New recycling surcharges that will take effect later this year are based on a flawed system, one Whitehorse tire shop owner believes.

That’s according to Cal Murdoch, co-owner and vice president of Integra Tire.

He says the categories the Yukon government is using to figure out charges for consumers who purchase tires may not be the best way to go about it.

The fee structure is not based on what the intended use for the tires are, which is how most of the industry classifies it on a grander scale, Murdoch told the Star Wednesday.

“That’s the way the industry does it throughout the world,” he said.

Medium truck tires (those between 22 inches and 24.5 inches) would have come with a hefty $50 fee if the government had implemented its planned changes last year.

Those proposed changes came in 2017 and were to take effect in February of this year.

After public outcry and criticism from the tech and tire industries, Community Services Minister John Streicker pressed pause on the plans, allowing for more time for consultation.

These meetings ran from December 2017 to February of this year, according to a Yukon government webpage that details public engagements.

“In the long run, the tire industry in the Yukon would have been decimated,” said Murdoch, reflecting on the $50 fee that was proposed for semi-truck tires. Those will now cost much less at $9, he noted.

Though he was happy with some of the price changes and drops, he said he was “extremely upset with the process” of getting to this point.

“Pricing needs to be the same in the Yukon as it is in B.C. or Alberta, so we don’t have price disadvantages when we’re trying to compete with businesses,” he said.

Calling the new changes “much better,” Paul Bubiak, Integra Tire’s president and other owner, said the industry was more than willing to offer help and offer alternatives.

He pointed to a couple of companies in B.C. that offered to accept tires and only charge for the cost of transporting, which was proposed to YG by Murdoch.

“That was just a few phone calls, not somebody being paid to find out other choices,” Bubiak said.

His colleagues also suggested the possibility of cutting tires in half for greater efficiency in storing them into trucks when transporting.

“Nobody seemed to want to do any research; they just wanted to charge more,” Bubiak sighed. Even then, he added, fees may not necessarily be the silver bullet.

“We have no problem with there being recycling fees but we want them to be the same as neighbouring jurisdictions,” Murdoch said.

Bubiak agreed, but suggested the government’s efforts may be better directed in finding a more long-term solution.

“We still see no plan to do something with them,” he said, saying instead of letting tires pile up at the dump, they could be transported down south, among other things.

“We’ve not heard of any of that other than they want to charge more to recycle them,” said Bubiak, sighing that “they’re not dealing with the problem; they’re looking at more income.”

A government webpage assures this is not the case, with an Environment Yukon page stating that fees collected are not taxes. They will be used for recycling only, including the collection, transportation and processing costs.

The fees are to apply to online sales as well, according to a release from the government – something that Murdoch remains skeptical of, saying enforcement could prove tough.

“Do you really believe that YG will be able to collect fees from every single online agency?” he asked.

Even when it comes to tires, Murdoch suspects people will find a way to avoid the territory’s fees. Instead, they may opt for cheaper ones elsewhere, he said.

Admitting the new fees won’t “decimate the industry,” he said it could “cause people to buy it Outside and bring it up” from areas like B.C.

Bubiak agrees: “That’s what they said: you can’t really jaywalk, but people do.”

He said he hopes people will be honest but wouldn’t be surprised if they chose to actively find ways to avoid the surcharges.

Still, Murdoch doesn’t remain as hopeful.

“There’s not much else that can be done, so at this point I’m just going to get ready for it,” he sighed.

Meanwhile, a group representing some tech-driven companies in the territory seems to be applauding the government’s efforts.

In a statement to the Star Wednesday from Tech Yukon’s interim executive director, the group said it’s grateful the government put “forward revisions that aim to address local realities within a global marketplace.”

It continued that its members would continue to co-operate with YG to make sure the process of implementing the fees is “as seamless as possible.”

The new fees are to take effect Oct. 1