Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Education Minister Patrick Rouble

‘Misunderstandings' have marked saga, minister says

Education Minister Patrick Rouble is standing by his man – embattled Premier Dennis Fentie – after the Aug. 28 defection of high-profile cabinet minister Brad Cathers.

By Jason Unrau on September 9, 2009

Education Minister Patrick Rouble is standing by his man – embattled Premier Dennis Fentie – after the Aug. 28 defection of high-profile cabinet minister Brad Cathers.

"I'm not going to call Mr. Cathers a liar. That's unprofessional and inappropriate. I think on this whole issue, there have been many misunderstandings,” Rouble said Tuesday.

He was responding to a question about Cathers' depiction of Fentie as a bully who misled the cabinet and the public about negotiating a selloff of the Yukon's public electricity utility to Calgary-based energy giant ATCO.

Both the premier and his cabinet have remained silent in the wake of Cathers' resignation and a cabinet shuffle, which saw Archie Lang moved into the Energy, Mines and Resources portfolio vacated by Cathers.

On Tuesday morning, reporters cornered Rouble following the presentation of a literacy award in the Yukon government main administration building (see story, p. 7).

"There have been manoeuverings done for whatever reasons that I'm certainly not aware of ... different politicians have their own reasons for doing different things,” was Rouble's take on recent events that have scandalized the Yukon Party and reduced it to minority government status.

When Cathers announced he was leaving the government's caucus to sit as an independent, his rationale was that he would not compromise principles for political power.

"(Fentie) made it unmistakably clear that (he) is not willing to correct the record, not willing to acknowledge the facts and is intent on trying to pressure me into publicly endorsing and repeating untruths he has said on the public record,” Cathers told reporters when he announced his resignation as Energy Minister and as government house leader.

Word that Fentie orchestrated negotiations to sell off, then privatize Yukon Energy Corp. assets, first came to light in June after four corporation directors resigned to protest the premier's intentions for the public utility.

Through a series of subsequent media interviews, Fentie denied the allegations.

Amidst calls from opposition party leaders that the premier resign, Fentie put two high-level bureaucrats into the firing line to support his claims.

While Cathers, the MLA for Lake Laberge, said his cabinet colleagues were "unhappy” and faced "a similar moral dilemma”, for Rouble, there appears no such quandary.

For the record, here is the Education minister on his leader and why he continues to stand by the Yukon Party government:

"Premier Fentie is a strong leader. We have a mandate. We ran on the first election in 2002 when we were elected – re-elected in 2006, where Yukoners reaffirmed that we were heading in the right direction and we have a responsibility to do the work that we were elected to do.

"I've made a commitment to Yukoners, to my constituents, to do the best that I can for the territory and I will continue with my responsibility to do that and to work with all of my colleagues, both within cabinet and members from the opposition.”

Rouble refused to entertain further questions, such as whether the Yukon Party's mandate from voters included privatizing the energy corporation, or if he agreed with how Fentie has handled the situation to date.

Cathers has not been available for comment since his resignation announcement.

Comments (5)

Up 0 Down 0

namewitheld on Sep 13, 2009 at 5:11 am

so rouble supports fentie, and who can be suprised.

rouble picked up an MBA with government help in studying the WCB....whatever came of that?

let's see....who else will support fentie and why?

archie lang probably because of shared business interests in watson lake (hotels and construction companies)and for sliding through on cutting down the woods on his property without a permit from his own department....fenie let him off on that one without a wimper.

elaine taylor probably because of shared business interests in watson lake (tow truck company and construction company). she got her friend's tow truck out of jail by overuling the justice department. fentie let her off on that one without a wimper.

glenn hart probably because of support in getting the road in front of his army beach cottage fixed and getting the new piece of highway installed in front of his golf course. Not a word spoken by fentie on these two nice little assists to hart while he was the minister responsible for the funds.

ted staffen probably because fentie has left him in the speaker's chair and the two are co-dependent when the house is in session.

marian horne probably because fentie has left her alone in her ministry throughout the scandal....not a peep, not a slight, so how could she complain.

its doubtful Kenyon will support fentie, having been stabbed so publicly.

its doubtful Nordick will support fentie given the fact that he's still kept on as a backbencher and not given a minister's file in the midst of this crisis and shortage of MLA's.

That makes six who will hang in with number seven fentie. the others are up for grabs.

fentie has certainly done this math fifty times by now.

there just aren't ENOUGH there left to carry you through fentie, so just go on and hit the road now before the drubbing you are going to take becomes uglier than this.

Up 0 Down 0

Max on Sep 10, 2009 at 9:26 am

The issues surrounding privatization of our hydro are far more complex and risk-prone than a simple "rationalization" or export of profits to southern firms. I encourage everyone to see the online video at http://nauresistance.org/2009/09/powerplay-nafta-trying-to-privatize-canada-fresh-water/

While this video is focussed on what has been happening in BC recently, there are many issues which are relevant to the Yukon.

Up 0 Down 0

David Griffiths on Sep 10, 2009 at 4:42 am

It's fine fine thing that Mr Rouble has declared himself for Mr Fentie. It simplifies the process of weeding out politicians for whom I will not vote.

Up 0 Down 0

Jack Malone on Sep 9, 2009 at 1:58 pm

Okay, okay, I have been berating the members of Fentie's Cabinet to speak up and do something rather than sit around mute hoping that everything would blow over. I regret that since Rouble's comments are embarrassing and patronizing - Yukoners don't want to hear bullsh*t anymore. We're not stupid. People are angry and want honesty and accountability. Perhaps they should be mute unless they have something intelligent to say.

Up 0 Down 0

Doug Rutherford on Sep 9, 2009 at 7:58 am

If Minister Rouble believes Premier Fentie to be on the right track, why won't he answer questions about privatizing Yukon Energy?

This is probably related to the fact that you cannot get an Access to Information request on the topic since the government's response is that negotiations are still ongoing between YTG and ATCO. Don't assume that the media coverage has ended this situation.

This has long past the time where our elected officials start answering to us. If they think that ignoring their superiors (and in many cases, this is true in more than one way) is how things should be done, have the guts to call an election on the subject and let the chips fall where they may.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.