Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Photo Submitted

STATING THEIR CONCERNS – Yukoners are seen with messages about the state of mid-wifery services they brought to the Yukon Government Main Administration Building

NDP observes a year without midwives

Good Friday marked the one-year anniversary of the Yukon government introducing the Midwifery Regulation into the territory.

By Tim Giilck on April 18, 2022

Good Friday marked the one-year anniversary of the Yukon government introducing the Midwifery Regulation into the territory.

The NDP marked the occasion – which they said isn’t a memorable one – last Thursday in the legislature.

“(Good Friday) will mark the one-year anniversary of the Midwifery Regulation coming into effect in the Yukon,” the party added in a news release. “This means it has been a year since Yukon midwives were last able to practise in the territory.”

According to the NDP, the new regulations require midwives to be registered for at least one year in another Canadian jurisdiction in order to practise in the Yukon. This prevented local midwives from practising here the day the regulations came into force.

That has forced Yukon midwives to take jobs elsewhere. The NDP said one has moved to Fort Smith, N.W.T., while another is practising in Vancouver while her family remains in the territory.

“It was clear from the start that it would take at least one year for Yukon midwives to fulfill the new requirements,” said NDP Leader Kate White.

“Yet, the government put new regulations in place with no real interim solution. This government is failing expectant parents.”

The posted salary for midwives is also far below salaries in neighbouring jurisdictions, White noted.

“The government is expecting midwives to practise outside of the territory for a year, come back to the Yukon, and accept a lower salary. It shouldn’t take a year to realize this is an issue,” said White.

She said much the same thing to Tracy-Anne McPhee, the minister of Health and Social Services, during question period last Thursday.

McPhee tried to shift the blame away from the government, saying there is a national and international shortage of medical professionals of all stripes.

She also said the government is negotiating the salary matter with the Yukon Employees’ Union, which objected to the idea of placing a rider on midwives’ salaries, rather than simply changing their salary category.

While talking to reporters, White said McPhee didn’t have her facts correct on that issue.

She said she had spoken to Steve Geick, the president of the YEU, and said the real issue over the rider was that the excess salary beyond what was in the collective agreement wasn’t pensionable income.

“That’s what the union is objecting to,” White said.

She told reporters that “Yukon communities have also been waiting to have birthing options closer to home, Whitehorse currently being the only place in the territory to give birth.

“We all recall the Yukon Party’s failure to provide birthing options in the Dawson City and the Watson Lake Community Hospitals,” the NDP leader added.

“The Liberals have had years to fix it – but here we are. No midwives anywhere in the territory, and no birth options in communities.

“It’s unacceptable to see families having unattended births at home because they feel they have no other choices,” said White.

Brad Cathers of the Yukon Party agreed with White on the issue.

“The minister is trying to blame anyone other than herself and her colleagues for the fact that when they put in place the regulations, they didn’t have a plan to actually transition into a model that would actually allow midwife services to transition to a regulated model,” Cathers said.

“They rushed it as a pre-election announcement and were more focused on the photo-op than the results at that time,” he added.

“They were prepared to tolerate a gap on midwifery services of some months, but in fact it has now been a year and that is going to continue.”

“Effectively, Cathers said, “all they did was ban unlicensed midwives from practising for a one-year period, creating a gap in services.”

Cathers and White said they know Yukoners who have chosen to have home births without midwives in the last year.

“They weren’t happy with the situation,” Cathers said.

“There have been some serious problems. I know one mother in particular who has had previous children with the help of midwife services, and was not happy she was deprived of the choice due to the Liberals shutting down the service.”

Comments (19)

Up 0 Down 0

A+ on Apr 22, 2022 at 4:24 pm

@mathew

‘Pregnancy Ward’?
Wow, you seem, as alway highly educated on this topic. Buahahahaha

Up 5 Down 1

Fathers have Rights on Apr 22, 2022 at 2:00 pm

Joseph,
A husband may not have the final say in delivery methods, but his input should still be valued and considered if the decision being made impacts the baby. The baby belongs to the father as much as it belongs to the mother.

Up 7 Down 3

Observer on Apr 22, 2022 at 12:10 pm

I usually agree with what the NDP want to do for the common folk, not sure I would ever vote for them in the one side or other political environment we presently find ourselves in.
With that said, Yukoners are quite lucky with the medical systems that we have in place now, it is not the time for "nice to haves".
Also, man when a baby is coming, things happen fast, I wouldn't want to risk mother and baby outside of a hospital.

