Whitehorse Daily Star

MD diagnoses woman's illness as case of E. coli

The daughter of a woman who became violently ill Wednesday after eating steak purchased Tuesday says the hospital emergency room doctor diagnosed it as a case of E. coli.

By Chuck Tobin on October 25, 2012

The daughter of a woman who became violently ill Wednesday after eating steak purchased Tuesday says the hospital emergency room doctor diagnosed it as a case of E. coli.

Cathy Stannard, the territory's director of Community Health Programs, said today she is very limited in what she can say for reasons of confidentiality.

Stannard said she could not even confirm whether the communicable disease unit or environmental health officials have even received notice regarding a concern of E. coli.

Jacqueline Shorty told the Star she purchased blade steak from a local store Tuesday.

She and her family and her mother, Emma Shorty, had it for dinner Tuesday night.

By 4 p.m. Wednesday, her mother was vomiting violently, had diarrhea and couldn't even walk, Shorty said.

She said her 79-year-old mom stayed the night Tuesday, and drove out to her home at the Yukon River Bridge to gather up some things before returning to stay again Wednesday night.

Emma was still at her home and feeling fine at 3:30 p.m. when her son left. But within 15 minutes she had become so ill, so quickly, she called a friend to asked if she drove over could her friend drive her into the Whitehorse General Hospital, Shortly explained.

"My mom called back five minutes later and said, ‘you'll have to come and get me because I can't even walk,” another daughter, Elaine Shorty, explained this morning.

Elaine said when they arrived at Whitehorse General Hospital, her mom's friend put her in a wheelchair and left her inside at the admitting desk while she went and parked.

By the time she returned, hospital staff had already taken her mom into the emergency trauma room, she said.

"Somebody looked at her and somebody said, ‘this woman needs immediate attention.'”

Emma received treatment, and is OK today, but the family is very upset, Elaine said.

"We are incredibly lucky, incredibly lucky my mom was able to get to the hospital and they could treat her right away and do the things they did because we could have lost her,” she said.

Jacqueline Shorty said emergency room staff took blood and urine samples, and samples from the vomit.

Jacqueline said she was in the trauma room with her mom, along with two other professionals from the First Nation health unit, when the attending doctor told them straight-out it was a case of E. coli from the blade steaks.

"He was the doctor, and he was very adamant,” she said. "He said it was a case of E. coli from the meat we bought from the ....”

Elaine said when her mom suddenly became ill, she could not stop throwing up. Her heart rate had jumped to 124 beats a minute, significantly higher than normal.

"They thought she might have been having a heart attack,” Jacqueline said.

E. coli, they were told, can be particularly hard on the elderly and the young, Elaine said.

"We're lucky her system was able to reject it as quickly as she was able to get it out of her system.”

With no regular beds available at the hospital, she added, Emma would have had to stay the night in the emergency room if she'd decided to stay, but she didn't want to.

Instead, she spent the night at Jacqueline's, under the watch of Jacqueline and her family.

Jacqueline said it didn't have anything to do with the way the meat was cooked, because her mom likes her steaks well done, and it was well done.

She said her partner felt a little ill Tuesday night after dinner, but they didn't think much of it at the time.

The director of community health programs said the only way to confirm E. coli is through a stool sample sent to an outside lab for analysis.

There are different types of E. coli, Stannard pointed out.

It is the 0157H7 strain that was at the heart of the Canada's largest recall of beef products last month and earlier this month, she noted.

Comments (6)

Up 0 Down 0

raw meat barbecues... on Oct 31, 2012 at 1:04 am

I go to barbecues where the majority of people throw steaks on the pit for a minute on each side, just barely enough time to singe the outside while the inside of the steak is still entirely raw and then eat it. There are obviously still people out there that don't realize or care that eating uncooked meat can put your life in danger, whether from E.Coli or some other contaminant.

Up 0 Down 0

Max Mack on Oct 30, 2012 at 3:06 am

Until Escherichia coli 0157 has been positively confirmed as the culprit through lab testing, the doctor's "diagnosis", if indeed such a diagnosis was made, is nothing but speculation.

I am not sure how this story helps the public.

Up 0 Down 0

MS on Oct 28, 2012 at 9:58 am

From Govt of Canada website on e-coli safety:

These tips will help protect you and your family from E. coli:

•Cook food to a safe internal temperature using a digital thermometer.

•Do not eat hamburger patties that are pink in the middle. If served an undercooked hamburger, send it back for further cooking. Ask for a new bun and a clean plate, too.

•Avoid spreading harmful bacteria. Keep raw meat separate from ready-to-eat foods. Wash hands, counters, and utensils with hot soapy water after they have come in contact with raw meat. Never place cooked hamburgers on the unwashed plate that held raw patties. Wash thermometers in between testing patties.

•Eat and drink only pasteurized juice, cider, milk and milk products.

•Drink water from a safe (treated or boiled) supply.

•Wash your hands thoroughly before preparing or eating food.

•Wash raw fruits and vegetables thoroughly with clean, safe running water before you prepare and eat them. Use a brush to scrub produce with firm or rough surfaces, like oranges, cantaloupes, potatoes and carrots.

•Wash your hands after contact with animals (at home, farms, petting zoos and fairs).

•Keep pets away from food storage and preparation areas.

•If you think you are infected with E. coli bacteria or any other gastrointestinal illness, do not prepare food for other people.

Up 0 Down 0

north_of_60 on Oct 27, 2012 at 4:23 pm

Factory beef, especially from the front quarters, should be cooked well, and not eaten 'pink'.

'Chuck' and 'blade' cuts are often mechanically tenderized, which pushes the bacteria into the center.

Correct cooking kills e-coli and salmonella, the two common contaminants on industrial meat.

Up 0 Down 0

Pat T on Oct 26, 2012 at 8:06 am

In the interest of public safety why is the name of the store censored out of this story?

June, I'm not sure your information is accurate. On a larger cut of meat or a cut with bone in you could easily have temps +/- 10 or 20 degrees

Up 0 Down 0

June Jackson on Oct 25, 2012 at 9:48 am

Cooking meat to 160 degree's kills everything.

Why would a Doctor start a potential scare without confirming a diagnosis? Especially now with E-coli in the news big time. That Doctor should have to go back to school.

That said..I am glad your mom recovered ok and that your family is well.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.