Minister acknowledges abuses within civil service
The Yukon government isn’t doing enough to confront workplace harassment and support its victims,
The Yukon government isn’t doing enough to confront workplace harassment and support its victims, cabinet minister Richard Mostyn told the legislature Thursday.
He spoke to “a culture within the civil service that has to change,” referencing incidents he is personally aware of in which managers “acted badly” and “have been abusive.”
Mostyn is the minister responsible for the Public Service Commission.
His comments came in light of a report released Thursday by Employment and Social Development Canada. It found 60 per cent of respondents to a federal government survey had experienced harassment in their respective workplaces. Thirty per cent of respondents had dealt with workplace harassment that was sexual in nature.
Women comprised 94 per cent of those voluntary survey participants who indicated experience with workplace harassment.
While three-quarters of respondents who experienced harassment said they had reported the incident(s), more than half of these individuals said there was no attempt made to resolve the issue. Many of those who didn’t report their harassment indicated it was for fear of reprisal.
“There is, unfortunately, no reason to believe that these statistics are any different in Yukon,” said NDP Leader Liz Hanson.
She asked the government for specific statistics related to workplace harassment in the territory, as well as what options and protections exist for public and private sector employees.
Give numbers
Mostyn indicated he will attempt to provide numbers on harassment within the government, assuring the house that he and his fellow Liberals MLAs “take this issue seriously.”
While he stated the government has procedures in place to respond to incidents of workplace harassment, he did not elaborate as to what exactly those are.
Nigel Allan, a spokesperson for the commission, said the government uses a variety of legislation and internal policy to address harassment in the workplace.
Those include the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Yukon Human Rights Act, the Yukon Government Respectful Workplace Policy and collective agreements with the Yukon Employees’ Union (YEU) and the Yukon Teachers’ Association.
A Respectful Workplace Office is open to any YG employee experiencing harassment, Allan said.
But, “It comes down to a management,” Mostyn told the house. “We have to have managerial buy-in to this process and make sure that, when abuse happens and when bad behaviour happens in the workplace — terrible behaviour, unacceptable behaviour — that managers actually take appropriate action.”
Hanson told the minster that he and his government are ultimately responsible for and accountable to YG employees.
“The status quo is not acceptable,” she said.
She cited mounting evidence across the country – like Thursday’s federal government report – that shows many women fear reporting workplace harassment due to potential retaliation and those who do report are often not believed.
“Can the minister please outline what new approaches this government is taking?” Hanson asked. “How are they identifying gaps in the current system? How is he ensuring ... senior management accountability and how is it improving its response to harassment in the workplace?”
This is when Mostyn expressed his belief that the government has more work to do.
Looking at issue
“I’m conveying that we have to do better. I have done that with my officials and they are looking at this issue.”
Meanwhile, he encouraged people who have experienced workplace harassment to come forward and report the incidents.
Allan provided a more concrete answer to Hanson’s question to the Star this morning.
The government launched a new online resource in September called Violence Ends with Us. It’s designed to support YG employees in addressing domestic and sexualized violence.
Presentations on the new resource were made to management when it was released, Allan said.
Managers are also offered regular training and workshops to help facilitate “healthy and open communications so that employees feel safe,” he wrote in an email.
Respondents to the federal government survey expressed the view that while one’s employer should be the primary source of support for victims of workplace harassament, the government and unions also have a responsibility to do so.
YEU president Steve Geick confirmed to the Star today that workplace harassment and specifically workplace sexual harassment definitely affect Yukoners.
Those involved in precarious work – part-time or auxiliary on-call employees for example – as well as equity group members – i.e. women, Indigenous people, LGBTQ individuals – are more vulnerable to such harassment, according to Geick.
The YEU provides the employees it represents a variety of resources and support to deal with workplace harassment, he said.
Both the Yukon Status of Women Council and the Victoria Faulkner Women’s Centre were unable to provide comment for this story today.
Comments (18)
Up 1 Down 0
drum on Nov 10, 2017 at 11:13 pm
The YEU have ignored this for years. They know that paying union members are being harassed . They are part of the problem. They have to demand that the Respectful Workplace office is done away with because it is completely useless.
The YEU have to protect their members. They have to work with YG to come up with something that will work to protect employees from bullying and harassment. The Respectful Workplace office is not working!!!!!
Up 15 Down 4
Yukon Watchdog on Nov 9, 2017 at 7:50 am
It makes me sick to think our hard-earned tax dollars are used again and again to defend these people that continually abuse their power and authority in the most offensive way. Power gone to people's heads where they forget the real reasons for their existence in the jobs they are in (usually because the job is way over their head and they're blinded by their sheer luck in landing that job with the big fat paycheque - by virtue of favourtism, nepotism or discrimination).
