Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by CP

FIRST OF TWO EX-MINISTERS – Jody Wilson-Raybould appears at the House of Commons Justice Committee on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Feb. 27. Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick

Image title

Photo by CP

Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick

Philpott calling it quits a big loss: Bagnell

Jane Philpott’s absence from the federal cabinet will be greatly felt, Yukon MP Larry Bagnell said Monday.

By Palak Mangat on March 5, 2019

Jane Philpott’s absence from the federal cabinet will be greatly felt, Yukon MP Larry Bagnell said Monday.

The continuing aftermath of the SNC-Lavalin affair claimed another casualty as the recently-shuffled Philpott stepped down Monday.

Bagnell had watched as Philpott was shuffled from the Indigenous Services portfolio into the presidency of the Treasury Board in January.

“I wasn’t in cabinet, but from what I could see, (she was) a very effective minister,” Bagnell told the Star Monday afternoon of Philpott’s performance.

He listed the assisted dying and the child welfare files as among her important works throughout the years.

Philpott had a short-lived tenure with the board of fewer than two months. It began after Scott Brison stepped down from the helm early this year and retired from politics.

Just hours after Philpott’s resignation notice Monday, Jody Wilson-Raybould, the former justice minister and attorney general, sent out a message of support on Twitter to Philpott.

“For almost 4 years our country has witnessed your constant & unassailable commitment to always doing what is right and best for Cdns,” Wilson-Raybould’s account showed.

“You are a leader of vision & strength & I look forward to continuing to work alongside you.”

For her part, Philpott expressed her support for Wilson-Raybould, who testified before the federal justice committee last Wednesday, in her resignation.

“Unfortunately, the evidence of efforts by politicians and/or officials to pressure the former Attorney General to intervene in the criminal case involving SNC-Lavalin, and the evidence as to the content of those efforts have raised serious concerns for me,” Philpott wrote.

“Those concerns have been augmented by the views expressed by my constituents and other Canadians.”

That wasn’t entirely a foreign concept to Bagnell, as the MP noted he’d had conversations with his own constituents about the matter.

“I have heard of a few on both sides on that case, not a lot,” he said Monday, explaining they included the technicalities of deferred prosecution agreements and their usefulness.

As an outsider not in cabinet watching the matters unfold, Bagnell saw first Wilson-Raybould step aside, followed by Philpott on Monday.

Much like last week, he shied away from saying definitively whether he has lost confidence (like Philpott) in his party’s leader, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

“My mood is a bit disappointed that we lost two good cabinet ministers, but like I said, it wouldn't be fair (for me to comment),” he said.

“I’m just hoping that when the rest of the information comes out, this (can be) settled.”

In efforts to get to some of that information, the federal NDP raised a motion on Feb. 20 that called on the prime minister to waive privilege and urged the government to launch a public inquiry.

Bagnell joined a host of all but two Liberal MPs in voting that motion down, noting that he hoped the two other events would help provide clarity.

Philpott’s letter, meanwhile, wasn’t cryptic in her support for Trudeau.

She noted that “sadly, I have lost confidence in how the government has dealt with this matter and in how it has responded to the issues raised.

“There can be a cost to acting on one’s principles, but there is a bigger cost to abandoning them,” Philpott added.

Bagnell said there is still much more left to be heard, calling Philpott’s resignation “a big loss for cabinet.

“We’ve heard Wilson-Raybould’s (side), which I thought was very good and detailed which was excellent, but there’s another witness coming this week,” he said of Gerald Butts.

The former principal secretary and close friend of the prime minister, Butts resigned last month. He was scheduled to appear before the justice committee Wednesday.

“I don’t think it’s fair to judge in this particular situation until all the evidence is brought forward,” Bagnell said, referencing Butts’ appearance.

“I’m just carrying on in my regular work.”

Bagnell was asked if he’s nervous about his political prospects or alignment with the party going forward, with just over seven months left until the next federal election. He maintained that isn’t the case.

“I’m confident that I’m doing the best job I can, and that’s why I got elected; I’m continuing to do that,” he said.

“It’s not about me, as I’ve always said.

“It’ll be up to the electorate in relation to this particular item.”

