Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Dr. Sunit Ranade

No need to tighten public health rules: MD

Revised - As a new COVID-19 variant spreads through neighbouring B.C., and respiratory illnesses resurge this season following relaxed public health measures,

By Ethan Lycan-Lang on January 11, 2023

Revised - As a new COVID-19 variant spreads through neighbouring B.C., and respiratory illnesses resurge this season following relaxed public health measures, the Yukon’s chief medical officer says the territory has no need to tighten restrictions, but will stay the course in learning to live with the virus.

Speaking with the Star this week, Dr. Sunit Ranade said the Yukon’s health care system handled the social holiday season without any excessive added burden caused by the spread of respiratory illnesses like COVID-19 and influenza.

He said influenza has surged compared to other years during the pandemic, but numbers were about normal compared to previous years.

COVID cases, he said, have remained stable.

“We were a little bit worried that we would get overwhelmed in terms of treatment capacity by having too many people sick in general at once,” he said of the holiday season, when socialization and gatherings are more common. “That didn’t seem to happen.”

The Star asked the Department of Health and Social Services this week for the territory’s most recent COVID case and vaccination numbers, as well as the number of COVID-related deaths in 2022.

There has been no response to the inquiries.

The Yukon Hospital Corp. has some figures, though.

Spokesperson Isaac MacDonald said in an email today that Whitehorse General Hospital doesn’t have anyone admitted with COVID-19 nor any other respiratory illnesses, but is continuing to see higher levels of emergency department visits related to these viral illnesses.

He said staffing levels haven’t recently been affected by these viruses either.

Dr. Ranade said in December that this flu season, which was just beginning, could see a lot of respiratory illnesses spreading this year as masks and other public health guidelines eased. Recently, there’s been 
 another concern.

Asked about the new variant of COVID-19, nicknamed the “Kraken” variant, Ranade said the territory is acting as if it had already arrived in the Yukon.

The contagious variant has been making the rounds in British Columbia this month, with 12 cases reported last week.

Ranade said though the variant is more contagious, there’s no strong evidence that people with updated vaccinations are being severely impacted, so he’s cautious but not exceedingly concerned about it right now.

“The general trend, as we see more and more strains of COVID, just as we see many, many different strains of flu, is that they’re typically more and more transmissible, but less and less severe,” he said.

Ranade also said he dislikes the moniker the XBB.1.5 variant has been given: “Kraken”. 

“(It) predisposes you to a lot of fear about something that we don’t have the basis for having that (much) fear yet,” he said.

Though, as noted, Health and Social Services has been unable to provide recent numbers, Ranade said vaccination rates are reassuring as the new variant spreads south of the territory.

He said booster dose uptake has been stagnating, but people in “higher-risk categories”, be it older Yukoners or the immunocompromised, are keeping up with their vaccinations.

He said that’s reassuring, and encouraged Yukoners to treat the vaccine like a flu shot.

“There will continue to be variants,” he said. “Make sure that you stay boosted when you’re eligible.”

Ranade said keeping up with vaccinations will allow the territory to move on from the pandemic.

He still encourages people to wear masks if they feel uncomfortable or sick when out in public, and to stay home if they can when they have COVID symptoms.

However, he sees no reason to reintroduce pandemic-level restrictions as things are now.

“A lot of that is about judging your own kind of comfort level, right, as opposed to the actual risk level necessarily,” he said.

“And that’s totally fine. But what I would say is, the biggest challenge here is that unless you’re willing to completely cut yourself off from your social life, at a certain point, you will be exposed to respiratory diseases.”

In November, the Yukon shifted its pandemic response to begin treating COVID-19 like any other respiratory illness.

The change, the government said in a press release at the time, was the result of new variants with less severe outcomes, the availability of safe and effective vaccines, high vaccination rates and the availability of treatments that lessen the severity of COVID-19.

British Columbia, where the new COVID-19 variant is already present, currently has no plans to reintroduce pandemic-related public health measures.

Ranade said hospitals weren’t overwhelmed by respiratory virus cases over the holidays, and he’s not yet concerned of any imminent capacity issues.

However, with a lack of family doctors in the territory, many Yukoners use emergency departments for non-urgent care, meaning an uptick in illnesses could place added stress on hospitals.

The Department of Health and Social Services responded after publication with figures the Star asked for earlier this week. They are listed below:

Nineteen Yukoners died of COVID-19 in 2022. Nine of those deaths involved people aged 40-69, five were aged 70-79 and the other five were 80 and older. Five Yukoners were medevaced out of the territory with the virus.

