embarrassing that a rich, elitist, celebrity, activist lawyer from the lower 48 would come up here and spew such ill-informed non-sense about an issue and a process about which he clearly has no understanding.”
Mr. Dixon went out of his way to embarrass himself and the majority of Yukon residents with his small town approach to Mr. Kennedy's comments. Mr. Dixon should be ashamed of the way he presented himself. I know I am!
Mr. Dixon's comments reinforce why the majority of Yukon people are very wary of the Yukon Party government because of the way they are listening only to the industries that contribute to their campaign contributions.
The Peel issue reflects how the Yukon Party is anti-modern, how it listens only to a select group of mining and oil and gas companies also know as political campaign contributors- and its openly hostile to environmental groups, first nations and the majority of Yukon residents.
Lets get together and offer Bobby Kennedy Jr. a guided trip down the Wind River. If he actually sees how very special it is, he will become more involved in what is a small town issue in the Yukon Party's eyes when its actually an international environmental issue!
Thanks for your insight Mr. Kennedy!