As for Philpott’s comment on the government’s handling over the last several weeks, the Yukon representative did share some words about a B.C. MP who likened Wilson-Raybould’s concerns to “sour grapes.”

That’s Jati Sidhu, a Liberal who told The Abbotsford News that he suspected the former attorney general spoke up because her father or somebody else was “pulling the strings.

“The way she’s acting, I think she couldn’t handle the stress,” Sidhu said then. His comments were called misogynistic and sexist by the opposition – prompting an apology from Sidhu on the floor.

“He should never have said that, and he apologized in the House of Commons,” Bagnell said Monday.

“If there are individual MPs in any party making negative comments related to women, obviously, that’s totally unacceptable.”

As for what’s next: Butts’ committee testimony, and Trudeau gearing up to deliver his third cabinet shuffle for this calendar year.

Comments (25)

Up 17 Down 3

Peter Cambridge on Mar 9, 2019 at 7:41 pm

Justin has deeply hurt his brand.
He should have confined the DPA lobby to 2 staff members. He keeps digging himself a little deeper every time he assigns blame and gives non answers. Changing his message does not help at all.
He and the Liberals can recover from this but he needs to say, yes we crossed the line and I take full responsibility for not making things clear with my staff. He needs to apologize for letting the lobbying situation go on for so long and it has to admit it was disrespectful to the AG.

Up 12 Down 3

Josey Wales on Mar 8, 2019 at 9:37 pm

Hey NNNorton....yes it does look odd when one factors in this is near
Stalingrad rife with commi lite and commi max minions marching in step with their masters.

A communist is really just a socialist, that really, REALLY...means it.
Think those numbers alarm you, wait till October.
If you need mental preparation, just watch CNN or CBC reruns of the US 2016 election cycle...have some tissue...maybe a bucket nearby?

Up 12 Down 1

Josey Wales on Mar 8, 2019 at 9:23 pm

Hey y’all...umm, geez I hate saying this.
The geezer has been brutally consistent on the potential for the Fortunate Son to do some serious social engineering, worse than his papa even.
Look it up, time stamps and very partisan.

...and here we are, as this mere thread suggests...gallons of JJ’s Kool Aid being chu UUgged down?
History is awesome, lessons not learned however...creates blind faith.

Question for all the SJWs, their handlers...”if everyone is cucked, who will storm the beaches?”
Precisely! By design, put JJs Kool Aid down...before we cannot show our ankles.

Hey OJW haters? Go to town, election year!!!!!!!
Ladies and gentlemen, LLLLLLlllllleeeeets GGeeeeeeeT... RReaaaaaaaady to RUMBLE!

Up 15 Down 3

Justin Thyme on Mar 8, 2019 at 5:43 pm

The Yukon Government claims to be:

“open, transparent and accountable...”
It is on the government website. It’s not just a party thing...

Up 10 Down 22

Politico on Mar 8, 2019 at 2:34 pm

@Guilty - Transparency? Name a political party in the last 20 yrs that did not run on a platform of transparency. It's a tired and over worked word which is just used as Pablum for the electorate. It means nothing and if you believe any party when they say that you will be sorely disappointed. You missed the point of the letter by letting your anti Liberal bias guide you. All parties are corrupt. Sheer made a great show of sweeping all the conflicts of the Harper era aside so he could be squeaky clean and chase the Liberals. If recent new conservative governments are any indication he is bringing his own dirty laundry to church! Give him time.

Up 11 Down 14

Atom on Mar 8, 2019 at 12:02 pm

@guilty
Transparency?....do all discussions on issues that affect this country get released to the public? Maybe we should hear how mineral companies work our politicians in Yukon with the loss of jobs if they pull out or don't invest? Maybe we shouldn't let our politicians look after economic interests in this Territory and Country....but what would they do if they didn't do that?.... maybe every discussion between big industry, our elected officials and their communications with the Prime Minister should be televised? Yeah that would be better. Perhaps then we would know when one of our elected officials was jilted and pissed off at the Boss. Could be entertaining.

