Photo by Vince Fedoroff
SETTING THE SCENE – Scott Howell makes his presentation Tuesday evening at city hall.
Photo by Vince Fedoroff
SETTING THE SCENE – Scott Howell makes his presentation Tuesday evening at city hall.
Two burials took place on Nov. 1, 1957 at the Pioneer Cemetery in downtown Whitehorse.
Two burials took place on Nov. 1, 1957 at the Pioneer Cemetery in downtown Whitehorse.
While a large state burial was held in one part of the cemetery for Yukon icon Martha Black, a small group of mourners gathered in another section to bury an infant.
"I can't tell you where Jeff is, but I'd like you to find him for me,” Scott Howell, the infant's younger brother, told city council Tuesday evening.
Scott was born after Jeff and another brother, Mickey, passed away.
On Tuesday, he asked the city to honour the lives of his brothers and the many others who were buried at Pioneer Cemetery and who now have no grave markers.
He argued the city needs to hold off on transferring title of three Steele Street lots to the Yukon government, which is planning to redevelop the Sarah Steele Building, until more work is done to acknowledge the lost graves in the area.
A recent radar survey identified 12 "sites of interest” in the Steele Street lots that could be grave sites.
The territory will be doing test excavations in an effort to find out what exactly is below the surface.
As Howell told council last evening, using Google Earth imaging to explain his points, there are a number of depressions in the ground around the cemetery that could be grave sites.
He noted that a number of years ago, the city tore down the wooden grave markers that were in the cemetery. He believes there could be upwards of 170 grave sites that aren't marked.
As it states on the city's website:
"Although the City of Whitehorse was established as a municipality in 1950, the city did not accept responsibility for managing the cemetery until 1965.
"Unfortunately, no consecutive records of burials were kept, apart from individual churches and the Masonic Lodge.
"About 20 years ago, most of the wooden markers were removed in a misguided cleanup of the area.
"As a result, there is no complete record of individual grave sites, apart from those with stone monuments.
"There seemed to be a need for a compilation of as many as possible of the names of those at rest in the cemetery, and a book titled Lost Graves was compiled.”
Howell said he doesn't expect the city to go in and do extensive excavation work to identify each and every grave in the area.
However, he would like to see a stone wall or plaque – some sort of permanent memorial – to preserve the memory of those buried there.
Howell has also been in touch with the Yukon Order of Pioneers, which is pursuing plans to improve the cemetery.
He stressed he wants to see the city not go ahead with third reading on the land transfer right now.
Council is set to vote on third reading next week.
In an interview following Tuesday's meeting, Mayor Dan Curtis said he doesn't favour holding off on the land transfer.
He said he trusts the Yukon government will do the necessary work with great care to identify any potential grave sites on the land.
He also said he doesn't see erecting a stone wall to recognize the lost grave sites, noting it would be subject to city bylaws which limit fence height.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (13)
Up 0 Down 0
CJ on Sep 11, 2013 at 1:36 pm
I don't know why the mayor referred to the fence height bylaw to shut down talk of a memorial. Even if it was relevant -- which it isn't -- it's not like they can't dive into the bylaw and amend it. Since they do that frequently.
I was also quite astonished to hear Doug Graham go before council and say YTG would relocate any remains. When did that get put on the table other than a few minutes before the vote?
I'm certain that memorial will happen. It's just a shame that council couldn't get on the right side of it. Now people will have to work harder when it should be a no-brainer for any elected official. It's just not a fashionable issue, I guess.
Up 0 Down 0
Frank Smith on Sep 11, 2013 at 2:10 am
I agree with James Richard
The City's actions were inappropriate- they should have taken better care of the grave markers and records. This happened in the past but they have to take responsibility and correct the injustice. A memorial, as suggested by Scott, would be nice. The mayor should be saying we will work with you on this rather than it may be too high and not conform to zoning.
I also agree with James on the ATV and skidoo trail issue thing. It's almost like mob rules prevail in this town. Respect for green spaces and the environment should begin with Mayor and Council. They need to set the tone for their planners and parks staff. Whitehorse was and could be a much nicer place to live and people who have been here awhile recognize how quickly it has fallen.
Thanks Scott for bringing well thought out plans and concerns forwards. Shame on the city for the dogma and letting this city be run down by complacency and mob rules.
Frank
Up 0 Down 0
Marianne on Sep 9, 2013 at 6:40 am
The more I think about this the more it bothers me. Even in big cities like Toronto and Vancouver, where land pressure is intense, land around cemeteries is accorded a measure of respect.