As for vaccinations, 37,185 Yukoners have been vaccinated and close to the same number, 35,756, have received at least one booster. After that, it starts to drop – 21,803 Yukoners have three doses, 10,270 have four and 2,276 have five.

Yukoners aged 70 and older, a part of the population especially vulnerable to the virus, are the highest vaccinated, the department said: 99 per cent are vaccinated and 64 per cent have had at least one booster shot.

Children 4 and younger are the lowest vaccinated demographic: only seven per cent have received a shot. Just less than half of children aged 5 to 11 have had their first dose.

The department also said 37 Yukoners have been admitted to the hospital with influenza since Aug. 28.

Comments (30)

Up 4 Down 7

Roy on Jan 17, 2023 at 4:28 pm

@ Joe :"the only thing that got people vaccinated was the federal mandate that you could only fly if you had vaccine status. Had nothing to do with provincial leaders or any thing else. We live in Canada, flying is essential and those liberal dictators mandated vaccines by eliminating the ability to fly. Everything else is smoke and mirrors."

Nice try but no. About 40% of Canadians and Americans fly per year.
At least 80% of North Americans have received the covid vaccine.

In Alberta it's over 80% - but yet only 40% of Albertans fly regularly. Weird how wrong you are huh?
Our *opinion* of why people choose to be vaccinated isn't supported by anything other than the smoke and mirrors inside your skull.
People chose to be vaccinated because they examined the risks versus the benefits and made their own decision.

You were and still are 100% free to not be vaccinated. You are free to accept the consequences of your own choices - this is nothing new - your parents should have taught you this reality.

You are free to drink all the alcohol you want. You are not free to drink and drive. You are free to shout "FIRE!" inside your home. You are not free to shout it in public in a packed theatre. This shouldn't blow your mind.
Need any more lessons today?

Up 9 Down 2

Joe on Jan 17, 2023 at 2:52 pm

@ Roy..the only thing that got people vaccinated was the federal mandate that you could only fly if you had vaccine status. Had nothing to do with provincial leaders or any thing else. We live in Canada, flying is essential and those liberal dictators mandated vaccines by eliminating the ability to fly. Everything else is smoke and mirrors.

Up 9 Down 3

DL on Jan 17, 2023 at 12:31 pm

Why is this 'doctor' continually failing to mention the increasing rates of myocarditis, blood clots, neurological disorders and deaths following the uptake of the covid injections, i.e. since 2021. Please show us the DATA on excess deaths in Canada, and be transparent about the fact that it coincides with the distribution of the covid shots. That's what public health is supposed to be about.

Up 4 Down 10

Roy on Jan 16, 2023 at 10:07 pm

@ Jeff B

Thanks for supporting the efforts of Yukoners at minimizing the effects of covid! Because the vast majority of us got vaccinated and wore masks and kept up other measures like social distancing we managed to keep the death totals at such low levels! Success!

Imagine if we just followed the wishes of the fringe youtube experts instead - we woulda had so many more deaths!

Imagine if we spent a bunch of money buying big pharma medicines like ivermectin that were never ever shown to work and were never approved despite the lies some people were determined to spread - we'd be poorer AND we'd have more deaths.

Just wanted to thank you for celebrating the success. It wasn't easy but the majority of adults used adult behavior - and in turn we managed to keep it as safe as possible even for the selfish people who felt their "freedom" was more important.

You don't have the freedom to yell "Fire!" in a theatre - but some people are under the delusion that they have the freedom in our society to say and do whatever they choose. It's not true - but we'll still do our part to keep them safe despite their delusions.

So once more thanks for your post - great to see those numbers that are a testament to the vaccines and measures. Cheers!

Up 3 Down 7

Roy on Jan 16, 2023 at 9:58 pm

@ groucho: "I was in fact giving the government credit for listening and responding to these criticisms and altered their approach as a result."

They altered their approach because the pandemic changed as predicted - it had nothing to do with the loud fringe. Even the idiot Trump stated in spring 2020 "someday soon this will go away" (he was wrong about the soon part) - he wasn't talking about protestors making it go away - he was referencing what his experts were telling him about how pandemics behave. If that dumb dumb can get it why can't you?

"You appear to believe that the public protest has been discounted and had nothing to do with these changes and the government's position and processes remain the status quo."

I and the majority of Canadians discount the protests - another fact that doesn't care about how you feel.
"Do you believe the government ignores the wishes of the electorate and a display of public outrage did not alter their methods?"
Governments also ignore the wishes of people who think the world is flat - that shouldn't come as news to you. They also ignored the wishes of people who really wanted hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin to work on covid (they didn't). The government doesn't do the bidding of 5% of people just because you're being loud.