Up 25 Down 3

Ed Norton on Mar 8, 2019 at 11:00 am

This issue has been dissected from every direction, except one, who is SNC? Who is the president, who owns SNC, who are the people that are on the board of directors? This country has to change in how we give business a free pass on almost everything.
Look in this paper, companies are named or the company is numbered but no name is attached to it. How often have companies gotten away with crap because they have been dissolved and do not exist anymore.

Up 29 Down 2

Guilty on Mar 8, 2019 at 9:41 am

Politico, well I guess it makes it more palatable by comparing other political party corruption. But this Prime Minister ran his campaign on transparency, which he has shown to be anything but. All he has shown is his ability to side step any critical issues. The bottom line is he is the only Prime Minister to be found guilty of ethics violations. Not once, but multiple times. Now it is shown he used his influence to try and change a justice ruling to prevent criminal charges to one of the liberal party’s large contributors. All while trying to justify it by claiming the possible loss of 9000 jobs, which there was no evidence. All they would have had to do is either let the justice system do their job or take ownership of the situation and let the votes dictate what Canadians think about judicial interference. But transparency this is not.

Up 10 Down 14

Yukoner75 on Mar 7, 2019 at 9:25 pm

It's rather curious that after meeting with SNC Lavalin lately, Scheer won't commit to prosecuting them. But perhaps when they met, they just discussed sports and the weather. Certainly not their legal case lol.

Up 22 Down 4

Yukonemist on Mar 7, 2019 at 5:30 pm

Yes Juniper!
Moose - Trudeau is destroying the Country by damaging its credibility. Fostering corruption by preserving the corruption that is SNC Lavalin... Etc... I can expand on this if you like?

Absolutely correct Max Justice - The Yukon is overly politicized and corrupt at a fundamental level. It eschews due process for cronyism.

Up 8 Down 32

Darryl on Mar 7, 2019 at 4:44 pm

You and the Liberals Mr. Silver, have been doing fantastic in your first two years of Government. Let's keep her go'in.

Up 22 Down 27

Politico on Mar 7, 2019 at 2:22 pm

All this scandal and yet the anti Liberals conveniently forget the Conservatives sweeping the off shore accounts under the rug. The conservatives were quiet then but out raged when another party shows corruption now. The problem is both parties are corrupt and it's the money men that run the country. Politicians are just for show.

Up 11 Down 44

CJ on Mar 7, 2019 at 1:29 pm

How long can Jody Wilson-Raybould continue to have the country believing that everything that happened in her career since December is of national importance? Of course, my lack of sympathy for her is influenced by being relieved that she was relieved of the justice minister position. She wasn't a good one.

I'd consider not voting for the Liberals if there was a hint that one or both of them would make it back to cabinet. Jane Philpott is a loss, but nobody is irreplaceable.

Up 43 Down 8

Juniper Jackson on Mar 7, 2019 at 2:03 am

Jody Wilson-Raybould has agreed to go back to the investigation and testify again.. Gerald Butts resigned from his position when the SLN scandal broke, but now he wants to talk? It is not beyond a Liberal I think to perjure him/herself, but Mr. Butts did not have to worry about that..he refused the oath. That makes anything he says nothing more than kitchen table chit chat and should be discounted... We have a PM that has picked up 5 guilty charges of bribery..He has blown every trade agreement.. funded terrorist groups, If I, average person, brought 200 ISIS fighters into the country, gave them money and a place to live..I'd be in prison.. and that is what should happen to "Trudeau and the gang of liars that still protect him in the party.... who is ok with this behaviour in the leader of country.

Up 16 Down 44

Moose on Mar 6, 2019 at 10:15 pm

@Guncache - How exactly has Trudeau destroyed the country? Does legal pot scare you? Are you upset that scientists are no longer muzzled? Are you upset that the Liberals moved the retirement age back to 65 after the Conservatives moved it to 67? Are you upset that we have the best debt-GDP ratio in the G7? Is it the lowest unemployment in Canadian history? Taking action on climate change? You are obviously a salty conservative partisan if you think any of this is negative for Canada.

Up 12 Down 35

BnR on Mar 6, 2019 at 8:49 pm

Ok guncache, you said “He has destroyed Canada like no one before him. It will take many years to rebuild Canada.”
What exactly do you mean? How has “he” “destroyed” Canada?
Be specific, show your work.
How do we “rebuild”? Again, be specific.
Or is this more of your normal hot air?