Up 2 Down 8

Joseph on Apr 21, 2022 at 10:08 pm

@ Mitch Holder
I must point out that this statement is pretty arrogant "...a father has a say in the means of delivery of their child." Actually you don't have the final choice, as was pointed out. That rests, as it should, with the mother to be. She has the final say as to whether it is mid-wife or Doctor. It is what is comfortable for her. You may have an opinion but that is all you have.

We all know, and must admit, there are way too many ghost fathers. Yes, useless is an excellent description for these people. It is why many women have a jaded view on men in general. Furthermore, in my many years on this planet I have seen a lot of slovenly husbands or spouses that treat their ladies like door mats. Some still think it is their right. In fact there are societies where women are mere objects. It is embarrassing to say the least to the men that do right. While you may object, I suggest you take a step back and have a look around you some. You will find a good number right here in the Yukon. It is nothing to be proud of. So the next time we hear women sound off it is better to listen, absorb and pay attention to what is really the root of what is being said. Take it from a guy that has been happily married for 54 years, because I practice what I preach.

Up 12 Down 1

Honest Questions on Apr 21, 2022 at 4:21 pm

Bruce and Chuck, thank your for your helpful replies.

Jane and Wendy, I agree that people shouldn't be obnoxious and rude. I disagree that men need to be silent on the topic. Should childless women be silent on the topic as well? They haven't had children. Like it or not, there are plenty of men who have significant experience in the field, and who are knowledgeable about the birthing process. I would argue that there are many women that would agree with me on this.

Up 12 Down 2

Mitch Holder on Apr 21, 2022 at 2:07 pm

@Jane - Curious ma'am, which woman are you referring to? I am afraid I must disagree, a father has a say in the means of delivery of their child. You might disagree, but I challenge you to explain why your disagreement is of consequence, as in, why do you feel your opinion will benefit a parental partnership as opposed to mine? Now, as I often must do when expressing opinion, let us clarify that I know and fully support several midwives.
Where we live, the remote geography, it is a blessing. What I contend with is the view you expressed about useless men and so forth; How does that advance the equality and cooperation of genders in the raising of a child? If you are a mother, I would ask you to consider that badmouthing men will not be experienced by your children as a benefit and you will not be seen as a benefactor for such. What you will get is a runaway teen or a real hard time. Am I a parent? No. But I grew up in that household and it took years to reverse the damage. Please consider that your opinion might be damaging everyone elses' attempt to be civil to one another. If you do this, I will try to do the same. I am admittedly long overdue.

Up 7 Down 7

Orwell’s foreshadow was really an explication of the naturalistic devolution under Liberalism's press… on Apr 21, 2022 at 11:03 am

Just to note the absurdity of this supposed controversy - Monty Python's The life of Brian - I want to be a woman.

Maybe men cannot have babies but we can agree with the notion that they can, absent of ability, have the right to have babies… Yes… That, virtually, makes good Liberal sense - This is simply the process by which they take over the means of communication and enforce the ideals of form over content as the defacto governing principle - Nothing makes sense unless they say it does! That is true Orwellian power… Submit!

Link:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sFBOQzSk14c

Up 16 Down 2

origin of the term 'midwife' on Apr 20, 2022 at 3:48 pm

Nathan Living, you asked a question that made me curious. 'Mid' is the Old English term for 'with' (doesn't mean 'middle'). And @Honest Question, a search for 'hospital births or midwife deliveries' turns up all sorts of interesting points. But one of the main ones, for me at least, is to not treat pregnancy as an illness that has to be treated by a doctor. Midwives can and should perform a valuable service, monitoring pregnancies and delivering babies. @Jane, I do think men get to comment here, especially as dads who are involved in the pregnancy and birth - unlike in my day, when they weren't even allowed in a delivery room.

Up 9 Down 10

Wendy on Apr 20, 2022 at 1:24 pm

This is the first time I have ever posted in the Star. Usually I just lurk.

