Photo by Vince Fedoroff
COUNCIL RECONVENES – The first Whitehorse city council meeting of 2021 took place Monday evening, after a holiday break of several weeks.
Photo by Vince Fedoroff
COUNCIL RECONVENES – The first Whitehorse city council meeting of 2021 took place Monday evening, after a holiday break of several weeks.
A Whitehorse non-profit organization is asking city council to write off $68,672 it owes because of a contractual obligation, council heard at its meeting on Monday.
A Whitehorse non-profit organization is asking city council to write off $68,672 it owes because of a contractual obligation, council heard at its meeting on Monday.
The Options for Independence Society of Yukon (OFI) entered into a contract arrangement with the city in 2012 under the city’s Development Incentives Policy. OFI provides services for 14 adults with Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder.
Under the incentive policy, the city agreed to pay the property taxes for 10 years on a major addition OFI undertook to turn a Fourth Avenue duplex into a 14-room facility for 14 adults with FASD.
The contract stipulates if ownership of the property were to change hands or the services were no longer provided during the 10 years, OFI would have to repay all property tax grants received.
OFI is under financial stress because of the mortgage it has to pay on the development.
It was decided in discussions with the Yukon government in November 2019 that the best approach would be to transfer ownership of the property to the Yukon Housing Corp. But OFI would remain as the service provider.
As a result of a proposed change in ownership, OFI would be obligated to repay the seven years of property tax grants it has received, totalling $68,672.
But the non-profit is asking council to waive the debt because it is already under financial stress.
City administration is recommending that council agree to forgive the debt.
Council will vote on the matter at next Monday’s meeting.
While there were concerns raised at last night’s meeting by members of council regarding setting a precedent under the incentive policy for other non-profits, there was also strong recognition about the important work OFI provides for the community.
There was also emphasis on how OFI will continue to provide and manage the services to persons with FASD, even though Yukon Housing would own the building.
“The only reason OFI has decided to relinquish ownership of the property is due to financial hardship associated with mortgage payments,” says a Nov. 13, 2020 letter from OFI to the city.
“Repaying the grants will only make our already financially precarious position worse.”
In its letter, the non-profit laid out several benefits that have resulted from its services.
The facility has been kept at full capacity, and all clients are stable in their placement, it says.
It notes eight are employed and are productive citizens.
None have been negatively involved with the criminal justice system but rather are contributing to the safety and well-being of Whitehorse residents, says the list of benefits included in the letter.
OFI still provides supportive housing to persons with disabilities since the completion of the development in 2014.
“It is also noteworthy that one of our staff received the Mayor’s Award for Outstanding Service in 2016,” says the letter.
City administration pointed out to council Monday that once the change of ownership occurs, there will be no more grants provided under the incentive policy.
It was also pointed out the city would begin receiving payments from the Yukon government in lieu of taxes assessed against the Fourth Avenue property.
The YG, as a senior government, does not pay property taxes but rather provides annual grants to the city in lieu of property taxes.
“Non-profit organizations rely on government grants to undertake the important work they do in the community,” says the administrative report provided to council at its meeting Monday.
“An intent of the (incentive) policy was to ensure that grants provided for supportive housing would benefit local groups providing the services.
“OFI has provided supportive housing for 14 adults with Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder during the eight-year time frame since the development incentives agreement took effect.”
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (25)
Up 11 Down 0
drum on Jan 10, 2021 at 4:54 pm
Let's get back to basics for those living in the Yukon. Our power bill is going up, our gas bill has just gone up and our grocery bill is getting out of hand. Who agrees!!!!!!!
Up 8 Down 0
drum on Jan 10, 2021 at 4:49 pm
I have had so many friends with genuine medical issues supported by their doctor and the nurses that visited to help - everyone said they should be in Senior Housing. They all died before they were even considered. I believe that this unit of the YG should be more transparent and the waiting list should be available to those who are on it!!!! Not allowing relatives of (important people!!!!) to jump the line.
