Minister fields questions about major bridge project
The Yukon Party is claiming the territorial government is dragging its feet on the Nisutlin Bay Bridge project near Teslin.
By Morris Prokop on October 19, 2022
The Yukon Party is claiming the territorial government is dragging its feet on the Nisutlin Bay Bridge project near Teslin.
The current bridge, built by the Department of National Defence, opened to the public in 1955. The new structure will be constructed beside it.
The project was recently budgeted at $80 million, but that has now doubled to $160 million.
The new bridge was first approved in 2019, when the Yukon government and the Teslin Tlingit Council (TTC) signed a project charter for the
bridge replacement.
“The project is anticipated to begin in the coming weeks and be complete in 2026,” the Star reported last May.
The bridge is expected to take three years to build.
But according to Pelly-Nisutlin MLA Stacy Hassard of the Yukon Party, virtually no work has been done on the project. He asked a series of
questions in the legislature Tuesday.
“The government has touted this as the largest project in Yukon history, and it is, and you know, we’d certainly hoped that things would be
moving smoother and a lot quicker than they are,” Hassard later told reporters.
“And the other concern I have is the fact that the minister (Highways and Public Works Minister Nils Clarke) was so unable to answer questions about it in the legislature, and, as it is the largest project in Yukon history, I certainly would have hoped that he would have been a lot more a lot better versed in his answers today.”
Hassard elaborated on where he believes the project should be at now.
“The concrete abutments should have been poured and in place, there probably should have been somewhere in the neighbourhood of 30,000 metres’ worth of gravel moved already to put a preload on those abutments so that they would have time to settle into place,” he said.
“A lot of work should have should have taken place already. And unfortunately, none of that has happened.”
Hassard added, “We still don’t know for sure where the gravel, where the aggregate is even coming for this project. We don’t have a rock source proven up yet. They have potential rock sources, but they don’t know if they’re suitable or not.
“We don’t have water licences fully in place. We don’t have authority from DFO (Department of Fisheries and Oceans).
“I mean, there’s so many things that the government has completely dropped the ball on .… the minister talked about (how) this project was
supposed to happen eight years ago and didn’t,” Hassard told media representatives.
“Well, you know, we’ve now had all of those eight years extra to do the planning and unfortunately, it appears that this government didn’t do any of the planning.”
He called it “really unfortunate” that the contractors have been placed in this situation.
“The community is put in a situation where the government is scrambling to – and actually making the contractor scramble – to try and get the project moving.”
Hassard was asked what the delay means.
“It means that every year Highways and Public Works has to send contractors down to do emergency repairs to the bridge,” he replied.
“It’s ongoing – has been ongoing for years. They’re currently there now doing major welding repairs to the bridge and you know, eventually you can only repair things so long and then they will fail.”
NDP Leader Kate White said she believes the questions are valid.
“It’s a really big project, and all of those should have been in place and they should be clearly understood by this point,” she said.
“You know, we’ve seen bridge replacements in other places in the territory and, you know, the challenges that come with that. And this is,
you know, a major bridge access into the territory.
“And so, you know, I’d like the minister to answer the questions. I’d like to know where we’re at,” White said.
Clarke attempted to answer some of those queries after question period.
“This project almost got off the ground in 2014,” he reminded reporters.
“However, at that time, the Yukon Party (government) was, for various reasons, unable to get the project going. And at that point … one of the main issues was a perceived lack of consultation and inability to work with the Teslin Tlingit Council,” the minister said.
As for Hassard’s question about a water licence, Clarke said, “I can advise that the water licence is in fact in place. The project is currently on track and we are holding … a groundbreaking ceremony with the Teslin Tlingit Council, the village of Teslin and the contractor, Graham Infrastructure, and the officials from the Department of Highways and Public Works on Friday.”
Pile driving for the bridge will take place later this fall, he said.
According to Clarke, $30 million to $40 million is budgeted for the project in 2022-23.
“I’ve understood that there may be a request for them to accelerate the schedule,” said Clarke. “So I haven’t received that request yet.
“But if that were the case, then actually a not insignificant portion of the budget, or, of the work, could be done or spent in this fiscal year.”
Clarke was asked why the project budget has exploded.
“When was actually tendered about a year ago, at that point – it had already gone to a low estimate of $110 to $120 (million) … so there’s still significant price acceleration.