Having read some of the comments I just can not hold my tongue. I agree with Jane. Comments about Val's note are disrespectful to Val and to women as a whole. Yes, Val may have come across hard - but you know, sometimes people just seethe until they explode. She is entitled to her opinion. I don't think you have to agree, or even like we she has to say. She does not need some of the commentators, like Red and Bruce, being rude and obnoxious. All you do is get under the skin of many women who see this as another example of male dominance - or an attempt to put women down. I can never understand why men just don't keep silent. They do not speak for me, nor will they ever. Issues that affect women belong with women. If we invite you into the discussion, always remember you were invited. It does not mean you get to make the final decision or have a vote. That is in part what Val was saying I believe. Women are no longer the slaves of the dark ages.

Up 7 Down 17

Jane on Apr 19, 2022 at 10:28 pm

I find it rather interesting that the only woman to voice an opinion was denigrated by a bunch of men. I never knew men had babies. Seems these men have a lot to say about something that they have never experienced nor ever will. I suggest you just zip it and leave this topic to women. Of course if you think you know better about birthing, from first hand experience, then go for it. Of course these are likely men who want to see women as stay at home mothers while they go out beer guzzling. So much for women's rights...

Up 5 Down 13

Nathan Living on Apr 19, 2022 at 7:12 pm

Midwife, can't they come up with a better term?

I keep thing if there is a forwife and aftwife which makes my head spin a little.

Up 14 Down 6

Chuck Farley on Apr 19, 2022 at 3:57 pm

Honest Question - Baby delivery medical procedures in Canada

Average cost with no insurance
Prenatal ultrasound C$300 - C$500
Birth and delivery in the hospital C$5,000- C$8,000
Cesarean section in the hospital C$10,000 - C$12,000
Home birth and delivery with midwife C$2,500

Up 23 Down 4

Bruce on Apr 19, 2022 at 11:50 am

@Honest Questions
As the Yukon is very far behind the rest of the country and the world as it pertains to the integration of midwifery into the medical system, questions like this are expected and incredibly relevant. The first thing to understand is, the choice isn’t between having a “midwife and birthing in the hospital” Midwives attend births in a variety of setting's. As midwives have hospital privileges, approximately 70% of the births they attend are in the hospital, the rest happen in peoples homes, home like settings, or birth centres. The benefit of having a midwife for your care is that a midwife specializes in normal pregnancies while recognizing risk factors and the need to intervene and consult with specialists as required. The model of midwifery puts the birthing woman in the drivers seat and provides her and her partner with all the information in order to make decisions that best suit their individual needs and beliefs. As midwives develop trusting relationships with their clients, through longer prenatal visits and 24/7 call, midwives help to reduce risks for mothers and babies by recognizing issues earlier, rather than creating risk for these clients, which is a common misconception.

Up 18 Down 3

Honest Questions on Apr 19, 2022 at 10:32 am

Honest question here,

What are the benefits to using a midwife, as opposed to using the hospital?

Up 17 Down 20

iBrian on Apr 19, 2022 at 6:30 am

If the NDP are campaigning for something, I don’t pay attention anymore. Lost all respect for the party. I never had any for the Liberals to begin with especially with Blackface leading.
Midwives are important, but with the NDP on your side, it’s hard to get people to care.

Up 22 Down 11

Matthew on Apr 18, 2022 at 9:12 pm

Sad really. Even though staff are fantastic at the hospital in pregnancy ward there should 100% have option of having comfortable birth at home. Pathetic since we have a doctor as MP. Not to mention, no walk in clinic either..

Up 15 Down 14

Bruce on Apr 18, 2022 at 6:25 pm

If Val was right, do you think midwives would be a regulated health care profession in Canada? Does Val understand that registered midwives offer high quality maternity care both in the community and the hospital setting? Does Val understand that home births have been proven in peer reviewed studies to be as safe as hospital births but have lower rates of interventions? Val, do you understand that midwives enjoy respectful and collegial relationships with other members of the obstetrical care team? Again, please educate yourself ..because the only one living in the dark ages..is YOU Val.

Up 28 Down 32

Red on Apr 18, 2022 at 4:27 pm

Val, please become educated on a topic before making such ignorant statements. You know nothing of what you speak of.

Up 37 Down 38

Val on Apr 18, 2022 at 3:29 pm

Blah, blah, blah - I want, I want, I want. Go to the hospital. Never mind midwives. We don't live in the dark ages anymore.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.