Operational spending deficit may become chronic
The Yukon government is forecasting a $31.6-million deficit in 2020-21, according to an interim report released Thursday.
By Gabrielle Plonka on October 2, 2020
The Yukon government is forecasting a $31.6-million deficit in 2020-21, according to an interim report released Thursday.
This is due, in part, to a $95.9-million increase in operations and maintenance spending, which includes public health spending and financial aid packages.
“Most of this is COVID-related,” Premier Sandy Silver told media Thursday afternoon. It was the first afternoon MLAs had convened in the legislature since last March.
The fiscal update shows $88.7 million of that projected increase is due to financial aid and health care spending related to COVID-19.
The premier said he is still optimistic about the territory’s financial health.
“The interim fiscal and economic update shows the Yukon as one of only two other Canadian jurisdictions expecting to see real GDP growth in 2020,” Silver said.
The Yukon’s budget saw the third-lowest impact of any province or territory in 2020-21, according to the report.
Canada’s smaller economies were less affected due to the large percentage of public sector employees. The Yukon’s mining sector has also gone relatively uninterrupted during the pandemic.
“That’s not to say that we don’t have a lot of businesses right now that are in serious triage … we need to keep our vigilance up for the business community,” Silver said.
The government is expecting $52.9 million in federal support to off-set the COVID-19 costs.
The premier conceded that the operational spending deficit could become chronic over the next few years.
“I don’t think there’s a government in Canada or internationally that’s not very, very concerned,” Silver said.
“It’s very concerning to Yukoners and it’s very concerning to us as a government that we can have the ability to not pass on debt to future generations.”
Total government revenue in 2020-21 is forecast to be $1.3 billion, which is a $10-million decrease from earlier estimates.
The stunted revenue is because personal incomes have not risen as expected due to COVID-19, according to the report. There have also been reductions in camping and hunting revenues, as well as the waiving of fees to the mining and aviation industries.
The Dempster Fibre Project has been deferred to 2021-22 due to permitting delays.
This deferral has resulted in a reduction in forecast capital spending, the report says.
Gross capital expenditures are projected to decrease by $3.7 million from the main estimates.
The report estimates that the Yukon’s economy will see gradual improvement, assuming a wave of infection doesn’t force another aggressive lockdown.
“Community spread of COVID-19 in Yukon is the biggest downside risk to the forecast, especially if mining work sites are affected,” the report says.
The report also notes that the pandemic may change consumer behaviour long-term, meaning tourism activities may not bounce back.
Interventions by banks have also helped avoid a financial crisis, but this system is vulnerable due to growing consumer debt and public spending.
The unstable economy may benefit the mining sector, the report suggests.
The prices of copper and silver have increased during the pandemic.
“As investors look for safe investments during a time of economic and market upheaval, metal prices have seen notable appreciation in recent months,” the report says.
“If metal prices hold their value after the crisis dissipates, it could lead to renewed interest in the territory’s metal resources.”
The report also notes that economic forecasting is extremely difficult, because the future of the pandemic is unknown.
“Even if a vaccine were to become widely available late this year or in 2021, the virus is likely to drag on economic performance over the medium term,” the report says.
When the budget was originally tabled on March 5, there were only 105,000 confirmed COVID-19 cases worldwide. Two weeks later, case numbers tripled and the financial markets collapsed.
“While conditions seem to have stabilized, the experience over the last several months shows how quickly risks can materialize,” the report says.
The Yukon lost 4,000 jobs between March and June this year. Most of these job losses were in the service industries. Food and accommodation employment was cut in half and accounts for one-third of overall job losses.
The unemployment rate in August was eight per cent – the highest it’s been since June 2015.
When the number of unemployed individuals who were not looking for work during the pandemic are accounted for, the unemployment rate balloons to 12.5 per cent.
Almost 9,000 Yukoners applied for the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) and received an estimated $72 million.
About 4,000 Yukoners saw their wages subsidized due to the Canada Emergency Wage Subsidy (CEWS).
The housing, mining and construction industries are staying afloat in the Yukon despite the pandemic, the report notes.
“Even with the gradual reopening of the economy underway, 2020 will be a challenging year for Yukon’s economy,” the report says.
“Fallout from the virus is expected to extend into next year and possibly beyond, with potential ramifications affecting both Yukon’s economic and fiscal outlooks.”