Not so long ago we were all getting lectured about our attitude towards death -- which some contrived to find deficient in order to push the crematorium zoning in Porter Creek. Now the city appears to be leading the way in being callous about Pioneer Cemetery.
I can't help but think it's another episode of pushing something through before people have a chance to realize what they're proposing.
And by the way, the development that was proposed as part of the crematorium never materialized. What's holding YTG to building what they say they're going to build? Ultimately anything could go there. This is no emergency situation for YTG or the city. Just a test of character.
Up 0 Down 0
Just Say'in on Sep 8, 2013 at 3:56 pm
My wife has a younger sister that died premature. Her remains are in an unmarked grave in that cemetery dating back to the late 50's. I have never been able to understand how the city could do such a poor job with this cemetery. They took it over in 65 and what have they done to preserve it. I think that is what happens when we have a bunch of people in power here that believe that the whole world started when they arrived and nothing was important before. Do your job council or you will all be fired. As you can see from the letters many hold this cemetery close for very good reasons.
Up 0 Down 0
Sylvia Burkhard on Sep 8, 2013 at 5:16 am
Unmarked graves in Dawson's cemeteries from the turn of the century I can understand but burials from the 50's and 60's not marked anymore is inexcusable. Plans to develop in this area is unbelievable, the whole area should be left alone, glad I don't have anybody in my family buried there! Why aren't burial sites of all nations treated the same way and given the same respect?
Up 0 Down 0
Ron Daniels on Sep 5, 2013 at 9:34 am
Burial site for Bert Brame and child has not been found. This burial took place in the early 1960's
Up 0 Down 0
yukoner on Sep 5, 2013 at 4:02 am
James shut it or stay on topic - yes the city took the markers down, now spend the time and put them back.
Up 0 Down 0
Noname on Sep 5, 2013 at 3:57 am
Having witnessed many funerals in Europe and Canada, I'm surprised that there aren't bylaws to cover identifying remains after burial. In Europe, all coffins carry an engraved nameplate with the date of death. In the case of the old cemetery where the well intentioned messed up as to identifying graves, such a step would have resolved many such issues. Even now, would this be a help to future generations?
Up 0 Down 0
A Numbered Company on Sep 4, 2013 at 2:48 pm
What's the hurry? And also -- the city took down markers and didn't replace them? And they wonder why we don't just trust them to "do the necessary work with great care".
This is actually pretty upsetting and the mayor's stance of "Gotta make decisions, I trust YTG" dismays me with its insensitivity. More than that, the city took responsibility for the cemetery. Does he really expect YTG to surpass the sorry standard the city already set?
Mayor and council need to examine their values. This is about as core as it gets.
Up 0 Down 0
Ruth Mark on Sep 4, 2013 at 1:16 pm
Thank you for taking a stand on this issue. I too have an baby brother buried at this grave site in an unmarked grave. I think that it is only fitting that some sort of marker be placed in the area in memory of those who are buried there. I like the idea of stone wall or something simpler with the names of those who were put to rest there.
Up 0 Down 0
Doug Beaumont on Sep 4, 2013 at 12:34 pm
Yes, thanks Scott. I have an older sister and brother (twins) buried in that cemetery. I too would appreciate some sort of 'memorial' for them. They were noted in Peg Crook's book on the cemetery, 'Lost Graves', and a memorial wall would be ideal for all that can and can't be identified.
Up 0 Down 0
James Richard on Sep 4, 2013 at 12:13 pm
The City should elevate resolving this issue out of respect for the many people who are buried there and do not have grave markers.
Anything less is very uncaring and disrespectful.
Why were the markers torn down rather than restored? It would have been so much easier to restore them and involve the community in the effort.
Our City has changed very quickly in a negative way. I hate to bring up another distressing City development issue, but it seems you cannot walk our beautiful walking trails without seeing and hearing noisy off road vehicles and skidoos which roar around like they are on a racetrack. Why is this allowed? Where is the planning?
Lets deal with the cemetary and lets also have city planners make this place a better place for older people like me who enjoy a quiet nature walk.
Up 0 Down 0
Maureen Stephens on Sep 4, 2013 at 7:53 am
Thanks for speaking up, Scott. My grandparents, Philip Mundy Blaker and Ethel Violet Blaker are both in the back of the Pioneer Cemetery in unmarked graves. Both pioneers who contributed to the Yukon. It is sad that there is no way for us to know exactly where they are and that there is no memorial to them and every other unmarked gravesite in that cemetery.