Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Pictured above: Bruce McLennan, Don Inverarity and Steve Cardiff

Official ‘flabbergasted' by Liberals' reaction to board appointment

Official ‘flabbergasted' by Liberals' reaction to board appointment

By Jason Unrau on February 11, 2010

The naming of former deputy Finance minister Bruce McLennan as chair of the Yukon Utilities Board is a six-month interim appointment, according to Gordon Steele, principal secretary to Premier Dennis Fentie.

McLennan told the Star earlier this week he was informed his appointment had been at the behest of the all-party Standing Committee on Appointments to Major Government Boards and Committees. Later, he revised his statement.

"I was told the premier consulted with (Liberal Leader Arthur Mitchell and NDP house leader Steve Cardiff),” McLennan said. "I don't know if it went through the actual committee process, per se.”

Steele confirmed Mitchell and Cardiff were in Fentie's office on Jan. 28 to be informed of McLennan's appointment, that it was to be on an interim basis, and at a later date the standing committee could meet and recommend a permanent chair.

"It will go through that process, and in fairness to Mr. McLennan, he was probably not aware the standing committee had not met,” Steele said.

"There will be a normal process; Mr. McLennan may submit his résumé to it.”

However, the Liberals issued a press release Tuesday afternoon accusing Fentie of acting "unilaterally” to appoint McLennan.

"A new chair has already been appointed by the premier and yet the committee hasn't even discussed the vacancy,” Liberal committee member Don Inverarity is quoted as saying. "This is just another case of Premier Fentie dictating how things have to happen.”

The chair position has been vacant since December, Inverarity noted, allowing "plenty of time to involve the committee.”

The release failed to mention Mitchell's and Cardiff's meeting with Fentie, and that the trio appeared to be in agreement with the decision, according to Steele, who was also present at the Jan. 28 meeting.

"I'm flabbergasted by this (Liberal) reaction because the premier and I had a good long discussion with Mitchell and Cardiff, and there appeared to be consensus,” Steele said. "That was my view; we gave them a heads-up and there didn't seem to be any problem with it.

"Don Inverarity wasn't even at the meeting .... We thought this was a proper way to (fill the vacancy) because of the time. After Christmas, it's difficult to get people together,” added Steele.

Former chair Wendy Shanks quit the utilities board with more than a year remaining in her planned tenure.

That, combined with the lack of interest among remaining board directors to assume the role, the government was in a pinch to continue with Mayo B hydro expansion hearings, Steele said.

From Cardiff's perspective, he thinks Shanks' resignation caught the government off-guard, leaving it scrambling to fill her position, and lack of interest locally forced the search to venture Outside.

"They did what they had to do; unfortunately they didn't seem well prepared, I believe. They didn't have someone local that they could go to,” Cardiff told the Star Tuesday afternoon.

"It would've been prudent to have names in the bank of people they could approach, even if it was on an interim basis.

"It would've been better to have gone through the standing committee, but we ended up circumventing that. I understand there are time constraints,” Cardiff added.

McLennan worked for more than 20 years with the Yukon government, holding down key roles as deputy minister of Education, Health and Finance.

Following his retirement in 2007, McLennan moved to B.C., and now resides in Nanoose Bay.

Comments (6)

Up 0 Down 0

name withheld on Feb 19, 2010 at 9:33 am

Now that Mr. McLennan is coming back and is employed by the Yukon taxpayer, it would be fair to have him appear before the Public Accounts Committee and explain his actions vis a vis the ABCP issue.

It seems his successor had to bear the brunt of the scrutiny that accompanied Sheila Fraser's scathing report, which was so brusquely and conveniently dismissed by fentie and company. If I were Mr. Mclennan I would certainly feel obliged and greatly indebted to fentie for dismissing Ms. Fraser's report as he did; coming back to accept this new position would be the least he could do in kindness.

Up 0 Down 0

JonathanBaru on Feb 18, 2010 at 3:59 pm

Greetings all of you!

I felt that I should to say hello to you all. I am hoping that that we all will have great conversations together!

So Greetings!

-Jon

Up 0 Down 0

name with held on Feb 17, 2010 at 8:49 am

In response to Thomas Brewer, I agree with your obvious questions....all are quite relevant.

I'm not sure however, how you can assess Mr. Mclennan's abilities without remembering he was the DM on watch when the ABCP investments were made. It seems Sheila Fraser would disagree vehemently with the generosity of your analysis, especially given the fact that she said the law was broken (the Financial Administration Act), and that as the DM of Finance, Mr. Mclennan was responsible for guiding the government's behaviour in that regard, and ensuring the government was always advised appropriately where the FAA was concerned.

Further, working as a public servant across the terms of numerous government ruling parties is a qualification held by an extremely large number of senior and not so senior public servants. I don't know how this charactaristic would make one qualified for such an appointment.

The bottom line is that such an appointment, done as it has been, doesn't mean the appointee really merits same. Nobody knows all of a government's motivations in appointing any given person, and this government is no exception to that. What would be appropriate would be a competition. What would be more appropriate would be that the government clearly table its plans for Yukon Energy, and the mandate it hands to Mr. Mclennan. Without that sort of transparency, we just have more of the same sort of transactional smoke we've been inhaling for the last year or more. In this case however, the smoke may be drifting from the ABCP scandal to the Yukon Energy scandal.

Up 0 Down 0

Nile on Feb 11, 2010 at 10:36 am

Sounds like Hier Mitchel only only supplies his Liberal subordinates information on a need-to-know basis and aparently Inverarity is so usless he doesn't need to know.

Up 0 Down 0

Thomas Brewer on Feb 11, 2010 at 8:31 am

Where are the answers to these obvious questions:

What does the Chair of the YUB receive in remuneration?

Is having a non-resident of Yukon (albeit a former one) appointed to a position of this calibre a normal thing?

By appointing a resident of Vancouver Island, what additional costs are we anticipating on spending for travel/per diems etc that a local appointee would not receive?

Not that I have any doubts about Mr. McLennan's abilities - he was a very well respected public servant (across numerous government ruling parties - something that's quite rare).

Here's hoping that both YECs get a bit of a dressing down by the temporary Chair and we end up with more economical and stable power.

Up 0 Down 0

Arn Anderson on Feb 11, 2010 at 8:15 am

Once again Mr Fentie proves he is the master of the legislature. All the other parties whom cannot be named because nobody knows or remembers them are confused and 'flabbergastered'. This is why you clowns continue to lose because of your own confused state.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.