Comments (25)
Up 5 Down 0
Jake The Bosun on Oct 9, 2020 at 6:41 am
Many good comments, one thing that seems to always get missed is that increased taxes remove any incentive for "Government" to be thrifty. SO too does the system of having an unaccountable bureaucracy reporting to an elected (temporary) management.
The bureacracy always seem to win, and grow. For how many years has now the COW tried to match the spending habits of senior Governments? Yes capital projects traditionally are good for an economy, but we no longer know what is ESSENTIAL! The palace on the hill benifits who, exactly? I wish there was another Duke or two in our future.
Up 2 Down 0
EJ-- on Oct 8, 2020 at 7:05 pm
Go do what Bill Gates did and then tell me about it. Yes, people who work for their money should choose where it goes. Each cent was taxed while it was being earned and now the gov gets to tax again? How many times can you tax a single dollar?
The larger point that was being made was if a government can't run the economy while being the one of the highest taxing countries in the 1st world; i doubt more money is going to solve the issue.
Up 3 Down 3
EJ on Oct 7, 2020 at 9:14 pm
@I Hate
Yes, we definitely shouldn't have an inheritance tax. It's better that we have a few families just continue passing down wealth for many generations at the expense of everyone else. People born into extreme wealth deserve every penny and should not have to contribute to the greater good at all. If Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates want to make sure the next 20 generations of their offspring don't have to work a day in their life - that's their business. Just like Trudeau worked really hard to be born into a life of privilege.
Taxation is theft. Leave the elites alone with their hoards of inherited, unearned gold. If you disagree with me and think everyone should work for their money- you must be a communist.
Up 6 Down 7
Max Mack on Oct 7, 2020 at 3:45 pm
@ Mick
Your reply to Dean has the same angry and dismissive tone as the poster who replied to my comment on the story re: Joe Sparling demanding that we spend money on his airline.
Are you the same government or Liberal party insider?
Up 16 Down 3
So do well sell everything to the strongest economies now or later? on Oct 7, 2020 at 2:38 pm
Keep posting pictures of beautiful unique wilderness. Then ask why foreign investors are buying up huge plots of land. This country will be bought out from under us and no Canadian will have a chance to compete because you'll tax those with any wealth into the poor house.
Up 20 Down 7
I hate this liberal government. on Oct 7, 2020 at 2:35 pm
How about you tell us the sacrifice government workers made by not taking paid vacations or taking more unpaid days off.
You can't. The deficit is strictly from the gov. Worse still is linking the CERB to workers comp; gonna drain that fund too.
Oh and WE scandal, SNC lavalin, Khans island, etc etc. Swept under the rug.
The joke is that in the land of gold we're being run into the ground by Silver.
Any limits or restrictions on people from outside moving in? Any followup to see how much of the CERB went to unemployed that only had a SIN # How are you going to squeeze a cent from anyone who only receives tax dollars to survive. I hate this government. New taxes to be introduced, asset tax + inheritance tax.
This is what happens when you have people that have never earned a dollar manage money.
Up 31 Down 6
North-of_60 on Oct 6, 2020 at 8:54 pm
Have you tried to communicate with any functional govt person recently? Their govt office phone goes to voice mail they never answer, they won't answer e-mails, and the govt info desk won't give you the workers govt cell phone number. Too many are using this as a golden opportunity to get paid for doing sweet FA.
Up 13 Down 10
Brian Melanson on Oct 6, 2020 at 7:28 pm
@ everyone who thinks cutting the transfer payment will solve any issues they have.
Guess you don’t understand how’s a country works on maintaining Sovereignty over a land mass.
Once you realize that, you people will realize that you sound like a grade 4 giving Business Advice.
Canadian Government cuts transfer cheque’s, start learning Russian or Mandarin.
Up 30 Down 2
Gringo on Oct 6, 2020 at 9:22 am
"part of which includes public health spending" ...there were no surgeries, one person since March hospitalized for Covid so I am at a loss regarding money overruns for public health.
Up 24 Down 8
Nathan Living on Oct 6, 2020 at 1:38 am
Let's lobby for lower federal transfer payments.
When the dust settles Yukon would be a better place to live.
Government would be trimmed, housing prices would be much lower. Many of those terrible drivers would be gone and you may be able to safely cross any street in Whitehorse.
Back to the good old days when people were poor but nice.
