Photo by Chuck Tobin
DISCUSSING DEFEAT – Yukon MP Ryan Leef chats with APTN reporter Shirley McLean Monday evening. Leef will leave office after serving a single term.
Photo by Chuck Tobin
DISCUSSING DEFEAT – Yukon MP Ryan Leef chats with APTN reporter Shirley McLean Monday evening. Leef will leave office after serving a single term.
There was no zip at Ryan Leef’s campaign headquarters Monday night. Not like there was four years ago, when the Conservative MP unseated Liberal stalwart Larry Bagnell.
There was no zip at Ryan Leef’s campaign headquarters Monday night. Not like there was four years ago, when the Conservative MP unseated Liberal stalwart Larry Bagnell.
There was no buzz or pop in the small to modest crowd who gathered to watch the returns, no freshly printed T-shirts boasting Leef’s name, like there were in 2011.
As party supporters watched the Liberals sweep across the country, beginning with Atlantic Canada, there was a shade of disbelief.
There was resentment of how national pundits were predicting the possibility of a Trudeau majority even before local polls closed.
“It’s not the end of the Conservatives, it is a new beginning, and you can all be part of that again,” Leef told a gathering of some 40 supporters as his loss to Bagnell was all but confirmed.
He said the party will rebuild, because it has to, as Canadians clearly indicated last night.
But not to worry, Leef assured, the Conservatives have and will rise again.
Leef encouraged his fellow Tories to stand behind the Liberal elect, to give him their support because he will need it as he works to advance the territory’s issues in Ottawa.
“It’s a pretty tall order right now because that was a pretty hard sting,” he said in the wake of the Liberal onslaught locally and nationally. “We have our values and we still have those values; it’s just not what Yukoners wanted this time.”
Leef thanked his campaign team, emphasizing their dedication and hard work was the cornerstone of Conservative success, past and present.
As the Liberal tsunami washed away the blue across the country, it did so here too.
From the earliest returns, Bagnell was out front by large margins, taking 45 and 50 per cent of votes cast, poll after poll. For the rest of the night, the competition needed binoculars just to catch of glimpse of the leader.
While Leef placed second with 4,800 votes, or 24 per cent of the votes cast, Bagnell received a smoking 53.6 per cent of the popular vote – 10,715 votes in all. NDP candidate Melissa Atkinson placed third with 3,890 votes and Frank de Jong of the Green Party received 577 votes.
Conservative Senator Dan Lang arrived early at party headquarters with former Yukon Party cabinet minister Archie Lang, and he was among the last to leave.
Early on, it was obvious to Lang the Liberals would win, but at that point, the senator was predicting a minority government, not the mammoth majority Prime Minister-designate Justin Trudeau was able to pull together.
When you’re in government, you have to make tough decisions, and tough decisions alienate some people, said Lang, while watching red move east to west across the flat screen TV.
“It’s almost like the shelf life of government is 10 years, good, bad or indifferent,” he said. “I think Ryan has acquitted himself very well in Ottawa. He has been able to articulate Yukon’s point of view on numerous subjects.... He deserves a second chance.”
But it was not to be, not even close.
Carol Leef, Ryan’s mom and driver who took him to Bagnell’s headquarters later on for the traditional congratulatory handshake, said more than anything, it was the wind of change propelling last night’s Liberal victory.
“I am surprised people are not thinking a little bit more seriously about what it means to have a very young and inexperienced prime minister,” she said.
“However, that is the democratic process.
“I did not expect a majority. All I know is that he has worked his heart out.”
The wind of change, as Leef’s mom described it, a 10-year shelf life as Lang put it, seemed to be the solace the party faithful embraced, as though it was time and time alone that brought about defeat, not Conservative policy and legislation.
One supporter said everybody’s he’s talked to either in the coffee shop or on social media predicted an anti-Stephen Harper movement, not an anti-Conservative vote.
And as another described the wind of change: “The grass is always greener on the other side, until the grass stops growing.”
Pat McInroy, the Yukon Conservative Party president, said late in the evening he was already concerned about what a new Liberal government in Ottawa will mean for his local business.
He’s concerned there’ll be a very real impact from the Liberal increases in unemployment and Canada Pension Plan contributions.
