Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Chuck Tobin

PROPOSED ASPHALT PLANT? – Castle Rock Enterprises' current quarry is approximately three kilometres away from the Hidden Valley School, which is located at the entrance of the MacPherson subdivision. They are proposing a temporary asphalt plant there (top). Aerial photo courtesy GOOGLE EARTH QUARRY SITE – Castle Rock Enterprises is planning to place a portable asphalt plant at the existing site of its quarry below Haeckel Hill. Star photo by VINCE FEDOROFF

Plant proposal stirs up long list of concerns

City council faced a barrage of concerns at its Wednesday night meeting from residents worried about plans to locate an asphalt plant at an existing gravel quarry north of the city.

By Chuck Tobin on October 14, 2011

City council faced a barrage of concerns at its Wednesday night meeting from residents worried about plans to locate an asphalt plant at an existing gravel quarry north of the city.

There is the possibility of air pollution causing illness in nearby neighbourhoods, the potential for ground water contamination, dust poisoning streams leading into the Yukon River and a wide range of other implications, council heard.

It was also noted that next to nobody in the surrounding neighbourhoods of MacPherson, Hidden Valley and Ibex Valley are aware of the proposal by Castle Rock Enterprises, and many are just hearing about it now.

"I live about two kilometres from where this plant is going to be,” council heard from Charlene Patterson, the first of many to speak Wednesday. "The air is a concern to me because where I live on Echo Lane.”

Patterson said the prevailing south wind will blow any emissions in the direction of her home and Echo Lake.

Diesel fuel and other hydrocarbons used in the production of asphalt which fall to the ground will find their way into the water table very quickly, she said of what she's been told by experts.

Patterson emphasized Echo Lake is not far away.

"I am a supporter of business but I'm not sure that location is going to be a good location.”

Laura Grant said she grew up in the MacPherson subdivision and is raising her own family in Hidden Valley.

She chooses to live in the rural neighbourhood because it's beautiful, it's clean and it's quiet, Grant said.

The Hidden Valley School, she pointed out, is nearby and providing approval of the asphalt plant means more trucks and a heavier mix of industrial traffic and school buses.

"It is a beautiful place and it would be devastating to see industry move into the area,” she said.

Grant, like many who appeared before council, said area residents need more information, because right now they know very little if anything of this proposal.

Castle Rock has applied to the city to place a portable asphalt plant at its quarry site below Haeckel Hill, on the south side of the Alaska Highway.

Asphalt plants are provided for in the city's zoning bylaw as a conditional use at quarry sites. There is no requirement for any official zoning or land use amendments, but simply a yes or no from city council following a public-input session, which was held Wednesday night.

Castle Rock was recently awarded a $12.9 million contract to construct the roads, sideways and provide asphalt surfacing for the new Whistle Bend subdivision. Skookum Asphalt bid $13.9 million, and P.S. Sidhu bid $14.4 million.

Coun. Dave Austin suggested if the asphalt plant was required for Whistle Bend construction, perhaps it could be located at the new subdivision.

Representatives of Castle Rock, however, told council Wednesday the plant needs to be located at the pit next to the gravel source.

They said it appears there is a lot of misinformation floating about, and they suspect area residents are picturing some large industrial complex being built with hundreds of trucks coming and going.

Nothing could be further from the reality of the proposal, Castle Rock vice-president Ted Danyluk told city council.

He said Castle Rock has done its research and is planning to purchase state of the art technology which meets or exceeds the B.C. air emission standards, the toughest in Canada and North America.

Danyluk suggested residents are already smelling the smell everybody knows from standing next to a street being paved, or their neighbour's driveway been done.

The portable plant, he said, is a closed loop system that emits next to nothing.

Danyluk said noise hasn't been an issue with the existing quarry operation, and it won't be an issue with the asphalt plant.

Distances to the subdivision are almost double that of the distances from the Skookum Asphalt plant on top of Robert Service Way to the Lobird Park, he said.

He pointed out the distance from Skookum's plant to the Christ the King School is 2.5 kilometres, while the Haeckel Quarry is three kilometres from the Hidden Valley School, and 2.68 kilometres from the MacPherson subdivision.

Murray Arsenault dismissed the suggestion there'll be 10 or 15 trucks an hour rolling in and out of the quarry. In fact, he said, Castle Rock is estimating there'll be an increase of about five per cent in truck traffic, which currently runs anywhere from zero to 15 trucks per day.

Arsenault also impressed upon council that Castle Rock is seeking permission to proceed with an industrial activity that is already identified in the zoning bylaw compatible with a quarry operation.

The proposal, he emphasized, does not require an environmental screening.

"This is not a major industrial development going on at our quarry,” Arsenault said. "If you are not disturbed by our existing operation, you won't be disturbed by our asphalt plant.

The portable plant in question, it was pointed out, can be moved on three flat-bed trucks.

Arsenault told council Castle Rock is on a tight timeline, and needs an answer soon, as there is a four-month lead time to order the plant if it's to be here in time.

"We hope the system that is in place to regulate does not get changed while we are going through the process,” he said.

City administration informed council at last week's meeting that it could always limit approval of the plant to four years, to provide an opportunity to review the operation when Castle Rock's quarry lease comes up for renewal in 2015.

Administration also told council the project proposal was advertised, and the three residents within 1.5 kilometres were notified by mail.

Under the zoning bylaw, it was noted, concrete plants are primary use for quarry operations which would not require further approval of council.

Coun. Florence Roberts asked residents if they were aware of the existing plans by the Yukon government and city for Stevens Quarry.

Stevens Quarry is located on the north side of the highway, between the Mayo Cutoff and the city boundary. Drill work is currently being conducted to further define the quarry, with an aim of bringing it into production.

