
Photo by Whitehorse Star
NDP Leader Kate White and Opposition Leader Currie Dixon
Photo by Whitehorse Star
NDP Leader Kate White and Opposition Leader Currie Dixon
Yukon opposition leaders say the Liberal government’s $26.2-million supplementary budget falls well short of expectations.
Yukon opposition leaders say the Liberal government’s $26.2-million supplementary budget falls well short of expectations.
Opposition Leader Currie Dixon came out of the legislature Thursday afternoon with both barrels firing.
“We have raised the concern that the Liberal government is not taking the inflation crisis seriously, and what we saw today was that exact fear played out ….” Dixon said.
“We had telegraphed all week – both myself and the NDP – had telegraphed to the government that we would be raising inflation as the number one issue … the responses from the government were weak at best, to say the least,” Dixon said.
Last week, the governent announced several measures to help Yukoners cope with the cost of living.
Those include another $150 per customer in power rate relief over three months, on top of an initial $150 earlier this year; one-time $150 payments to social assistance recipients and Yukon Seniors Income Supplement recipients; a six-month extension of $500 per month to caregivers of children in out-of-home care; and a rebate of up to $50 per cord of wood to heat homes, up to 10 cords.
“None of those are in the budget … so it’s clear to us that they’ve come up with these on the fly,” Dixon said.
“This is not something they’ve been preparing for over the course of the summer. They simply have made these announcements over the last two weeks because they knew that they were going to get grilled on it in the legislature and they’ve come up with a few of these measures to address it … so it’s clear that they’re making this up as they go.”
Dixon explained how his party would handle the current inflationary pressures.
“We think it would be more broadly supportive of Yukoners to cut the fuel tax to assist in the price of gasoline, the price of fuel and the price of food, as the majority of our food comes up by truck,” he said.
“We also today suggested removing the carbon tax from home heating fuel, as you see in other jurisdictions.
“The NDP has provided a number of things that they think would be useful, and now I understand the premier is saying he’ll consider some of these suggestions from the NDP, but where was this two months ago? Where was this in the spring?”
He added his position on the carbon tax has been clear all along.
“I don’t think the carbon tax is the best way to reduce emissions in the Yukon. I never have. We’ve said that for years now.
“I think that there are other measures that would be better suited at reducing emissions in the Yukon and I think that’s what we should be focusing on,” he said.
“But our question today was very specific: will the government ask the federal government to remove the carbon tax from home heating fuel? That’s something that’s well within the government’s gamut of opportunities to consider.
“And we’ve seen it play out in other jurisdictions. The Northwest Territories negotiated the exemption of the carbon tax to home heating fuel. We think that should be done here.”
Ideally, he would like to see the carbon tax removed altogether, “but we know that’s not likely, so what we’d like to see is it removed at least for home heating fuel during this period of unprecedented inflation.
“We know that home heating fuel is a significant driver of household budgets.”
He was asked why he thinks the Liberal government is reluctant to drop the territorial fuel.
“My view is that any suggestion that comes from the Yukon Party they will inherently oppose,” he said.
“And so, because we have suggested it, I think that they don’t want to do it because it’s our idea. I would be happy if they stole that idea from me; I really wish they would.”
Independent economists have found that Alberta’s elimination of the fuel tax led to a direct reduction in the cost of fuel, Dixon said, “and everybody who travels down to Alberta sees the difference at the pumps.”
NDP Leader Kate White also didn’t hold back with her opinion on the government’s supplementary budget.
“I think there’s real opportunities when we talk about budgets and we talk about things that they can do, and when you listen to a budget speech and it’s like listening to paint dry, you wonder how something that can be so important to the health of the economy and the health of a territory can be so dull,” White said.
“And so I think that there will be a lot of opportunity in the next number of weeks to really pull that stuff apart but you know, question period today was brutal in terms of the complete lack of recognition of the experience of Yukoners right now. If that sets the tone for the fall sitting, it’s gonna be a long one.”
When politicians discuss these issues, she added, “it’s not just how it’s affecting us as individuals, but how it’s affecting all of us. I think we’re all in this and some of us, the experiences are far, far harder than others.”
White was asked if there were any surprises for her in the supplementary budget.
“Honestly, no. It takes a long time for budgets to be prepared and so it’s interesting that the first inflation announcement was included, but it doesn’t include the ones that were just made in a – I would say it’s kind of a haphazard way – last week and so, we see part of that, we don’t see all of that.
