RCMP to close doors of downtown drunk tank
The Whitehorse RCMP's drunk tank, where a Carmacks man died in 2008 under circumstances which shocked and angered many in the territory, is closing.
By Justine Davidson on January 12, 2011
The Whitehorse RCMP's drunk tank, where a Carmacks man died in 2008 under circumstances which shocked and angered many in the territory, is closing.
The Yukon government and the RCMP yesterday announced the building of a "secure assessment centre” which will replace the holding cells at the Whitehorse police detachment. The facility will be added on to the new jail currently under construction on Range Road, and is scheduled to open in the spring of 2012.
The creation of the facility is one of dozens of recommendations coming out of two reports – a review of the Yukon's police force and the results of a task force on acutely intoxicated people – released this week.
The police review and the task force were prompted by the deaths of Raymond Silverfox and Robert Stone. Silverfox died after being held in RCMP cells for more than 13 hours. He was violently ill the entire time he was there, but was never given any medical attention. He was dragged from his cell when an officer noticed he was no longer moving. He was not breathing and had no heart beat. Silverfox, 43, was pronounced dead at the hospital.
Stone died in the Sarah Steele Building detox centre in May 2010. He was first picked up by paramedics, became violent and was arrested, then taken back to emergency and released. He died a few hours later after checking into detox. A coroner's inquest into his death has been called, but not scheduled.
"It's unfortunate that it took two peoples' deaths to really deal with the issues, but I think this is a real opportunity to change the way we deal with people with addictions,” James Allen, Champagne-Aishihik chief and co-author of the acutely intoxicated report said today. "... We have to start dealing with them in a humane way – with dignity and respect.”
The new holding centre will offer 24-hour medical care in the form of registered nurses and specially trained guards, and will draw on the jail's resources such as the kitchen, laundry, interview rooms and secure medical wards. It will also allow corrections officers to keep women and youth completely separate from male prisoners, which the police cannot do in their current cell block.
There is no word yet on how many people the new building will be able to hold.
Once built, the secure facility will house almost all those who are now going into RCMP cells after being arrested. Although the so-called secure assessment centre was inspired by the problem of chronic, hard-core alcoholics who draw heavily on police and hospital resources, it will also house sober prisoners.
As RCMP spokesman Sgt. Don Rogers noted today, "a large portion” of the people usually found in the RCMP cell block are intoxicated.
Meanwhile, the RCMP will do a scaled-back version of previously planned upgrades to the existing cells at their Fourth Avenue headquarters. Those holding cells will still be used for various purposes, including holding suspects for questioning during the first hours of an investigation, Rogers noted.
In that "infrequent” scenario, prisoners will be guarded by corrections officers instead of the commissionaires who currently work in the RCMP cell block, according to Justice spokesman Dan Cable.
The centre was hailed as a huge step forward by all the officials present at a media briefing on the facility held today.
Deputy ministers Dennis Cooley (Justice) and Stu Whitley (Health and Social Services) both defended the decision to add the facility to the jail, rather than build a whole new facility downtown, as has been done in Winnipeg, where a similar facility is right next door to a detox centre and a shelter.
It's a matter of using what the Yukon has now, assistant deputy minister of Justice Bob Riches said. "We are essentially able to hook on to the side of this building and hook into the various services it offers,” he said.
The jail is a huge expense for the territory, and offers state-of-the-art security, he said, and it should be used to its full extent rather than thinning resources out around the city.
A "sobering facility” will likely be built downtown in the next few years, Whitley noted, but moving the care of prisoners from the RCMP cells to a place that can offer medical services needed to be done as soon as possible.
"It's a great first step, said Dr. Bruce Beaton, who worked with Allen on the report on acutely intoxicated people, and recommended a downtown sobering centre for people detained under the Liquor Act.
Currently the responsibility for dealing with addicted people "is pegged on law enforcement,” he said. "We need to swing that pendulum toward health care.”
The Yukon government has budgeted $3.5 million for the additional work to be done on the jail, although the final amount has not been approved by the legislature.
Comments (13)
Up 0 Down 0
Francias piilman on Jan 21, 2011 at 10:15 am
For starters, how about you stop judging us. Kind of being a hypocrite aren't you? I do have empathy for people who deserve it. Living someone else's life is not helping anyone except for your ego. No one deserves empathy who refuses to take responsibility for their own life. Period.