Up 8 Down 0
Juniper Jackson on Jan 9, 2021 at 5:52 pm
However it happened, however they got there, at the end of the day we have 14 people that are to some capacity, brain damaged and unable to care for themselves. These 14 hit the jackpot, they have a safe home, someone makes sure they have food, some are capable of working, and someone makes sure these 14 have those opportunities. There are hundreds more of these individuals, if not thousands, some are used by others to participate in crimes, some are drinking and on the streets. But, I'd say.. the collective tax paying 'we' saved these 14. We are going to have to pay for them one way or another all of their lives. Sure, it could have been prevented..but it wasn't. So, THIS is what we have. Take a look at the ethnic makeup, if FN, (and many are not.. you think a young FN woman is the only one hanging out in the bars? look again) ask them to contribute a sum, Christian's? Ask them to contribute a sum, refugees? Ask the Feds to contribute a direct sum. Forgive the taxes when the owners have reneged on their original agreement? There is no such thing as forgiving taxes.. there is simply moving your taxes to my account.. and I and the other taxpayers get to pay your bill for you. I do NOT want to do that..I'm paying too much now for what I receive. I pay snow removal twice. Once though my taxes, and once to the guy that actually comes and plows for me. The City has also hiked their borrowing power. What's it look like when a City goes bankrupt, or the bank says, nope.. we are not covering those payroll checks?
Whatever the city does, and I suspect being a primarily Liberal council that they will expect me to pay someone elses bill, those 14 had better be taken care of in the safe, well fed way they have become used to.
Up 12 Down 0
prevention is better on Jan 8, 2021 at 4:12 pm
FAS is 100% preventable. Simple solution. Do not drink booze while pregnant. Give alcoholic pregnant women whatever they need to stay sober while pregnant. Create a spa-retreat waaaay out in the bush. Deluxe services, food, programming, medical care. It would be a heck of a lot cheaper than housing and helping the victims of their alcohol addiction for the next 80 years each.
There is nothing wrong with that conversation and it needs to be had, big time. Also, I do think there should be a recognition that the mother caused harm to another human's brain, if the pregnant woman decides to carry the pregnancy to term. Sorry, but that's a fact, and I am very much pro-choice and women's rights. I am also a believer in the right of babies that are born having the brain they could have had if their mother didn't prefer to booze it up. Alcoholism does lead to massive selfishness, and that is not something we should avoid confronting. I get it that it's a complicated problem, but it's not like this is a big frickin' mystery. Enough of the nonsense!
Up 17 Down 1
Anie on Jan 7, 2021 at 2:27 pm
Yes, Will, most people know what a grant in lieu means. That will be going forward. I was speaking to the matter if taxes that were forgiven in the past, subject to conditions that now have not been met. Those taxes, according to the contract, are now due to the City. In taking on the mortgage, Yukon Housing should also take on that debt.
Up 22 Down 1
My Opinion on Jan 7, 2021 at 1:46 pm
I am so sick of hearing "NON PROFIT" as though it is somehow more righteous.
This money they save buy being a NP and no Yukon or Federal Taxes obviously is not put aside for a rainy day as a normal business would do. No it is spent on themselves. High wages, all sorts of perks. Some we know about from the Muddy Waters (Many Rivers) organization. Even paying for advanced education for the person in charge.
Profit is not a dirty word it is what gets you through the tough times.
As a business owner I don't like the Landscaping demands on a Commercial Property. Can I get my money back when I sell????? Yep I know, that's different.
So the answer for OFI is an absolute NO. You entered into this agreement because it was in your best interest, so pay it back. Maybe you should have had some of those NASTY PROFITS to draw on and not have burned it all up in wages.
Up 14 Down 1
My Opinion on Jan 7, 2021 at 1:34 pm
There is a reason they have to operate uninterrupted for 10 years. They do not want people to line up for these development incentives and in a couple of years decide they no longer want to provide the services and just move on with a lot of extra value accumulated in the Real estate value that the owner can redeem in the sale, as they have just done.
Up 18 Down 1
My Opinion on Jan 7, 2021 at 1:30 pm
That is that place across from the High Country Inn. That was the most expensive and crazy building ever. They incorporated and old duplex into a two story building that is much bigger, up on stilts on either end. It took forever to get it done and ran waaaay over budget. Was almost nothing left of the house other then the facade when they were done.
Up 18 Down 4
Josey Wales on Jan 7, 2021 at 6:59 am
hmmm...ironic as of 08:00 hrs Josey has 14 down thumbs.
guess those 14 fetus hosts or their enablers...are representing?
repeat...100% avoidable F.A.S....fact check that please.
Up 2 Down 2
Benn on Jan 7, 2021 at 5:02 am
Hey JCs you guys only got 7 votes, I got 29.
