
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Community Services Minister Richard Mostyn, Yukon Party Leader Currie Dixon, Yukon MP Brendan Hanley and Yukon NDP Leader Kate White
Photo by Whitehorse Star
Community Services Minister Richard Mostyn, Yukon Party Leader Currie Dixon, Yukon MP Brendan Hanley and Yukon NDP Leader Kate White
Now that a federal funding shortfall of over $100 million has forced the Yukon government to pull its Canada Games bid for 2027,
Now that a federal funding shortfall of over $100 million has forced the Yukon government to pull its Canada Games bid for 2027, the territory’s opposition parties are asking if federal funding is a question for other big infrastructure projects.
The government announced Monday that the federal government only offered $16.75 million to help Whitehorse host the Games.
That included $3 million in capital funding for an event with estimated capital costs of $185 million that would go to improve or replace recreational infrastructure like the Takhini Arena, and build up to $65 million worth of housing for athletes – to be subsequently used by the general public.
Essentially, the territory was offered only three per cent of the federal funding it was depending on. For context, the City of Whitehorse was ready to contribute $11 million for capital alone.
“Without any meaningful contribution from the federal government to support the Games,” Community Services Minister Richard Mostyn told the legislature Monday afternoon, hours after the government had announced it would pull its hosting bid, “we were left with no other option.”
Some of the repercussions are obvious.
Whitehorse misses out on a chance to draw tourists and showcase itself to the rest of Canada.
The territory misses out on legacy infrastructure, like the Canada Games Centre from the 2007 event – 15 years later, that facility is still used for recreation by 3,000 people daily in the winter.
The planned housing money now needs to be found elsewhere, though Mostyn told reporters the government is still pursuing that funding independent of the Games bid.
But for Yukon Party Leader Currie Dixon and Yukon NDP Leader Kate White, the lost bid raises a bigger question.
If the government was relying on close to $200 million from the feds, and was only offered a small fraction of that, how confidently can the territory depend on federal money for other, more important infrastructure projects in the Yukon?
“The rejection by the federal government to fund (the Games),” Dixon told reporters, “it certainly raises concerns about other projects as well.
“The Atlin hydro project, the Moon Lake project, Dawson rec centre: These are all projects that will require significant investment from the federal government.”
The Atlin Hydro Expansion Project, for instance, needs $60 million from the federal government to get underway and help Yukon Energy replace electricity generated by fossil fuels as part of its renewable energy target for the decade. It’s unlikely that funding could come from any other partner on the project, and the gap could put it in jeopardy.
White also wondered how sure federal funding could be for other infrastructure projects when the Canada Games request seemed so certain.
“It sounded like the $160 million was a done deal and we were moving forward and hosting the Games,” she told reporters.
Mostyn spoke with reporters he learned of the federal government’s offer last week.
He said he was disappointed by the federal response, but remains confident Yukoners can rely on future federal infrastructure funding in other areas.
“It’s as a result of the federal decision to really hold the line on their spending on this sporting event that we’ve had to pull our bid,” he said, acknowledging the financial pressures on the federal government following relief spending during the COVID-19 pandemic and rising inflation this year.
“The federal government has contributed immense amounts of infrastructure money to the territory over the last six years. It’s been record investment. And so they’ve certainly been very supportive.
“But we’re in a new era now in the country.”
Mostyn said staffers in his department had spoken with federal employees in a meeting last week, and new infrastructure spending was being allocated for the federal budget next spring.
Spending on public transit, sewer water and infrastructure that would prepare Canada for a changing climate are “the areas the federal government is looking to invest in in the future,” he said.
“And so I have no doubt that there will be more infrastructure money coming to Canada and to this territory.”
Dixon was more critical of the federal government.
He said he expected some belt-tightening from the feds, but was disappointed by Ottawa’s offer for the hosting bid.
Given the offer, he said, he thought the Yukon government made the right decision to abandon its considering the massive funding shortfall.
He said he was surprised by how big that shortfall wound up being, though, and called the federal government’s offer a “slap in the face” to Yukoners.
“What is particularly concerning to me is that this is the federal government that has shown a lack of interest in the North,” he said.
“This is just the most recent example of that.”