Up 39 Down 5
John on Oct 5, 2020 at 9:06 pm
No Sandy, the deficit is because half of govy staff is sitting at home getting full pay and no work is getting done.
Up 14 Down 12
Moose on Oct 5, 2020 at 8:50 pm
@ JC "Well, like the NDP, the Libs like to spend like drunken s++++rs. Now, we have to elect a Yukon Party Government to straighten things out."
Bahahah. You realize the Yukon Party made a mess of the financial books last time they were in power right? Fentie did well but Pasloski and his crew (including their currently leader Currie) absolutely did not.
Plus, they have currently been demanding massive extra spending in Education to get kids in school full time even though this won't be needed after the pandemic ends so would be a dumb investment (would need extra space costing millions). Then they demanded that the government expand socialized healthcare for diabetics, expand the shingles vaccine, spend millions more fixing up the Alaska highway near the border, add another MLA to the number of MLAs currently in the legislature (aside from Brad Cathers who voted against), build a school in Burwash, build a tourism centre in Watson and the list goes on and on. At the same time, they are angry that fees are going up for things like camping, rural garbage collection etc and are adamantly opposed to any tax increases. Now surely you can see how it is financially "unwise" to demand massive increased spending while opposing any new revenues to cover said spending! So let's not pretend that our financial situation would improve with the Pasloski crew back at the helm.
Up 16 Down 6
Wilf Carter on Oct 5, 2020 at 5:35 pm
Don't forget Alberta has given $600 billion more than they got back. So we should support buying services and goods from that province.
The premier of BC told us that he does not want Yukoners in his province for health care.
Up 16 Down 14
Mick on Oct 5, 2020 at 3:42 pm
@Dean
Try to keep up. The Territorial Formula Financing is not a gift from Ottawa it's an annual unconditional transfer payment from Canada's federal government to the three territorial governments of Yukon, the Northwest Territories, and Nunavut to support the provision of public services.
That money comes from Canadian's including Yukoners who pay federal taxes (you pay taxes right?) to run government services/programs including the ones that devolved a decade or two from the Feds to the Yukon. It's based on population with the understanding that goods and services cost a lot more to deliver in the North. Take for example Hospitals. We have 3 or them for a population of $45k, in Toronto a hospital the size of WGH might service 10 or 20 times that many people. Do you honestly think we should get rid of a hospital here and make Yukoners use facilities in the provinces because they are cheaper to deliver? We pay the same tax, we get the same (within reason) service.
Up 23 Down 7
Dean on Oct 5, 2020 at 7:11 am
Remember when you say our “revenue” is 1.3 billion, over 1.1 billion of that is a gift from the federal government, other peoples tax money. $1,1166,630,000 is from the feds, out of 1.3. The next biggest revenue in the Yukon is in tax at only $131,516,000.
Up 28 Down 6
motive unclear on Oct 4, 2020 at 5:27 pm
Well, I suppose a "goodly portion" of the deficit, (hahahhaha) went for the "upgrade" by the airport so we can have an eight lane highway for the dwindling traffic we are experiencing on the Alaska Highway. And this was a selling feature of the liberals during the last election. The waste of fuel, the pollution, the waste of time, not to mention a pile of money down the drain, and for what exactly? Then there is the fact that our government, to protect us from the common cold, continually drove up and down the highway all summer to the border to tell people not to spend a dollar more than they have to in the Yukon, and to beat it out of here as fast as humanly possible, thereby consigning our tourism industry to the dustbin for I'm guessing a decade or more... So tourism related businesses bit the big one and town councillors and pols and civil servants lost nary a dime. Good times! Can not wait for the reduced tax receipts to begin to bite into govern men revenue in the coming months...
Up 49 Down 8
Nathan Living on Oct 3, 2020 at 11:29 pm
Think we have to work towards no deficit.
It's time to allow some GY jobs to not be filled when people retire. It's time for people to stop being so entitled and live more modestly and pay more taxes so that we improve the balance between GY revenue and all those free federal transfer payments and infrastructure give always.
It's time to build a system for Yukon children that is based upon reality.
Stop bragging about fiscal responsibility when you are just spending other Canadians money.
Up 36 Down 9
Unfeckingbelievable! on Oct 3, 2020 at 11:14 pm
I agree Matthew. If I would have received the $2000 per month on top of my work income I would have spent every penny of it to keep Yukon businesses afloat. Some new hunting and fishing gear from Sportslodge, new footwear and winter coat from Coast Mountain, a new iPhone, 60 inch TV with 3D, coffee shops, a bunch of books from Macs Fireweed, a gold chain from Murdoch’s, some kitchen ware from Brambles and maybe some trinkets from the Midnight Sun... I would have had a great time... But alas not...