Yes, I have personally experienced this at YG. I could name names.... starting in HPW and working my way through each department.
The Respectful Workplace Office is a sick joke that raises employees' expectations that something might be done when nothing is EVER done to the abusers. The only thing you get from a visit to the RWO (besides holding hands and a hug or two) is to become pegged as a problem employee. A visit to the RWO is the first step to working yourself out of a job. I highly recommend you never go there.
Up 26 Down 2
Groucho d'North on Nov 8, 2017 at 11:32 am
Rule one in government is "Don't go looking for trouble (of any kind)" and when you find it pretend it didn't happen. Most senior managers are out of their depth in dealing with people issues and allow the problems to fester rather than managing the problems. The HR people get real grumpy when a manager deals with an issue instead of calling them in to hold hands and chant about our feelings and how we all need to respect each other better - DING goes the finger cymbal telling us our time for today is done. It's a day by day documentary on the Peter principle.
Up 32 Down 0
Lost in the Yukon on Nov 8, 2017 at 7:17 am
There was a Director in a department who was an absolute tyrant. She played a major role in getting rid of the former director ... she was promoted into the position and protected by a DM (who was eventually fired). Morale within the Branch went to an all time low ... she would yell and scream at people. Rather than deal with her she was first given a "project" and then moved to another department as a Director.
This is the stuff that goes on all the time at YG ... everyone knows it but the powers to be do nothing and the politicians could care less
Up 9 Down 18
Grease gun on Nov 7, 2017 at 5:17 pm
What type of poisonous demeaning work atmosphere did "The Yukon Party" let manifest itself under their tutelage. We need one term just to straighten out their gross negligences.
Up 41 Down 8
ralpH on Nov 6, 2017 at 2:51 pm
It runs rampant, and all those that are bullies and think they have power are ones that could not survive in private life. They are a joke, but they cause good civil servants to leave. What's left usually are ones that sell their dignity just to keep their jobs. Sad but true. Those that leave can survive in the private sector and as long as it is overlooked and ignored nothing will happen.
Up 31 Down 10
Jeannie on Nov 6, 2017 at 11:39 am
Every story I have read is also “my Story”. There is additional element to my story! I was sexually assaulted by a co-workers boyfriend. I told the appropriate people like my Supervisor and within a month I was being harassed, demeaned, bullied and shunned. I was mocked at work for always being “so negative, so anxious” and needing help for PST. No one in my Department helped me and I begged! I begged for help. I was discounted by every person who had the ability to help me. I actually received a letter advising me to “stop talking to so many people” and “ leave the Minister and other officials in Government alone because I was being a bother”.
I still cry to this because I lost it all! I was subsequently fired. I lost it all after 20 years of service to the Government. A single middle-aged white woman who committed no crime. I have been existing with the help of friends and finally have been granted social assistance. Should the Minister, the Premier or any other person tasked with “cleaning up the abuse” need to hear my story I am available. My name is Jeannie.
Up 43 Down 4
Dis-function with a capital D on Nov 6, 2017 at 7:45 am
Looking at the comments, you can sort of tell whether the comment was YEU or other.
However, before one jumps all over management at YG, you have to examine what they had to manage. The YEU protects all sorts of dead wood. This dead wood can poison any unit or branch it winds up in.
And just as YEU members can be to blame, there are certain MG level employees that keep turning up in different management level assignments after being removed form the previous. Like the proverbial bad penny, they just keep getting passed around because senior managers can't be bothered to performance manage, and HR within YG is all over the map with respect to how they deal with issues like this. Why are there different HR units for each department? There should be just one.
And scrap Respectful Workplace. Either that or get rid of its incompetent/ineffective director.
Up 27 Down 1
Tom Stevens on Nov 6, 2017 at 7:41 am
Workplace Harassment is the norm in every government institution. Look at the RCMP and the mess it is and how much money has been set aside to pay off that mess. In government the slurps and suck holes advance and the worker bee types suffer. The slurps cover for the slurps and bring them along on the road to advancement. Good luck changing any of it. As long as they spend tax dollars, have little or no accountability this will continue because most politicians come from the ranks of the abusers and suck holes.
Up 35 Down 9
ProScience Greenie on Nov 5, 2017 at 12:20 pm
A complete housecleaning of about 80% of DMs, ADMs and those a level or two below that would solve a lot of these issues. If the union for once would stop supporting the few but very active full time trouble makers in their ranks that would also help. It might also help if YTG put a little more effort into hiring locals (our friends, family and neighbors) rather than so many Outside hires.