In a statement released Monday, Yukon MP Brendan Hanley said he was disappointed the Yukon government has withdrawn its bid, but added the federal government will continue to help fund other areas critical to Yukoners.
“Federal contributions to priorities such as housing, health care, infrastructure, and climate change – areas that we know Yukoners care deeply about – will continue as we invest in the growth and well-being of all our communities, in collaboration with all Yukon partners,” the Liberal MP said.
Those areas are where the Yukon government should be requesting funding, White told reporters.
“When you recognize the level of housing insecurity in the territory, and how inflation increases affect individuals, there’s a lot of other things that $160 million could really do to benefit the territory.”
The Yukon government submitted its bid for the 2027 Canada Games in 2021.
The 18-month process was announced with the support of representatives of the City of Whitehorse, Kwanlin Dün First Nation, the Council of Yukon First Nations and the Canada Games Council.
Mayor Laura Cabott said in a statement Monday the Yukon government’s decision “is disappointing, but we also understand the circumstances surrounding such a decision.
“While the Games would have offered an opportunity to showcase our city on a national stage, hosting multi-sport games requires substantial investment.
“Without partner funding, the legacy investments which are integral to a meaningful bid would not have been possible,” Cabott said.
She thanked chair Piers McDonald and the Whitehorse bid committee “for their incredible work bringing us to this point.
“Their bid highlighted the economic potential of the games and showed the Canada Winter Games bid evaluation committee Whitehorse is a community with world-class potential,” the mayor said.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (26)
Up 2 Down 1
drum on Nov 20, 2022 at 5:19 pm
The Golden Age Society that gives social functions and contact for seniors to its members receives no money from the Governments. We support Staying At Home as long as possible. We need help from the Governments. That Includes Dr. Hanley at the Federal Level We have worked long and hard as volunteers to keep our doors open throughout the Pandemic. All the Ministers of the Yukon Government can say is thank you for doing a wonderful job for Seniors but do not want to help. We need Core Funding. We are 28% of the population. That is a lot of votes.
Up 6 Down 2
Groucho d'North on Nov 20, 2022 at 9:10 am
Trudeau recently concluded his latest ego-trip to distant lands for meetings where he pledges millions more of our tax dollars to foreign governments and save the world projects. I have yet to find a running tally on how much of our goodwill he has shared with others, but there is lots of hype for each funding announcement. Google 'Trudeau pledges' to sample some of his recent beneficiaries. This at a time when inflation is crippling some Canadians, housing, food, home heating, and many other aspects of our lives have been driven to the unaffordable by government policies and taxes.
Charity begins at home, but it is not as ego-building than giving other people's money to your favourite charity du jour. Trudeau has already got a plan for where to spend what was not gifted to the Games project.
Up 10 Down 1
Sylvia Burkhard on Nov 19, 2022 at 1:15 pm
THe Negative Nelly in me questions the figure of 3000 people a day using CGC, that is 200 different folks every hour for 15 hours a day, or any other mix of numbers. Seems really high and surely can’t be every day, would love to see actual numbers, plus the cost of running CGC. Like that will ever happen, even though our various governments claim to be open and accountable.
Up 3 Down 3
Mick on Nov 18, 2022 at 4:50 pm
@ Mathew
It’s pretty clear your understanding of politics is…well…limited.
Services cost money. Running the CGC is a service, it costs money. Just like the RCMP, Highways Crews or whatever.
No one with more than two brain cells complains the Highways crews are costing money….they provide a service.
What colour is the sky in your world?
Up 13 Down 1
Sunny on Nov 17, 2022 at 9:11 pm
I would have loved to give North_of_60 about a million thumbs up!!!! You nailed it with every word North of 60! Thank you!
Up 12 Down 2
No Career Politicians on Nov 17, 2022 at 2:51 pm
@Making Mountains. I couldn't agree more about having a clean slate of politicians. That likely won't happen but at least we can have new leaders for the parties. We will soon be rid of Silver by the sounds of things but I doubt Kate White and Currie Dixon will follow him out. Too bad, because it would be refreshing to have 3 new leaders to choose from in the next election.
Up 34 Down 3
North_of_60 on Nov 16, 2022 at 5:34 pm
@Erwin Glock "As we can see now that the Federal Government is on a money saving course, what if they cut the yearly funding of the Yukon (is it 1.7 billion) suddenly in half? What would happen?"