“It’s the price of … global structural steel and other components, supply chain issues, labour shortages. So that was all a factor.
“It’s vital transportation infrastructure in the territory that we do not want to have failing; it’s the longest bridge span in the territory. And as I
indicated in my comments today, the bridge is about 70 years old. And we’ll be facing significant repair costs on an annual basis,” he added.
Maintenance costs of the existing bridge are between $500,000 and $1 million per year.
The money committed for the new bridge involves both federal and territorial contributions.
In 2018, the government conducted a study to estimate the cost of preserving the existing bridge versus replacing it.
At that time, the cost to upgrade it fell between $50 million and $67 million.
“With the pandemic, inflation and supply chain issues, we know these costs would be significantly higher today than these estimates,” the department said today in a short statement to the Star.
“Through this study, we found that replacing the bridge was the best option and provided the most benefits for the community.”
Friday’s ceremony will include Clarke, Alex Oakley, the deputy chief of the Teslin Tlingit Council, and Teslin Mayor Gord Curran.
The celebration will be followed by a community lunch.
Comments (16)
Up 4 Down 4
We live in a world of make believe with great pretenders… on Oct 22, 2022 at 8:48 am
Dear Anie on Oct 21, 2022 at 3:22 pm:
As you/we are well aware, the word charter means very little. As we have seen with the ignorance of the Constitution our Charter of Rights and freedoms are illusory, fantastical, creatures that disappear into the cover of the living tree doctrines that grow in the forest of Justice Denied or, the Black Forests of Judicial Activism.
They are densely written, impenetrable documents of subjective intent which requires a special key held by an individual dense enough to understand that facts are a matter of interpretive license to be wielded in a contest of interested litigants. A charter sets out the following:
“a written grant by a country's legislative or sovereign power, by which a body such as a company, college, or city is founded and its rights and privileges defined.”
So, if we look at both examples the word charter seems to be on a parallel with story telling, the oral traditions, and blah, blah, blah, yada, yada, yada… It’s a way to impose one’s will at the threat of expensive litigation. And you, you, and you as the taxpayer get to pay for this circus - The Fool King’s clown show!
How about you, you, and you do some thinking next time you’re at the ballot box of fate. Quit choosing the blue pill! Take the next opportunity to explore reality perhaps.
Up 8 Down 1
JustSayin' on Oct 21, 2022 at 8:54 pm
@Yukoner
Cobalt has a agreement with NND, thus they get a BV reduction on their bids. This is how reconciliation works.
@Anie
Yep. That's why it took so long for the bridge to be implemented because drafting of the charter.
Up 13 Down 2
Anie on Oct 21, 2022 at 3:22 pm
I wonder what a "project charter" is. I think it might be a new way if describing a "here's a whack of money now don't protest our project" agreement
Up 33 Down 0
Yukoner on Oct 20, 2022 at 3:15 pm
How in any way is Cobalt able to get this contract? They are in charge of the disgrace that is the North Klondike Highway road improvements which have been going on for 3 years! The conditions they put that road in are atrocious and shouldn't be happening.
Can't wait for Cobalt to drag this project out an extra couple of years to pad their coffers at the expense of Yukoners' tax dollars and vehicle's!
Up 22 Down 7
BnR on Oct 20, 2022 at 1:20 pm
Y'know what would be refreshing?
That for once we could see all parties just working forward for Yukoners in a manner that puts partisan politics aside.
As Mr. Hassard knows full well, construction projects rarely follow exact schedules, especially ones of this magnitude.
The Yukon government is not in the business of construction management, as Stacey knows. Look at what happened at the Dawson City hospital. I don't recall anyone in the Yukon Party leaping up to take responsibility for that, nor should they have.
Sometimes projects get delayed and it's just that simple.
Maybe it's time we go back to a legislative model like the NT?
Up 13 Down 4
Nisutlin Bay on Oct 20, 2022 at 12:55 pm
United Northern
Thank you for correcting me re. The Honourable members affiliation with the company mentioned.
Additionally, thank you for reassuring his constituents that there is no conflict of interest. I’ll sleep better with your calming words.