Up 29 Down 12

Max Justice on Mar 6, 2019 at 6:17 pm

What is happening at a federal level - veiled threats, pressure to suppress the truth, make the PM look good has been happening at the Territorial level since this government came into power. Anyone who attempts to speak truth to power loses here in the Yukon, the group home scandal was of course the most recent and obvious - maybe now there is no more hiding and those who want to do what is right to protect what little is left of our public service will stand up.
The good news in all of this - the liberals will hopefully not return to office and we will spend years cleaning up their mess. I hope the next party that gets in makes amends to those the liberals and their merry band of DM's and ADM's wronged during their time in power. It is quite a novel idea to run on that platform - we will right the wrongs and expose the truth about what really happened Plumbing Gate, the Pam Constanzo report are a few that come to mind. Those on the wrong side will be asked to leave and those that were harmed - staff and youth will be apologized to and compensated. I would vote for that party not this unethical, deceitful group now !! For shame

Up 36 Down 7

drum on Mar 6, 2019 at 4:36 pm

Trudeau the Feminist thought by having lots of women in his cabinet that he would be able to control them (the weaker sex)- HA HA - they are showing him that they are stronger than him and his buddies.

Up 7 Down 40

Ed Norton on Mar 6, 2019 at 2:54 pm

I would suggest that the Whitehorse Star check your voting mechanisms, the neo cons must be stuffing the online voting system?

Up 8 Down 4

Dexmurphy on Mar 6, 2019 at 12:50 pm

It is an interesting bunch of spin and it is both informative and misleading.
It's not who you believe but in what motive. Any government (all Ministers) should act in the interest of this country, not just some of it or for some of the people in it.
It is very interesting, and had been tossed around as a scenario by folks in discussion of what was happening actually here, that until there was a cabinet shuffle and the Minister (Raybould) was reassigned, that there was nothing, at all, reported by her regarding any 'pressure' to sway how she would have directed the SNC case. It actually appears that by not giving consideration to the DPA option there was bias by the Minister, given that she was part of a government charged with looking out for the well being of people who elected her party into power.
It is interesting, if not obvious, that personal gain and party gain are and are not the same thing here. What an interesting, troublesome, scenario.

Up 8 Down 51

Peter Cambridge on Mar 5, 2019 at 6:44 pm

I am glad Justine will not appear for the time being. There needs to be an opportunity for the 11 people to give their perspective first.

I am glad Larry voted the way he did. Why would the Liberals play into the hands of the other parties which likely told Lavalin that they would have offered a SPA if they were in power.

Up 46 Down 7

Brenda on Mar 5, 2019 at 5:23 pm

Kudos to Ms Philpott and Ms Wilson-Raybould these are people with integrity and principles they are not afraid to stand up and say "this was wrong". Take a really good look people there were whistle -blowers in our midst they stood up for youth in care and they got fired. This is another example of getting caught in your wrongdoing only this time these incredible women were able to publicly call out the wrong doers and are now heralded as the hero's they are. Our whistle blowers were not so lucky but are no less admirable. Truth to power only this time the good guys are on the right side and everyone can see it for what it is. Way to go

Up 57 Down 10

Guncache on Mar 5, 2019 at 5:06 pm

Typical Larry, vote the party, not the people. I'm glad these people left Trudeau Jr. Surely he can't get voted in again. He has destroyed Canada like no one before him. It will take many years to rebuild Canada. Larry is in it for the pension, bbq's and photo ops. Why are MP's attendance records confidential?

Up 92 Down 5

Joe on Mar 5, 2019 at 2:44 pm

You voted the motion down, that's your true colours. Party before principle...

Up 92 Down 8

NeilAlexGeddy on Mar 5, 2019 at 2:04 pm

So Larry decided to muzzle the former justice minister because he felt that the inner circle of the PMO would set concerned Canadians straight.
Larry suggests that his constituents who are concerned might be confused because of the complexity of differed prosecution agreements. I am sorry Larry , I am concerned that the Liberal machine has put its political interest above the law.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.