Leef’s defeat, said McInroy, was not linked to any specific issue, such as Bill S-6, the legislation to amend the territory’s environmental review process that raised the anger of First Nations and many other Yukoners.
The party president said the only time he heard S-6 mentioned was during the debates, and he did not hear it at the doorstep.
“I worked hard, everyone on this team worked hard,” he said. “We have everything to be proud of.”
McInroy acknowledged the Conservatives had their butts kicked locally and nationally.
“Now we do what responsible people do: we assess, and we carry on.”
Leef said early in the evening, he started off election day by putting up signs before he took advantage of the beautiful weather for his afternoon run “to grab some of my own space back,” as he often does.
He was not pre-occupying himself with the numbers game.
“Once it’s in the hands of the electorate, I just let it roll,” he said.
And roll it did, right over the blue machine.
“There is the natural life cycle of every government,” he said afterwards in defeat.
Like his party president, Leef dismissed any suggestion his loss was tied to specific issues, such as Bill S-6.
He said many issues have come and gone over his four years in office. Looking back, said Leef, there are many tangibles, many successful community projects and improvements the Conservatives forged for the Yukon.
“Justin Trudeau is young and dynamic, and everybody started grabbing onto that, and once it started, it was very difficult to stop,” he said.
In his address to party supporters before leaving for the obligatory visit to Bagnell’s camp, Leef encouraged his party supporters to celebrate, celebrate democracy and celebrate the results.
“Don’t worry, the sun will come up tomorrow morning,” he said. “Our party will get stronger.”
Leef said he was not going anywhere, that the Yukon is and will always be his home, though the ex-RCMP and conservation officer hasn’t given any thought to what his next career choice might be.
“You have made my job,” he told the gathering. “We have been part of the national discussion like never before, and people have taken notice.
“I can assure you this is not the last you are going to see of me in politics.”
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (18)
Up 4 Down 0
corblimey on Oct 25, 2015 at 7:03 pm
A man who is outwardly strong and inwardly weak is useless.
A man who is outwardly gentle and inwardly strong is a healer.
Up 5 Down 2
June Jackson on Oct 23, 2015 at 2:12 pm
To: JC. I laughed when I read your comment. The Star OFTEN disallows my comments. I either have do some more research and rewrite it or let the topic go. The Editor will also judicially trim out some portion of my comment and print the rest. i.e. I will write what I consider to be a well written, factual informative piece, and end it with.."too bad they are such ****ing pigs that should be shot at dawn." That will get chopped and never see the light of day.
I am sorry that some of your pieces don't get printed. There have been times, that I posted a comment, and someone else posted something exactly opposite with enough thought or information to change my mind, or make me think..
I think a LOT of people read these forums, wish more would post.
Up 61 Down 2
Jack Malone on Oct 22, 2015 at 3:34 pm
What a long, exhausting campaign. Yukoners deserve a pat on the back for caring about democracy: 76 percent turnout. Awesome. Melissa and Ryan were gracious during election night - it must have been tough for them. As Yukoners, let's move on now, leave the partisan insults and work for a better future. Let's not allow the political process to continue to divide us - we are less than 40,000, we need to work together for healthy communities, sustainable jobs, and a healthy environment.
Up 41 Down 4
wundering on Oct 22, 2015 at 11:26 am
Just go back to being "Progressive Conservatives".
Up 8 Down 3
JC on Oct 21, 2015 at 9:40 pm
June Jackson must have stock in this newspaper. Maybe I should buy some. Maybe then more of my comments will be printed. I forgot about josey wales. He must be on vacation this week.
Up 68 Down 15
Yukoner on Oct 21, 2015 at 8:29 pm
To Leef and Harper,
bye bye for good, please!
Up 7 Down 8
corblimey on Oct 21, 2015 at 7:23 pm
Strong, stronger, these are words that Mr Leef uses. But what does he mean by strong? We could find out if he told us what he thinks weak means. There is a very good chance that it could mean 'Might is Right'
Up 42 Down 5
Zeppo on Oct 21, 2015 at 6:48 pm
@Carol Leef : Justin Trudeau has more parliamentary experience than Barack Obama, David Cameron, Mulroney and his own father when they became leaders. He is the same age as JFK when he became president and 4 years older than Joe Clark when he became PM. Justin is ready don't even worry about it.