Up 4 Down 8
Wilf Carter on Jan 6, 2021 at 7:45 pm
Why do some Yukoners not like being questioned on their comments?
Up 28 Down 1
joe on Jan 6, 2021 at 1:01 pm
Yukon housing for real ?? That organization is so reliant on taxpayers it's terrible. It used to fund its own operations with mortgage revenues but one DM later the whole place is a mess and just a money pit. Check out the budgets.
Up 25 Down 0
Sheepchaser on Jan 6, 2021 at 11:16 am
Fine, cut them a cheque. However, then it’s time for a financial colonoscopy and that should be a strict condition. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on Many Rivers. Need to make sure the financial stress isn’t related to management perks of any kind and that the organization will be solvent moving forward.
Up 30 Down 2
Yoduh on Jan 6, 2021 at 10:47 am
What a crock!
If you had no intention of paying the piper, you should never have been allowed to ask for the tune.
City of Whitehorse taxpayers all over this city are suffering, and if the COW agrees to this crap, then a precedent is set, and I urge any and all businesses to start a class action suit, to also have their taxes forgiven.
Up 2 Down 28
Nathan Living on Jan 5, 2021 at 9:36 pm
A tough situation, it would be nice to have the city help this organization.
Up 5 Down 18
Wilf Carter on Jan 5, 2021 at 8:20 pm
Interesting comments so far:
Anie - Yukon housing is not buying the building but taking ownership and assuming the mortgage. City will grant money from YTG instead of taxes which in simple terms the city gets something else than money.
Benn - Yukon Housing is a good organization and has done a lot of good for Yukoners over the years. Federal Government has not kept their promises for $350 million dollars in housing over the last 4 years, and $300 community which means land development. Just before the last Federal election, our MP put out a statement that the Federal Government would commit $950 million to support Yukon social economic needs but has delivered nothing of support.
Wales your statement is interesting but does not add up in real terms.
Up 12 Down 6
DMZ on Jan 5, 2021 at 6:20 pm
Too far, Josey. You seem kind of wild, but not usually mean.
Up 27 Down 0
Jim on Jan 5, 2021 at 5:21 pm
First off, I don’t see a problem with the City helping non-profits. But they can’t be selective to help some and not others. They just went through an exhaustive tax battle with our museum over back taxes. Even though the two provide different services, they both operate to help the community and both rely on funding to operate. They had no issue with the museum having to cut services due to lack of funding that they held back due to back taxes. By setting a precedent like this they may very well have a lineup at their door for tax relief. It’s a slippery slope to start determining who of the non-profits is worthy and who is not.
Up 18 Down 6
Jc on Jan 5, 2021 at 3:40 pm
Somebody phone Larry B, Justin Ts Financial Officer. He'll cut them a check a week before election day.
Up 11 Down 5
Jc on Jan 5, 2021 at 3:38 pm
So Benn, are you saying only the Yukon Liberal Party represents all the people of the Yukon?
Up 61 Down 3
Anie on Jan 5, 2021 at 3:13 pm
Wait a minute. Yukon Housing are the buyer. They should assume the tax debt, buy paying that much more for the building, then the society can pay the debt out of the money they get from the sale. This group provided services to all Yukoners, not just to Whitehorse residents. Why should the City residents eat the whole bill? What a bad precedent. Don't enter into contracts, City of Whitehorse, if you don't plan to take them seriously.
Up 33 Down 19
Benn on Jan 5, 2021 at 2:47 pm
Yukon Housing is a misnomer just like Yukon Party is. Neither represent all Yukoners, in fact only a small percentage but like to allude to the grandiose false claim.
Up 40 Down 18
Josey Wales on Jan 5, 2021 at 1:38 pm
Send that bill to the 14 fetus hosts, that created that 100% avoidable issue.
However...in the land of enablers...CoW pre determined outcome syndrome kicks in...I presume as per the history.
..hey takes a village, to be responsible for those clueless to the concept.
All completely relevant points, to a conversation everyone is too scared to have!
Seems B.O.L.E. shut that down AND enables the cycle...cue the bleeding heart vile haters of truth.
Up 62 Down 9
Matthew on Jan 5, 2021 at 1:18 pm
Were all under financial stress.. can the CoW pay my taxes too?
Up 74 Down 11
Groucho d'North on Jan 5, 2021 at 1:00 pm
Perhaps the Liquor Corporation could contribute to the solution of this situation? They benefitted from contributing to the problem.