Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

MAKING A POINT – Premier Darrell Pasloski addresses the legislature Thursday afternoon as ministers and MLAs listen.

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Liberal Leader Sandy Silver and Official Opposition Leader Liz Hanson

Opposition detects a ‘cynical’ vote-buying scheme

Territorial party leaders accused the premier of vote buying after the Yukon Party tabled its 2016-17 budget in the legislature Thursday.

By Sidney Cohen on April 8, 2016

Territorial party leaders accused the premier of vote buying after the Yukon Party tabled its 2016-17 budget in the legislature Thursday.

This is the last budget the premier will deliver before his five-year mandate runs out in October.

Official Opposition Leader Liz Hanson of the NDP called the part of the Department of Education budget a “cynical approach to buying votes in September.”

Pointing to the surplus, which is down from last year’s estimate, Liberal Leader Sandy Silver said the 2016-17 budget is “an attempt for the Yukon Party government to try to buy the hearts and minds of Yukoners with all the money that’s supposed to be in reserves for future years.”

At just $9.5 million, this year’s surplus estimate is markedly smaller compared with last year’s estimate of $23 million, though the estimated surplus for 2015-16 was recently revised to $1.2 million, significantly down from the 2014-15 surplus, which was a bit over $68 million.

Premier Darrell Pasloski told the Star Thursday he believes that had the Liberals or NDP tabled the budget, they would have run “a significant deficit.

“What we have is a modest surplus,” he said.

“The surplus is smaller because of the reduced revenues – we got less money on the transfer payment from the federal government than we were supposed to get, and our revenues are down as well, as a result of the downturn in the economy.”

Because of changes to the way the territorial transfer is calculated, the Yukon received $6.5 million less in 2016-17 federal transfer money than it had anticipated during the winter.

However, the territory still got more money from Ottawa in 2016-17 than ever before for a total of $1.07 billion in federal transfers and recoveries such as infrastructure investments.

Last year, the Yukon received $1.05 billion in health, social and territorial transfers and recoveries.

Pasloski noted in his speech to the legislature that his government is proposing a budget with a surplus, and without tax increases to Yukon residents and businesses, nor debt.

“We are a small economy and vulnerable to external forces.” he said.

“I believe that we should never put our economic future at risk, or that we have any right to ask our children – or our children’s children – to pay for the cost of our ER visits or the social services we all use today.”

Silver takes a different view.

“What we’re seeing here is money being spent more on a political basis as opposed to a five-year plan,” said Silver.

In a scrum following the premier’s budget speech, Silver said the government is taking on projects in the lead-up to an election, with little consideration for the long term.

He noted major capital projects currently underway, and the $3 million this year that will go toward construction of the new F.H. Collins Secondary School.

“When you spend all your money in that final year ... you create a false economy, you create this one year of build where what’s going to happen?” he said.

“We’re going to have a lot of companies come from down south and they’re going to come up here and try to grow roots.

“It’s great to have competitive industries, but the way in which we create that false economy in that last year, nobody’s going to be sticking around for the next year, and the next year after that.”

After health care and social services, the budget allocates more money to the Education department than any other.

This year’s Education budget is $160 million, up about three per cent from last year’s $155 million.

Included in that is $520,000 for school supplies, which amounts to about $100 per student.

The plan right now is for school councils to take responsibility for spending the money.

Hanson questioned how much impact such an initiative will have on Yukon families.

“(As if) $100 a kid is somehow going to change the territory,” she said.

“I think most Yukoners are going to see it for what it is: a cynical vote-buy that we’ve seen previous Conservative governments try.”

Hanson also mentioned “boutique tax credits,” such as the Yukon children’s fitness and arts tax credits, which she said don’t apply to many “ordinary Yukon families.”

She pointed instead to the federal Canada Child Benefit as an example of a program that will put “real money into the pockets of lower income families in the territory.”

Under the Yukon children’s fitness tax credit, families can claim up to 15 per cent of enrolment fees, up to $1,000, for any child under 16 who participates in a sports league or fitness program that’s supervised and at least eight weeks long.

Deputy Finance minister Katherine White said Thursday that 1,700 tax filers claimed the fitness tax credit in 2014.

The Yukon children art’s credit functions in much the same way as the fitness tax credit.

Families can claim up to $500 for each child under 16 years of age who is registered in an arts, cultural and/or outdoors program for at least two months.

White said 650 tax filers claimed this credit in 2014.

The numbers aren’t out for 2014 yet, but in 2013, the number of Yukoners who filed income taxes was 27,000.

Under the federal Canada Child Benefit that Hanson mentioned, families are entitled to monthly, tax-free payments of up to a total of $6,400 per year. Families earning net incomes under $30,000 a year and with young children will get the highest benefit.

Ottawa projects that about nine in 10 families will get more money out of this new tax program.

See editorial commentaries in opinons.

Comments (14)

Up 0 Down 0

Wow, Liberals and NDP coming unhitched on Apr 14, 2016 at 4:50 pm

by the numbers shown. NDP goes into Alberta and tells the Premier we are closing down their oil and gas. It is interesting because the Premier was a great person that died to soon and I had the opportunity to know him a bit.
Then you have liberals going both ways right or left I am not sure.
Far as spending goes, the YPG has done the best job possible given all the negative killing of the NDP and Liberal talk.

Up 83 Down 37

Be Honest on Apr 13, 2016 at 10:45 am

Dallas: "they are spending money like drunken sailors....we certainly don't need that."