This display of public outrage you mentioned was small considering on day 2 of the protest in Ottawa there were only 3,000 people still there and only 250 protestors still participating by day 3. That's tiny! No one is gonna change policy just because 250 people having nothing better to do than honk their horns and wave confederate flags.

"The PM has stepped away from being the primary spokesman for this"

Clearly you weren't paying attention - but the primary spokespeople throughout the whole pandemic were the Chief Officers of Health (except for Alberta and Ontario where is was more the premiers - who ironically are both Conservative leaders instilling those mask mandates, lockdowns, and vaccine mandates)

But yeah - as Jeff B says "God Bless those peaceful protestors" - all 250 of them that stuck it out LOL.

Up 13 Down 11

Jeff Bikaboom on Jan 16, 2023 at 3:01 pm

"Nineteen Yukoners died of COVID-19 in 2022"
14 or so died on 2021, and 1 died in 2020. Like the rest of Canada, we just had the worst covid year yet. Starting early 2021 covid deaths increased, just like all cause mortality which is still around 30 percent higher than pre-pandemic. Sad news, but at least we have our God given freedoms. Bless those brave truckers and the peaceful protesters.

Up 15 Down 4

Groucho d'North on Jan 16, 2023 at 8:55 am

@Roy
It would appear that my comments triggered your passionate reply, but you went off in other directions in your rant in an attempt to be glib.
My original comment was that our federal government has changed their approach to informing Canadians about how to deal with COVID and that it was perhaps inspired by the public reaction to the over-reaching mandates imposed on us and their negative impacts felt by some workers.
I was in fact giving the government credit for listening and responding to these criticisms and altered their approach as a result. You appear to believe that the public protest has been discounted and had nothing to do with these changes and the government's position and processes remain the status quo. Do you believe the government ignores the wishes of the electorate and a display of public outrage did not alter their methods?
The PM has stepped away from being the primary spokesman for this, I suggest it is because he became the primary focal point for public anger and image is everything to somebody who may want to be re-elected.

Up 7 Down 20

Roy on Jan 14, 2023 at 5:19 pm

@ Groucho

The vast majority of provinces and territories were lead by Conservative leaders -FACT.
Every province and territory runs it's out health care system - which is why each of them has a chief medical officer of health - so in this case each Conservative lead province had its own chosen CMOH - FACT

Conservative provinces had vaccine mandates and their borders locked down and masking instituted and schools shut down etc - FACT
All your favorite political leaders are vaccinated - FACT

Are these Conservative premiers (who were in control of the vast majority of Canada) so spineless that they couldn't make softer rules and not have mandates? Why were the provinces led by Conservative leaders enacting some of the strictest rules? They must be wimps and under the thumb of Justin right? Wow so strong and free and powerful. Better vote for those pushovers again huh?

Why do you ignore the above facts and only talk about the Federal Liberals?
Is it because to admit that more Conservative leaders put in mandates and lockdowns than Liberal ones would in turn destroy your image of the Lib boogeyman? Sorry if your worldview is now wrecked!

If you want to know why the mandates and lockdowns are over it has nothing to do with the fringe thousands (out of multi-millions of Canadians) that supported a bunch of selfish morons flying confederate flags in the streets of Ottawa and are now too dumb and disorganized to pull off another rally - it's because as predicted the pandemic is winding down and all leaders (Conservative and Liberal) have looked at the data and seen that - again as predicted - these measures that were necessary (as per the Conservative premiers) are now no longer needed.

Horn honking and confederate flags changed nothing but drained money from fools and embarrassed the fringe supporters. And put some losers in jail for wanting to kill the police that the fringe only supports when it suits you.

Try aloe vera for your burns.

Up 22 Down 6

Groucho d'North on Jan 13, 2023 at 5:02 pm

@Roy
I enjoy your posts. It provides insight into the thinking process Liberals employ in their governing. Consider: thousands of citizens took time from their lives to let the Libs know how they felt about the draconian measures enforced on the Canadian public, they raised millions of dollars for supporting the convoy and stood along the highways and cheered in support as the trucks rolled past. Pretty clear positioning by the great unwashed doncha think? What caused the Libs to change their methods from enforced mandates to helpful suggestions? Trudeau as we know is stubborn and is loath to admit he was wrong about anything. What caused him to change his position? Who whispered in his ear? Was it Mr. Butts or perhaps the Emergency Act inquiry? Or maybe the various polling firms who ask about failing and increasing party popularity about this and that?
I anticipate another change in communications direction come February when the Emergency Act inquiry report is released to the public. Expect back-peddling and attempts to justify why the government choose to ignore the electorate and march on with their own oppresive agenda.

