Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

MAY'S AUGUST VISIT - Federal Green Party Leader Elizabeth May listens Friday afternoon as John Streicker, the party's Yukon candidate in the 2008 and the next federal election, speaks with local reporters. Below: May signs her book at Mac's Fireweed Books on Saturday afternoon. Photo By Kieran Oudshoorn

Ottawa has failed aboriginal people: May

With a dash of humour, federal Green Party Leader Elizabeth May launched the party's Arctic Strategy on Friday, during her weekend visit to Whitehorse.

By Jason Unrau on August 24, 2009

With a dash of humour, federal Green Party Leader Elizabeth May launched the party's Arctic Strategy on Friday, during her weekend visit to Whitehorse.

"I just want to make it clear to media that at this press conference you are allowed to ask questions," said May while standing in front of Yukon Green Party headquarters on Wood Street.

An hour earlier, at a media event featuring Prime Minister Stephen Harper, the PM virtually ignored local media, taking just four questions - three of which came from members of a national media pool who shadowed Harper on his five-day "Arctic Sovereignty" tour.

"I thought it would be useful to get that out of the way, in case you were under any misapprehensions that we don't like spontaneity, interface with people, questions, that's all good," she added, earning a laugh from gathered reporters.

But May quickly shifted to a more serious tone as she blasted the federal government for its failure to live up to obligations made to Canada's aboriginal people.

"It's important for Canadians from coast to coast to know that the modern day treaties are not being any better implemented than the historic treaties about which we're now ashamed," said May, fresh from a meeting with Council of Yukon First Nations' chiefs.

The implementation is unacceptably slow, May continued, citing key agreements to hasten closure to deals inked under the Umbrella Final Agreement, "just sit unimplemented."

"All the rhetoric has improved, but the performance has not improved by the Government of Canada ... in the last hundred years and that is shocking."

May then turned her scorn towards the Conservative government's policies for improving the lives of northerners by asserting its claims to the land and water in the Arctic archipelago.

"It clearly focuses on resource exploitation and sovereignty expressed through military presence," May said.

"In our view, Canada's sovereignty ... is best exemplified by commitment to communities, to environmental protection in the Arctic, to paying attention to being a constant presence in the region.

"Our best evidence of sovereignty in international courts is the use and occupation of these territories over millennia by people of first nations and by the Inuit," said May, a lawyer by trade who helped found the Sierra Club of Canada and headed that organization for nearly 20 years.

The Green Party leader said any development in Canada's North must "involve full engagement" of aboriginal people inhabiting the region.

May said that receding sea ice in the Arctic should not be viewed solely as a resource extraction opportunity.

"There is of course deep irony in that because the Western Arctic is one of the regions most impacted, most seriously by the climate crisis," she said. "And the effort to get at more fossil fuels and burn them suffers under a dangerous delusion of the nature of the crisis and what our response should be."

Under its Arctic policy, the Green Party believes the Arctic Council - an intergovernmental forum established in 1996 that promotes cooperation among the Arctic states - should formulate international policy on how the region is managed, particularly resource exploitation, and guide any new circumpolar treaties Arctic states may sign in the future.

"We think that's the proper vehicle and we think the need to have an international consultation on what kind of regime makes sense for the Arctic should've begun some time ago," May said.

"And have in our minds something like the common heritage of mankind in terms of how Antarctica is being treated and we take some lessons from that and move forward to ensure the protection of Arctic environment while investing seriously in ways that have not been done in improving community health throughout the region."

Comments (16)

Up 0 Down 0

francis pillman on Sep 2, 2009 at 12:48 pm

I'm glad you point out the term racist. Because according to your definition, first nations imply racism when they hire people. First nation only! reads the ad. As a native can you honestly sit there and claim that is not racism? And I'm glad you resort to petty attacks on myself, calling me un-intelligent, uncaring, etc. It shows what kind of person you are. I'm none of those things you say. And my native friends hold the same view as I do, so please stop spouting useless rhetoric on something you have no clue about. In my experience, people who are usually right are attacked, verbally that is. What are you hiding? Please come back when you have something intelligent to say, not childish attacks.