Up 25 Down 2
Greasy palms on Oct 20, 2022 at 12:08 pm
Projected cost has doubled. That phrase is becoming all but a boiler plate in every capital project story. I would be happy to blame it on Putin or Covid, but this has been the Yukon way with capital projects for decades. I wonder who benefits most when projects run 2-6 times over budget? (I already know who doesn’t…)
Up 24 Down 3
@Politico on Oct 20, 2022 at 9:38 am
The article stated the new bridge was approved in 2019, pretty sure the YP was not in power then as we have been suffering under Liberal ineptitude since 2016 friend.
Up 16 Down 5
Sum Ting Wong on Oct 20, 2022 at 8:32 am
Now I am no biologist sir, but isn't a million a year tiny spuds compared to 160 million minimum with interest on that and please don't suggest "we have the money"? We are drowning in debt now, individually, nationally, and globally.
Let's see... should I pay 1 million a year to maintain the bridge or put 160 million on my visa? And as we all know, no contractor ever padded their bills upon completion of a project... haha, so the price (may rise just a little bit because supply chains)
Then the simple removal of the existing bridge, and all the while, a global shortage of diesel fuel looms so let's just blow off as much as possible while we still can, right? It will be good for an environment, right?
This dog should have been taken behind the barn long ago.
Up 28 Down 3
United Northern on Oct 19, 2022 at 11:29 pm
@ Nisutlin Bay, the Member for Pelly Nisutlin (not Teslin) was never a shareholder of Deadman Creek Enterprises and has no affiliation with that company other than being related to the owners. Deadman has done some groundwork for the contractor Graham Infrastructure in so far as they have hauled gravel for the camp and laydown yards. To the best of my knowledge they have not done any other work and seem to be being excluded on any major works due to the BVR as they are not a FN company. Graham has a "quota" of TTC/FN slated dollars that are allocated for this project so that is where most of the work seems to be going at present. So I think your mislaid fears of the current MLA meddling in public contracts for personal gain, as you seem to be insinuating, is completely unfounded.
Up 10 Down 6
bonanzajoe on Oct 19, 2022 at 8:52 pm
@Politico on Oct 19, 2022: Have you found a parking spot for your UFO yet?
Up 17 Down 8
Roy on Oct 19, 2022 at 7:43 pm
Both parties are staffed by ineffectual bureaucrats sniping at each other for their respective failures to move this project along - meanwhile the delays mean the price just keeps going up.
Press thumbs down if you’re a Yukon Party supporter who doesn’t want to think about how much cheaper it would have been to start this project in 2014. It’d be finished by now and for half the price. Thanks Yukon Party!
If only the Yukon Party knew how to work well with others instead of texting funny jokes to each other.
If only the Liberals knew how to focus on what’s needed instead of dreaming up special projects. I’m surprised they aren’t building a 6 lane bilingual bridge just for midwives to use to get to the hospital.
Up 19 Down 5
JustSayin on Oct 19, 2022 at 6:18 pm
@Nisutlin Bay
I undertake research is difficult, but most of the work has gone to TTC citizens as Graham has signed a charter. The remaining work has gone to Cobalt another Indigenous contractor ( partnership with NND).
Deadman creek is not affiliated with the MLA. The MLA has his own numbered company in Teslin that does work.... check the Villiage of Teslin Business directory.
Up 27 Down 55
Politico on Oct 19, 2022 at 4:11 pm
So the YP started the project, terrible it missed the budget estimated and are now blaming the Liberals for the problems. Admit it Currie, the problem is the YP's lack of local consultation and bad budgeting. Maybe , instead of complaining all the time help all Yukoners by getting this project moving ahead?
Up 36 Down 9
Groucho d'North on Oct 19, 2022 at 3:29 pm
In the headline 'field' I believe is the appropriate word because in typical Liberal fashion, he sure as hell did not answer the questions asked of him during Question Period but rather shared the information with the media at the break.
Childish political games, and you can listen to these live while the Legislature is sitting Monday through Thursday 1 PM to 6 PM. Dial in 93.5 and determine for yourself if these people are worth their generous pay. No radio? Read Hansard; the verbatim record of who said what or not. All the house business is available here: https://yukonassembly.ca/ Perhaps if more of the electorate were listening and commenting, they would begin to act like they should for the jobs they have.
Up 42 Down 19
Nisutlin Bay on Oct 19, 2022 at 2:41 pm
Can the Honourable Member for Teslin confirm for the public that his former company Deadman Creek Enterprises is in no way affiliated with this project?