Lake Laberge MLA Brad Cathers appeared before council Wednesday to recommend further public consultation on the asphalt proposal, which he only became aware of during the recent election campaign.

Cathers said he was not there to debate the specifics of the project, but to recommend more public consultation be carried out.

City council would be wise, he suggested, to accept the suggestion that Castle Rock organize some neighbourhood meetings so area residents have an opportunity to understand exactly what's being proposed.

Jim Boyd told city council there is well established research which shows airborne particles from asphalt plants are deadly for salmon and other fish.

With streams in the area leading down to the salmon-bearing Yukon River, and with the chinook salmon population already in trouble, it's best to exercise caution, he said.

Hidden Valley resident Liz Reichenback told council she has gone to great lengths and expense to build her new home because she suffers from multi-chemical sensitivity caused from a work place injury.

Is there any guarantee she won't be affected by a nearby asphalt plant? she asked.

Reichenback wondered if the trucks leaving the quarry will be covered to prevent any exposure of the material.

Thomas Luxomberger said when he and his wife sit on the deck of their Echo Lake home for coffee in the morning, the very sound of their voices will cause the Arctic loon family on the lake to go quiet. It's rare to have Arctic loons in this neck of the woods, but the lake offers the habitat they require, he said.

The loons, he added, have been there for years, and he wonders what impact the asphalt plant would have on their continued interest.

Comments (7)

Up 0 Down 0

Billy Polson on Oct 17, 2011 at 9:56 am

Josey Wails along with the rest of the prejudice crowd.... you complain that First Nations aren't doing anything profitable....and when they are..."doi".

Nobody worries about the diesel YE burns everyday to feed the mines...but a little paving plant tips the scales.

Up 0 Down 0

BL on Oct 16, 2011 at 10:01 am

Joel..this not about who got to first base first. This is about long term environmental concerns.

Ya gotta scratch your head..the first nation groups are always harping about protecting their land. I guess when there is a buck to be made the land comes in second.

A well respected FN elder coined the term "Together today for our children tomorrow"

(GOOGLE the term-interesting what comes up!)

"Together today for ourselves" - should be their new chant

Where are the elders when issues like this come up? Take a look at a City land map. The Ta'an Kwach'an First Nation has land adjacent to this proposal.

I wonder what their position is? Big bucks now or long term preservation of their aboriginal land?

Up 0 Down 0

mark on Oct 15, 2011 at 12:37 am

if castle rocks research is correct about non air pollution. I say let them build the plant. if when in production , and if air pollution is affected. C.o.w at anytime can lay a huge fine and shut down the facility.

Up 0 Down 0

BL on Oct 14, 2011 at 11:25 am

So Castle Rock (CR) is trying to push this through because they were the successful bidder on the new sub-division paving program. Maybe CR should have put some thought into their bid.

"Castle Rock vice-president Ted Danyluk told city council.

He said Castle Rock has done its research and is planning to purchase state of the art technology which meets or exceeds the B.C. air emission standards, the toughest in Canada and North America."

"Arsenault told council Castle Rock is on a tight time-line, and needs an answer soon, as there is a four-month lead time to order the plant if it's to be here in time."

Doesn't sound like any research and planning has been done. if this was the case there would have been meetings and consultation with concerned persons and groups. Even the local YTG MLA was not aware of the proposal with-in his riding. Obviously there has been no planning by CR. The only plan was to get the job then buy the equipment.

But I am sure our present City council led by "round about Bev" will push this through otherwise their already over budget and over plowed Whistle Bend sub-division will even cost more and be pushed back further.

Was any thought given to the tender. Did they ask the successful bidder if they had the equipment to do the job. Hell NO. Just give it to the lowest bidder and "git er done"

Now the City is put in a position to make a decision based on a tight time-line.

Too bad.

Suck it up council and do the right thing.

Listen to Brad and the area residents.

At the very least do an environmental review. I don't give a damn if one is not required - this project has the potential to have a huge environmental impact!

We are about to get a major rock quarry in the area - more trucks hauling gravel to guess where? Probably Whistle Bend.

Up 0 Down 0

Francias Pillman on Oct 14, 2011 at 11:19 am

You people are wasting your time. People by know should know the COW could care less if it's citizens have "concerns" The current council and mayor have no clue how to run a city. Now that Doug Graham is an MLA, it will be downhill even faster. He was a big part for all the messes this COW have found themselves in. Please Whitehorse answer me this : Why do you constantly elect useless robots who haven't got a basic grasp on intelligence? You people whine and complain about all the problems they created.

Up 0 Down 0

Josey Wales on Oct 14, 2011 at 10:25 am

Hmmm? Where to start, well I'll keep it short...I tend to go...!

Castle Rock as scads & scads of other companies now is a F/N's owned company. Part of the kazillions of dollars handed out all over Canada, keeps the stats impressive to politicians and their legacy.

But other folks whom built their companies based on sweat equity and hard work? They try to compete with free money...their own damn money too!

To say it is getting a tad ridiculous around here...is an understatement.

Governments at all levels TRIPPING over each other to "award"/give contracts to these new PC endeavors.

Summary? The plant will go wherever Castle Rock wants it to go.

Anybody out there know the history of our new library?

Tendered?Awarded?By whom?Open to competition from regular folks?

Certainly somebody here would have built another "lease" building for a guaranteed pool of gravy ...for I do believe 50 years?

Anybody?

Up 0 Down 0

Joel on Oct 14, 2011 at 9:37 am

If the quarry predates your house, you should have nothing to say about this...the quarry was already defined and you decided to build your house there anyways.

If your home was there before the quarry was, then you have a legitimate complaint and should be heard.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.