A whole lot of freeloading parasites moved to the Yukon only to pursue the generous opportunities that federal funding brought. What would happen is they would leave, the housing bubble would deflate, housing and rents would become affordable and the people who actually care about the Yukon could continue working to make it a better place without the albatross of those opportunistic freeloaders weighing us down. A reduced budget would force the Yukon govt to live within our means and stop the ideological driven woke climatard fantasies that have destroyed the Yukon that so many of us are proud to call our home for life.
Up 22 Down 1
Making Mountains on Nov 16, 2022 at 2:24 pm
Creating a controversy where none exists. Plenty of real problems to be contending with. Too complicated though, right? Much easier to sling mud. Desperately trying to stay relevant to ‘the narrative’ while very obviously not doing their jobs. Freeloaders all. Yukon needs a clean slate election. Reasonable potential leaders won’t participate in this circus.
Up 20 Down 4
John on Nov 16, 2022 at 1:50 pm
Perhaps some honesty from Lord Mostyn, et al, might be beneficial.
It appears that we. the public, have been fed some rather over ripe shyte regarding the demands from CWC. In a CBC interview with Paul, the CEO of CWC said.""The proposal was definitely, you know, a shinier version than what would have been required to host the Canada games. There could have been other opportunities presented that would have met the Canada Games standard. But this is the one that met the requirements for the city of Whitehorse and the government of Yukon to grow through this opportunity." It was our high and mighty being haughty-taughty with a bid we could not afford. Pie in the sky. My thoughts are that Ottawa saw through the haze and rightly said we will fund a scaled down version if you offer something more in keeping to what is affordable and needed.
The article goes on to say that: "Paul said it would have been up to the host and the bid committee to reduce costs."
In summation we could have provided a venue site that was the Volkswagen model but instead our leadership chose the Mercedes Benz. So if there is "any blame" it is ours and ours alone. We got greedy and dazzled by our unnecessary ego and self-importance.
The truth always comes out - you just have to ask the right people and the right questions. We, actually our wonderful governments, fell on their own sword. What a bunch of cretins, and an embarrassment.
Up 20 Down 1
Erwin Glock on Nov 16, 2022 at 1:36 pm
As we can see now that the Federal Government is on a money saving course,
what if they cut the yearly funding of the Yukon (is it 1.7 billion) suddenly in half?
What would happen? Any suggestions?
Up 13 Down 5
John - with a J on Nov 16, 2022 at 12:47 pm
This is hilarious. The same people that posted complaints about having the games a few weeks ago are the same people who are complaining that they have been dumped.
I think some people need to start listening to the sound of their own voices. Better still - just say nothing. You’re not showing your intelligence, you’re showing your lack thereof.
Up 14 Down 2
Jake on Nov 16, 2022 at 11:21 am
@ Matthew if that only costed 5 mil a year I would be happy. Wages alone would eat up most of that. I am betting double. And that is before any capital upgrades
Up 20 Down 9
Groucho d'North on Nov 16, 2022 at 10:59 am
Federal reliability? Apart from driving us deeper into a recession and assorted hard times, what else can the Trudeau Liberals be reliable for?
Up 9 Down 6
Matthew on Nov 16, 2022 at 5:15 am
The territory misses out on legacy infrastructure, like the Canada Games Centre from the 2007 event – 15 years later, that facility is still used for recreation by 3,000 people daily in the winter.
I hear it cost taxpayers 5M/yr to keep open.. this simply isn't feasible! Is this true?
Up 16 Down 11
Juniper Jackson on Nov 16, 2022 at 12:14 am
Don’t worry about money! Trudeau is printing tons of money..bucket loads, as he closes down business after business, there won’t be any thing to buy with it. In a lot of places, there won’t even be food…save those paper bills though to light your fires.
Up 23 Down 1
Lynx on Nov 15, 2022 at 9:22 pm
So the feds said no to one ask from the Yukon. That certainly doesn't mean the gravy train is ending as many people here are saying. The only way the gravy train really ends is if Yukon Government is forced to put in place its own taxes and greatly raises fees for everything to be comparable with the south. Until then, we will continue to have our lives up here heavily subsidized by southern taxpayers. Yukon does very little to raise money off of its own tax base the way all of the provinces do.
