Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Kate White and Yvonne Clarke

Report confirms longstanding concerns: opposition parties

The opposition parties are taking the Yukon government to task over the 2022 Report of the Auditor General of Canada on Yukon Housing.

By Tim Giilck on May 26, 2022

The opposition parties are taking the Yukon government to task over the 2022 Report of the Auditor General of Canada on Yukon Housing.

The NDP was quick to slam the government on the issue even before ministers and officials held a news conference Wednesday afternoon to address the findings of the report.

“The report confirms what Yukoners have been experiencing for over a decade,” the NDP said in a statement.

“That when it comes to housing, successive Yukon Party and Liberal governments have failed to take the required actions and fix a broken system.

“The audit blasted the Yukon Housing Corporation and Department of Health and Social Services for its frequent use of plans, strategies, and committees and its almost complete inability to put any of them into operation.

“Many issues identified in the auditors’ 2010 report remain unaddressed and unchanged,” the party said in the statement.

Party leader Kate White said “this just confirms what the Yukon NDP have been highlighting for over a decade.

“Both Liberal and Yukon Party governments have spent millions on short-term hotel stays without ensuring that they provide adequate and secure housing. There is not enough support for people once they have been housed, and the government’s solution to all of it, is more committees,” White said.

Emily Tredger, the NDP’s housing critic, added, “This report has cemented everything I’ve heard from Yukoners in the last year as housing critic.

“The approach of this government to housing remains deeply inadequate to the challenge of providing access to quality, dignified housing to all Yukoners.”

The party said, “For years the Yukon NDP has been calling on the Yukon government to review its use of hotels as accommodation for low-income Yukoners.

“The auditors’ report echoes this call. The Liberal government has often hidden behind working groups and committees while limiting their ability to provide recommendations or drive change.

“This report confirms that their approach has not worked, and a new direction is needed.”

“The Auditor General in the report has once again highlighted how rural communities are still not having their housing needs met,” added Annie Blake, the NDP MLA for Vuntut Gwitchin.

“It is clear when we see only five out of 18 community needs assessments completed in the last three years. This government needs to listen to communities and start addressing their unique needs.”

The Yukon Party was also blunt with its criticisms.

Yvonne Clarke, the party’s housing critic, said, “We are disappointed to hear from the Auditor General that this Liberal government has not followed through on items identified in previous reports, including the 2015-2025 Housing Action Plan.

“Their inaction is making the housing crisis worse,” Clarke said.

“The OAG report confirmed the Liberals have not kept up with social housing demands, as the wait list increased by 320 per cent between 2015 and 2021, growing at a faster rate than the Yukon’s population.”

Clarke added, “It is also deeply concerning the OAG found that from 2014 to 2021, the government did not provide adequate and affordable housing for Yukoners in greatest need, such as those who are homeless.

“During that time, the wait times for housing increased from a year to 17 months, and priority groups remained on the wait list for housing almost twice as long as non-priority groups.”

She added, “We hope action is taken to address an aging social housing stock as identified in the report.

“The OAG report highlights the Liberals have failed to operate as ‘one government’. The report highlights that the corporation and the department have not worked together or with housing partners, even under the control of the same minister (Pauline Frost) from 2016 to 2021.

“Ultimately, the premier holds responsibility for overburdening the same minister with the Housing and Health and Social Services portfolios,” she added in reference to Frost, who was defeated in the April 2021 election.

Clarke continued to criticize the government.

“While the Liberals have accepted all of the OAG’s recommendations, their track record is not promising,” she said.

“The OAG report found the Liberals have made little progress on the delivery of housing as recommended in the Putting People First report.”

Comments (16)

Up 1 Down 2

Groucho d'North on May 31, 2022 at 4:52 pm

@Yukoner32
The last two general elections were November 7, 2016 and April 12, 2021. The Silver Liberals won them both. Look it up!

Up 8 Down 4

Groucho d'North on May 31, 2022 at 10:01 am

Kate, your continued support of the Confidence and Supply Agreement you made with the Silver Liberals also continues to support the on-going mismanagment and hardships in Yukon's housing market and some of the social housing issues the public is aware of. Imagine what has been hidden away from public knowledge.
The ball is in your court Kate, please do the right thing.

Up 5 Down 1

Orville on May 30, 2022 at 5:45 pm

I had been bally-hooing this for sometime and now someone finally listened to me.