Up 41 Down 6
Bev on Oct 21, 2015 at 3:40 pm
Now please go pick up your signs, election is over, now it is littering. This goes for all
Up 44 Down 28
quit being so hard on the guy on Oct 21, 2015 at 2:53 pm
I didn't vote for Ryan Leef, but my goodness he hasn't done anything to deserve such nastiness. Anyone who has the courage to run for public office - and he won fair and square 4 years ago - deserves a little more than the mean-ness he's been getting. I have to say, there are a lot of mean-spirited people out there these days, and that goes for some of the gloating by some people in the Liberal camps too (although not the guy who actually won - he is a class act).
Up 47 Down 48
Matt on Oct 21, 2015 at 5:22 am
Nobody can take away the fact that Ryan Leef almost single handedly arrested a small lady defacing his signs. Do I see an "order of Canada" coming up?
Seriously the Conservatives were completely out of touch with Canadian values with the exception of the radical zealots.
Up 40 Down 4
Adele Sandrock on Oct 20, 2015 at 11:52 pm
@ Carol Leef - “I am surprised people are not thinking a little bit more seriously about what it means to have a very young and inexperienced prime minister"
I assume that applies also for young unexperienced MP's (age 41).
Up 46 Down 5
AgeIsJustANumber on Oct 20, 2015 at 5:26 pm
Obama was 46 when he assumed the presidency. Tony Blair was 43 when elected UK PM. William Pitt the Younger was 24 when he became PM in England. I rather doubt that 43 is too young to become Canadian PM.
Good luck Larry.
Up 68 Down 10
Adios on Oct 20, 2015 at 4:29 pm
Standing with Danny and Archie Lang?
Remember, Yukoners, what these men stand and stood for. From the moment Together Today for Our Children Tomorrow was drafted, they fought Yukon First Nations from education to basic rights. Always behind closed doors. This is the Yukon (Reform) Party's approach and always will be with relics of outdated thought running the think tank. Paz will soon be out too.
Up 40 Down 34
R.M. JUBY on Oct 20, 2015 at 4:24 pm
Well, Mr. LEEF, you're the author of your own demise. But, don't despair, dig out your best Ninja suit, grab your mag-lite and handcuffs and head on down to Walmart, they're hiring!
Up 77 Down 10
CJ on Oct 20, 2015 at 3:46 pm
"The party president said the only time he heard S-6 mentioned was during the debates, and he did not hear it at the doorstep."
When people stop talking to you, you know you're losing.
As for Lang's rote speech about "making the tough decisions", it's worth thinking about the fact that Harper and the Conservatives didn't lose any votes since 2011, or so one analyst has it. More people showed up to vote.
You can "make tough decisions" all you want, but until you legislate against democracy --which Harper came perilously close to, in my opinion -- you'll have to answer to the people about the "tough decisions" that you rammed through, when people did want to talk about them at the doorstep.
Ryan was very gracious to Larry in defeat.
Up 100 Down 47
June Jackson on Oct 20, 2015 at 3:39 pm
Good bye Mr. Leef. I am sure your defeat could not have been a complete surprise. The forums here have been vocal in their dissatisfaction with your service. The forums all over the country have been vocal in their dissatisfaction with the Conservative party. Harper, I think, made a classic mistake.
In the forums, I like everyone's view on the table. If you only read and listen to people who agree with you, you eventually isolate yourself from reality. That is what Harper did. He surrounded himself with yes men and lost any connection with the people who would be casting votes. That is also the mistake the Paslowski government is making. The yes men who prop up their egos and assure them it's only a couple of nut cases that don't want a seniors care facility in Whistle Bend..it's only a few crazy greenies that don't want fracking.. Because they don't listen to anyone's opinion but their own..they too will be very surprised when they are voted out.
Up 163 Down 28
Yukoner on Oct 20, 2015 at 3:24 pm
Carol Leef, Ryan’s mom and driver .....“I am surprised people are not thinking a little bit more seriously about what it means to have a very young and inexperienced prime minister,” she said.
These kinds of statements keep baffling me. Trudeau is 2 years younger than Harper was when he first took office. Harper was 45, Trudeau is 43. So what's the magic age for being an "experienced" PM? 44? 44.5? Whatever Harper and the boys say it is? How do you get to be an "experienced" PM? You have to be a PM, that's how, or did God just grant Harper this "experience"?