The people who did get the money wasted it on weed and alcohol... Heavily taxed items... Reinvesting I guess? Gotta keep the money tree watered...
Up 42 Down 13
Wilf Carter on Oct 3, 2020 at 8:34 am
Cut capital spending until we have the funds to do the work that is needed.
Debt will kill Yukon's economic future like it is doing in other places.
Yukoners all voted no to any debt or new taxes like a sales tax.
But our MP does not listen to Yukoners and if the Feds bring in another increase in carbon tax that will drive up costs to heat our houses by 50%
Carbon tax will hurt our mining sector greatly because we will not to be able to produce mineral at competitive price like south Africa and America.
We need a research and development center at the university to head up development of other opportunities for Yukon economics.
It was Dennis Fentie who put in pace a system to get the mining industry growing.
We had one bad experience with a mine north of Watson Lake that was sold to Chinese and it should have not opened at all.
The person sold that mine gave $50,000 to liberal party in Yukon.
His name is well known in mining circles.
We can't let a another Faro take place either which NDP opened and put no proper rugs in place and a mess was created.
Seniors have received nothing from this government and they worked all their live to build up the Yukon and we get nothing but talk from this government.
Up 44 Down 10
Al on Oct 2, 2020 at 10:10 pm
...and now all will know why this government applied for, and received, permission to raise the governments debt ceiling to 800 million. Now we just need to wait for the spending spree to get to that pinnacle.
Up 40 Down 10
Juniper Jackson on Oct 2, 2020 at 9:33 pm
"Total government revenue in 2020-21 is forecast to be $1.3 billion, which is a $10-million decrease from earlier estimates."
Is this supposed to be good news? Down 10 million? Jeez..what's the interest a month on this? It's one thing for a family with 2 jobs to be living from credit card to credit card, just paying the interest every month..at the end, they either sell their house and pay off debt, or move in with parent for a few months.. and quite another for a government to be doing that. 1.5 trillion is the federal forecast.. that's 3 billion a month in interest payments. The Bank of Canada is issuing bonds like crazy, and the Canadian peso doesn't go very far. Voters do know some day, those lenders are going to want their money.
People would vote in Satan to get a guaranteed monthly income so they don't have to work. I wish someone would post, absolutely anonymous, and say why they want someone else to take care of them? Highest unemployment rate in the G7...really? Yes..and there are over 500,000 TFWs..
What a mess.
Up 39 Down 3
Bud McGee on Oct 2, 2020 at 6:25 pm
O&M increases and deficits would have occurred regardless of COVID. Governments in the Yukon (regardless of the party) have been using federal infrastructure money to build more and more capital infrastructure, but the concomitant operation and maintenance costs are more of an after-thought (e.g. Dawson Wastewater Treatment Plant). The Yukon Government also has a weak and decentralized asset management program. It's expensive to run complicated facilities like water treatment plants in places like Old Crow. You have to throw buckets of cash at people to want to work there, so the answer is to often fly people in on rotation.
Up 40 Down 9
Crunch on Oct 2, 2020 at 5:59 pm
So they had to admit to a 32M dollar deficit. With the advantages of creative accounting everyone knows this number is much higher so you continue to never admitting the truth. And so goes the saga of trust and the relationship to the taxpayer. I hope the system doesn't think they are fooling anyone.
Up 37 Down 22
Jc on Oct 2, 2020 at 5:05 pm
Well, like the NDP, the Libs like to spend like drunken s++++rs. Now, we have to elect a Yukon Party Government to straighten things out. And nobody likes that because they have to bite the bullet. Now, I would like to know what the young millennial generation will say when they have to Pay off the one and a half trillion dollar debt and half a trillion dollar deficit Justin and his Liberals racked up for them. And that's only to date. Justin with the lovely black curly hair has 3 more years to go, Spend Libs spend - pay millennials pay.
Up 54 Down 8
Matthew on Oct 2, 2020 at 4:47 pm
I never took a penny. Will I get tax rebates or have to pay more? Why can't we all have got the "free money". I mean isn't that sexist, ageist, racist and all the other ists, haha.