Up 10 Down 5

Yukoner32 on May 29, 2022 at 10:43 pm

"Clarke added, “It is also deeply concerning the OAG found that from 2014 to 2021, the government did not provide adequate and affordable housing for Yukoners in greatest need, such as those who are homeless."

Well this is embarrassing for Yvonne Clarke. Perhaps she isn't aware but in 2014, 2015 and 2016 it was the Yukon Party in power. Included in that government was Currie Dixon, Wade Istchenko, Stacy Hassard, Scott Kent, Brad Cathers and Patti Mcleod. So she is slinging as much mud at her fellow MLAs as she is the Liberals. Well played, (slow clap).

She obviously didn't check with her own party before spouting off to the media.

Up 5 Down 2

Charlie's Aunt on May 29, 2022 at 7:51 pm

A few things mystify me about employment and housing in YT, especially Whitehorse. If I considered a move for new employment, the first things I would consider is ensuring I had a place to live and checking out availability of physicians. Parents of children may also check out schools and day care. Are people told of limited housing when they apply or do they just find out when they arrive? When staff were hired from outside by Health Canada there was always accommodation for singles in the nurses' residences but now they have been swallowed up as offices by the ever expanding YT gov. There was also gov housing for families e.g Takhini, Valleyview. YT had 2 year terms on those rentals under their control and that gave new hires a chance to find their own home. Those houses have now been sold which isn't wrong but why does YT keep hiring people when they know they have nowhere to live? YT gov is nuts; when WBP was close to completion they had no staff so had to bring people in from elsewhere, then they were asking existing employees to find room in their homes to house them. Did YT consider building a staff residence with rooms to rent, of course not. Thankfully many of the new hires were from a culture who didn't mind several families banding together to buy a house and they were smart enough to do that. That didn't help our housing crunch but our Care Homes would be in a mess without these people. Doesn't anyone in gov think beyond their nose when they make decisions on hires?

Up 21 Down 6

Dallas on May 28, 2022 at 6:58 am

Anyone who votes Liberal or NDP are part of the problem.

Up 14 Down 3

bonanzajoe on May 27, 2022 at 6:06 pm

Bnt: "Give more money to Yukon First Nations". The governments have given them millions for this and other things, but nothing gets done. Where does those millions go? I think most of already know and it's not for the problems.

Up 20 Down 3

bonanzajoe on May 27, 2022 at 6:03 pm

Kate White, you are propping up the Liberal government.

Up 12 Down 13

John on May 27, 2022 at 2:06 pm

Chilkoot Inn can house over 30 people who otherwise have no place to live yet Libs and NDP wont help them fix it up... go figure.

Up 22 Down 1

Hobo on May 27, 2022 at 12:14 pm

Maybe if the YTG would dedicate some effort to the well being of general population -as oppossed to just one sector- things, like housing might get going again.

Up 20 Down 3

Mitch Holder on May 27, 2022 at 12:07 pm

I'm with Moe and Juniper, you can call me racist for desiring sustainable immigrations as opposed to whatever the hell this is these days, but I will argue, correctly, that selling immigrants short after selling residents short is profiteering derived from systemic racism, which is all this government will ever have to offer anyone in Canada, regardless of party. Force them out (the Feds I mean)! And reduce immigration by at least 75 % for the next 10 years at least so we can build.

Up 12 Down 7

Wilf Carter on May 27, 2022 at 8:40 am

Kate talk is cheap but what is the NDP plan for housing. In 2007 I worked for aboriginal housing in Yukon and we worked with an Architect from CMHC on housing needs study for the Yukon as a whole. Yukon needed $200 million to bring Yukon up to standard and that included land. Federal government put $50 million in northern housing trust fund plus offered another $180 over 6 years which we got most of it. It did a lot for housing in Yukon communities especially seniors, handy cap, social housing and private sector housing. Now we need at min $500 million injection by Federal Government in connection with Yukon Housing Municipal services, aboriginal governments and Yukon Government. In 2007 we also studied in having one housing crop for all levels of government including aboriginal like Alaska did. It would put more benefits in every Yukoners pockets as one. We have to be one in Yukon for interest of all not divided as we are now. It is costing way to much for all of us with food costs up 30%, housing way over priced, energy up by 22% and heating fuel up by 28% now and going up according to suppliers. When is it going to end. NDP call an election in September and get a government that listens to the people as a whole.