We already have that lol. Don't you think its odd that YG bureaucracy has grown immensely under the YP? Don't you think its odd that despite having no operating mines in Yukon, the department of Energy, Mines and Resources hasn't laid anyone off and has actually grown in size? Paying for this huge bureaucracy (and severance payouts to multiple ADMs and DMs probably costing millions alone) is ridiculous. Give your head a shake, this government's best before date has long passed. Too many professional politicians involved.

Up 129 Down 207

Cynical is the facts are on Apr 13, 2016 at 8:28 am

Liberal mayor just wasting CoW money as fast as he can.
The Liberal and NDP calling for tax increases and carbon tax, sales tax, wage and price controls.
They don't give one reason why we need taxes increased.
NDP and Liberals want to put taxes on people for no purpose or reason other more taxes.
There is no business case for higher taxes of any type if you manage the funding properly like the YPG has done for the last number of years.
I can see the NDP are in panic mode just by the numbers on the comments.
Very defensive, especially after last week end.
NDP leader in New Brunswick does not agree with the Federal NDP and have supported more conservative type moves on such things like pipeline east.
The talk is Trudeau will support both pipe lines east and west but will wait years before approval
Pipe line east can go through the top of New Hampshire and Maine into NB.
All you need to do is get those conservative states to agree.
New York and other states in between will want some of the oil and gas that goes through that pipeline. Nova Scotia already feeds that area from Sable Island but they want more.
The Population is 50 Million in that area or more.
Then you by-past Quebec but they want the oil and gas too because there is refineries in Montreal.
What kind of public policy is cynical.

Up 243 Down 314

The real party in history is the NDP in Alberta on Apr 12, 2016 at 2:18 pm

The Alberta Premier told the Federal NDP go pound sand this week end on oil and gas development.
She is more conservative than most conservatives.
The Federal NDP go into Alberta and tell Albertan's we are going close down their oil and gas pipe lines, need to increase government spending.
The Federal NDP are done.
The local NDP are worse than the Federal NDP party as far as direction and without a clue on how to build economy.

Up 123 Down 258

Rorex1983 on Apr 12, 2016 at 10:53 am

@ June Jackson
"this will be another election based on who the voters despise the least." The real truth about every election ever. You're never voting for a party your 100% behind or believe in, and if you are, you are in for a rude awakening.

@wolverine
"and how is this any different from the NDP's pandering to the left and 'vote-buying'" Again completely true. What is a platform other than an attempt to get votes. Nothing sinister about passing a budget either in fact I would argue that at least with a budget (in comparison with a platform) it's more than just words or a promise.

Personally given the aging nature of our demographics, the increase health care costs associated with that, I find it outstanding that the government is continuing to balance the books. Other jurisdictions and even federally the deficit is growing every year. It's important that we don't leave large debts for our children.

Up 18 Down 1

james on Apr 12, 2016 at 1:00 am

This entire story is rather naïve, any budget tabled by any government of any party is a vote buying exercise.

To think otherwise, would be putting your head in the sand.

Up 4 Down 3

BnR on Apr 11, 2016 at 8:34 pm

Dallas
If your comment is serious, it's a joke, and if it's a joke, it doesn't work so well.
And good lord, who has so much time on their hands to be bumpin up the comment reputations? Wild for one I guess.

Up 560 Down 377

Cliff on Apr 10, 2016 at 10:15 am

The Yukon Party is anachronistic.

Up 97 Down 20

Politico on Apr 9, 2016 at 8:10 pm

@Dallas Schaber Yes, and we just have to look at the Canadian economy to see how well they starve the poor and give tax cuts to the rich have done. How much money did the Harpercrites help the rich and their companies hiding overseas? Spoiler alert, $200 Billion

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2015/05/16/corporate-tax-havens-canada_n_7293410.html

Up 757 Down 975

LIz and Sandy have already stated they are going to raise taxes, on Apr 9, 2016 at 9:46 am

bring in a carbon tax, run large deficits like the Feds, spent in a way not to support the economy and just the liberals only going to run $10 billion deficit but $29.4 billion dollars.
The liberal and NDP can't keep the books straight and would destroy the Yukon economy like they did before.
Yukon Party would have to come in and clear up another mess.
Liberals and NDP just don't get it at all or they would make statements that made sense to Yukoners.
Nothing in by Liberals or NDP nothing out.
No substance here.

Up 577 Down 813

Dallas Schaber on Apr 8, 2016 at 9:19 pm

The last thing this territory needs is a NDP or a liberal government, just take a long hard look at Manitoba, Alberta and the current federal party in power and how they are spending money like drunken sailors....we certainly don't need that.

Up 503 Down 784

wolverine on Apr 8, 2016 at 4:32 pm

“I think most Yukoners are going to see it for what it is: a cynical vote-buy that we’ve seen previous Conservative governments try.” Hanson's statement says.

...and how is this any different from the NDP's pandering to the left and 'vote-buying' with their greenwashed foolishness and carbon tax promises?

Up 74 Down 21

Andrew on Apr 8, 2016 at 4:15 pm

This is just like Doug Ford handing out $20 bills in the housing projects.

Up 602 Down 351

June Jackson on Apr 8, 2016 at 4:15 pm

Too little too late.. I hope the Yukon Party bites the dust.. this will be another election based on who the voters despise the least. Personally, I find the Yukon Party and Paslowski contemptible and I hope never to see any of them in office again.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.