Photo by Whitehorse Star
Linda Bonnefoy
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Linda Bonnefoy
City council will be seeking the advice of the territory's medical health officer before it responds to a proposal on banning vermiculite from community gardens, pre-schools and any area where children are close to the garden in the city.
City council will be seeking the advice of the territory's medical health officer before it responds to a proposal on banning vermiculite from community gardens, pre-schools and any area where children are close to the garden in the city.
Linda Bonnefoy, a gardener who oversees a pre-school gardening program, called on council for the ban at its meeting Monday night.
"I am asking mayor and council to consider the health of our children," she said after recalling her own experience learning of the dangers of the mineral.
Bonnefoy learned while studying for her masters gardener certification through the University of Alaska that vermiculite could be used in organic gardens.
An organic grower, Bonnefoy had only used local compost in her garden until she opted to try out vermiculite and hired two master gardeners to assist with her program.
Without reading the back of the bag, they began working with it.
"The back of the bag insists that if you're going to be using vermiculite, it's a toxic substance and you need a respirator mask, ventilated area, eye goggles, hands wear and your whole body needs to be completely attired," she said, showing council the bags she bought.
Bonnefoy noted it also states the material is toxic and should be kept out of reach from children.
The gardeners she hired had never seen anything like it on the back of a bag of material used for gardening, she said.
"You can understand my horror when I came across the bag and I saw this on the back label," she said, adding that over the long term, there can be respiratory problems in working close to vermiculite.
"Everybody was alarmed that we had actually exposed children to this," she said.
Trade agreements with the United States and Mexico prevent the substance from being banned at the federal level, she said. However, municipalities such as Kamloops, B.C. have passed their own bans on fertilizers and pesticides in community gardens and in growing food with children.
From a sustainability perspective, it's important to grow food locally and to know what's going into the soil, Bonnefoy said, praising the city for its sustainability plan.
She also found that growing with vermiculite required a lot more watering than it did when she used compost.
Following her presentation, Mayor Bev Buckway asked that administration note the name of the product and send a letter to medical health officer Brendan Hanley for an opinion on it.
Hanley is away and could not be reached for comment this morning.
As Bonnefoy noted last night, despite the warnings on the bag, Health Canada still deems it a safe product and it can be used in certified organic gardens.
"But you have to have a respirator mask on when you're handling this, especially with little children, and it's long-term exposure," she said.
Councillors Dave Austin and Dave Stockdale were absent from last night's meeting, with Coun. Jan Stick attending by conference call.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (4)
Up 0 Down 0
Dave G on Apr 28, 2009 at 10:41 am
This reeks of grandstanding. The City has dozens of more pressing issues than dealing with a product that already carries appropriate warnings. Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm off drink a refreshing glass of antifreeze. I checked with the City and it isn't 'banned' so it must be okay.
What a waste of tax dollars. Use your common sense people.
Up 0 Down 0
QC on Apr 24, 2009 at 6:38 pm
I agree! We should immediately ban any product suggested by local "experts" to have a negative health impact.
If the reporter had done diligent research, they would have found that vermiculite itself is harmless. A volcanic compound, vermiculite has been in use in industry for over 80 years. The controversy is around the main source of vermiculite pulled from the Libby mine in Montana 30 years ago. This product contained tremolite, a type of asbestos. This mine was shut down in 1990.
Apparently a "Masters gardener certification" implies that one is not only a domain expert on geolocial compounds (ie. can read the back of the package), but a chemist as well. Anyone who has used vermiculite as a soil conditioner knows that water absorbtion and nutrient retention is the primary purpose of using the material. That the "expert" would demonstrate amazement that it absorbs more water than compost illustrates her "expertise" in this area.
The National did a nonpartisan investigation of this product some time ago.
Up 0 Down 0
Arn Anderson on Apr 23, 2009 at 9:51 am
instead of using it , why not just ban it
Up 0 Down 0
geof barrington on Apr 22, 2009 at 3:01 am
instead of banning it , why not just stop using it