“I’m not surprised. Everyone right now, we should be talking about the financial effects of climate change … $60 million for wildfire, $3 million for flooding and those are all numbers that are only gonna get bigger.
“We’ve seen landslides like we’ve never seen before, right? And those may be affecting the City of Whitehorse, but it definitely affects the territorial government along the (North) Klondike Highway and so we’re going to continue to see those things augment but that money will have to get spent. It’s something we can’t scrimp on.”
Would she have liked to have seen more?
“Absolutely. Because I think there was a real opportunity. We could have really done some good for people with that surplus, as far as trying to help with people’s reality right now, the lived reality of where they are with the cost of everything going up.”
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (11)
Up 6 Down 5
Justin Trudeau on Oct 11, 2022 at 7:22 pm
Ahhhh errrrr ummmm I hate to kinda admit if Ej buuuut Sandy is spending everything I send him and I get it from Alberta and the new gal in charge is talkin about cutting off the transfer payments and then my favorite province kbek and all the other welfare provinces and territories including Ukon will be gettin a big fat goose egg for beer money, I mean if Ukon would develop its vast quantities of oil and gas it would be a have territory instead of a welfare case. I was up there a long time ago and nutin has changed, the biggest employer is the city, the territory and us the big meat grinder called the feds, anyway I sure hope Alberta continues payin, cheers to all my liberal ndp supporters, Hag Jyst hollered from the bathroom make sure to say hi.
Up 6 Down 15
KC on Oct 11, 2022 at 2:35 pm
Well... The Liberals haven't given me any reason to back them lately but the inflation mitigation policies they announced the other week are better than the Yukon Party's so there is that.
Up 11 Down 5
AdmiralA$$ on Oct 11, 2022 at 1:16 pm
Funny how I can give clear examples and the reason why yet, some still seem so confused.
I get sick of trying to explain economics to people who still think fiscal and monetary policy are the same thing.
At this point all I can say is...look another Lemming, right off the cliff they went.
Up 8 Down 13
Yukoner32 on Oct 11, 2022 at 10:43 am
@Admiral. That's quite the theory you have there ha ha. So most countries around the globe are having problems with high inflation, but somehow in your mind it is not a global problem. Think about that for a second.
It's a hell of a coincidence if they are not connected wouldn't you say?
Up 7 Down 7
bonanzajoe on Oct 10, 2022 at 9:40 pm
Has supporters of climate change scam/hoax ever considered many of these natural disasters are caused by humans interfering with nature? Let the climate adjust itself like its supposed to and nature won't let mankind down. And I would like anyone to use science to tell me the Yukon has a climate problem.
Up 17 Down 10
AdmiralA$$ on Oct 9, 2022 at 5:03 pm
Inflation is a not a "global" problem that's just something our media tells you and which ever nations decided to spend their way out of this pandemic. Which is most of the EU and NA.
Example:
Swiss inflation data shows approx. 3.2% now. They are already raising rates and preparing tightening measures. Amazing what a dedicated central bank can do.
If you believe inflation is a global problem then you just accept jumping off a cliff like a Lemming because, you know....they did it, Very clever. Proves you know little about inflation, aside from what CBC is saying.
Up 25 Down 15
Groucho d'North on Oct 9, 2022 at 10:04 am
@North_of_60
Everything going awry is being blamed on climate change, as it supports the narrative of doom. I've even heard double yolk eggs are a result of climate change. But hey, "The science is settled."
Up 18 Down 18
Ej on Oct 8, 2022 at 1:14 pm
@Pierre. What fiscal dysfunction are you talking about? The government is running a surplus right now. Do you want the Liberals to spend all the money we don't have like the NDP are suggesting? Or maybe you just expect the territory to fix global inflation.
Up 44 Down 11
Pierre on Oct 7, 2022 at 7:39 pm
The headline reads "opposition" then there's the mug shot of Kate however didn't she sign up with the Liberals hence part and parcel of the fiscal dysfunction.
Up 41 Down 15
North_of_60 on Oct 7, 2022 at 6:50 pm
None of the wildfires, floods or landslides are unusual from a historical perspective. In any case, if the LIB\NDP are blaming it on ClimateChange™ from fossil fuel CO2 emissions in the Yukon, then it's obvious their Fossil-fuel Carbon-tax has no effect and must be scrapped.
Up 65 Down 16
Jim on Oct 7, 2022 at 5:00 pm
I’m not sure why any media outlets interview Kate. She talks a brave game but when it comes to the vote her little sheep hand follows her master Sandy.