Up 0 Down 0

Cindy on Sep 2, 2009 at 10:28 am

some people are so ignorant,I have alot of family and friends who went to residential school,and it awful to see them have to relive this nightmare they had went through when they where children.And alot of thier kids have live with it also, so it affects alot people,and to mention other countries is NOT a nice thing to say.because we are in Canada not another country,u r mean and selfish.

Up 0 Down 0

Proud First Nation Man on Sep 2, 2009 at 3:25 am

Francis, Racism is often defined as follows:

"'Conduct or words which advantage or disadvantage people because of their color, culture or ethnic origin.”

Anytime you make a generalized statement about a whole race of people it is a Racist comment. For instance your comment "First nations as a whole need to stop blaming everything that happens to them on someone else” is racist as you are inferring that the whole race of Aboriginal people is blaming other people. Lucky for the First Nations in this country your attitude is not shared. Majority of the non-aboriginal people I have had contact with are compassionate, intelligent and caring people who would blow people like you off in a second as nothing more than a bitter and selfish person. To say that aboriginal people are in certain positions because of things they have done themselves completely negates years and decades (recent included) of horrible traumatic events. Lastly I would be surprised that you have any friends let alone numerous ones, and if one by chance happens to be Aboriginal please share you archaic views with them and see if they remain your friend.

Up 0 Down 0

come on... on Sep 1, 2009 at 12:26 pm

All of you are painting with very wide brushes. This article is about a wannabe politician who thinks she can get the vote of the disadvantaged. And yes to varying degrees they are still there.

Also, we have so many people of muti-mixed backgrounds, who are we even talking about? We're all related!

Up 0 Down 0

IMHO on Sep 1, 2009 at 10:23 am

With all due respect...

Out of the Yukon bubble, residential schools still existed 10 years ago in Ireland. Ireland just finished a 2,600-page final report of Ireland's Commission to Inquire Into Child Abuse. These residential schools run by the Sisters of Mercy and the Christian Brothers took children away from their families and severely abused them physically, sexually and mentally. This happened throughout the UK and Australia too in the forms of workhouses, orphanages, and residential schools. This continues to happen in Ukraine, Russia, Africa,and China.

My point here is the pain of residential school is not just a First Nation issue, but because we live in the Yukon firstly, and in Canada secondly, we hear about the pain suffered by First Nation people (mostly through media and not through First Nation people themselves), and very little recognition has been allowed for "those of European descent" who have been through it too. Overlooking this fact has caused some people to feel like their pain is minimized, while another peoples pain is viewed as more important. I think that perception is skewed in the North around this because SO MANY PEOPLE were affected by this in one way or another. Compassion and healing is cross-cultural and it needs to go both ways.

I did not "choose" to live in Canada, I was born here like my relatives of the last 500 years. I am a Canadian. Like one does not "choose" to be First Nation. You are or you aren't.

Proud First Nations Man said "Funny how it always comes down to money from people of European Decent."

Does it always? Or are you becoming what you despise...would it be ok if I used a different cultures name? No. If I know you I sure hope that is not what you are thinking of me.

Lady of the Lake is right that there are some great things ahead...we all need to move past the anger and hurt first. And until we can all do that HONESTLY and SINCERELY, here we sit.

Oh and Elizabeth? Nice try but you need to try a little harder than that, pretty elementary for the people of the Yukon .

Up 0 Down 0

francias pillman on Sep 1, 2009 at 9:28 am

So the only ones with values are natives?, according to your statement. Stop living in the 1920s, and look at what's going on. The people above are stating what reality is, you just attack them because it dosent fit what u believe in. And who has let the yukon down? It can't be the natives who idlying sit by and let outsiders trash or environment with their useless mines. Your land? Protect it then. Please take a page from happened in oka quebec over 10 years ago, because those are real natives, standing up and protecting their land, not just hoping the government will do it for them.

Up 0 Down 0

A CANADIAN on Sep 1, 2009 at 8:27 am

Once again we are being racial. Why can't we all just be CANADIAN? I was born in Canada, so was my fmaily, and my family before me, we are non race as we are Canadian. Why can't we just get over all this and move on for CANADA, no matter what your race is or how long your race has been here.

One race, One pLanet.

Up 0 Down 0

Proud First Nation Man on Sep 1, 2009 at 1:56 am

Way to go Lady of the Lake! It's great to see that there are people on here with decent values. I can't believe we are still hearing these types of comments. If anyone should be reading a book it's Joseph Campbell. Funny how it always comes down to money from people of European Decent. Northerner you have let all Yukoners down with your petty words. I'm a proud FN person who will continue with my brother's and sister's to succeed in spite of most like you not because of.