If you want to be a true libertarian and not be a financial drain on the rest of Canada, the best thing you can do is move south and start paying your own way.
Up 1 Down 1
No, Virginia on Nov 15, 2022 at 6:31 pm
@Yukoner ‘71: it’s a beautiful idea, but, no, I don’t think there’s anything better on the horizon. Look around you. ❤️
Up 14 Down 2
Sum Ting Wong on Nov 15, 2022 at 6:14 pm
What a contry!! what a contry!! Where 16 million buckaloons is "a slap in the face".
Slap me baby! Slap me hard!!
Up 30 Down 2
Iceberg averted, Captain Smith on Nov 15, 2022 at 5:21 pm
It would have offered an opportunity to showcase our city? You know what else would really make Whitehorse pop? Some snow removal, some O & M and some architecture aside from social housing projects with shed roofs, corrugated steel, primary colours and unchecked crime. Some restaurants, theatres and clubs would be great, too. As an economic spinoff, it might even make the downtown condo scene worth the current rate of $850 per square foot. Their nightlife and shopping now consist of empty shelves at Walmart and Superstore. The city and the territory should rejoice Whitehorse won’t be showcased. It will save us all a heap of embarrassment.
Up 21 Down 4
Jake on Nov 15, 2022 at 4:08 pm
@ Yukoner ‘71 yes it is. Party is over. We are gonna see belt tightening like never before. Been in Yukon 44 years and never seen the money that has been wasted on stupid projects and mismanagement.
Up 12 Down 47
Politico on Nov 15, 2022 at 3:37 pm
If the opposition has questions why don't they contact the Feds to find out what's going on? Why are they always whining to the government about what the feds are doing? Oh, I know. The Feds don't talk to anyone about their plans and this gives the opposition a chance to make some cheap headlines even though nothing gets done!
Up 56 Down 2
Anie on Nov 15, 2022 at 3:22 pm
Looks like the gravy train doesn't come this far North any more.
Up 52 Down 3
AdmiralA$$ on Nov 15, 2022 at 3:11 pm
Hold up...you mean the green fed feed troughs you p!gs eat from could like...end? whoa totally.
Four clowns suddenly concerned about Funding there fancy lives and fancy policies. No this was not a slap in my face Mr Dixon. It was settle high five and a wink from the Fed's that said "don't worry we can't afford this whimsy either".
Pretty rare you'll catch me saying this but, thank the Fed's for this one. Yikes that was close! Now if we just stopped stealing from Canada and had a real economy...yeah I know, THAT'S whimsy.
Up 43 Down 13
Roy on Nov 15, 2022 at 1:42 pm
Currie should be careful not to hurt himself straddling the fence like that LOL
He can't make up his mind about the Winter Games - not having them is a failure of the Yukon Liberals but having them would be ridiculously expensive at a time when more important projects need funding. Solid job courting both sides and not actually taking a firm stance. It's this double-speak that has him in the top job!
It's almost like there isn't an endless pot of money to be given to the Yukon from Ottawa. And that maybe we should spend that limited money on higher priorities than a 2 week party for mediocre athletes.
It's like Currie is almost there...he's so close to figuring it out...but he doesn't want to upset voters with kids that are definitely gonna make it to the NHL but they need the 2 weeks of winter games experience to pull it off.
He also never misses a chance to take a shot at the feds "What is particularly concerning to me is that this is the federal government that has shown a lack of interest in the North"
Hey Currie just maybe the federal government is in fact "showing a lack of interest in wasting money on a two week party in the North" - and you should be thanking them instead of trying to score cheap political points. Be an adult and take a stance instead of a politician trying not to upset your base.
Up 59 Down 5
Yukoner ‘71 on Nov 15, 2022 at 1:36 pm
Gasp, could the southern taxpayer funded gravy train finally be over? Is some semblance of fiscal responsibility finally on the horizon?
Up 56 Down 9
Funny on Nov 15, 2022 at 1:07 pm
Kate white criticizing the liberals? LOL. Pull the CASA agreement then Kate. But that means her face wouldn’t be in the Whitehorse star every day, so she probably won’t.