Up 6 Down 23

Roy on Jan 13, 2023 at 4:25 pm

@ T "I can remove my tin foil hat. Can you remove your spike proteins?"
Yeah of course I can. My immune system already removed them.

If you get infected by covid 19 you get covid spike proteins in your bloodstream. Sounds like you didn't know that.
If you get a covid vaccination (which over 90% of people have) you get covid spike proteins in your bloodstream.
At this point in time it's probably close to 100% of Canadians have had covid spike proteins in their body - either from vaccination and/or from covid exposure.

If you're worried about my spike proteins you therefore should also be worried about your own - because they are the same. That's how vaccines work.
Don't believe me? Have a look at the list of vaccines you got as a kid. Multiple "jabs" of the same vaccine over years in order to build up protection. If you're worried about a few covid shots you should contact your parents and ask them why you likely got 20+ vaccinations as a kid.

Each check mark is a vaccine shot:
https://hnhu.org/wp-content/uploads/schedule-vaccine.jpg

Funny I don't see jacked up Dodge Rams driven by the Timbit Taliban honking their horns about this. There - now I've given you guys something to do on the weekends now that covid is over. You're welcome!

Up 15 Down 4

CJ2 on Jan 13, 2023 at 1:53 pm

Backing off from tightening the rules is more about having kept them in place too long, without being able to point to meaningful results. Here we are, three years later, with tales of overtaxed health facilities. Not to mention all the other fallout that the medical community was so dismissive of, while scolding politicians.

They can't impose 2020 measures if they're uneasy about how much compliance they'd get. Apart from the fact that the actual threat is not very clear, since it seems to come down to the health services they mismanaged, while saying that's what we were protecting. The rationale that was so compelling in 2020 has become white noise. No need for the fringe to take credit.

Up 14 Down 8

T on Jan 13, 2023 at 9:37 am

@Roy

I can remove my tin foil hat. Can you remove your spike proteins?

Up 9 Down 26

Roy on Jan 12, 2023 at 6:59 pm

“It appears that the trucker protest convoy has had a measureable influence in how our governments are advising the public to deal with the virus.”

Thanks for the laugh! We all needed that. The only thing the clownvoy accomplished was annoying citizens of Ottawa, costing taxpayers millions (if you include the Windsor and Alberta gong shows), and embarrassing themselves.

Oh and a few went to jail for stockpiling firearms to kill cops.

They had zero measurable effect on actual public health policy and communications.
But you keep telling yourself that if you need to - special snowflakes need to feel like they’ve accomplished something special. We’ll get all the horn honkers participation medals.

Up 16 Down 1

North_of_60 on Jan 12, 2023 at 4:22 pm

If a person is taking 3 or 4 vitD tabs per day, then they are far less likely to get sick with any form of cold or flu.
Evidence that Vitamin D Supplementation Could Reduce Risk of Influenza and COVID-19 Infections and Deaths
https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/12/4/988/htm

Up 18 Down 9

Juniper Jackson on Jan 12, 2023 at 4:02 pm

Ho Hum... Yawn. I had the &&&**(d granddaddy of colds this winter,. I though, OMG, i have a nother variant of Covid, and I'm gonna die. Got heat? yup, got the ice gag, yup, got the barf bag, jup, got the gingiale with a straw? yup..I wanted to go to the store, but there was my Mom in the back of my mind, don't be so stupid get back in that bed. I had covid earlier on, and this rack and cough cold, had nothing on that cold. I rolled through my suggestions to see if i've changed my mind about anything with all the new data out... Nope. Same old crap. My "same old crap" recommendations for covid and covid wannabes:.

Your're sick (hangover? carry on) Covidf flu, cough, everything else. Get your aspirin, cough drops, nasal sprays right by your bedside with your remote and 3 or 4 movies you really wanted to see.. hire a baby sitter or takre the kids to care, or school. Stay home. From there. Wear the stupid mask if you have to go out, it really does prevent your spit from landing on his sandwich.

As I understand it, you can only catch the title C0vid 19. 1 time. Yes, your body builds up an immunity. BUT, Always gotta stick a butt in there, Just like a cough, flu, a couple hundred variants wander in to mkle like interesting for you. You will only have a immuity build up to one at a time.

I wish everyone to be safe, and be healthy. BUT, do it your way. Think outside the box. The box is the government. A Final reminder? the governmnt is NEVER your friend.