Up 0 Down 0

francias pillman on Aug 31, 2009 at 1:03 pm

Ignorant comments? Any time natives are critzied it automatically racism. Sorry but your opinion is that of the minority. First nations as a whole need to stop blaming everything that happens to them on someone else. If these comments are racist please define job ads in the paper that say first nation only. Well, sorry to burst your bubble but that is blatant discrimination and against peoples human rights. You can't question my last sentence. Would I be able to put a job ad in the paper that reads, WHITE PEOPLE ONLY? Nope because I'd probably be charged with a hate crime. And I'm tired of people using their skin color as a tool. And before you label me racist I have numerous native friends who are doing something to improve their lives, not just sitting around and feeling sorry for themselves. But I also see a lot of people(white and native) who just want to sit there and get handouts, then complain about things that are their own doing.and these types of people don't deserve the time of day. Its dosent matter if your brown or white, na na na na.......

Up 0 Down 0

Lady of the Lake on Aug 31, 2009 at 2:46 am

Wow I thought we were moving past these type of ignorant comments, especially here in the Yukon where we are breaking trails in regards to First Nation Self Governments. I find it odd that people who choose to live in Canada (a land that has been occupied and governed by First Nation people for time immemorial) still put forward questions like "what do First Nations bring to the table”. The comment about residential school is even more offending when you consider the fact that the last residential school still operated less than 30 yrs ago. The people who spout this incoherent dribble are the ones who show how much learning still needs to be done. I particularly love how the comment regarding First Nations putting obstacles in front of them selves show's how uninformed that reader/author is. What an easy comment and philosophy it is to say that First Nation people need to "get over it”. I find it ironic that the author says it's time for First Nation people to stop blaming yet they lay the blame on First Nations for not resolving obstacles. Maybe if some of these readers had even an iota of compassion and understanding of what the obstacles are that are facing First Nations their answers would not be so ignorant.

Up 0 Down 0

Arn Anderson on Aug 28, 2009 at 4:49 am

Looking for native votes in all the wrong places to pay for the fraudelent carbon tax.

Up 0 Down 0

Yukon lady on Aug 26, 2009 at 8:06 am

Stop talking about what First Nation bring to the table..First Nations people bring lots to the table and even teach their culture to non first nations..So, please stop been so racist to First Nations people of Canada.. Yes, the First Nation settled and got their monies, but all the government do is keep taking the first nation's land after they settled...Joseph your the one who talks nonsense..STOP THE RACIST towards the First Nation people and love all.

Up 0 Down 0

northerner on Aug 26, 2009 at 5:52 am

The only one who has let the First Nations down is themselves. They have to stop blaming the white people, the government, Ottawa, etc and start making the changes necessary for them to overcome the obstacles they put in front of them. I am tired of hearing about PJ's drinking problem stemming from something that happened to his grandfather 7o years before.... stop making excuses for your behaviour and change it. We all have these choices in front of us no matter what our colour is, but it is depends on the choice you make that makes your life what it is. I know many successful First Nations people who have made better choices and they share the same history as the ones who choices are not so good. It is always easy to point the blame at others...but remember whenever you point the blame- 3 more fingers are pointing right back at you!

Up 0 Down 0

PS on Aug 25, 2009 at 9:50 am

Stop trying to get the support of the First Nations.... we've all seen people like you before! If you can talk the talk let's see you walk your walk.

Up 0 Down 0

Joseph Campbell on Aug 24, 2009 at 1:19 pm

This woman talks nonsense. I don't know who she thinks she's impressing. Certainly not me. The First Nations got their settlements and the money. Now, its time they did something with it. Why do these glory seeking phonies always have to stir up the fires of descension. Don't they have better things to do, like tell the truth. Now, lets talk about the First Nations. What do they bring to the table for the rest of Canada. I'm still waiting for that. Haven't we non aboriginals paid enough for this country? Ms. May, go read a book or two.

Up 0 Down 0

Delta Dawn on Aug 24, 2009 at 8:52 am

Elizabeth you aren't the first Want to be leader to say that and get in office to run Canada so quit trying to get votes

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.