Up 0 Down 0
barb on Jan 21, 2011 at 8:18 am
JC, Andrew MCGee, Francias Pillman, Judging from your comments, it's not that hard to tell that you are people of no heart, empathy or any sense of understanding in regards to compassion. You have it all figured out. I feel for you, cause if this is how you see other people, then I am scared to see what you don't see in yourselves. From here, and I can't see much from here, but I can tell its a big empty space, where are heart should be.
These are people you are talking about, their circumstances did not entitle them to a silver spoon, but maybe at least some compassion.
Up 0 Down 0
DG on Jan 19, 2011 at 3:23 pm
It ain't free to send them to the hospital, drunk tank, detox, jail or prison.
Literally pick your poison it will kill our pocket books one way or another.
Up 0 Down 1
Francias pillman on Jan 19, 2011 at 11:35 am
And it's inexcusable to say there is no cure being being drunk and high all the time. Why can't people just grow up and take responsibility for their own life? According to your guys logic, it's always someone's else's problem. I refuse to give sympathy to people who want others to take care of them and treat them like a little baby.
Up 0 Down 0
anonymous on Jan 18, 2011 at 2:03 pm
I think people need to start seeing drug addictions and alcoholism for what it really is...an illness. These people should be treated as we would any sick friend...as they are sick with a mental and physical illness and need our help. There is no cure, it is progressive, and with out help fatal. It is sad that many still hold such judgment on our sick brothers and sisters that need our help. What happened in our local drunk tank and detox is really a disgrace to all northerners. I am ashamed of my own Yukon authorities for letting the two deaths happen. It is inexcusable.
Up 0 Down 0
Michelle Danda on Jan 17, 2011 at 9:28 am
Additionally, it is well established that the criminalization of people who have addictions issues is not a cost effective way to handle these problems. You may not realize this but it is not free to keep someone in prison.
Up 0 Down 0
Michelle Danda on Jan 17, 2011 at 9:25 am
I work in a drunk tank which is connected to a detox centre. When someone is taken to the drunk tank it's not because they have necessarily committed any type of crime, it's because they are drunk in public. People that are brought to the drunk tank are sometimes people with long standing addictions issues but also those who had too much to drink are out on the street are not in a condition to care for themselves or tell a police officer where they live. Someone's life is not worth any less because they have an addictions issue or because they have had too much to drink.
Up 0 Down 0
Anonymous on Jan 17, 2011 at 8:42 am
Jc, are you saying that people that end up in the drunk tank shouldn't have rights and needs? I believe everyone deserves the right to get both of those. Just because someone ends up in the drunk tank doesn't mean they shouldn't have the right. Calling people that end up there criminals as well, it happens..sometimes people get to drunk, it just happens. There is no need to call them criminals. I'm pretty sure you haven't lived a straight arrow life to be an angel and have done something illegal. Would you call yourself a criminal?
Up 0 Down 0
anonymous on Jan 17, 2011 at 7:54 am
Being drunk in public isn't committing a crime against someone so who are the victims you are talking about? I've met these people and most of them are not that bad.
So again I say it must be nice being so perfect. Nothing has ever gone wrong in your life. You are the perfect human being and everyone should stare in wonder at this perfect specimen. I would go one step further but then my comment would not be posted. LOL.
Up 0 Down 0
JC on Jan 14, 2011 at 7:34 am
anonymous: "Rights and needs"? They're criminals. They live by the code of "wrong". And for their "needs", they need to straighten up and fly "right"! Those who should have "rights and needs" are the victims, which evidently you don't seem to identify with.
Up 0 Down 0
Andrew McGee on Jan 14, 2011 at 5:23 am
I have to agree with JC...to a point. I get very frustrated when everyone is so quick to blame the government for their inaction when something bad happens. Let's be honest, perhaps with the exception of Mr. Silverfox, the deaths that have occurred in police cells in Whitehorse...and numerous other places within Canada are inevitable. If someone spends half their life in jail there's a 50% chance they're going to die in jail.
Up 0 Down 0
anonymous on Jan 13, 2011 at 10:22 am
Well JC it must be nice being so perfect. They have rights and needs just like the rest of us.
Up 0 Down 0
JC on Jan 12, 2011 at 9:37 am
Why not just build them a five star hotel with maid and room service?