Up 46 Down 12
Thomas Brewer on Nov 5, 2017 at 10:51 am
I'm quite worried that the pendulum has swung too far and this topic is becoming a witch hunt... oh wait, I probably triggered someone by using 'witch'.
Up 40 Down 11
Former YG Employee on Nov 5, 2017 at 1:35 am
Harassment and abuse is definitely rampant in the government. The respectful workplace office and the 1-800 employee assistance number is an absolute joke. I especially love the quote about how managers have to take accountability; well when it's a manager that's the problem nothing happens. Look at some of these positions and how many times they've been turned over and how many employees have come and gone. Can you really tell me that 12 or 13 employees in a four or five year period is really the result of employees wanting to leave? People quit people they don't quit jobs. The union also isn't always a help either. They're all well and dandy to help you but as soon as they find out who it is that you're having a problem with, there's some people that they know there's nothing they can do so they just stop helping
Up 35 Down 9
June on Nov 4, 2017 at 6:51 pm
As a former YTG employee for many years I must say I have never seen as much harassment and verbal abuse in the past 5-9 years than I have ever seen before. Yes, I tried every avenue and when I went to the workplace harassment committee they said I should go to the Yukon Human Rights but after you are in a similar situation you have no confidence left. I left YTG as I felt like I had no other options or fight left in me. No one had listened yet so what was going to change.
They ask for statistics but are they really going to get accurate stats? Ask for the statistic of how many people did the harassment committee see year to year. I can name almost a whole branch of 70+ people who were there. Or will they count that as one case?
As why YTG has so many new PTSD people on disability? Could it really be the workplace? Could it have been alleviated by listening to your employees?
Just my thoughts....
Up 29 Down 11
June Jackson on Nov 4, 2017 at 4:58 pm
I partially agree with most posters, however, I also know that in the front line positions there are a lot of gripers, bitchers, complainers, liars, and thieves. Some of these employee's rob government blind.. how many tablets are not accounted for huh? And who got fired for it? No one. I personally know a supervisor who was accused under the old harassment office and had to face an investigation because the accuser wanted another job, didn't think she could pass the exams and thought she would be moved to another job if she screamed harassment. A doesn't like B so the Yukon public will be ill served? We are ill served because employee's don't face any disciplinary action for behaving badly, showing up for work in their pants (mind you, I've seen Doctor's show up for work dressed in dirty clothes, greasy man buns etc) have no concept of what client service is, and couldn't care less. Paycheck every two weeks.
If you have a problem with your supervisor, I see nothing wrong with discussing it..if you can't do that, I see nothing wrong with mediation by the director or ADM or DM or a Union rep. But I do see something wrong with people getting to scream I'm hard done by, with no proof, no witnesses and when a complaint is found to be 'frivolous' absolutely no consequences for the accuser.. while the supervisor has been sent off to training, management, personal, interactive.
So, by all means, take every complaint seriously, and when the complaint is found to be valid, just fire the accused, and when it is found to be frivolous.. fire the accuser and make sure they never, ever get another job with government.
Up 28 Down 7
YT on Nov 4, 2017 at 8:08 am
Shouldn't premier Pillai be addressing this?
Up 48 Down 5
drum on Nov 3, 2017 at 7:09 pm
Respectful Workplace office does not do investigations. They do hold hands and forgive each other - so ineffectual when someone is being harassed. Circle love. Let's just sit around a circle and spread the love.!!!!!!! They take months to even get to meet with people who have complained and are completely ineffectual. Private companies make a fortune doing investigations which can take forever. People in the meantime are named as trouble makers and do not get promotions - most leave because of stress!
Try getting help from the supposed Employee Counselling Service - let's try the 800 number. In the past their was service one number away from a local professional company but PSC had to save money so came up with this non functioning cheaper service. Harassment is alive and well in the YG. It will never be fixed until it is taken seriously and qualified professional people are put in charge of fixing it.
Up 20 Down 23
jc on Nov 3, 2017 at 6:22 pm
The morals of the nation have deteriated since the 60s. I know why, but won't say. Star wouldn't print it. So, all I can say is, suck it up and toughen up.
Up 57 Down 4
Lost in the Yukon on Nov 3, 2017 at 5:48 pm
The abuse is rampant ... unqualified people in Director and ADM positions being protected ... a bureaucracy that is top heavy while frontline positions remain unfilled, overworked and undervalued
A truly independent review is needed to expose the ugly side of YG ... only then can a process be put in place to change the culture.
Until that happens the Yukon public that pays the bills will continue to be ill served.