Past, present MLAs fete 40 years of party politics
Past, present MLAs fete 40 years of party politics
By Palak Mangat on December 28, 2018
Earlier this month, one-time clerk Patrick Michael paused to reflect as he addressed a crowd made up of those who played active roles in governing the territory dating back four decades.
Explaining his and wife Janet Moodie’s move up to the Yukon, the mustachioed Michael smiled as he remembered that fond time in the front of his listeners at the Yukon Government Main Administration Building.
“We were what (former NDP leader) Tony Penikett ... called boomers,” he said. “We were going to come up for two years, have a good time here then go back to civilization,” he joked as chuckles spread across the lobby.
But Michael would eventually become a lifer, and embark on a career that would allow him to see the first official elected members of the legislative assembly take office just a year later in 1978.
That celebration was at the heart of a gathering that featured a who’s who of Yukon politics on Dec. 13. Nils Clarke, the current Speaker of the legislative assembly, hosted a celebration event of the 40th anniversary of party politics in the territory.
It truly was a family affair, with those who played pivotal roles since the introduction of party politics into the Yukon rubbing elbows with current MLAs, officials and civil servants.
“Party politics was really the forerunner of just being able to get responsible government,” Michael said shortly after his remarks.
His role as clerk meant he swore in the 16 members of the legislature in 1978. They were made up of 11 Progressive Conservatives, two Liberals, one NDP and two Independents.
“It took me a moment or two to realize I was there then,” he laughed, reflecting on being asked to deliver remarks at the event.
While that may be true, some nearby smiled knowingly as Clarke explained there was some level of party lines and affiliation dating back decades before that.
Back then, there were a handful of candidates who were known to have party connections and were supported by them. The late-’70s election cemented this though, said Clarke.
“It was truly historic – with that election, party affiliation became a central organizing principle of elections,” he said.
The year saw Liberals, Conservatives and New Democrats form associations and parties that chose leaders and contested elections, Clarke explained. “So the move to party politics was more of a process than a single event.
“What was different was the formal recognition that registered political parties ... selected leaders,” he said.
That first year, for example, saw about 43 of 52 candidates eye a seat by running under a banner.
“Party politics had arrived,” Clarke said, before adding that having parties was not necessarily an end in itself.
“The ultimate goals were broader: greater self-determination, responsible government and the holy grail of political aspirations at the time: provincehood,” said Clarke.
While the Yukon is still not a province, the move to a more province-like system did bring in some of the benefits that style tended to go hand-in-hand with.
For instance, during that 1978 election, there were two Indigenous MLAs elected – Alice McGuire for the Liberals in Kluane, and PC Grafton Njootli (now deceased) of Old Crow.
That was more than a decade after 1961, Clarke said, adding that those who held Indian status couldn’t vote in territorial elections nor be candidates for the former territorial council before 1961.
He beamed that voter turnout has also been relatively strong over the years, with the figure hovering around the 70 per cent range or higher. (It sat slightly lower at around the mid-60 per cent mark during the two elections before 1978.)
For the current premier, the move also meant more control of the territory for those actually living here.
“Today’s party system is well-entrenched in the Yukon,” said Premier Sandy Silver. “In 1978, that was not necessarily the case.”
He explained that there was a quasi cabinet group of sorts that helped the federally-appointed commissioner, who chaired that group, in the goings-on of the day. “But the political landscape was to change,” Silver said.
Looking at the results of that day, he said it was clear that “Yukoners embraced party politics.”
Of the 16 seats available, two went to independent candidates – and those two, including the late Bob Fleming of the old Campbell riding – were convinced to join a party come 1982. Fleming joined then-government leader Chris Pearson’s Conservatives.
“Tonight we pay tribute to the many people who played a role in getting us to a place where decisions about Yukon are made by Yukoners,” Silver said.
Among them were Doug Bell, who was the feds’ top official as commissioner of the territory and oversaw the final transition period to responsible government.
As the ceremonial head of government, the commissioner has a number of duties, including assenting to bills, signing orders-in-council and other legislative functions throughout its appointment.
Bell’s responsibilities were effectively much of the same as premier at that point. That began to shift when one of his predecessors brought two elected representatives onto the executive committee.
That eventually paved the way for Jake Epp, the one-time Northern Affairs minister under Joe Clark’s short-lived Conservative government, to draft the historic “Epp letter”. It instructing the commissioner’s office to release some of its powers and help transition the territory toward responsible government.
Bell was subsequently the first commissioner to swear in a fully elected Yukon government – headed by Pearson.
For his part, Bell read from some of the remarks he made during that era, citing a speech he delivered.
Smiling that he has been used to introducing and addressing endless guests through his various roles in the territory, Bell looked out into the crowd. “Fellow Yukoners is my title for you tonight,” he said.
The speech he read from referenced “a day that signals the beginning of the end of our form of colonial status that moves us one step closer” to the Canadian confederation.
For her part, outgoing Yukon NDP Leader Liz Hanson kept her remarks to the crowd relatively brief.
“1978, if anything, was a coming-out party,” she said.
“We all knew what we were, we just finally said it out loud – so I think that’s a great thing to have.”
The night also featured comments from the Yukon Party’s Geraldine Van Bibber, who served as commissioner for the territory between 2005 and 2010. That was after her role as an administrator from 2001 to 2005.
