MLA's decision ‘horrible,' ex-colleague says
The MLA for Vuntut Gwitchin has crossed the floor of the legislative assembly, joining the governing Yukon Party after having left the Liberals to sit independently last summer.
By Ainslie Cruickshank on July 8, 2013
The MLA for Vuntut Gwitchin has crossed the floor of the legislative assembly, joining the governing Yukon Party after having left the Liberals to sit independently last summer.
"It's an exciting time for me, and it's no secret that I've always tried to do what's best for my constituents,” Darius Elias told reporters late this morning.
"While I believe that I have been able to accomplish much with the limited resources afforded me as an independent member, it is clear to me that working within the government will provide me with the resources and opportunity to do much more.”
The move gives the Yukon Party 12 seats. The NDP has six and the Liberal party one.
Liz Hanson, the leader of the NDP official Opposition, raised concerns that Elias' constituents were not consulted on the shift.
"I'm not sure that the people of Old Crow would be happy to know that they have yet another Yukon Party member, a party that has very seriously disrespected First Nations since 2002 when they were elected, most recently with the Peel and their concerted attempts to overturn what was a very clear land use planning process,” she said following the announcement.
"Now, this tired old government's got another member; did the people of Old Crow have a choice in that?
"I don't think so. I think the people of Old Crow should have a choice.”
The NDP's policy would require a byelection before allowing an MLA to join its caucus, she noted.
Elias defended the decision to make the move without holding a byelection, arguing that "political metamorphosis” happens all the time in the territory.
As well, everyone knows the majority of voters in his riding vote for the individual rather than the party, he added.
"I received a very strong mandate the last election (in 2011). I had full, steadfast support when I moved to be an independent member and I'm going to have the support with this political move as well,” he said.
He is in constant communication with his community, he added.
While Sandy Silver, the interim leader of the Liberal party, said he thinks Elias' decision is the wrong one, he doesn't believe a by-election is necessary.
"I think this is a horrible decision, and I can't see how he's going to walk back into his community with his head up after you take a look at how he presented himself as being a champion for a specific party and also a specific position on that political spectrum,” Silver told the Star.
"That's his to eat from here on in. But you know, people vote for parties, but they also vote for people, and more so in the North, I find.
"You live and die by your decisions in that. He was voted in for a mandate of five years, let him do what he thinks is right in those five years,” he said.
Both Hanson and Silver also voiced significant concern that Elias' move stacks the membership of the select committee on hydraulic fracturing in the government's favour. Four of six members now sitting on the government side.
Silver said both he and Jim Tredger, the NDP committee member, planned to raise the issue at a committee meeting scheduled for this afternoon.
"There's no way that (the Yukon Party) can have a majority on this committee after looking at Hansard and all the times that (they) defended the committee and the way that the vote was going to role out, saying that it was not a majority.
"But now it is, so that has to get dealt with,” Silver said.
Hanson commented that the public may also have a few comments if the committee moves forward with a government majority.
During this morning's announcement, Premier Darrell Pasloski welcomed Elias' experience as an MLA to his caucus.
"I am very pleased that the member for Vuntut Gwitchin will be sitting at this table, at the government table, as we move forward with the challenges that we face ahead, and I am confident that his perspectives will assist us in our efforts to continue to provide the kind of governance that Yukoners have asked for and that they deserve,” he said.
"For the past several months, it's really become very clear that the independent member for Vuntut Gwitchin and the governing caucus really do share very similar perspectives on a number of very important issues.
"The government has benefited from the views and the experiences and certainly the passion that Mr. Elias brings, and this can only benefit the Yukon Party caucus as we move forward.”
Elias agreed that he does indeed share many of the same views as his new colleagues.
However, he added that they will differ, and where they do, he will bring new perspectives for consideration.
Differences already exist, concerning the Peel watershed, for instance.
Elias has previously criticized the government's approach to the land use planning process, but today seemed only mildly concerned that it would be an issue moving forward.
"I've spoken with the premier on this very recently and we've come to the agreement that I'm going to be watching this file very closely.
"What I do understand is that no decisions have been made. I understand that consultations between the parties are ongoing, and I expressed to the premier that it is my hope that when the Peel land use plan is signed that all parties are satisfied,” he said today.
The premier took the opportunity to reiterate that his government has and continues to follow the process outlined in the Umbrella Final Agreement.
The four affected First Nations are currently considering the government's land use vision for the area.
The government must then consider comments from the First Nations before making a final decision to accept, reject, or modify the plan he said.