Up 32 Down 8

Anonymous on Jan 12, 2023 at 11:20 am

Keep getting boosted with the same vaccine that was designed for the delta variant. Wear a mask in stores, but not restaurants. Safe six, two weeks. Climate change causes heart attacks. More news at 11.

Up 26 Down 12

Groucho d'North on Jan 12, 2023 at 8:45 am

It appears that the trucker protest convoy has had a measureable influence in how our governments are advising the public to deal with the virus. You only hear the word "mandate" from the frightened zealots who demand government take a more assertive role in the prevention of COVID.
Government communication techniques are now more subtle and softer and they must be chomping at the bit to become more dictitorial given that ICUs across the nation are filling up with patients presenting with respiratory complaints of various kinds. How soon before we once again experience the "It's for your own good" doctorine?

Up 18 Down 7

Khoudung Flunghi on Jan 12, 2023 at 7:31 am

"So now our fearless leaders have the expense to the tax base of the venom-injured survivors in addition to the normal costs of caring for an ever more aged population! The pensions we don’t have to pay because the pensioners that have weirdly died somehow, do help the national balance sheet but if you injure more people than you kill, you’ve really increased the costs of running the country, and nullified the gains of the whole operation, haven’t you?"

skulltripper dot com

Up 10 Down 6

CJ2 on Jan 12, 2023 at 12:10 am

Why are doctors being so humourless about "Kraken"? It's hilarious. If they don't like people audaciously choosing their own names for variants, why didn't they go back to naming them after the Greek alphabet?

Up 31 Down 2

Gringo on Jan 11, 2023 at 6:12 pm

Fend for yourself as you see fit…that said cannot figure out people driving around alone in a vehicle with a mask on.

Up 56 Down 26

Matthew on Jan 11, 2023 at 3:35 pm

This surely has to be a joke isn't it? People are'nt scared of "Varient XB12" or whatever silly numbers and letter they decide. They use a mythical sea creature called "Kraken" to sacre the public into another shot. What is fully vaxed anyways right now? 4 shots? Lol! I can't keep up.

Up 30 Down 39

Roy on Jan 11, 2023 at 3:33 pm

Whenever someone dies from Covid:

"Hey! How do we know it was covid? I bet it was all other medical conditions they had. You can't say it was covid! You just don't know! That lung failure coulda been from all kinds of things"

Whenever anyone dies of not covid:

"A-ha! What could possibly have cause this you ask? Something they received in the last couple years? That's right. It has to be the vaccine. Forget anything else. The covid vaccine caused it. Nobody ever died of anything before the jab came along. Pro athletes dying left right and center - no I can't name a single one - but it's true. The NFL player that collapsed? Vaccine. Slam dunk. Don't need to know anything else about their health to make this firm statement. It's so clear to me as a non expert - even from a distance. I saw a youtube on it."

And then again someone dies of covid:

"Hey how can doctors be sure it was covid? I bet it was something else. We just don't know do we."

You see the contradiction right? Right?

Up 38 Down 18

JC on Jan 11, 2023 at 3:20 pm

Of course he does'nt. The liberals really found their guy. What a clown.

Up 25 Down 19

Toe on Jan 11, 2023 at 3:18 pm

Ask questions if you're a person that uses their Brain and don't be a Brainless sheepeople.

Up 30 Down 11

KC on Jan 11, 2023 at 2:54 pm

What a weird headline. The idea of "tighten[ing] public health measures" is a such a fringe position that almost no one outside of certain Twitter ecosystems advances.

Up 30 Down 36

Himbo on Jan 11, 2023 at 2:52 pm

Great choice not locking down things again, but if it does come to that, how about doing it for the people who would actually be seriously affectied by Covid? Lock down for 60+, lock down for People with pre existing medial conditions, not for the healthy people who will cough once and there back to normal…

Up 35 Down 12

John on Jan 11, 2023 at 2:45 pm

Why do you keep hammering away at this stuff? Must be a slow news week.

Up 18 Down 61

Politico on Jan 11, 2023 at 2:21 pm

Let's celebrate. The anti vaxxers have won and science is dead! Maybe now is time to move science books to the fiction shelves and get the christian creation books into the schools! Christian prayers every morning.

Up 44 Down 23

Richard Smith on Jan 11, 2023 at 2:19 pm

This article avoids the glaring question we all have - what are the stats of those who have updated covid vaccines and boosters compared to those who are not vaccinated?
The fact that Dr. Ranade continues to avoid this stat question is clear proof it makes no differrnce at all which many studies confirm.

Up 42 Down 18

Crunch on Jan 11, 2023 at 2:18 pm

No lockdowns folks. The election is too close. The swab is smeared with politics.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.