Up 12 Down 7

BnT on May 27, 2022 at 6:32 am

Listening to Yvonne Clarke trying to out-NDP the NDP is why I love Yukon politics.
The NDP can criticize all they want because they know they’ll never form a government and have to carry out their plans.
The YP can criticize and paint themselves as the real social conscience of the Yukon because of they form a government, they know their supporters won’t actually expect them to deliver on social housing promises.
Like it or not, many of the homeless are Yukon First Nations. Give more money to Yukon First Nations and let them come up with community based solutions for their members. Getting them back to their homes in the communities is going to have better outcomes for everyone.
Bear in mind that the more taxpayer money we dump into socialism housing in Whitehorse will result in increased numbers of service shoppers moving elsewhere this is exacerbating the problem.
Homelessness is the end result of a litany of issues that no political party has a coherent plan to deal with, and honestly, Canadian tax payers are not interested in dumping in the amount of money that solving these issues will require so we’re going to keep bandaiding this issue forever.
Get used to it and quit wasting money on reports that no political party (never mind the general public) has any interest in dealing with.

Up 21 Down 6

moe on May 26, 2022 at 5:57 pm

Record immigration levels are not helping the situation.

Up 20 Down 4

Juniper Jackson on May 26, 2022 at 4:57 pm

No where in Canada can housing keep up with the numbers of refugees', immigrants, migrants and illegals flooding into Canada. They do get housing first. Even they are not faring so well...i know a particular household where 11 people, 9 adults and 2 children, share a 3 bedroom 1.5 bath. Canada is a rich country, we should be able to build, house, look after everyone, Canadian homeless as well as new comers. But the Trudeau government has mismanaged our resources, employment services, health and entry so badly that the country has responded with increased violence, teen and child suicide, increased drug use, greatly increased mental health in citizens, but not in the appropriate services.. jees..if i were 17 and knew that I was never going to have a home, family, like my parents, that I would not be able to have that vacation every 2 or 3 years.. you know, the unspoken promises of the west..The American Dream, the Canadian Dream, all in the sewer.. What's the dream now? It would be very tempting to hide for the hopelessness of a future with drugs, escape somehow..od? did I care? Trudeau and the Liberal party have a lot to be responsible for. How do they hide?

Up 46 Down 14

Mitch Holder on May 26, 2022 at 3:22 pm

Sorry Kate, not to be a jerk, but as I recall, the NDP Yukon of the 90s was a disaster under Tony the Tiger and what has your party done to rectify the housing crisis that you can foist accountability at the feet of the two other parties? As it stands, you currently represent an illegally occupying and unelected government coalition that generally pisses this country off in a big un-ignorable way. I respect you, I always have, you actually helped with trailer owning concerns and listened. So listen now.

We are finished with watching ineffective leaders project their inability upon one another while we pay for you folks to do that. What we actually payed for was for you all to work together for "us and our pressing needs", not blame each other for your collective inability to tackle societies more existential crises.

I would invite all of you to reflect on that and the next time you meet, it shall be in unity in regards to taking this long overdue problem (as in this was a problem even under NDP and that was a long time ago, like Fresh Prince long time ago). You are an arbiter Kate White, be the median these parties need to move forward together. None are blameless in this.

AND TO ALL PARTIES - how much you want to bet you have spent more than the 18 million in feds funding circa 2010 on "studies" instead of "housing"? Since people can conclude this without your studies, what does that say about your research?

Canada is dead soon without homes, more than immigration, more than equality, people need a place to live in dignity, the home! That the narrative always prioritizes social justice over the things that would actually facilitate equality, such as healthcare, education and civil maintenance, belies your desire to perpetuate systemic inequality as a federal government mandate and that is quite frankly, stale and disgusting, not to mention disempowering for EVERYONE.

You need to start governing as if you aren't only doing it for yourselves. Skip the next bike trail and build a park, fill some potholes, get some beat-cops. And stay the hell out of our personal lives. Hell, that is a campaign platform that could win an election on. If only one single overpaid civil servant could see that. I can, and I am nobody. What is your excuse YTG?

I know it is your job to point these things out Kate, don't take my criticism to heart. As is the case often, I criticize not to assign blame, but to point out we are watching everything you do and decide and assessing how that impacts us and as of late, it is pretty grim.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.