Comments (12)
Up 0 Down 0
Jackie Ward on Jul 17, 2013 at 7:18 am
The comments here defending Darius is laughable. "We'll as long as he represents his constitutes, blah blah blah". I'm sorry, you don't just go from right wing to left wing on a monthly bias. Where's the credibility? Where's the accountability? Politicians are self serving no matter what they say to your face to get votes. All they care about is their fat pension. Someone who changes party's no matter what the situation, in my opinion can't be trusted. Public office is a position of trust. Maybe you forgot about that. I can't believe people can defend pathetic displays like this. How? Because he is a nice guy to you? Who cares? Actions speak louder than words. And flip flopping like this should be outlawed. Join the winning team? That's all you are doing. It's the easy way out. And save us the bull about "it's all about the constituents". No one believes that lie anymore. Aw well, we won't forget come election time. I wouldn't vote for a candidate that flips flops and either should you. Send them a message that this is adult world. Not choosing the party that can give you the fattest pay cheque . Edzerza did it. Fentie did it. Who's next? No wonder no one votes anymore. You should be ashamed of your childish behavior. That in the end hurts our democracy. Because all it does is make a mockery of it.
Up 0 Down 0
Sam Witherspoon on Jul 14, 2013 at 11:18 am
I am with Sandy Silver on this one.
This was a ‘horrible' decision for a First Nation MP.
I cannot wait to see how Darius Elias reacts to his new Party's final stance on the Peel, on ongoing consultation with First Nations who have land claim agreements and especially on those who do not have agreements. I suspect Darius will be under pressure to moderate how the Yukon Party deals with FN people.
And what kind of expression is that on Darrel's face. He was clearly unhappy or uncomfortable or both at the press conference.
Up 0 Down 1
Rob on Jul 13, 2013 at 10:37 am
Darius is a great guy..I worked in Old Crow for a season and watched him interact with his community members every day..he truly cares about his people and his riding ..who cares what party he switches to..he serves his people well...he interacts and gets involved and is a positive influence for that community! You can only go so far as an independent! I don't judge by the party..I judge by the man! Good work Darius !!!
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Jul 11, 2013 at 8:39 am
"Often MLAs make decisions based on personal agendas or regional concerns"
Yes, that's called representing the constituents that elected them, instead of following some party dogma.
Up 0 Down 0
Jack on Jul 11, 2013 at 4:40 am
@north_of_60. I disagree with your statement that the non-partisan approach in the NWT and Nunavut work better. Believe me, I am not convinced that our partisan system works well - but I know, based on experience, that the NWT system is a mess. Who stands for what? Often MLAs make decisions based on personal agendas or regional concerns - rather than focusing on the "big picture" for the territory - there is no accountability or transparency. No discipline for wayward MLAs - look at the absenteeism problem for MLAs in the NWT!
Up 0 Down 0
disappointed on Jul 10, 2013 at 2:19 pm
I am from Old Crow and I am not one to support this move. I have never met a premier that has been so disrespectful to First Nations and then the person I voted for moved on into his party? oh wait! is this someone that shows up when I have a party? Not sure why he would move into something that I don't see would become benefit to our people in Old Crow..I couldn't agree with you more Northern Tut..I am utterly disappointed in you Darius. And I don't recall you checking in with "your constituents" before you made the move.
Up 0 Down 0
north_of_60 on Jul 10, 2013 at 9:03 am
The Yukon is too small for party politics.
The political model in the other Territories is better suited for small populations.
Up 0 Down 0
northerntut on Jul 9, 2013 at 6:04 am
The party jumping speaks volumes about the person doing the jumping, opportunist with no real measure of convictions and no sense of loyalty. It's a shame that people donate their time, money and names to support someone whom they believe will represent their values, beliefs and convictions, yet, once elected so many modern politicians abandoned their supporters to line their own pockets one way or another. No wonder the electorate has a very low opinion of politics and politicians. We the electorate must demand and insist that party jumpers some how pay back their hard earned money and time when they decide the grass is greener on the other side.
Up 0 Down 0
johnny seymore on Jul 9, 2013 at 5:04 am
Can't believe he used WISDOM, and GREAT LEADER in his victory speech.
First of all a great leader would not resign, and let his colleague hang out to dry. He's got a lot of nerve using the word wisdom... He hasn't shown us wisdom yet... talking about Yukon Men program, and wanted special license plates for DUI.. what a waist of tax payer's dollars. Can't wait for his next big idea..
He's suppose to be paving the way for the younger generation, telling them it's okay to quit and leave your party high and dry.. Let's spin the bottle and find out where he ends up next..
I'll give him 5 years, and he'll be knocking on NDP's door..
yeah what a great leader
Up 1 Down 0
Max Mack on Jul 8, 2013 at 5:50 pm
One word -- pathetic.
Up 0 Down 0
Sam Finnigan on Jul 8, 2013 at 9:57 am
Not impressed at all.
And when is constant anger really passion?
The Conservative Party won this one. But how will Darius Elias sell the pro-mining anti-Peel Watershed protection to his constituents and other Yukon First Nations?
The Yukon Party is anti-modern Darius, you should have throught it through and returned to the Liberal Party or gone with the NDP.
Up 0 Down 0
not impressed on Jul 8, 2013 at 8:30 am
Picture tells it all - you can tell the interest of YP with First Nations - not much