“Often times when you’re in politics, you get to be involved in parts of the process but sometimes you don’t get to reap the rewards,” Hanson explained.
She pointed to predecessors Penikett (who governed over the territory from 1985 to 1992) and Piers McDonald (1996-2000) as being involved in eras that included work on files during a term that ended before formal agreements were signed.
“One of the challenges we find, and part of our partisan politics, is we share a common vision of this territory but who the person is that gets to be in the limelight at various times is never predictable,” Hanson said.
“That’s one of the neat things about being involved in politics in this territory,” she smiled. “I think regardless of where we are on some form of the political spectrum, we all believe we’re serving all of you.”
And with that, the night came to its formal end – but not before a shout-out from Clarke to one-time Liberal premier Pat Duncan.
The current-day feds had announced earlier that week that she would fill the sole vacant seat in the Senate for the territory.
“Responsible government, a larger assembly, First Nations members, more women members and a higher voter turnout,” Clarke said.
“That, I think, is fair to say was the legacy of the general election of 1978 and other elections up to the current day.”
Agreeing the year marked a coming-out of sorts, Michael smiled.
“In territorial councils, people always knew what the political leanings were of people running; they always knew.” The year just marked a formalization of that, he said.
The Yukon has been run by all three major parties (the Yukon NDP, Yukon Party and now Yukon Liberals) since the formal advent of party politics in 1978.
Comments (9)
Up 0 Down 1
Jim on Jan 3, 2019 at 6:14 pm
Northwest Territories doesn’t have party politics. They negotiated a heating fuel exemption for the carbon tax. We have a Liberal territorial government and can thank them for towing the Liberal party lines and having no exemption for heating oil. How’s the party going so far?
Up 3 Down 1
Ben Alvey on Jan 2, 2019 at 5:36 pm
@June, June this is what was said as taken from Global News article not what you twisted it into. "Why are we still fighting against certain veterans’ groups in court? Because they are asking for more than we are able to give right now,” Trudeau said to some shouts and boos from the crowd.
“You are asking for honest answers.”
Up 11 Down 9
Juniper Jackson on Jan 2, 2019 at 8:27 am
Ben Avery.. so you think its all right..even preferable to have a Party in office whose leader, Justin Trudeau has 5 guilty ethics charges against him for bribery.. who is corrupt and has a corrupt cabinet too? Who said it doesn't matter how long ago it was, sexual assault should be brought forward and the woman is always believed and he is 'the Kokanee Groper".. You think its alright to 'borrow' 2 billion dollars from CPP and send it off to Mumbai, India for THEIR housing? And it's all right to tell a veteran, right to his face, that he was fighting giving veterans pensions because they are asking for too much? The veteran has no legs, they were blown off by a roadside bomb. I could go on .. but if anyone thinks these things are all right, especially in a country leader, you have problems with ethics and morality too.
Up 5 Down 7
Juniper Jackson on Jan 1, 2019 at 1:43 pm
I personally do not believe, or vote party. I look at the best person, I look for honesty, reputation..I know that all goes to crap after they get elected, but ya' gotta start somewhere... I would not vote Liberal again, but only because Trudeau is not a good man, or a good leader, he has 5 guilty charges on him for bribery. I don't think that is ok in any leader.. this one happens to be Liberal. Regardless of the party, its the people in it that make it or break it.. Paslowski was Conservative..but also, a BAD leader, and was voted out.. not because he was conservative.. . More people need to run for our public offices.. to give people choice and selection. Can someone explain to me why no one ran against the current Conservative candidate? Any independents running? As for this article..I don't care what anyone did 40 years ago.. the winner always writes the history.
Up 13 Down 1
Max Mack on Dec 30, 2018 at 4:00 pm
I'm not at all convinced that party politics leads to "responsible government", as claimed in this article. Quite the contrary. In my view, party politics in the Yukon has lead to tribalism, corruption of all kinds, group think, and mob rule. Most significantly, it has led to the silencing of all-important contrarian voices within the party.
Up 10 Down 13
J Trapnell on Dec 30, 2018 at 2:59 pm
It is disappointing that the photos accompanying this article showed only men, even though the reporter noted the presence of politicians Geraldine Van Bibber, Pat Duncan and Liz Hanson at this event.
I worked for former MLAs Alice McGuire, Bob Fleming and Ron Veale as a researcher in the Yukon Legislative Assembly Office in 1980-81 and served as a Yukon government bureaucrat for 35 years. I know that many noteworthy women have played key roles in shaping the territory’s political development as legislators, in party politics, and in the administration of responsible government.
Surely there were more than a few such women attending this celebration whose photos could have been published alongside their male counterparts.
Up 13 Down 18
Ben Alvey on Dec 30, 2018 at 2:20 pm
Vote as you like but make sure the Liberals get in. I mean can you imagine judging from the calibre of the opposition candidates. Seriously it's a wonder we staggered through those Yukon Party crony years the way we did. No one wants to return to that mistrust.
Up 14 Down 2
Patti Kaker on Dec 29, 2018 at 8:23 pm
Not a hint of remorse in any of them.
Up 27 Down 6
Joe on Dec 29, 2018 at 11:38 am
The system is flawed, party lines are blurred, campaign promises follow the flavour of the day and MLA’s are elected for who they are, not the party they represent. This expensive ineffective system is archaic and only serves the purpose of maintaining chaos long term to ensure those big fat politician pensions.